| Vasireddi Srimanthu and others v. Devabhaktuni Venkatappayya and another (ILR 1948 Madras 18) |
Attachment outside territorial jurisdiction requires transfer of decree to competent court |
Relied upon by Subordinate Judge to hold Delhi Court lacked jurisdiction to attach money at Simla |
| Bhagawati Prasad Bajpai v. Jai Narain Hanuman Das (AIR 1958 Allahabad 425) |
Territorial jurisdiction governs execution of decrees; exceptions under Order XXI Rule 48 and Rule 52 |
Decree-holder relied on this decision to argue exceptions permitting attachment outside jurisdiction |
| Gayoor Ahmed Khan v. Hazarima and others (AIR 1965 Raj. 41) |
Execution court has jurisdiction to execute decree beyond ordinary civil jurisdiction |
Followed by decree-holder to support attachment by Delhi Court |
| Laxmi Narain and others v. Firm Ram Kumar Suraj Bux and others (AIR 1971 Rajasthan 30) |
Affirmed jurisdiction of decree court to execute decree beyond territorial limits |
Decree-holder relied on this to support execution by Delhi Court |
| Hanuman Dutt v. Hazarimal (AIR 1958 Raj. 235) |
Attachment outside territorial jurisdiction is irregular; proper procedure is transfer of decree |
Followed by this Court to hold attachment irregular and to reject refund after payment |
| B.V Patankar and others v. C.G Sastry (AIR 1961 SC 272) |
Execution court can set aside orders breaching mandatory provisions of law |
Distinguished by this Court as not applicable to irregular attachment of money |
| Prem Chand Dev v. Mokhoda Devi (ILR 17 Cal 699 (FB)) |
Execution of decree relating to immovable property must be by court within territorial jurisdiction |
Supported territorial jurisdiction rule in execution |
| Begg. Dunlop and Co. v. Jagannath Marwari (ILR 39 Cal 104) |
Prohibitory orders under Order XXI Rule 46 require debt or garnishee to be within jurisdiction |
Applied to hold prohibitory orders invalid outside jurisdiction |
| Imperial Bank of India v. Mt. Bibi Sayeedan (AIR 1960 Patna 132) |
Attachment of debt by prohibitory notice under Rule 46 does not require immediate payment |
Clarified the nature of attachment but upheld jurisdictional limitation |
| Padmanabha Pillai Bhaskara Pillai v. Bank of Kerala Limited (AIR 1956 Trav. Cochin 100) |
Attachment of debt payable outside jurisdiction is invalid unless garnishee is within jurisdiction |
Supported territorial jurisdiction rule in execution |
| Jai Lal J. in Bilas Mal Damodar Das and others v. Hari Das and others (AIR 1929 Lahore 645) |
Attachment outside jurisdiction not competent under Order XXI Rule 46 except Rule 48 |
Supported territorial jurisdiction limitation |
| Gyarsilal v. Shankar Nao and others (AIR 1950 Nagpur 46) |
Order XXI Rule 52 is not an exception to territorial jurisdiction rule |
Followed to reject attachment outside jurisdiction under Rule 52 |
| Bisseserdas Daga and others v. Gabdumal Brahmin and another (AIR 1934 Nagpur 167) |
Executing court has no jurisdiction to pass prohibitory orders unless debt or person is within jurisdiction |
Applied to limit jurisdiction under Order XXI Rule 46 and Rule 52 |
| Sivaskanda Raju v. Raja of Jeypore (AIR 1927 Madras 627) |
Territorial jurisdiction is a condition precedent to court selling property |
Supported territorial jurisdiction principle |
| Ambika Ranjan Mujumdar v. Manikganj Loan Office Ltd. (AIR 1929 Cal 818) |
Sale of property outside local limits must be effected by court within local limits |
Supported need for territorial jurisdiction in execution |
| Veerappa Chetty v. Ramaswamy Chetty (AIR 1920 Madras 505) |
Transferred execution court has no jurisdiction over immovable property outside territorial limits |
Supported territorial jurisdiction requirement |
| O.V Belusami v. Official Assignee, Madras and others (AIR 1939 Madras 811) |
Prohibitory order outside jurisdiction is invalid |
Applied to invalidate order under Order XXI Rule 46 outside jurisdiction |
| Veerappa Chetty v. Ramaswamy Chetty (AIR 1920 Madras 505) |
Execution court without territorial jurisdiction cannot order sale or attachment |
Reinforced territorial jurisdiction principle |
| Ramanna v. Nallappa Raju (AIR 1956 SC 87) |
Transferee court can execute decree related to transferred subject-matter; money decrees require transfer of decree |
Applied to distinguish execution of money decrees from other decrees |
| Gowrammal v. Lingappa Gowader (AIR 1968 Madras 99) |
Transferee court lacks inherent jurisdiction over immovable property without decree transfer |
Supported necessity of decree transfer for execution |
| B.V Patankar and others v. C.G Sastry (AIR 1961 SC 272) |
Executing court can set aside illegal orders breaching mandatory law |
Distinguished as not applicable to irregular attachment here |