Structured Summary of the Opinion — Mahesh Chandra, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff, M/s. Saraswati Industrial Syndicate Ltd. (IJT), sued the defendant, M/s. Apollo Tyres Limited (ATL), for recovery of Rs. 1,60,633.83 as the remaining principal and Rs. 3,87,592.34 as interest. The dispute arose from an agreement dated 11 February 1975 for supply, erection and commissioning of two boilers. Differences emerged over amounts payable, and on 25 February 1982 the parties recorded minutes of a meeting (referred to in the plaint as the "Settlement") in which ATL acknowledged dues totaling Rs. 3,21,267.66 and agreed to pay in two instalments; interest was to be decided by the managing directors of the parties. ATL paid Rs. 1,60,633.83 by cheque dated 13 May 1982 but did not pay the remaining Rs. 1,60,633.83, prompting the present suit for recovery.
The defendant filed an application under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act seeking a stay of the suit on the basis of clause 9.05 of the 1975 agreement, which contained an arbitration clause. The defendant claimed differences (including alleged defects in the boiler) were referable to arbitration and asserted readiness to arbitrate; it also alleged coercion in signing the 25 February 1982 minutes. The plaintiff contested the application, asserting the settlement was voluntary, had been acted upon (part payment made), that the defendant had not been ready and willing to arbitrate at the appropriate time and had repudiated the arbitration agreement, and therefore the application was misconceived and should be dismissed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, in the circumstances of this case, there existed a subsisting arbitration agreement between the parties that would require a stay of the suit under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act.
- Whether the defendant was, at all material times (including at commencement of proceedings), unconditionally ready and willing to do everything necessary for the proper conduct of arbitration, such that a stay under Section 34 should be granted.
- What effect, if any, the settlement/minutes dated 25 February 1982 had on the arbitration clause in the original agreement.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant's Arguments
- The agreement dated 11 February 1975 contained clause 9.05 providing for adjudication by two arbitrators and, if necessary, an umpire; disputes should therefore be referred to arbitration.
- By a legal notice dated 30 August 1982 the defendant maintained that the boiler supplied was defective and substandard, making the differences referable to arbitration.
- The defendant asserted it had been and was still ready and willing to have disputes adjudicated by arbitrators and therefore the suit proceedings should be stayed under Section 34.
- The defendant alleged in its application that it had been "compelled and coerced" to sign the minutes of 25 February 1982 (the settlement).
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The application under Section 34 was misconceived and not maintainable.
- The settlement dated 25 February 1982 was arrived at voluntarily and there was no compulsion or coercion on the defendant to sign the minutes; this denial was made in the plaintiff's reply.
- The settlement had been acted upon by the defendant (a payment of Rs. 1,60,633.83 was made), showing the parties accepted the settlement.
- The defendant was not ready and willing at the appropriate time to refer the dispute to arbitration and had, in effect, repudiated the arbitration agreement; the Section 34 application was an afterthought.
- Because the settlement resolved the disputes, the arbitration clause could not now be invoked to stay the suit.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Food Corporation of India & Another v. Yadav Engineer & Contractor, AIR 1982 SC 1302 |
“When in breach of an arbitration agreement a party to the agreement rushes to the Court, unless a clear case to the contrary is made out the approach of the Court should be to hold parties to their bargain provided necessary conditions for invoking Section 34 are satisfied.” |
The court acknowledged the principle that parties should generally be held to arbitration agreements, but found that the settlement between the parties abrogated the arbitration agreement and therefore the principle did not entitle the defendant to a stay in this case. |
| Food Corporation of India v. M/s. Thakur Shipping Co. Ltd. & Others, 1975 (3) SCR 146 |
Under Section 34, an applicant for a stay must show that he was, at the commencement of proceedings, ready and willing to do everything necessary for proper conduct of the arbitration. |
The court relied on this principle to assess whether the defendant had been unconditionally ready and willing. It found letters on record showing the defendant had denied the right to refer to arbitration and had raised conditions, indicating a lack of unconditional readiness. |
| M/s. National Small Industries Corporation Ltd. v. M/s. Punjab Tin Printing & Metal Industries, AIR 1979 Delhi 59 |
“To stay a suit, there must be an existing dispute between the parties. If there was no dispute, there is nothing to arbitrate.” |
The court used this principle to support the conclusion that because the parties had mutually settled their disputes by the 25 February 1982 minutes (and acted on it), there was no longer a dispute referable to arbitration, and thus no basis for a stay. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court framed the threshold for granting a stay under Section 34: the defendant must establish (inter alia) that a subsisting arbitration agreement existed and that the defendant was unconditionally ready and willing to do everything necessary for proper conduct of arbitration (para 4).
The court examined the arbitration clause (clause 9.05) of the 11 February 1975 agreement, which required parties to try amicable settlement by negotiation and, failing agreement, to refer disputes to two arbitrators, with the provisions of the Indian Arbitration Act, 1940, incorporated (paras 6 and 31-32).
The court then scrutinized the settlement/minutes dated 25 February 1982 in detail (paras 7, 19–30). The defendant had alleged coercion in signing those minutes; the plaintiff denied coercion and the court observed there was no other record evidence supporting the coercion allegation. The court noted that the defendant had acted upon the settlement (payment of Rs. 1,60,633.83 by cheque dated 13 May 1982) and that correspondence on record corroborated that payment (paras 8 and 31).
From these facts the court concluded that the parties had mutually arrived at and acted upon the settlement, thereby resolving their differences in accordance with the first part of clause 9.05 (which calls for amicable settlement by negotiation). The court held that where parties mutually settle disputes and act on that settlement, the original arbitration agreement is effectively given a "go by" — it is abrogated, abandoned, discharged and waived, and cannot thereafter be revived by any party (paras 31–35).
The court further addressed the defendant's contention of operational difficulties with the boiler and noted those matters were specifically contemplated and dealt with in the settlement (para 36).
Independently, the court considered whether the defendant had been unconditionally ready and willing to arbitrate. It relied on letters on record (plaintiff's letter dated 27 April 1984 and defendant's reply dated 12 May 1984) which, the court found, showed the defendant had denied the plaintiff's right to refer matters to arbitration and had imposed conditions (e.g., asserting arbitration should be held at Cochin rather than, as the court inferred from clause 9.06, New Delhi). The court held such conditional readiness did not satisfy the strict requirement of unconditional readiness at the relevant time (para 12).
Because the settlement had resolved the disputes and because the defendant was not shown to have been unconditionally ready and willing to arbitrate at the relevant time, the court concluded the defendant was not entitled to a stay under Section 34 (paras 33–40).
Holding and Implications
APPLICATION DISMISSED.
Direct effect on the parties: The defendant's application under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act for a stay of the suit is dismissed. The court held that the settlement dated 25 February 1982 was mutually arrived at and acted upon, thereby abrogating and discharging the arbitration agreement; alternatively, the defendant failed to demonstrate unconditional readiness to arbitrate at the relevant time. Consequently, the plaintiff may proceed with the suit for recovery based on the settlement.
The opinion does not articulate any broader or novel precedent; it applies established principles to the facts of this case and records the dismissal of the Section 34 application.
Date of Order: September 2, 1986.
Result recorded in the file: Application dismissed.
Show full summary ...