Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff (appellant) filed a suit on 24 November 1969. On 27 July 1972 Mr. S.N. Kumar, Advocate, appeared and asked for permission to withdraw as counsel, which was granted. Because the appellant was then unrepresented, notice was ordered for 10 August 1972 but service was not effected until 19 October 1972 when the appellant appeared in court. The case was adjourned to 17 January 1973 for the remaining evidence and the court made clear no further adjournments would be granted.
Mr. S.N. Kumar subsequently appeared on 27 October 1972 and 30 November 1972 for an application for return of documents which was allowed. On 6 December 1972 the matter was placed before the Deputy Registrar but no one appeared for the appellant; counsel for the defendant did appear. On 17 January 1973 Mr. S.N. Kumar appeared and stated he had no instructions to proceed; the appellant was not present. The learned single Judge then ordered: “The counsel for the plaintiff says that he has no instructions to proceed with the suit. He wishes to withdraw from the case. The plaintiff is not present. No evidence has been summoned. The suit is, therefore, dismissed for non-prosecution.”
On 16 February 1973 the appellant applied under Order 9 Rules 4 and 9 and section 151 CPC for review/restoration of the suit. The learned single Judge dismissed that application by order dated 3 April 1973. The appellant filed an appeal challenging that dismissal.
Procedural events on appeal: the certified copy of the impugned order was applied for on 2 May 1973 and delivered on 16 May 1973. The appeal was filed on 17 May 1973 (the last date for filing). On 26 May 1973 the court office raised an objection that the copy was insufficiently stamped and suggested the appeal be returned for refiling within a week; the Deputy Registrar initialled the office note. The court was in summer vacation from 28 May to 7 July 1973 (though the office remained open). The appellant’s clerk took back the memorandum of appeal on 14 June 1973 and it was refiled on 16 June 1973 after remedying the deficiency. Subsequent office objections led to further returns and refilings; the appeal was refiled on 26 July 1973 and was admitted on 23 August 1973, when the respondent’s counsel accepted notice and raised no objection then to delay.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appeal against the learned single Judge's dismissal of the application for restoration was barred by limitation because the memorandum of appeal was returned by the court office and refiled after the time suggested by the Deputy Registrar.
- Whether the re-filing during the court's summer vacation affected the running of limitation and rendered the appeal time-barred.
- Whether the learned single Judge erred in dismissing the application for restoration without affording the appellant an opportunity to lead viva voce evidence to explain the alleged mistaken noting of the date in counsel's diary.
- Whether the impugned order was appealable (i.e., whether it was under Order 9 Rule 8/9 or under Order 17 Rules 2 and 3 and thereby not subject to the form of appeal taken).
Arguments of the Parties
Respondent's (Mr. A.C. Gulati) Arguments
- The appeal was barred by time because the Deputy Registrar ordered the memorandum of appeal to be returned and to be refiled within a week; re-filing on 16 June 1973 was beyond that time and therefore time-barred.
- He relied on Rule 5 of Chapter I-A of Volume V of the Rules and Orders of the Punjab High Court (applicable to this Court) to argue the Deputy Registrar had power to require refiling within a limited time and that the rules had statutory force.
- On the merits, he emphasized the appellant's past conduct during the suit (lack of diligent prosecution) and the delay in filing the restoration application; these matters weighed against allowing restoration.
- He also contended the order under appeal was not an order under Order 9 Rule 9 (and hence not appealable in the manner taken) but rather an order under Rules 2 and 3 of Order 17, which would affect maintainability of the appeal as filed.
Appellant's Arguments
- The appeal was filed within time: the appeal as originally filed on 17 May 1973 was timely; subsequent office objections and returns and the fact of vacation meant limitation did not run such as to make re-filing time-barred.
- The Deputy Registrar’s initialling of the office note did not amount to an express time-fixing that would automatically bar the appeal if not complied with; Rule 5(2) contemplates listing before the Court and the Court has discretion to condone delay.
- On merits, the appellant contended that the next date had been wrongly noted as 19 January 1973 by counsel (and in his diary) instead of 17 January 1973; affidavits from Mr. S.N. Kumar and two others supported this contention and the appellant sought an opportunity to lead evidence to explain the discrepancy.
- The appellant sought condonation/extension under section 149 read with section 151 CPC and section 5 Limitation Act if any delay was found.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Fazal Ilahi v. Mohd. Ismail Khan, AIR 1929 Lahore (29) (1) |
That wrong noting in counsel's diary has been considered a sufficient and bona fide cause for non-appearance of a party when the suit is called for hearing. |
The Court relied on this authority to support the proposition that the appellant's counsel's claimed wrong noting could constitute sufficient cause for non-appearance and, therefore, the appellant should have been afforded an opportunity to lead evidence explaining the discrepancy before the restoration application was finally dismissed. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court addressed first the preliminary objection as to limitation. It reviewed the chronology: the impugned order dated 3 April 1973; certified copy applied for on 2 May 1973 and delivered 16 May 1973; appeal filed 17 May 1973. On 26 May 1973 the court office raised a stamping objection and suggested return for refiling; the Deputy Registrar initialled the office note. The Court noted that the court was in summer vacation from 28 May to 7 July 1973 (office open but court closed) and the roster stated limitation would not run during vacation.
Interpreting Rule 5 of Chapter I-A (Volume V of the Rules and Orders of the Punjab High Court) the court observed that the Deputy Registrar may return a memorandum for amendment and refiling within a time not exceeding ten days at a time and 40 days aggregate, and that if not amended and refiled within the time allowed it shall be listed for orders before the Court (Rule 5(2)). The Court concluded that the initialling of the office note by the Deputy Registrar did not necessarily amount to a fixed short-time bar that operated automatically to defeat the appeal; further, even if the time prescribed had not been met, Rule 5(2) contemplates listing before the Court and the Court can in its discretion condone delay.
The Court also applied section 4 of the Limitation Act, 1963: where limitation expires on a day when the court is closed, the suit or appeal may be instituted on the date the court reopens. The Court held that the opening of the office during vacation did not affect the fact that the court was closed and that the roster explicitly stated limitation would not run for instituting appeals during vacation; accordingly the re-filing on reopening was within time.
On the merits, the Court recited the factual record that the appellant had a history of seeking adjournments and at times counsel had been allowed to withdraw; Mr. S.N. Kumar had appeared intermittently and had made applications on the appellant's behalf. The single Judge had been influenced by the appellant's past conduct, the delay in making the restoration application, and the fact that the appellant's counsel did not in his affidavit explain why he did not bring the diary discrepancy to the court's attention on 17 January 1973.
Nonetheless, the appellate Court emphasized that the appellant had filed uncontradicted affidavits — that the next date had been wrongly noted as 19 January 1973 — and had asked for an opportunity to produce viva voce evidence (including producing Mr. Kumar) to explain the omission. The Court held that where there is an uncontroverted affidavit and the applicant seeks an opportunity to lead evidence to explain a bona fide error (such as wrong noting in counsel's diary), the trial court should afford that opportunity before finally dismissing a restoration application. The Court relied on the cited authority that wrong noting may be a sufficient cause and concluded that the single Judge should have allowed the appellant to lead evidence to test the affidavit. If, after such evidence is recorded, the learned Judge remains unconvinced he may dismiss on the basis of probabilities, past conduct or delay; but dismissal without giving the opportunity to produce the evidence was improper here.
The Court also considered but did not decide the technical point whether the impugned order was appealable under the specific provision urged by respondent (Order 17 Rules 2 and 3). The Court observed that the single Judge had treated the dismissal as an order under Order 9 Rule 8 and had not dismissed the restoration application as non-maintainable; the appellate Court therefore did not find it necessary to resolve the objection to appealability and found no justification to convert the order into one under Order 17 which neither party nor the court had contemplated.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is allowed. The order of the learned single Judge dismissing the application for restoration of the suit is set aside, and the application is remanded to the learned single Judge to afford the appellant an opportunity to lead evidence in support of his restoration application and then decide the application in accordance with law.
Implications:
- The direct effect: the trial Judge must receive and consider the evidence the appellant seeks to produce (including, if necessary, viva voce evidence and attendance of Mr. S.N. Kumar) to explain the alleged wrong noting of the date. Only after hearing that evidence may the Judge decide whether the dismissal should be set aside or not.
- The Court left to the learned single Judge the question of imposing terms (as to costs or otherwise) if restoration is allowed after evidence, so the appellate Court did not preclude imposition of conditions.
- Procedurally, the appellate Court overruled the preliminary objection of limitation and made clear the Court has discretion under the rules to condone delay and that vacation rules and section 4 Limitation Act operate in the circumstances described.
- No new binding precedent was announced beyond the application of existing principles (including the cited authority on wrong noting in counsel's diary); the decision remands the matter for evidentiary hearing and final determination by the learned single Judge.
Final procedural directions: Parties were directed to appear before the Deputy Registrar on 12-11-1973 for fixation of appearance dates. There was no order as to the costs of the appeal.
Show full summary ...