Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Judicial Opinion Summary: M.L. Jain, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent, Kampa Wati, filed an eviction petition against the appellant, Chander Kishore Sharma, under clause (a) of the proviso to Sub-section (1) of Section 14 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958, alleging non-payment of rent. According to the record, the tenant had, by 13-4-1976, paid arrears by money order amounting to Rs. 495 and had deposited further sums in court on various dates totaling Rs. 2,090 by 31-1-1979.

The learned Additional Controller issued an order on 31-5-1979 under Section 15(1) of the Act, which was later modified in appeal by the Rent Control Tribunal on 16-10-1979. The combined effect of the Controller's order and the Tribunal's modification required the tenant to pay within a month all arrears of rent due by 31-5-1979 after adjustment of amounts already paid. The Controller and the Tribunal initially held that the rent for May 1979 had not then fallen due and rejected an execution application that relied on non-payment of May 1979 rent.

Subsequently, an argument was advanced before the Tribunal based on a review of past payment challans suggesting that there was no payment relatable to April 1978. The Tribunal treated this as a lapse, reversed the Controller's decision, and directed eviction of the tenant. The appellant challenged that reversal, leading to this appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, having regard to payments made (by money order and court deposits), any arrears of rent were due as of 31-5-1979.
  2. Whether payments of arrears must be allocated to specific months (i.e., split and related monthwise) or whether the total amount paid must be treated as a lump sum for the purpose of determining outstanding arrears.
  3. Whether the Rent Control Tribunal erred in reversing the Controller's order and directing eviction on the basis of an apparent absence of a payment relatable to April 1978 discovered from past challans.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Tenant's) Arguments

  • The tenant had made payments of arrears: Rs. 495 by money order by 13-4-1976 and additional deposits totaling Rs. 2,090 by 31-1-1979, which when accounted for left no arrears as of 31-5-1979 after permitted adjustments.
  • Payments should be considered in aggregate (as a lump sum) and not dissected and related to particular months; therefore, the challenge based on an alleged lacuna in a particular month's payment (April 1978) was misconceived.

Respondent's (Landlord's) Arguments

  • The respondent initially relied on non-payment of rent as ground for eviction under the proviso to Section 14(1) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958.
  • An execution application asserted that the order of the Controller had not been complied with because rent for May 1979 was not paid (an argument rejected by the Controller and Tribunal as May 1979 rent had not fallen due at that time).
  • On review of past payment challans presented before the Tribunal, it was argued that there was no payment relatable to April 1978; treating this as a lapse, the Tribunal reversed the Controller and ordered eviction.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the sequence of payments and the orders made by the Additional Controller and the Rent Control Tribunal. The judge found a substantial error of law in the Tribunal's approach. The key legal reasoning is as follows:

  1. The court held that when considering payments of arrears one must treat the total amount paid as a single lump sum, even if those payments were made monthwise or by separate transactions. In other words, the payments cannot be artificially split and allocated to specific months for the purpose of determining whether arrears exist.
  2. The argument presented before the Tribunal—based on scanning past challans to find the absence of a payment attributable to April 1978—relied on precisely the kind of month-by-month allocation the court held to be impermissible. The opinion characterizes that argument as misconceived.
  3. Applying the principle that payments are to be treated in the aggregate, the court concluded that after accounting for amounts permitted to be adjusted, there were no arrears due as of 31-5-1979. Accordingly, the Tribunal's decision to reverse the Controller and direct eviction, founded on the challan-based allocation theory, was legally unsound and could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ACCEPTED; impugned order of the Rent Control Tribunal dated 27-8-1982 set aside.

Consequences and immediate implications:

  • The eviction order made by the Rent Control Tribunal (dated 27-8-1982) is quashed; the tenant is not ordered to be evicted on the basis of the grounds relied upon in that order.
  • The judge ordered "No costs," meaning each party bears their own costs of the appeal.

The opinion does not purport to set a broader, novel precedent beyond the application of the stated principle (treat payments as a lump sum rather than allocating them monthwise) to the facts of this case.

    Shri Chander Kishore Sharma v. Smt. Kampa Wati & Anr.

    M.L Jain, J.:— The respondent Kampa Wati filed an eviction petition against the appellant Chander Kishore Sharma under clause (a) of the proviso to Sub-section (1) of Section 14 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958, on the ground of non-payment of rent. It appears that the tenant by 13-4-1976 had paid arrears of rent by money order to the tune of Rs. 495/- and had further deposited rent at various dates in the court to the tune of Rs. 2090/- by 31-1-1979.

    2. The learned Addl. Controller, however, made an order on 31-5-1979 under Section 15(1) of the said Act which order was later on modified in appeal by the Rent Control Tribunal on 16-10-1979. The order read with the modification amounts to this that the tenant was required to pay within a month all the arrears of rent that were due by 31-5-1979 after the adjustment of the amount already paid as aforesaid. As a matter of fact, after excluding the amount permitted to be adjusted, there were no arrears to be paid on the date of the order of the Addl. Controller made on 31-5-1.9-79. Yet an execution application for eviction was made on the ground that the order of the Controller was not complied with inasmuch as the rent for the month of May, 1979 was not paid. This argument was rejected by the learned Controller and the learned Rent Control Tribunal holding that the rent for the month of May, 1979 had not by then fallen due. There, I think, in the view taken by them, they were absolutely correct. A new and strange argument was then raised before the Tribunal that upon a scanning of the challans of the past payments, it was found that there was no payment of rent relatable to the month of April, 1978. Considering this to be a lapse, the learned Tribunal reversed the judgment of the Addl. Controller and directed eviction of the tenant. Hence, this appeal.

    3. On hearing the learned counsel for the parties, it seems quite obvious that the learned Tribunal has definitely fallen into an error of law which is substantial in nature. While considering the payment made of the arrears, one has to consider the total amount paid as one lump sum even if paid monthwise or otherwise and one is not required or permitted to split and relate the payment monthwise. The argument built up before the Tribunal was, therefore, misconceived and should have been rejected. After considering the whole matter, I find that there were no arrears due to be paid on 31-5-197). Hence, the order of the Tribunal cannot be sustained.

    4. The appeal is consequently accepted and the impughed order of the Tribunal of 27-8-1982 is set aside. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri Chander Kishore Sharma v. Smt. Kampa Wati & Anr.
    (May 6, 1983)