Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This Civil Revision Petition was filed by the petitioner/plaintiff seeking to set aside the order dated 11.03.2008 passed in I.A No. 79 of 2008 in O.S No. 81 of 2007 before the Additional District Court (F.T.C), Erode. The underlying suit (O.S No. 81 of 2007) was initiated by the petitioner/plaintiff for recovery of Rs. 6,46,000/- with interest, based on a promissory note. The respondent/defendant contested the suit and filed a written statement.

During the pendency of the suit, the respondent/defendant filed an application (I.A No. 656 of 2007) to send disputed documents to the Forensic Science Department at Chennai to determine the age of the ink on the promissory note. This application was withdrawn as not pressed on 11.01.2008. Subsequently, the respondent/defendant filed another application (I.A No. 79 of 2008) under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act to send the original promissory note to the Director of Forensic Science at Hyderabad for expert examination of the ink's age. The Trial Court allowed this application and appointed an Advocate Commissioner. The petitioner/plaintiff challenged this order by filing the present Civil Revision Petition.

The Court granted interim stay on 01.07.2008 and heard the parties' counsel before delivering the judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Trial Court erred in allowing the respondent/defendant’s application to send the original promissory note for forensic examination to ascertain the age of the ink under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act?
  2. Whether the withdrawal of the earlier similar application without liberty to refile affects the maintainability of the subsequent application?
  3. Whether expert opinion on the age of ink on the promissory note would be useful or only create confusion in adjudicating the dispute?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The Trial Court misdirected itself in allowing the application to send the promissory note for forensic examination of the ink’s age.
  • The respondent/defendant had earlier withdrawn a similar application without liberty to refile, and the Trial Court failed to consider this fact, vitiating the order.
  • The Court’s earlier judgment in S. Gopal v. D. Balachandran, 2008 (1) CTC 491, held that determining the age of ink does not resolve controversy but creates confusion, hence no useful purpose would be served by such forensic examination.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The earlier application was withdrawn because the Forensic Science Department did not have the required facility at that time.
  • Upon learning that the facility was now available at the Hyderabad office, the respondent filed the present application legitimately.
  • Though expert opinion on ink age is a weak piece of evidence, it may still benefit the defendant in establishing their case.
  • The Trial Court properly considered the facts and law in allowing the application, and this Court should not interfere.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S. Gopal v. D. Balachandran, 2008 (1) CTC 491 Expert opinion on the age of ink does not resolve controversy but creates confusion and is of limited evidentiary value. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that sending the promissory note for forensic examination of ink age would not serve any useful purpose and would only create confusion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the nature of the suit, which is for recovery of money based on a promissory note. It emphasized that it is the plaintiff’s burden to establish the authenticity and execution of the promissory note by the defendant. The defendant is not obligated to disprove the plaintiff’s case.

Relying on the precedent in S. Gopal v. D. Balachandran, the Court observed that forensic examination to determine the age of the ink on the promissory note would not clarify the controversy but rather create confusion. The Court also noted that the earlier similar application by the defendant was withdrawn without liberty to refile, and this procedural fact was not considered by the Trial Court.

Consequently, the Court found the Trial Court’s order allowing the forensic examination to be erroneous and liable to be set aside.

Holding and Implications

The Civil Revision Petition is ALLOWED. The order dated 11.03.2008 passed by the Trial Court allowing the application to send the promissory note for forensic examination of the ink’s age is set aside.

The direct effect is that the forensic examination as permitted by the Trial Court will not proceed. No new precedent has been established, and the decision primarily affects the parties by restoring the status quo ante. The related Miscellaneous Petition (M.P No. 1 of 2008) is also closed. No costs are imposed.

    Sundaramoorthy Petitioner v. R. Palanisamy

    1. This Civil Revision Petition has been filed by the petitioner/plaintiff to set aside the order dated 11.03.2008 passed in I.A No. 79 of 2008 in O.S No. 81 of 2007 on the file of Additional District Court (F.T.C), Erode.

    2. The plaintiff in O.S No. 81 of 2007 is the revision petitioner before this Court. The Suit in O.S No. 81 of 2007 was filed by the petitioner/plaintiff for recovery of money for a sum of Rs. 6,46,000/- with interest. Written statement has been filed by the respondent/defendant and the Suit is being contested. Pending Suit an Application in I.A No. 656 of 2007 was filed by the respondent/defendant to send the disputed documents to Forensic Science Department at Chennai to ascertain the age of the ink found in the disputed promissory note. However, the said Application was withdrawn as not pressed by the respondent/defendant on 11.01.2008 Thereafter, an Application in I.A No. 79 of 2008 was filed by the very same respondent/defendant under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act to send the suit promissory note to find out the age of the ink, through a Commissioner to be appointed in the above matter to hand over the original suit promissory note to the Director of Forensic Science, Government of India, attached to the office of the Government Examiner of questioned Documents, CFI Complex, Ramanathpur, Hyderabad-13 and get back the said original suit promissory note after getting the Expert's opinion. The said Application was resisted by the petitioner/plaintiff by filing a counter. The Trial Court by order dated 11.03.2008 allowed the Application and appointed an Advocate Commissioner. Aggrieved by the same, the above Civil Revision Petition has been filed by the Plaintiff.

    3. This Court on 01.07.2008 ordered notice and granted interim stay. The respondent/defendant has entered appearance through counsel.

    4. I have heard the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner as well as the learned counsel appearing for the respondent and I have also gone through the documents filed in support of their submissions.

    5. The learned counsel for the petitioner/plaintiff would submit that the Trial Court has mis-directed itself in allowing the Application for sending the original promissory note to find out the age of the ink of the writings and the signature found in the promissory note. According to him, a similar Application filed by the respondent/defendant earlier was withdrawn as not pressed by the respondent/defendant during January, 2008 without obtaining liberty to file another Petition and thereafter for the very same purpose, the present Application in I.A No. 79 of 2008 was filed by the respondent/defendant, and the same has been allowed. Therefore, he adds that the failure on part of the Trial Court to take note of this fact, which was withdrawn as not pressed by the respondent/defendant vitiates the order and the order is hence bad. The learned counsel for the petitioner would further submit on merits that this Court in earlier judgment in S. Gopal v. D. Balachandran, 2008 (1) CTC 491, has been observed that “the age of the ink cannot be determined, on the basis of the writing the ink in dispute was manufactured five years prior to the date of execution of the document and used effectively on a particular dated for the first time and an experts opinion as age of ink will not resolve any controversy, but it will help to create only confusion.” Therefore, according to the learned counsel for the petitioner that no useful purpose would be served by sending the promissory note to ascertain the age of the ink.

    6. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent would submit that the earlier Application was withdrawn only on the ground that there was no facility available with the Forensic Department at that point of time. But, thereafter, on coming to know of the availability of the facility to ascertain the age of the ink, in the Office of the Forensic Department at Hyderabad, the present Application in I.A No. 79 of 2008 was filed. Therefore, withdrawal of a similar Application filed earlier, cannot be put against the respondent/defendant. The learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that though such opinion from an expert is a weak piece of evidence, still, it will have some benefit to the defendant in establishing the case of the defendant. Therefore, according to him, the Trial Court, in due consideration of the facts and law has allowed the Application and the same does not require any interference by this Court. Hence, he prays for dismissal of the Civil Revision Petition.

    7. I have heard the rival submissions carefully.

    8. I am unable to accept the submissions made by the learned counsel for the respondent/defendant. In a case of this nature, where the Suit has been filed by the petitioner/plaintiff for recovery of money on the basis of promissory note, it is for the plaintiff to establish his case that the promissory note, out of which the amount is due, is executed by the respondent/defendant. The defendant need not take any steps to disprove the case of the plaintiff. In my view, no useful purpose would be served by sending the pronote to ascertain the age of the ink. As rightly held by this Court earlier, in the judgment cited supra, sending a document to an expert to ascertain the age of the ink would only create more confusion. Further, as rightly contended by the learned counsel for the petitioner, no liberty was obtained when the earlier Application filed for the very same relief was withdrawn by the defendant.

    9. Therefore, the order of the Trial Court is liable to be set aside. Accordingly, the Civil Revision Petition is allowed and the order passed by the Trial Court is set aside.

    10. In the result, the Civil Revision Petition is allowed. No costs. Consequently, connected M.P No. 1 of 2008 is closed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sundaramoorthy Petitioner v. R. Palanisamy
    (Nov 24, 2008)