| Kuldip Chopra I.T.O v. Sohan Singh Dhiman, 110 I.T.R 521 |
A false statement affecting assessment requires mens rea for prosecution. |
Supported the view that a wrong claim without mens rea does not constitute an offence. |
| D. Rahaman v. Bijaya Kishore Das, 136 I.T.R 855 |
Same principle on mens rea in false statements for tax assessment. |
Reinforced the requirement of mens rea for actionable falsehoods. |
| Bijayanand Patnaik v. Union of India, 136 ITR 861 |
Similar principle on false statements and mens rea in tax matters. |
Supported the court's approach on exemption claims and prosecution. |
| A.D Jayaveerapandia Nadar & Co. v. Income-tax Officer, 101 ITR 390 |
Filing a revised return to avoid trouble is not evidence of mens rea. |
Used to show the 1977 return was not proof of deliberate falsehood. |
| Commissioner of Wealth-tax v. B.M Bhandari, 123 ITR 554 |
Tax statutes must be construed reasonably and pragmatically, not pedantically. |
Supported liberal construction of exemption provisions in favor of assessee. |
| S. Radhakrishnan v. Commissioner of Income-tax, (1980) 17 C.T.R 349 (Mad) |
Interpretation of "was being used" as continuous use over the entire two years. |
Court disagreed with this strict interpretation in favor of a more reasonable one. |
| M. Viswanathan v. Commissioner of Income-tax, 117 ITR 244 |
Past continuous tense implies continuous use up to the date of transfer. |
Court held that continuous residence is not mandated strictly by statute. |
| Commissioner of Income-tax v. R. Mala, 135 ITR 302 |
Followed M. Viswanathan on continuous use interpretation. |
Used to contrast with the court's more liberal construction. |
| Commissioner of Income-tax v. Tikyomal Jasanmal, 82 ITR 95 |
"Was being used" means use mainly for residence within the two years, not necessarily continuous. |
Supported the court's interpretation that continuity is not mandatory. |
| B.B Sarkar v. Commissioner of Income-tax, 132 ITR 150 |
Use of property mainly for residence within two years suffices for exemption. |
Supported the conclusion that no continuous residence is required. |
| Commissioner of Wealth-tax v. Mrs. Avatar Mohan Singh, 83 ITR 52 |
Definition of exclusive residential use contrasted with commercial use. |
Clarified that use by family members counts as residential use. |
| Rajinder Nath v. M.L Khosla, I.T.O, 134 ITR 397 |
Return filed later can provide evidence to substantiate complaint. |
Revenue relied on this to argue falsity, but court emphasized need for offence disclosure. |
| Jyoti Parkash Mitter v. Haramohan Chowdhary, 112 ITR 384 |
Assessment must be completed before penalty or prosecution can be instituted. |
Supported the view that prosecution was premature. |
| Uttam Chand and others v. Income-tax Officer, 133 ITR 909 (SC) |
Same principle on necessity of assessment before prosecution. |
Reinforced court's conclusion on premature complaint. |
| Hazarilal v. Emperor, (1937) 5 ITR 610 |
Statements in income-tax return are not evidence in judicial proceedings. |
Supported that prosecution under section 193 IPC for return statements is invalid. |
| Lalji Haridas v. The State of Maharashtra, AIR 1964 SC 1154 |
Proceedings before Income-tax Officer are judicial proceedings within section 195(1)(b) Cr.P.C. |
Clarified the nature of proceedings but procedural safeguards differ from courts. |
| Balwant Singh and another v. L.C Bharupal and another, (1968) 1 SCWR 320 |
Sections 195 and 476 Cr.P.C. are to be read together for courts but not necessarily for Income-tax Officer proceedings. |
Supported procedural distinctions in tax prosecutions. |