Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondents, trading as New Era Electric Wares, applied on 14th April 1967 for registration of the trade mark "ESCORT" in respect of electric wires and cables. This application was advertised in the Trade Marks Journal, prompting opposition from the appellants, M/s. Escorts Ltd., a well-established manufacturing company incorporated in 1944. Escorts Ltd. claimed prior registration and use of the trade mark "ESCORTS" for various electrical goods, including electric irons and kettles, and opposed the registration on grounds of deceptive similarity and likelihood of confusion under the Trade & Merchandise Marks Act, 1958.

The Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks, Delhi, dismissed the opposition by order dated 28th November 1972, allowing registration of the mark "ESCORT" for electric wires and cables. Escorts Ltd. appealed against this order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the mark "ESCORT" applied for by the respondents is deceptively similar to the registered mark "ESCORTS" of the appellants, thereby likely to deceive or cause confusion under Section 11(a) of the Trade & Merchandise Marks Act, 1958.
  2. Whether the goods in respect of which the mark "ESCORT" was sought—electric wires and cables—are of the same description or allied to the goods covered by the appellants' mark, affecting the maintainability of opposition under Section 12(1) of the Act.
  3. Whether registration could be granted under Section 12(3) of the Act on the basis of honest concurrent user despite the objection under Section 11(a).
  4. The extent and sufficiency of the respondents’ evidence to prove honest concurrent use and continuous extensive use of the mark since 1958.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Escorts Ltd. contended that their registered mark "ESCORTS" was well-known and had been used since 1951 on various electrical goods.
  • They argued that the respondents' mark "ESCORT" was deceptively similar and likely to cause confusion among the public, especially since electric wires and cables are accessories to goods manufactured by them.
  • The appellants relied on Sections 11(a), 11(e), 12(1), and 18 of the Trade & Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 to oppose the registration.
  • They asserted that the respondents’ adoption of the mark was not honest but intended to trade on the goodwill of the appellants’ mark.
  • It was argued that if a mark offends Section 11, it cannot be registered under Section 12(3), relying on prior judgments between the parties, including Escorts v. Dalip Chand Aggarwal and Dalip Chand Aggarwal v. Escorts Ltd.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondents claimed honest adoption and extensive use of the mark "ESCORT" on electric wires and cables since 1958.
  • They contended that their goods were not of the same description as those covered by the appellants’ mark and thus the opposition under Section 12(1) was not maintainable.
  • They relied on their prior registration and evidence of use in other applications to support honest concurrent user under Section 12(3).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Escorts v. Dalip Chand Aggarwal (F.A.O No. 71 of 1967) Established that if a mark offends Section 11 of the Trade & Merchandise Marks Act, it cannot be registered under Section 12(3). The court relied on this precedent to hold that registration under Section 12(3) was impermissible once an objection under Section 11(a) was found maintainable.
Dalip Chand Aggarwal v. Escorts Ltd, AIR 1981 Del 150 Confirmed the principle regarding the burden of proof on honest concurrent user and the requirement of extensive and continuous use to justify registration under Section 12(3). The court applied this precedent to find the respondents' evidence meagre and insufficient to establish honest concurrent user.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the Assistant Registrar's findings that the respondents' mark "ESCORT" was deceptively similar to the appellants' registered mark "ESCORTS" and that use of the former was likely to deceive or cause confusion, satisfying the objection under Section 11(a) of the Act. Despite this, the Assistant Registrar had allowed registration under Section 12(3), finding the goods not to be of the same description.

The court held that once an objection under Section 11(a) is established, registration under Section 12(3) cannot be granted. It emphasized the heavy onus on the respondents to prove honest concurrent user with extensive and continuous use, considering duration, area, volume of trade, and likelihood of confusion. The respondents' evidence was found to be meagre, discrepant, and scanty, relying mainly on evidence from a previous application and opposition which had been overturned by a Division Bench.

The court further noted that the question of whether the goods were allied or of the same description was rendered unnecessary to decide because Section 11(a) covers cases where confusion is likely regardless of the goods' description. The appellants' mark had acquired a great reputation with substantial sales, whereas the respondents' use was limited.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed and the impugned order of the Assistant Registrar is set aside.

The direct consequence of this decision is that the respondents' application for registration of the trade mark "ESCORT" for electric wires and cables is refused. No registration under Section 12(3) of the Trade & Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 can be granted in the face of a valid objection under Section 11(a). The court imposed no order as to costs. This decision does not establish a new precedent but reaffirms established principles regarding deceptive similarity, the burden of proof for honest concurrent user, and the interplay between Sections 11 and 12(3) of the Act.

    Escorts Ltd. v. Surinder Nath & Ors.

    Y.K Sabharwal J.—The respondents were the applicants before the Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks, Delhi. They were trading under the name and style of New Era Electric Wares. On 14th April, 1967 the respondents made an application for registration in part ‘A’ of the Register a Trade Mark consisting the word “ESCORT”, in Clause 9, in respect of ‘Electric wires and cables’. The said application was advertised in the Trade Marks Journal and opposition was filed by the appellants, M/s. Escorts Ltd. (for short ‘Escorts’).

    2. In the opposition the Escorts pleaded that it was incorporated under the Indian Companies Act in the year 1944. They are a large manufacturing concern and are manufacturing various types of machinery and electrical goods. They pleaded that they are the registered proprietors of the trade mark ‘Escorts’ in various classes for various types of goods manufactured by them, the details of which were given in para 2 of the notice of opposition. It was claimed that they had been manufacturing some of those goods since 1951. The trade mark ‘ESCORTS’ under No. 202188 was registered on 1st May 1961 under clause 9 for electric flat irons and electric kettles and other class of goods mentioned in the certificate of registration. The registered trade mark No. 202190 registered on 1st May, 1961 besides others, included electric hearing elements, heating tubes, water heaters and other items mentioned in the certificate of registration. It was pleaded that the mark applied for, namely, ESCORT under No. 241605 for ‘electric wires and cables’ is deceptively similar to their registered trade mark ESCORTS. Escorts further pleaded that the electric wires and cables are accessories to electrical goods and apparatus which they are manufacturing under their registered trade mark ‘ESCORTS’. In short, they founded their opposition mainly on Sections 11(a),(e),12(1) and Section 18 of the Trade & Merchandise Marks Act. 1958 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Act’). They also pleaded that the adoption of the mark by the respondent was not honest as their intentions were to trade upon the goodwill, reputation and name of the appellants. The mark was adopted in order to cause confusion in the market and deceive the public with a view to benefit from the reputation and goodwill of the mark ‘ESCORTS’.

    3. By the impugned order dated 28th November, 1972 the Assistant Registrar dismissed the opposition and directed the registration of the trade mark. Escorts are in appeal against the said order.

    4. With regard to the objection of the Escorts under Section 11 (a) of the Act, the Assistant Registrar has found the objection of the appellants to be maintainable. In other words, the Assistant Registrar has come to the conclusion that the use of the mark by the respondent is likely to deceive or cause confusion. The Assistant Registrar has also come to the conclusion that the respondents' mark is deceptively similar to the appellants' (ESCORTS) registered trade mark. It has also been found as a fact by the Assistant Registrar that Escorts were using their mark prior to the date of the filing of the application of the impugned mark by the respondents. The Assistant Registrar further recorded the finding that on account of great reputation acquired by the appellants' mark the use of an identical or deceptively similar mark by another person is bound to cause confusion or the deception among the trade and the general public.

    5. The Assistant Registrar, in spite of the aforesaid findings, granted registration to the respondents as he found that the respondents' goods, namely, electric wires and cables cannot be considered as goods of the same description. He rejected the contention of the appellants that respondents goods were allied goods. Consequently, the Registrar found that although the applicant's mark is deceptively similar to the opponent's trade mark, the goods in respect of which the registration is sought are goods of different description, and as such objection, under Section 12(1) of the Act was held to be not maintainable. The Assistant Registrar granted registration under Section 12(3) of the Act holding that the respondents have honestly adopted the mark and they have been using it on their goods openly and extensively since the year 1958.

    6. In this appeal, the contention of Mr. Anoop Singh, learned counsel for the appellant is that if the mark offends Section 11 of the Act, it cannot be registered under Section 12(3) of the Act. Reliance in placed upon the judgment inter se the parties in F.A.O No. 71 of 1967, re: Escorts v. Dalip Chand Aggarwal” decided on 19th December, 1974, affirmed in appeal by a Division Bench of this Court Dalip Chand Aggarwal v. Escorts Ltd : AIR 1981 Del 150).

    7. In view of aforesaid, after having found the objection under Section 11(a) of the Act to be maintainable, the learned Assistant Registrar could not grant registration under Section 12(3) of the Act. The registration granted by the impugned order has to be set aside.

    8. There is another reason for reversing the impugned order. It is well established that the onus lies heavily on the person applying for registration to prove, the honest concurrent user; the quantum of user having regard to the duration, area and volume of trade and to the goods concerned; the degree of confusion likely to be caused from the similarity of the marks and to bring the case under Section 12(3) of the Act. In the affidavit filed before the Assistant Registrar, the respondents mainly relied on the evidence filed with application No. 214458 and also the evidence filed in opposition No, DEL-334 for proving honest concurrent extensive user since 1958. The respondents were granted registration under the aforesaid number for electric irons, electric kettles soldering irons and elements irons and elements for electric irons and kettles and the opposition No. DEL-334 filed by Escorts was rejected by the Assistant Registrar by his order dated 30th December, 1966. It is this order which was subject matter of F.A.O No. 71 of 1967 and the Division Bench judgment, referred to above, which reversed the order granting registration of mark ‘Escort’ to the respondents. This court came to the conclusion that the respondents are not entitled to registration under section 12(3) of the Act as the respondents had not proved the continuous user and the evidence filed by them was meagre, discrepant and scanty. In the present case also the main reliance before Assistant Registrar of Trade Mark, was on similarly evidence and for this reason also the same result has to follow. In view of the earlier judgment inter se the parties. I do not consider it necessary to elaborately discuss the evidence produced before the Assistant Registrar in the present case. In view of the above, it is also not necessary to give a finding on the question as to whether the two goods are allied or not. The Division Bench after considering the case law on the subject came to the conclusion that Section 11(a) also covers the cases where the goods may not be of the same description but if it is likely to deceive and cause confusion, the registration would be refused. Therefore, it is not necessary to give a finding whether the two goods are of the same description or not. The sales of the Escorts run into crores of rupees. Escorts is a known manufacturing Company and has a reasonably known name. On the other hand user by the respondents was very limited. There is no absolute right to have the mark registered. On the facts and circumstances of this case it cannot be said that the respondents had extensive user to come within the purview of Section 12(3) of the Act.

    9. The result is that the appeal is allowed and the impugned order of Assistant Registrar is set aside. In the circumstances of the case there will be no order as to costs.

    Appeal allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Escorts Ltd. v. Surinder Nath & Ors.
    (Nov 23, 1987)