| Barber v. Manchester Regional Hospital Board (1958) 1 A.E.R 322 |
Even if a formal service agreement is not executed, conditions therein may apply. |
Supported the view that Ordinance XII conditions apply despite no executed agreement. |
| P.R Jodh v. A.L Pande (1965) 2 SCR 713 |
Ordinance provisions confer legal rights on teachers of affiliated colleges. |
Used to confirm that Ordinance conditions have force of law and create legal rights. |
| Dr. Akshaibar Lal v. Vice-Chancellor, Banaras Hindu University AIR 1961 S.C 619 |
Statutory offices require due process before termination. |
Referenced regarding statutory protection of tenure. |
| Attorney-General and Board of Education v. County Council of the West Riding of Yorkshire (1907) AC 29 |
Meaning of "maintain" as "pay for" expenses of schools. |
Applied to interpret "Government maintained" college meaning. |
| Wilford v. County Council of the West Riding of Yorkshire (1908) 1 K.B 685 |
Obligation to maintain means to pay expenses, not control management. |
Supported interpretation of "maintained" in university context. |
| Trowbridge Water Company v. The Wilts County Council (1909) 1 K.B 824 |
Local authority's duty to maintain includes contracts for supplies and furniture. |
Reinforced the financial meaning of "maintain". |
| Rex v. Easton (1913) 2 K.B 60 |
Further confirmed meaning of "maintain" as paying for expenses. |
Used to clarify statutory interpretation. |
| Ridge v. Baldwin (1964) AC 40 |
Statutory office holders cannot be dismissed without cause and due process. |
Illustrated statutory protection of tenure beyond contract. |
| Parshotam Lal Dhingra v. Union Of India (1958) S.C.R 828 |
Permanent Government servants have a title to hold office and protected tenure. |
Supported distinction between contractual and statutory status. |
| Moti Ram Deka v. General Manager, N.E.F Railways (1964) 5 S.C.R 683 |
Termination of permanent Government servants requires compliance with Article 311. |
Affirmed statutory protection of tenure. |
| Dr. Boolchand v. Kurukshetra University (1968) 1 S.C.R 434 |
Statutory office termination requires opportunity to show cause. |
Confirmed public law remedies for wrongful removal. |
| Srimati Hira Devi v. District Board, Shahjahanpur (1952) S.C.R 1122 |
Legislature may confer statutory status on employees. |
Used to show statutory protection can be conferred beyond contract. |
| Roshan Lal Tandon v. Union of India (1968) 1 S.C.R 185 |
Government servant’s position is one of status, not mere contract. |
Supported statutory status concept over contract. |
| Vine v. National Dock Labour Board (1957) AC 488 |
Employees under statutory scheme have statutory status; wrongful termination is ultra vires. |
Distinguished contract breach from statutory violation. |
| Bagalkot Cement Company Ltd. v. R.K Pathan (1962) Suppl. 2 S.C.R 697 |
Termination contrary to statutory standing orders is breach of statutory provisions. |
Supported reinstatement remedy for statutory violation. |
| Tata Chemicals Ltd. v. Kailash C. Adhvaryu AIR 1964 Gujarat 265 |
Termination violating statutory provisions remedied by reinstatement. |
Applied reinstatement remedy for statutory breach. |
| S.P Srivastwa v. Banaras Electric Light and Power Company (1968) Allahabad Law Journal 257 (FB) |
Reinstatement granted in industrial adjudication. |
Distinguished remedies in industrial adjudication from courts. |
| Managing Committee of Meerut College v. Dr. V. Purifi 1969 S.L.R 521 |
Statutory protection for Principal’s tenure; wrongful termination remedied by reinstatement. |
Confirmed statutory protection of tenure for certain posts. |
| Executive Committee of U.P State Warehousing Corporation v. Chandra Kiran Tyagi 1969 S.L.R 799 |
Distinction between breach of contract and breach of mandatory statutory obligation. |
Held breach of regulations was breach of contract, not statutory obligation; no reinstatement. |
| Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Sunil Kumar Mukherjee (1964) 5 S.C.R 528 |
Statutory protection under Life Insurance Corporation Act entitles employees to reinstatement. |
Distinguished from mere breach of regulations. |
| Ram Babu Rathaur v. Divisional Manager, Life Insurance Corporation of India AIR 1961 Allahabad 502 |
Breach of regulations under Life Insurance Corporation Act is breach of contract, not statutory obligation. |
Supported contractual nature of service under regulations. |
| Pramodrai Shamaldas Bhavsar v. Life Insurance Corporation Of India AIR 1969 Bombay 337 |
Confirmed breach of regulations as breach of contract. |
Supported contractual status of employees under regulations. |
| Shri B.S Puri v. Shri L.C Gupta (Regular Second Appeal No. 120 of 1968) |
Rejected reinstatement where no statutory post or mandatory statutory obligation breached. |
Followed U.P Warehousing Corporation decision; relief limited to damages. |
| Western India Automobile Association v. The Industrial Tribunal, Bombay 1949 L.L.J 245 |
Industrial tribunals can grant reliefs based on broader justice principles. |
Explained difference between court and industrial tribunal remedies. |
| United Engineering Workers' Union v. K.W Devanayagam (1968) AC 356 |
Industrial adjudication reliefs are discretionary and not mechanical. |
Clarified industrial tribunal’s approach to reinstatement. |
| Praga Tools Corporation v. C.A Imanual 1969 (1) SCC 585 |
Mandamus lies against public officials or bodies to enforce statutory duties. |
Clarified scope of mandamus in employment disputes. |
| State of Indiana Ex. Rel. Dorothy Anderson v. Harry Brand 303 U.S 95 (1938) |
Divergent views on whether tenure is contractual or statutory; contractual tenure immune from impairment. |
Referenced to illustrate complexity in tenure classification. |
| Prabhakar Ramakrishna Jodh v. A.L Pande (1965) 2 S.C.R 713 |
Ordinance provisions confer legal rights on college teachers; not mere contracts. |
Used to establish legal force of university ordinances. |
| M/s. Hindustan Steels Ltd. v. A.K Roy AIR 1970 S.C 1401 |
Industrial adjudication tribunals have discretion on reinstatement vs compensation. |
Clarified judicial discretion in industrial disputes. |