Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, Messrs Remington Rand of India Limited, challenged an order passed by the Industrial Tribunal, Delhi, which overruled preliminary objections to an industrial dispute reference made by the Lieutenant Governor, Delhi, dated 28th March 1970, with a corrigendum issued on 10th June 1970. The dispute concerned demands by the workmen, represented by the Remington Rand Employees Association, Northern Unit, regarding the revision or removal of the ceiling on the maximum dearness allowance payable to employees under the administrative control of the Delhi Regional Office, including branches and depots outside Delhi.
The company’s administrative structure was such that the Delhi Regional Office exercised overall administrative control over branches and depots in Chandigarh, Jaipur, Amritsar, Jammu, and Simla. The dispute arose after previous awards and settlements concerning dearness allowance, including a Supreme Court decision in 1962 fixing the maximum dearness allowance at Rs. 200, later increased by the company to Rs. 270. Subsequent disputes and settlements retained the ceiling at Rs. 270, and a further demand to raise it to Rs. 300 was rejected by the Tribunal in 1969.
The present dispute involved a demand for removal of the ceiling on dearness allowance, which led to the Lieutenant Governor referring the dispute to the Industrial Tribunal. The original reference erroneously mentioned the "Delhi Branch" instead of the "Delhi Regional Office," prompting a corrigendum to correct this. The company raised preliminary objections challenging the validity and scope of the corrigendum and the jurisdiction of the Tribunal to adjudicate on employees outside Delhi.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Delhi Administration was competent to issue the corrigendum dated 10th June 1970 correcting the terms of the industrial dispute reference.
- Whether a demand for the upward revision or removal of the ceiling on dearness allowance was made on the management, and if not, the effect thereof.
- Whether the reference to the Industrial Tribunal was invalid or illegal due to the subsisting settlement and award dated 20th January 1969.
- Whether the establishments outside Delhi were beyond the scope of the reference and whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction over workers employed outside Delhi.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner (Company) Arguments
- The original order of reference was confined to the Delhi office at Asaf Ali Road, and the corrigendum improperly extended the scope to include branches and depots outside Delhi without disclosing reasons, rendering it bad in law.
- The award of 11th March 1969 was still in operation, barring any fresh reference or dispute on the same subject.
- No demand for upward revision of dearness allowance was made on the management, so no industrial dispute could arise.
- The Lt. Governor had no territorial jurisdiction to refer disputes involving employees outside Delhi.
- The corrigendum was not authenticated as required by Article 77 of the Constitution.
- The union failed to give notice to terminate the existing award, which remained in force.
Respondent (Union) Arguments
- The corrigendum was a correction of a clerical mistake, changing "Delhi Branch" to "Delhi Regional Office," reflecting the true scope of the dispute.
- The demand was made on behalf of employees working both inside and outside Delhi under the administrative control of the Delhi Regional Office.
- The Industrial Tribunal had jurisdiction because the Delhi Regional Office exercised administrative control over the branches and depots outside Delhi.
- The demand for removal of the ceiling was valid and had been pursued before the Conciliation Officer, indicating a genuine industrial dispute.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Remington Rand of India v. Its Workmen (1962-1 LLJ 287) |
Revision of dearness allowance scheme and fixing maximum ceiling. |
Established the background of dispute and prior fixation of maximum dearness allowance at Rs. 200. |
| State of Bihar v. Ganguli (D.N) and others (1958-2 LLJ 634) |
Appropriate Government cannot cancel or supersede a reference under Section 10(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act. |
Supported the proposition that the Government cannot cancel a reference but may amend it under certain conditions. |
| South India Estate Labour Relations Organization v. State of Madras (1954-2 LLJ 198) |
Government’s power to amend a reference is a technicality without substance and permissible. |
Clarified that amendment of a reference by the Government is permissible and not cancellation. |
| Dabur (Dr.) S. K. Burman (Private) Ltd. Deoghar v. Their Workmen (1967-2 LLJ 863) |
Correction of clerical errors in reference orders is valid and does not amount to cancellation. |
Applied to uphold the corrigendum as a correction of a clerical mistake rather than a fresh or superseding reference. |
| Thumbi Motor Service, Salem v. Labour Court, Coimbatore (1960-2 LLJ 563) |
References cannot be inconsistent or supersede earlier ones unless justified. |
Used to distinguish between permissible amendments and invalid supersession of references. |
| Kesorarn Cotton Mills Ltd. v. Second Labour Court (1962-5 Indian Factories and Labour Law Reports 308) |
State Government’s power to add parties to reference limited to Section 10(5) of Industrial Disputes Act. |
Emphasized that adding parties must comply with statutory provisions; corrections of apparent errors are allowed. |
| Dalmia Dadri Cement Ltd. v. State of Punjab (1957-1 LLJ 222) |
Limits on amendment of references and requirements for valid notification under Article 166. |
Struck down a corrigendum for improper amendment beyond the original reference and lack of authentication. |
| National Tobacco Co. Employees Union v. Manohar Singh (1968 AIR Punjab and Haryana 514) |
Administrative control is key to jurisdiction of Industrial Tribunal over employees in different locations. |
Supported the Tribunal’s jurisdiction based on administrative control exercised by Delhi office over regional employees. |
| M/s. Lipton Ltd. v. Their Employees (1959 Supp. 2 SCR 150) |
Jurisdiction is based on residence of parties or where the cause of action substantially arises. |
Applied to affirm jurisdiction of Delhi Tribunal over employees outside Delhi under Delhi office control. |
| Lalbhai Tricumlal Mills Ltd. v. Vin (DM) (1956 LLJ 556) |
Test for jurisdiction includes residence and cause of action location. |
Approved as a leading principle for jurisdiction in industrial dispute cases. |
| Management Of Indian Cable Co., Ltd. v. Workmen (1962 4 FLR 444) |
Jurisdiction depends on administrative control and location of dispute. |
Reinforced principles for determining jurisdiction of Industrial Tribunal. |
| Sindhu Resettlement Corporation Ltd. v. Industrial Tribunal, Gujarat (1968 1 LLJ 834) |
An industrial dispute arises only when demand is made by employees on the employer. |
Used to interpret the scope of the demand and its effect on jurisdiction. |
| Association of Medical Representatives (M & V) v. Industrial Tribunal Madhya Pradesh (1966 1 LLJ 614) |
Engagement in work within a State does not create an undertaking there without administrative control. |
Distinguished the facts of the present case to support jurisdiction based on control. |
| State of U. P. v. Om Prakash Gupta AIR 1970 679 |
Authentication requirements for orders under Article 77 of the Constitution. |
Considered in relation to the question of authentication of the corrigendum. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the nature of the corrigendum issued by the Delhi Administration and found it to be a correction of a clerical or verbal error, changing the term "Delhi Branch" to "Delhi Regional Office" to reflect the real dispute and intention of the Government. The Court relied on precedents establishing that while the Government cannot cancel or supersede a reference under Section 10(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, it can amend or correct it to accord with the true facts.
The Court examined the administrative control exercised by the Delhi Regional Office over the branches and depots outside Delhi and concluded that the Tribunal had jurisdiction to adjudicate disputes involving employees outside Delhi, based on the admitted overall administrative control, appointment powers, disciplinary authority, and previous settlements covering the entire region.
The Court rejected the contention that the demand for removal of the ceiling on dearness allowance was limited to employees in Delhi, noting that the union had made the demand on behalf of all employees under the Delhi Regional Office's control, including those outside Delhi. The absence of any affidavit from the management denying this was significant.
The Court further held that the subsisting settlement and award dated 20th January 1969 barred fresh adjudication only for the period it was in force (until 31st March 1969), and did not preclude the present reference relating to demands made thereafter.
Regarding procedural objections, the Court declined to entertain the challenge to the authentication of the corrigendum under Article 77 of the Constitution, as this ground had not been raised before the Industrial Tribunal and would require additional evidence.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition filed by Messrs Remington Rand of India Limited is dismissed with costs.
The Court upheld the validity of the corrigendum as a mere correction of a clerical error and affirmed the jurisdiction of the Industrial Tribunal, Delhi, to adjudicate the dispute involving employees both within and outside Delhi under the administrative control of the Delhi Regional Office. The previous settlement and award did not bar the present reference beyond their operative period. No new precedent was set; the decision confirms existing principles on the scope of industrial dispute references and the importance of administrative control in determining jurisdiction.
Show full summary ...