| Asa Ram v. Lagan Nath and others, A.I.R. 1934 Lahore 563 |
Where plaintiff alleges joint possession in a partition suit, court-fee is leviable under Article 17(vi) of Schedule II; section 7(iv)(b) does not apply to such suits. |
Cited to support that the present suit, pleaded as by a co-parcener in possession seeking partition, attracts Article 17(vi) fixed fee and not section 7(iv)(b). |
| Ram Narain Kaul v. Mst. Bishan Rani and others, A.I.R. 1938 Lahore 321 |
In partition of alleged joint family properties in joint possession, court-fee is under Article 17(vi) not ad valorem on the plaintiff's share. |
Reinforces the proposition that partition suits with alleged joint possession are charged fixed fee under Article 17(vi). |
| Mst. Durga Devi v. Parbati, A.I.R. 1933 Lahore 208 |
Earlier Lahore High Court authority taking similar view (partition with joint possession attracts fixed fee). |
Noted as supporting authority for the fixed-fee rule in partition suits. |
| Dewan Chand v. Dhani Ram and others, A.I.R. 1941 Lahore 123 |
On appeal arising from partition suit where plaintiff claimed actual or constructive possession, the fee payable on appeal is the same as in the suit (fixed fee under Article 17(vi)). |
Used to show consistency: characterization of the original suit governs fee on subsequent proceedings; supports fixed-fee treatment. |
| Tutika Lakshaminarayana and others v. Patharla Saraswati and another, A.I.R. 1969 (as cited) |
Held that where partition and separate allotment of alleged joint properties in joint possession is sought, the relevant Article (Article 17-A or equivalent) of Schedule II applies. |
Noted as an instance where partition with alleged joint possession attracted the fixed-fee provision in the relevant jurisdiction. |
| Raman Chandra Dey and others v. Gouralias Gharbaran Gur and others, A.I.R. 1962 Assam 137 |
Possession for purposes of the Act may be constructive; suit for partition where plaintiff alleges constructive possession does not attract section 7(iv)(b). |
Applied to confirm that constructive possession pleaded by the respondent brings the case within Article 17(vi) rather than section 7(iv)(b). |
| Saladi Satyam alias Satyanarayanamma v. Saladi Samanna and others, A.I.R. 1960 Andhra Pradesh 313 |
For court-fee one must regard the allegations in the plaint; the court should not test truth/probability while classifying the suit for fee purposes. |
Adopted to support the methodological rule that only plaint allegations determine classification for court-fee. |
| Nori Srirama Sastri v. Nori Lakshmidevamma and others, A.I.R. 1955 Andhra Pradesh 200 |
Suits for partition where plaintiff is in actual or constructive possession are incapable of valuation and chargeable with fixed court-fee under the relevant Article. |
Cited to underline that such partition suits are treated as incapable of valuation and attract fixed fee. |
| Nikka and others v. Fazal Dad Khan and others, A.I.R. 1930 Lahore 839 |
Where plaintiff alleges joint possession, Article 17(vi) of Schedule II is the proper provision to apply. |
Reiterated as supporting authority for fixed-fee treatment when joint possession is alleged. |
| Mt. Sat Bhawan v. Bedi Ram Kishan Singh and others, A.I.R. 1938 Lahore 275 |
Section 7(iv)(b) applies where a person is out of possession and seeks restoration to possession (a suit for possession), not to suits where a change in mode of enjoyment is sought. |
Cited to distinguish suits seeking restoration of possession (ad valorem) from partition suits seeking change of enjoyment (fixed fee). |
| Santosh s/o Gopala and another v. Rama s/o Ragho and others, A.I.R. 1949 Nagpur 305 |
Observed that Schedule II, Article 17 applies if the plaintiff is in joint possession of the whole estate (actual or constructive). |
Noted by the court but observed that the Nagpur High Court gave no reasons for limiting application to possession of the whole estate. |
| Mangal Dass v. Naunihal Singh and others, 1974 P.L.R. 255 (Punjab & Haryana High Court) |
Held that jurisdictional value of partition suits is to be determined on the value of the whole property in accordance with Rule 8 of Chapter 3‑C of Punjab High Court Rules and section 9 of the Suits Valuation Act. |
Relied upon to hold that the trial court erred in fixing jurisdictional value at the value of the plaintiff's 1/7th share; instead the whole property's value must be stated for jurisdictional purposes. |