Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 13(2) of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act (for short, the SARFAESI Act)
  • Section 2(d) of the RDB Act and under Section 2(c) of the SARFAESI Act, respectively:RDB Act: Section 2(d): Banks means(i)
  • provisions of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (for short, the B.R Act), the SARFAESI Act, the RDB Act
  • RDB Act and the SARFAESI Act, under Section 2(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act, the Central Government
  • RECOVERY OF DEBTS DUE TO BANKS AND FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS ACT 1993
  • Section 5(cci) and Primary Co-operative Bank in Section 5(ccv) of Section 56
  • SECTION 5 BANKING REGULATION ACT 1949
  • Section 2(e) of RDB Act and Section 2(d) of the SARFAESI Act,
  • Regional Rural Bank;SARFAESI Act: Section 2(c): Banks means(i)
  • provisions of the SARFAESI Act to the Co-operative Bank(s).
  • fact, Rule 8(8) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules,
  • provisions of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act.
  • Security Interest Act, 2002 (the Securitisation Act)41.
  • Security Interest Act, 2002 (the Securitisation Act)
  • Section 5(b), Banking Company under Section 5(c)
  • SECTION 3 COMPANIES ACT 1956
  • Clause (ccv) of Section 5, Primary Co-operative
  • Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002.
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 56 brought Co-operative Banks
  • Section 2(d) of the Securitisation Act
  • Section 2(1)(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act,
  • Section 5(c) of the BR Act by Act 23
  • Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act.5.
  • Section 5(c) as follows:5.(c) Banking
  • Section 2(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act,
  • Section 5(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act,
  • Clause (a) of Section 56 of B.R Act,
  • Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act
  • Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act,
  • BANKING REGULATION ACT 1949
  • Section 5 of Act 23 of 1965.
  • Section 56, Clauses 5(cci)
  • RDB Act.16. Section 5(c)
  • 16.3.1949 Section 3
  • Section 2(c)(v)
  • Section 56(c)
  • Section 5(d)
  • Section 5(c)
  • Section 2(c)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 13(2) of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act (for short, the SARFAESI Act)
  • Section 2(d) of the RDB Act and under Section 2(c) of the SARFAESI Act, respectively:RDB Act: Section 2(d): Banks means(i)
  • provisions of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (for short, the B.R Act), the SARFAESI Act, the RDB Act
  • RDB Act and the SARFAESI Act, under Section 2(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act, the Central Government
  • RECOVERY OF DEBTS DUE TO BANKS AND FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS ACT 1993
  • Section 5(cci) and Primary Co-operative Bank in Section 5(ccv) of Section 56
  • SECTION 5 BANKING REGULATION ACT 1949
  • Section 2(e) of RDB Act and Section 2(d) of the SARFAESI Act,
  • Regional Rural Bank;SARFAESI Act: Section 2(c): Banks means(i)
  • provisions of the SARFAESI Act to the Co-operative Bank(s).
  • fact, Rule 8(8) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules,
  • provisions of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act.
  • Security Interest Act, 2002 (the Securitisation Act)41.
  • Security Interest Act, 2002 (the Securitisation Act)
  • Section 5(b), Banking Company under Section 5(c)
  • SECTION 3 COMPANIES ACT 1956
  • Clause (ccv) of Section 5, Primary Co-operative
  • Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002.
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 56 brought Co-operative Banks
  • Section 2(d) of the Securitisation Act
  • Section 2(1)(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act,
  • Section 5(c) of the BR Act by Act 23
  • Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act.5.
  • Section 5(c) as follows:5.(c) Banking
  • Section 2(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act,
  • Section 5(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act,
  • Clause (a) of Section 56 of B.R Act,
  • Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act
  • Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act,
  • BANKING REGULATION ACT 1949
  • Section 5 of Act 23 of 1965.
  • Section 56, Clauses 5(cci)
  • RDB Act.16. Section 5(c)
  • 16.3.1949 Section 3
  • Section 2(c)(v)
  • Section 56(c)
  • Section 5(d)
  • Section 5(c)
  • Section 2(c)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Two writ petitions were heard together and decided by a common order. Writ Petition No. 9930 of 2008 (filed under Article 226) was moved by Raj Kumar Khemka (a guarantor) seeking a writ of mandamus forbidding the second respondent from exercising powers under the SARFAESI Act in relation to the loan account of M/s NEPC Agro Foods Limited. Writ Petition No. 23660 of 2008 (also under Article 226) was filed by M/s NEPC Agro Foods Limited seeking a writ of certiorari to quash a letter dated 29.8.2008 and to set aside a sale by private treaty of immovable property at Survey No. 99.A, Thimmapur Village, which the petition alleged was made by the first respondent to the second respondent under Section 13 of the SARFAESI Act without following required procedures.

The lender was Janata Sahakari Bank Limited (a Co-operative Bank registered under the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act). The Bank had earlier initiated proceedings before Co-operative Court No. I, Mumbai; that court dismissed the dispute on 1.3.2006. The Bank appealed to the Co-operative Appellate Tribunal, which allowed the appeal on 18.9.2006 and remitted the matter for fresh trial. Separately, the Bank invoked Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act and, after receiving the borrower's reply/objections dated 18.3.2006 and being unsatisfied, invoked Section 13(4) on 7.9.2006. The borrower filed Securitisation Application (Appeal) S.A. No. 68 of 2008 (originally filed in 2006 but numbered in 2008).

After remand by the Co-operative Appellate Tribunal, a consent award dated 15.2.2007 was passed by the Co-operative Court whereby the borrowers agreed to pay Rs. 15,51,00,000 as full and final settlement within a time. The borrower failed to make full payment, following which the Co-operative Bank proceeded under Section 13 notices and measures under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act.

While W.P. No. 9930 of 2008 was pending, this Court (on 30.9.2008) passed an interim order permitting the respondents to auction-sale mortgaged property but restraining them from confirming any sale or taking possession without the Court's prior permission. Despite these proceedings, the Co-operative Bank sold mortgaged properties at Hyderabad by private treaty, which the borrower challenged as improperly effected without consent and without compliance with the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002; this prompted W.P. No. 23660 of 2008.

Meanwhile S.A. No. 68 of 2008 remained pending before DRT-I, Chennai, and related interlocutory orders had been the subject of earlier Division Bench rulings of this Court. The petitioners sought leave to have contentions reserved for determination before the DRT in S.A. No. 68 of 2008.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the provisions of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 ("SARFAESI Act") apply to a Co-operative Bank.
  2. Whether a sale of secured immovable property by private treaty (rather than public auction/tender) made by the bank without the consent of the borrower/owner and without following the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002 is valid — although the Court indicated this issue need not be determined immediately if the first issue is decided in the affirmative and may be left to the DRT in S.A. No. 68 of 2008.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The SARFAESI Act does not apply to Co-operative Banks; Parliament lacks competence to legislate for Co-operative Societies in a manner that would bring them within the SARFAESI Act.
  • The Central Government’s notification (S.O. 105(E) dated 28.1.2003) specifying "Co-operative Banks" under Section 2(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act is ultra vires and constitutes conditional legislation beyond the central executive's competence, because Co-operative Societies fall under Entry 32 of List II (State List).
  • Sale by private treaty cannot be made except after consent of all parties: Rule 8(8) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002 provides that sale by methods other than public auction or public tender "shall be on such terms as may be settled between the parties in writing."
  • Reliance was placed on Supreme Court observations in Greater Bombay Co-op. Bank Ltd. v. United Yarn Tex (P) Ltd. (2007 (6) SCC 236) to argue that the Parliament cannot include Co-operative Banks within central enactments like SARFAESI in a way that would affect the State subject of co-operatives.

Respondent (Co-operative Bank) Arguments

  • The definition of "Bank" under Section 2(c) of the SARFAESI Act includes an express residuary clause — Section 2(c)(v) — authorising the Central Government to specify by notification any other bank, and the Central Government had validly specified Co-operative Banks by S.O. 105(E), dated 28.1.2003.
  • Accordingly, Co-operative Banks were validly brought within the scope of the SARFAESI Act and may initiate and continue actions under Section 13 of the Act.
  • Reliance was also placed on a Division Bench decision of the Bombay High Court (Aurangabad Bench) in Khaja Industries v. State of Maharashtra (2008 (1) Debts Recovery Tribunal Cases 270 / MANU/MH/0973/2007), though the opinion notes that that decision did not address the issue in proper perspective and was the subject of a Special Leave Petition pending before the Supreme Court with an interim order.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Greater Bombay Co-op. Bank Ltd. v. United Yarn Tex (P) Ltd., 2007 (6) SCC 236 Discussed (i) whether central enactments like the RDB Act apply to Co-operative Banks; (ii) relationship between Banking Regulation Act provisions (including Section 56) and Co-operative Banks; and (iii) constitutional division of legislative competence between Union and State with respect to banks and co-operatives. The Court relied on the Supreme Court's analysis of the BR Act and its treatment of Co-operative Banks, noting that the Supreme Court discussed SARFAESI and had not doubted the validity of Section 2(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act. The present Court used those observations to evaluate whether the Central Government could validly notify Co-operative Banks under SARFAESI and concluded that the notification and Section 2(c)(v) are constitutionally permissible.
R.C. Cooper v. Union of India, 1970 (1) SCC 248 Quoted for constitutional principle distinguishing legislative competence over corporations/banking and co-operative societies; used to show Co-operative Societies are distinct and that Entry 32 List II covers co-operatives. The Court recited the R.C. Cooper passage as part of the Supreme Court's reasoning in Greater Bombay; the citation was used in the discussion of constitutional entries (Entry 32 List II v. Entries 43/45 List I) but did not lead the Court to invalidate Section 2(c)(v) or the notification; rather, the Court balanced the entries and statutory provisions to uphold the central notification.
Khaja Industries v. State of Maharashtra, 2008 (1) Debts Recovery Tribunal Cases 270 (MANU/MH/0973/2007) Relied upon by the respondent as support for the proposition that Co-operative Banks can act under central recovery legislation (as addressed by the Bombay High Court, Aurangabad Bench). The Court observed that this Division Bench judgment did not discuss the issue in its proper perspective, noted that it was challenged before the Supreme Court in a Special Leave Petition with an interim order, and therefore did not treat it as conclusive authority for the present matter.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court identified the principal question as whether the SARFAESI Act applies to Co-operative Banks. It undertook a statutory and constitutional comparison between the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (BR Act), the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 (RDB Act), and the SARFAESI Act.

Key points in the Court's step-by-step analysis:

  1. Definitions and textual comparison: The Court examined Section 5(c) of the BR Act (definition of "Banking Company") and the insertion of separate clauses 5(cci) and 5(ccv) to cover Co-operative Banks and Primary Co-operative Banks. It noted that the BR Act's Section 56 contains modifications to apply regulatory provisions to Co-operative Banks, bringing them under regulatory machinery without altering the definition of "Banking Company" in Section 5(c).
  2. Comparison of definitions across statutes: The Court observed that the RDB Act and SARFAESI Act both adopt the BR Act's meaning of "Banking Company" for certain terms, but the SARFAESI Act's definition of "Banks" in Section 2(c) contains an additional residuary clause (Section 2(c)(v)) empowering the Central Government to specify, by notification, other banks for the purposes of the Act.
  3. Notification and executive power: The Central Government exercised the power under Section 2(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act via S.O. 105(E) dated 28.1.2003, specifying Co-operative Banks (as defined in Clause (cci) of Section 5 of the BR Act) as "Banks" within the meaning of the SARFAESI Act. The Court examined whether that step was constitutionally permissible.
  4. Constitutional allocation of powers: The Court considered the constitutional entries cited by the petitioners (Entry 32, List II — Co-operative Societies) and the Union entries dealing with banking (Entries 43/45, List I). It noted the Supreme Court's observations in Greater Bombay that Co-operative Societies are a distinct category and that Section 56 of the BR Act brought Co-operative Banks within the regulatory framework without changing the definition of "Banking Company."
  5. Precedential treatment: The Court observed that in Greater Bombay the Supreme Court discussed the BR Act, SARFAESI Act and RDB Act, and did not doubt the validity of Section 2(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act. On that basis, and reading the statutes together, the Court concluded that Parliament (and the Central Government via notification) could validly include Co-operative Banks within the class of "Banks" for the purposes of SARFAESI.
  6. Practical and procedural posture: The Court noted that the petitioners had not directly challenged the validity of the provisions (nor the notification) before the DRT, and that S.A. No. 68 of 2008 was pending before DRT-I, Chennai. The Court considered that contentions available to petitioners could be urged in that Section 17 application/appeal.
  7. Disposition of secondary issue: The Court held that the question of validity of a private treaty sale (and compliance with the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002) need not be decided immediately and could be left for the DRT if the primary jurisdictional issue was decided in the affirmative.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The Writ Petitions are dismissed.

The Court held that the respondent Co-operative Bank has jurisdiction to proceed under Section 13 of the SARFAESI Act by virtue of the Central Government notification S.O. 105(E) dated 28.1.2003 read with Section 2(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act. The first (primary) issue — applicability of the SARFAESI Act to Co-operative Banks — was decided in the affirmative.

Implications / Consequences:

  • Direct effect on parties: The Co-operative Bank may continue proceedings under Section 13 of the SARFAESI Act in relation to the borrower's account; the writ petitions seeking to restrain such action were dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
  • Procedural relief preserved for petitioners: The petitioners (borrower/guarantor) were granted liberty to raise the separate issue concerning the validity of the private-treaty sale and compliance with the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002 before the DRT-I, Chennai during the final disposal of S.A. No. 68 of 2008.
  • On broader precedent: The Court's decision rests on statutory construction (the residuary power in Section 2(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act and the executive notification) and on the interpretative discussion in Greater Bombay Co-op. Bank Ltd. v. United Yarn Tex. The opinion does not purport to set out extended, novel principles beyond its statutory and constitutional analysis; it addresses the parties' dispute and leaves the factual and procedural challenge to the sale to the DRT.

This summary is prepared strictly from the content of the provided judgment text. No information beyond what appears in the opinion has been added.

    Raj Kumar Khemka 2. M/S. Nepc Agro Foods Limited, Rep. By Its Director, No. 36, Wallajah Road, Chennai-600 002 Petitioners v. Union Of India, Ministry Of Finance, Rep. By Its Secretary, Department Of Banking, South Block, New Delhi-110 001. 2. Janata Sahakari Bank Ltd., Pune, Rep. By Its Chairman, Arvind Keshav Haladkar, Thorale Bajirao Road, Pune-411 002 3. Janata Sahakari Bank Ltd., 1444, Shukrawar Peth, Thorale Bajirao Road, Pune-411 002. 4. M/S. Kishore Tea, Rep. By Its Partner, Shri Dharamchand Jain, Thorale Bajirao Road, Pune-411 002 S

    Prayer: Writ Petition No. 9930 of 2008 filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, praying for issuance of a Writ of Mandamus, forbearing the second respondent from exercising powers under SARFAESI Act (Act 54 of 2002) insofar as the loan account of NEPC Agro Foods is concerned.

    Writ Petition No. 23660 of 2008 filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, praying for issuance of a Writ of Certiorari, calling for the records of the respondent in letter dated 29.8.2008, quash the same and consequently set aside the sale made by the first respondent to the second respondent in respect of the immovable properties at Survey No. 99.A, Thimmapur Village, Kottur Mandal, Mahboobnagar, Andhra Pradesh, made by private treaty under Section 13 of the SARFAESI Act.

    JUDGMENT

    S.J Mukhopadhaya, J.

    1. These Writ Petitions have been preferred by the borrower/guarantor, raising common question of law, pursuant to common proceedings pending before the Debts Recovery Tribunal (for short, ‘the DRT’)-I, Chennai. Therefore, they were heard together and decided by this common order.

    2. The borrower in these cases is M/s. NEPC Agro Foods Limited (writ petitioner in W.P No23660 of 2008). The lender is M/s. Janata Sahakari Bank Limited (first respondent in W.P No. 23660 of 2008 and second respondent in W.P No. 9930 of 2008) (for short, ‘the Co-operative Bank’), which is registered under the provisions of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act. The petitioner-Raj Kumar Khemka (in W.P No. 9930 of 2008) is the guarantor. The respondent-Co-operative Bank, having given certain credit facilities to the borrower, it initiated proceedings against the borrower before the Co-operative Court No. I, Mumbai and the dispute came to be dismissed by order dated 1.3.2006 Against the said order dated 1.3.2006, the respondent-Co-operative Bank filed an Appeal before the Co-operative Appellate Tribunal, which allowed the case, by order dated 18.9.2006 and remitted the matter for fresh trial to the Co-operative Court No. I.

    3. In the meantime, the respondent-Co-operative Bank invoked the powers under Section 13(2) of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act (for short, ‘the SARFAESI Act’) and after receipt of reply/objections, dated 18.3.2006, submitted by the borrower, being unsatisfied, the respondent-Co-operative Bank invoked Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act on 7.9.2006 Challenging the said proceedings under Section 13(4), the borrower filed Securitisation Application (Appeal) in S.A No. 68 of 2008, which was originally filed in 2006, but got numbered in 2008, in view of the fact that there was some doubt as to whether the Application under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act, was maintainable against a Co-operative Bank.

    4. It appears that after remand by the Co-operative Appellate Tribunal, after issuance of notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act, a consent Award dated 15.2.2007, came to be passed by the Co-operative Court No. I, Mumbai, by which the borrower(s) agreed to pay Rs. 15,51,00,000/- as full and final settlement of all the dues within a time, but in view of the non-payment of the full amount in terms of the said consent Award, the respondent-Co-operative Bank proceeded with, under Section 13(2) notice, followed by the measures taken under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act.

    5. At this stage, one of the guarantors, namely Raj Kumar Khemka filed Writ Petition No. 9930 of 2008 before this Court, forbearing the respondent-Co-operative Bank from exercising the powers under the SARFAESI Act, insofar as the loan account of the borrower-M/s. NEPC Agro Goods is concerned. Initially, no interim order was passed and on 30.9.2008, when the Writ Petition was being heard, this Court passed the following interim order:

    “During the pendency of W.P No. 9930 of 2008, the respondents may auction-sale the mortgaged property(ies) [secured asset(s)], but will not confirm the sale, nor take possession of the same, if not yet taken, without prior permission of the Court.”

    6. While Writ Petition No. 9930 of 2008 was pending, the respondent-Co-operative Tribunal sold the mortgaged property(ies) situated at Hyderabad by a private treaty. It is alleged that the said sale was bad without the consent of the borrower or the owner of the property(ies) and without following the procedures laid down under the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002. The respondent-Co-operative Bank, having intimated the matter relating to the sale of the property(ies) by letter dated 29.8.2008 to the borrower-M/s. NEPC Agro Foods Limited, the second Writ Petition in W.P No. 23660 of 2008 has been preferred by the borrower.

    7. It is informed that Securitisation Application (Appeal) under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act in S.A No. 68 of 2008 is still pending before D.R.T-i, chennai. intiallylly, conditional interim order was passed therein, but the same having been set aside by a Division Bench of this Court in W.P Nos. 35427 of 2007, 5947, 5948 and 6491 of 2008, by common order dated 29.4.2008, on the ground that it was a stereo-typed order, after remand, the DRT-I, Chennai, on hearing the parties, dismissed the Petition for interim relief, on 3.6.2008, against which, Appeal was preferred by the borrower before the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal (for short, ‘the DRAT’), Chennai, in IN. No. 489 of 2008. It is argued that in view of the fact that S.A No. 68 of 2008 is still pending before the DRT-I, Chennai, all the contentions available to the petitioners in both the Writ Petitions, may be left open to be urged in the Appeal (Application) under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act, in S.A No. 68 of 2008.

    8. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the writ petitioners (borrower-guarantor) made the following submissions:

    (i) The provisions of the SARFAESI Act do not apply to a Co-operative Bank.

    (ii) Sale by a private treaty cannot be made except after the consent of all the parties. In fact, Rule 8(8) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, reads as follows:

    “Rule 8: Sale of immovable secured assets.—

    (8) Sale by any methods other than public auction or public tender, shall be on such terms as may be settled between the parties in writing.”

    In regard to the first contention, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners relied on the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Greater Bombay Co-op. Bank Ltd. v. United Yarn Tex (P) Ltd., 2007 (6) SCC 236; that was a case where two questions were framed by the Supreme Court at paragraph 69, one relating to “interpretation clause”, viz., whether the RDB Act (i.e Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993) applies to debts due to Co-operative Banks constituted under the MCS Act, 1960 (i.e Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act), the MSCS Act, 2002 (i.e Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002) and the APCS Act, 1964 (i.e Andhra Pradesh Co-operative Societies Act) ? and the other relating to “Constitutional clause”, viz., whether the State Legislature is competent to enact legislation in respect of Co-operative Societies incidentally transacting business of banking in the light of Entry 32, List II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution ? Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners also placed reliance on paragraph 89 of the said judgment of the Supreme Court Greater Bombay Co-op. Bank Ltd. v. United Yarn Tex (P) Ltd., 2007 (6) SCC 236, which reads as follows:

    “89. In R.C Cooper v. Union of India, 1970 (1) SCC 248, this Court observed that power to legislate for setting up corporations to carry on banking and other business and to acquire, hold and dispose of property and to provide for administration of the corporations is conferred upon Parliament by Entries 43, 44 and 45 of the Constitution. Therefore, the express exclusion of Co-operative Societies in Entry 43 of List I and the express inclusion of Co-operative Societies in Entry 32 of List II separately and apart from but along with corporations other than those specified in List I and universities, clearly indicated that the constitutional scheme was designed to treat Co-operative Societies as institutions distinct from corporations. Co-operative Societies, incorporation, regulation and winding up are State subjects in the ambit of Entry 32 of List II of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution of India. Cooperatives form a specie of genus “Corporation” and as such Co-operative Societies with objects not confined to one State are read in with the Union List as provided in Entry 44 of List I of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution; the MSCS Act, 2002 governs such multi-State co-operatives. Hence, the Co-operative Banks performing functions for the public with a limited commercial function as opposed to corporate banks cannot be covered by Entry 45 of List I dealing with “banking”. The subject of Co-operative Societies is not included in the Union List rather it is covered under Entry 32 of List II of the Seventh Schedule appended to the Constitution.”

    Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners further submitted that in the light of the above observations of the Supreme Court, the Parliament cannot enact law relating to “Co-operative Societies” and therefore, the provisions of the SARFAESI Act cannot cover the “Co-operative Banks” and cannot provide for a procedure for recovery of debts by a Co-operative Bank. In other words, this power to regulate the Co-operative Societies including the Co-operative Banks, and providing for a procedure for recovery of a debt by a Co-operative Bank, cannot be the subject matter of a Central enactment. Consequently, the provisions of the SARFAESI Act could be read in the manner that it would exclude its applicability to Co-operative Banks. This alone makes the SARFAESI Act “constitutional” insofar as it relates to the Co-operative Banks.

    9. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent-Co-operative Bank placed reliance on the definition of the ‘Bank’ in Section 2(1)(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act, which gives power to the Central Government to specify any other Bank by the Notification for the purpose of the Act (SARFAESI Act). In fact, by the Notification in S.O 105(E), dated 28.1.2003, the Central Government has specified the “Co-operative Banks” as the ‘Banks’ for the purposes of the SARFAESI Act. It was further submitted by the learned counsel appearing for the respondent-Co-operative Bank that the said Notification under Section 2(1)(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act having been issued on 28.1.2003, the ‘Co-operative Banks’ can also take action under the provisions of the SARFAESI Act.

    10. In reply, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners submitted that if the Parliament itself cannot ‘legislate’ on the Co-operative Societies, including the Co-operative Banks, then the Central Government could not also issue the Notification extending the provisions of the SARFAESI Act to the Co-operative Bank(s). The said Notification dated 28.1.2003 being an example of conditional legislation, is beyond the jurisdiction of the Central Government. In view of this matter, according to the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners, neither the said Notification, dated 28.1.2003, nor the definition of the “bank” as contained in Section 2(1)(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act, would be of any use to the respondent-Co-operative Bank.

    11. Learned counsel appearing for the respondent-Co-operative Bank placed reliance on a decision of a Division Bench of the Bombay High Court (Aurangabad Bench) in the case of Khaja Industries v. State of Maharashtra, 2008 (1) Debts Recovery Tribunal Cases 270: MANU/MH/0973/2007 (W.P Nos. 2672 of 2007, etc., dated 3.7.2007), however, such judgment does not discuss the issue in its proper perspective and the judgment of the Bombay High Court is stated to have been challenged before the Supreme Court in Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 17573 of 2007, and interim order has also been granted by the Apex Court on 7.1.2008

    12. The main issue that requires for determination in the present Writ Petitions, is as to “whether the provisions of the SARFAESI Act, would apply to a Co-operative Bank”.

    13. The other issue relating to the sale by a private treaty without the consent of all the parties, may not be required to be determined at this stage, which may be determined by the DRT-I, Chennai, in S.A No. 68 of 2008, if the first issue is decided by this Court in the affirmative.

    14. Almost similar issue fell for consideration before the Supreme Court in the case of Greater Bombay Co-op. Bank Ltd. v. United Yarn Tex (P) Ltd., 2007 (6) SCC 236, but that was a case in which action was taken by a Co-operative Bank under the provisions of the RDB Act and not under the provisions of the SARFAESI Act. However, while dealing with the matter, the Supreme Court discussed the relevant provisions of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (for short, ‘the B.R Act’), the SARFAESI Act, the RDB Act and other Acts.

    15. Before discussing the observations and the findings of the Supreme Court in the said case of Greater Bombay Co-op. Bank Ltd. v. United Yarn Tex (P) Ltd., 2007 (6) SCC 236, it is relevant to notice and quote certain provisions of the Banking Act and the SARFAESI Act, for comparison of the same with the RDB Act.

    16. Section 5(c) of the B.R Act defines ‘Banking Company’, which reads hereunder:

    “5(c)‘Banking Company’ means any Company which transacts the business of banking in India;”

    Subsequently, instead of amending the original Clause (c) of Section 5 of the B.R Act, a separate Clause (cci) was added in Section 5 to cover the Co-operative Bank, to mean “a State Co-operative Bank, a Central Co-operative Bank and a Primary Co-operative Bank”. In the introduced Clause (ccv) of Section 5, “Primary Co-operative Bank” means “a co-operative society, other than a primary agricultural credit society”. The above said Clauses 5(cci) and (ccv) were noticed by the Supreme Court in the said decision 2007 (6) SCC 236, in the case of Greater Bombay Co-op. Bank Ltd., wherein the Apex Court observed that the primary object or the principal business of the “Co-operative Bank” should be the transaction of banking business.

    17. There is no definition of “bank” under the B.R Act, though it defines the ‘banking’ under Section 5(b), ‘Banking Company’ under Section 5(c) and ‘Banking Policy’ under Section 5(ca).

    ‘Banking Company’ has also been defined under Section 2(e) of RDB Act and Section 2(d) of the SARFAESI Act, as per which, the ‘Banking Company’ shall have the meaning assigned to it in Clause (c) of Section 5 of the B.R Act.

    On the other hand, though the ‘bank’ has not been defined under the provisions of the B.R Act, the following definition of ‘the Bank’ has been shown under Section 2(d) of the RDB Act and under Section 2(c) of the SARFAESI Act, respectively:

    “RDB Act: Section 2(d): “Banks” means—

    (i) a Banking Company;

    (ii) a corresponding new Bank;

    (iii) State Bank of India;

    (iv) a Subsidiary Bank; or

    (v) a Regional Rural Bank;”

    “SARFAESI Act: Section 2(c): “Banks” means—

    (i) a Banking Company; or

    (ii) a corresponding new Bank; or

    (iii) the State Bank of India; or

    (iv) a Subsidiary Bank; or

    (v) such other Bank which the Central Government may, by notification,* specify for the purposes of this Act;”

    *(The Central Government has specified “Co-operative Banks” as defined in Clause (cci) of Section 5 of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (10 of 1949) as “Bank”, vide S.O 105(E), dated 28.1.2003, published in the Gazette of India, Ext., Pt.II, S. 3(ii), dated 28.1.2003).”

    There is a distinction in the definition of the ‘Bank’ as shown in the RDB Act and the SARFAESI Act. While the first four clauses of the definition of the ‘Bank’ i.e (i) a Banking Company, (ii) a corresponding new Bank, (iii) State Bank of India, and (iv) a Subsidiary Bank, are common in both the RDB Act and the SARFAESI Act, under Section 2(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act, the Central Government had been empowered to notify such other Bank for the purposes of the Act, and those provisions are absent in the RDB Act.

    18. We have taken into consideration the aforesaid provisions as in the case of Greater Bombay Co-op. Bank Ltd. v. United Yarn Tex (P) Ltd., 2007 (6) SCC 236, while deciding the question of the applicability of the provisions of the RDB Act in regard to the Co-operative Societies, though the Supreme Court has not decided the question of the applicability of the provisions of the SARFAESI Act in regard to the Co-operative Societies/Banks, it discussed the relevant provisions of the B.R Act vis-a-vis SARFAESI Act.

    19. The relevant provisions of Section 5(cci) and 5(ccv) of the B.R Act, as also the Notification contained in S.O No. 105(E), dated 28.1.2003 issued by the Central Government in exercise of the powers conferred under Section 5(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act, were noticed, but the question of validity of Section 5(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act has not been doubted by the Supreme Court in the said case (2007 (6) SCC 236). For this purpose, it is necessary to quote relevant observations of the Supreme Court in the said case, as hereunder:

    “The Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (the BR Act)

    37. This Act was brought into force on 16.3.1949 Section 3 of the BR Act clearly provides that the Act would apply to cooperative societies in certain cases, subject to the provisions of Part V of the Act. The BR Act defines “Banking Company” under Section 5(c) as follows:

    “5.(c) ‘Banking Company’ means any Company which transacts the business of banking in India;”

    38. In Section 5(d) “Company” means any Company as defined in Section 3 of the Companies Act, 1956 (1 of 1956) and includes a Foreign Company within the meaning of Section 591 of that Act.

    39. Chapter V of the BR Act was inserted by Act 23 of 1965 w.e.f 1.3.1966 Section 56 of the Act provides that the provisions of this Act, as in force for the time being, shall apply to, or in relation to, Banking Companies subject to the following modifications, namely:

    “56.(a) throughout this Act, unless the context otherwise, requires,—

    (i) references to a ‘Banking Company’ or ‘the Company’ or ‘such Company’ shall be construed as references to a Co-operative Bank;

    (ii) … … …”

    The purpose and object of modifications were to regulate the functioning of the Co-operative Banks in the matter of their business in banking. The provisions of Section 56 itself start with the usual phrase “unless the context otherwise requires” is to make the regulatory machinery provided by the BR Act to apply to Co-operative Banks also. The object was not to define a Co-operative Bank to mean a Banking Company, in terms of Section 5(c) of the BR Act. This is apparent from the fact that instead of amending the original clause (c) of Section 5 separate clause (cci) was added to cover the “Co-operative Bank” to mean “a State Co-operative Bank, a Central Co-operative Bank and a primary Co-operative Bank”. In clause (ccv) “primary Co-operative Bank” means “a Co-operative Society, other than a primary agricultural credit society”. The primary object or principal business of the “Co-operative Bank” should be the transaction of banking business.

    40. The modifications given in clause (a) of Section 56 are apparently suitable to make the regulatory machinery provided by the BR Act to apply to Co-operative Banks also in the process of bringing the Co-operative Banks under the discipline of Reserve Bank of India and other authorities. A Co-operative Bank shall be construed as a Banking Company in terms of Section 56 of the Act. This is because the various provisions for regulating the Banking Companies were to be made applicable to Co-operative Banks also. Accordingly, Section 56 brought Co-operative Banks within the machinery of the BR Act but did not amend or expand the meaning of “Banking Company” under Section 5(c). On a plain reading of every clause of Section 56 of the BR Act, it becomes clear that what is contained therein is only for the purpose of application of provisions that regulate banking companies to Co-operative Societies. According to the expression “Co-operative Societies” used in Section 56 means a “Co-operative Society”, the primary object or principal business of which is the transaction of banking business. In other words, first it is a Co-operative Society, but carrying on banking business having the specified paid-up share capital. Other definitions also make it clear that the entities are basically Co-operative Societies.

    The Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (the Securitisation Act)

    41. Parliament had enacted the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (“the Securitisation Act”) which shall be deemed to have come into force on 21.6.2002 In Section 2(d) of the Securitisation Act same meaning is given to the words “Banking Company” as is assigned to it in Clause (e) of Section 5 of the BR Act. Again the definition of “Banking Company” was lifted from the BR Act but while defining “Bank”, Parliament gave five meanings to it under Section 2(c) and one of which is “Banking Company”. The Central Government is authorised by Section 2(c)(v) of the Act to specify any other bank for the purpose of the Act. In exercise of this power, the Central Government by notification dated 28.1.2003, has specified “Co-operative Bank” as defined in Section 5(cci) of the BR Act as a “bank” by lifting the definition of “Co-operative Bank” and “primary Co-operative Bank” respectively from Section 56, Clauses 5(cci) and (ccv) of Part V. Parliament has thus consistently made the meaning of “Banking Company” clear beyond doubt to mean “a Company engaged in banking, and not a Co-operative Society engaged in banking” and in Act 23 of 1965, while amending the BR Act, it did not change the definition in Section 5(c) or even in Section 5(d) to include Co-operative Banks; on the other hand, it added a separate definition of “Co-operative Bank” in Section 5(cci) and “Primary Co-operative Bank” in Section 5(ccv) of Section 56 of Part V of the BR Act. Parliament while enacting the Securitisation Act created a residuary power in Section 2(c)(v) to specify any other bank as a bank for the purpose of that Act and in fact did specify “Co-operative Banks” by notification dated 28.1.2003

    42. The context of the interpretation clause plainly excludes the effect of a reference to Banking Company being construed as reference to a Co-operative Bank for three reasons: firstly, Section 5 is an interpretation clause; secondly, substitution of “Co-operative Bank” for “Banking Company” in the definition in Section 5(c) would result in an absurdity because then Section 5(c) would read thus: “Co-operative Bank” means any company, which transacts the business of banking in India; thirdly, Section 56(c) does define “Co-operative Bank” separately by expressly deleting/inserting clause (cci) in Section 5. Parliament in its wisdom had not altered or modified the definition of “Banking Company” in Section 5(c) of the BR Act by Act 23 of 1965.

    43. As noticed above, “Co-operative Bank” was separately defined by the newly inserted Clause (cci) and “Primary Co-operative Bank” was similarly separately defined by Clause (ccv). The meaning of “Banking Company” must, therefore, necessarily be strictly confined to the words used in Section 5(c) of the BR Act. If the intention of Parliament was to define the “Co-operative Bank” as “Banking Company”, it would have been the easiest way for Parliament to say that “Banking Company” shall mean “Banking Company” as defined in Section 5(c) and shall include “Co-operative Bank” and “primary Co-operative Bank” as inserted in Clauses (cci) and (ccv) in Section 5 of Act 23 of 1965.

    20. From the aforesaid findings of the Supreme Court (at paragraph 40), it will be evident that the modifications given in Clause (a) of Section 56 of B.R Act, are to make regulatory measures provided by the B.R Act to apply to Co-operative Banks also, in bringing the Co-operative Banks under the discipline of the Reserve Bank of India and other authorities. A Co-operative Bank shall be construed as a ‘Banking Company’ in terms of Section 56 of the B.R Act. This is because, the various provisions of regulating banking business were to be made applicable to Co-operative Banks also.

    As per the said Section 56 of the B.R Act, though it may not be bring the Co-operative Banks within the meaning of the ‘Banking Company’, but that does not preclude the Central Government to bring a Co-operative Bank under the definition of “banking” as distinct from the ‘Banking Company’.

    21. Under Entry 32 of List II (State List) of Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India, though the “State” has been empowered with regard to “Co-operative Societies”, but under Entry 43 read with Entry 45 of List I (Union List) of Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India, the Central Government has the power of regulation in making laws with regard to “banking”, distinct from “banking business”. Therefore, it cannot be asserted that the Central Government had no power to introduce Section 2(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act, nor the Notification contained in S.O No. 105(E), dated 28.1.2003, can be held to be unconstitutional.

    We accordingly hold that ‘the respondent-Co-operative Bank’ has jurisdiction to proceed under Section 13 of the SARFAESI Act, in view of Notification in S.O No. 105(E), dated 28.1.2003, read with Section 2(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act and the first issue is decided accordingly.

    22. Apart from the aforesaid facts, it is not in dispute that the petitioners have not challenged the validity of any of the aforesaid provisions; it is the borrower-guarantor who have submitted before the DRT having moved in Appeal (Application) under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act, therefore, they cannot challenge the jurisdiction of the DRT.

    23. We find no merits in either of the Writ Petitions, which are accordingly dismissed, but in the facts and circumstances of the cases, there shall be no order as to costs, but give liberty to the petitioners-borrower/guarantor to raise the second issue relating to sale by a private treaty before the DRT-I, Chennai at the time of final disposal of the Appeal (Application) under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Raj Kumar Khemka 2. ... v. Union Of India, Mini...
    (Dec 8, 2008)