In this petition, petitioner seeks a direction to the respondents to
grant 12% interest for the delayed payment of retirement benefits viz.,
Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity, commuted value of pension and arrears of
pension from 31.3.1992 till 6.8.2002.
2. The necessary facts for disposal of this writ petition are as
follows,
(a) The petitioner retired as a Block Development Officer on
31.3.19 92 on attaining the age of superannuation. On the date of retirement,
he was working at the Polur Panchayat Union, Tiruvannamalai District. On
28.12.1991, the District Collector, Tiruvannamalai/second respondent herein
framed certain charges against the petitioner under Rule 17(b) of Tamil Nadu
Civil Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, relating to the discharge of
petitioner's duty while he was working as Block Development Officer,
Thurinjapuram Panchayat Union. The Charge mainly deals with non-entry of
26.680 MT of rice in the stock register, causing loss to the Government to the
tune of Rs.53,138/-. Consequential charge was also framed for non-appointment
of Manager ( RLEGP), when the then manager Venkatasubramaniam was on medical
leave, to hold additional charges, thus giving opportunity for non-entry of
the incoming rice stocks in the stock register. On 21.1.1992, petitioner
submitted his explanations denying the charges levelled against him.
(b) The District Collector, Tiruvannamalai/second respondent
appointed the District Town Panchayat Officer, Tiruvannamalai as Enquiry
Officer, who conducted enquiry and submitted his report on 10.2.1992. As the
petitioner's date of retirement fell on 31.3.1992, the Director of Rural
Development, by his order dated 26.3.1992, permitted the petitioner to retire
from services on 31.3.1992, but without prejudice to the disciplinary
proceedings initiated against him under the charge memo dated 28.12.1992.
Accordingly the petitioner retired on 31 .3.1992.
(c) On 23.5.1992, the Principal Accountant General, Tamil Nadu
sanctioned Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity of Rs.42,884/- and commuted value of
1/3rd pension of Rs.54,225/-, but however, with a direction to disburse the
said amounts after finalisation of the disciplinary proceedings.
(d) The disciplinary proceeding was kept pending for more than
seven years and on 7.12.1999, the Secretary to Rural Development
Department/the first respondent herein furnished a copy of the enquiry report
to the petitioner and asked for his written representation, which the
petitioner offered on 8.1.1999. On 14.7.2000, the first respondent issued a
show cause notice conveying the provisional conclusion to the effect of
reduction of Rs.100/- per month for a period of three years from the pension
payable to the petitioner, besides recovering a sum of Rs.1,32,585/- from the
retirement benefits. On 13.8.2000, the petitioner replied that the
provisional conclusion arrived at to recover a sum of Rs.1,32,585/- is
excessive since the actual loss is only to the tune of Rs.53,138/-, even as
per the charge memo. Thereafter petitioner received another letter dated
14.7.2000 asking him to show cause against the provisional conclusion to the
effect of reduction of Rs.100/- per month for a period of three years from the
pension payable to the petitioner, besides recovering a sum of Rs.13,285/-
from DCRG. For the said show cause notice, petitioner sent his reply on
18.10.2000 stating that the provisional conclusion amounts to imposing double
punishment inasmuch as there is a cut in pension, as well as recovery of a sum
of Rs.13,285/-. Subsequently, on 12.12.2000, the first respondent issued
another letter asking the petitioner to state as to whether he admits the
proposed penalty or to offer his reply. For that letter also petitioner sent
a reply on 8.1.2001 stating that the provisional conclusion arrived at amounts
to double punishment and expressed his willingness to pay a sum of
Rs.13,285/-.
(e) It is the case of the petitioner that in spite of the above
replies sent by him, the respondents have not concluded the disciplinary
proceeding and hence he filed O.A.No.519 of 2002 before the Tamil Nadu
Administrative Tribunal with a prayer to direct the respondents to conclude
the disciplinary proceedings initiated against him under charge memo dated
28.12.1991. The Tribunal by order dated 9.2.2002 directed the respondents to
pass final orders in the disciplinary proceedings within one month from the
date of receipt of copy of that order. As the said order was not complied
with, petitioner filed Contempt Application No.193 of 2002, and during
pendency of the said contempt application, first respondent passed an order
imposing punishment of reduction of Rs.100/- per month for a period of three
years from the pension payable to the petitioner, besides recovery of
Rs.13,285/- from the DCRG payable to the petitioner, to make good the loss
caused to the Government.
(f) It is further stated in the petition that the petitioner
attained the age of superannuation as early as on 31.3.1992, but in the
disciplinary proceedings initiated against him on 28.12.1991, though enquiry
was completed and enquiry report was submitted on 10.2.1992 to the
disciplinary authority, much prior to the date of retirement, for no fault of
the petitioner, the proceeding was kept pending for more than ten years and
only after filing contempt application for the disobedience of the direction
of the Tamil Nadu Administrative Tribunal dated 9.2.2002 in O.A.No.519 of
2002, final orders were passed in the disciplinary proceeding. In these
circumstances, petitioner prays for grant of 12% interest for the delayed
payment of retirement benefits from 31.3.2002 to 6.8.2002.
3. In the counter affidavit filed by the respondents it is stated
that though the Accountant General, Chennai had sanctioned pension,
Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity, etc., in the release order it is mentioned that
the amount will be disbursed only after the finalisation of the disciplinary
proceedings and therefore it cannot be termed as delayed payment as the same
was held up only due to the pendency of the disciplinary proceedings. It is
further stated that under the Tamil Nadu Pension Rules, no interest shall be
payable in cases where the delay in the payment of Death-cum-Retirement
Gratuity is due to the institution of departmental or judicial proceedings
against the Government servant concerned. Hence the petitioner is not
entitled to claim interest for the delayed payment of Death-cum-Retirement
Gratuity amount.
4. The learned counsel for the petitioner argued that in the
normal course, the Government is bound to settle the retirement benefits to
its employees immediately after the retirement, and if any disciplinary
proceeding is pending, the Government is empowered to withhold the retirement
benefits, but in the instant case, though the enquiry was over as early as on
10.2.1992 well before the date of superannuation of the petitioner, the
retirement benefits were disbursed to the petitioner only on 6.8.2002 after
the final order was passed belatedly, and hence the undue delay in disbursing
the retirement benefits caused irreparable loss, mental agony and financial
loss to the petitioner. Hence, according to the learned counsel, the
petitioner is entitled to interest for the delayed payment of DCRG, commuted
value of pension and arrears of pension from 31.3.1992 to 6.8.2002.
5. I have considered the rival submissions made by the learned
counsels on either side, in the light of the averments made in the affidavit
as well as counter affidavit. There is no explanation on the part of the
respondents for the undue delay of ten years in passing final orders, that too
after submission of enquiry report as early as on 1 0.2.1992.
6. The Honourable Supreme Court in its very recent decision
reported in 2006(1) Law Weekly 157 (P.V.Mahadevan v. M.D., Tamil Nadu Housing
Board) dealt with the issue relating to the delay in initiation of
disciplinary proceeding. In paragraph 16 of the Judgment the Apex Court held
thus,
Under the circumstances, we are of the opinion that allowing the
respondent to proceed further with the departmental proceedings at this
distance of time will be very prejudicial to the appellant. Keeping a higher
Government official under charges of corruption and disputed integrity would
cause unbearable mental agony and distress to the officer concerned. The
protracted disciplinary enquiry against a Government employee should,
therefore, be avoided not only in the interests of the Government employee but
in public interest and also in the interests of inspiring confidence in the
minds of the Government employees. At this stage, it is necessary to draw the
curtain and to put an end to the enquiry. The appellant had already suffered
enough and more on account of the disciplinary proceedings. As a matter of
fact, the mental agony and sufferings of the appellant due to the protracted
disciplinary proceedings would be much more than the punishment. For the
mistakes committed by the department in the procedure for initiating the
disciplinary proceedings, the appellant should not be made to suffer.
In the case on hand, even though there was no delay in initiating the
disciplinary proceedings against the petitioner, admittedly there is an undue
delay in completing the disciplinary proceedings, that too after submission of
enquiry report as early as on 10.2.1992. Had the final orders been passed
immediately or within a reasonable time, the petitioner would have got his
retirement benefits 10 years earlier.
7. In yet another earlier decision reported in (1974) 4 SCC 308 (
State of Mysore v. C.R.Sheshadri), the Honourable Supreme Court, in paragraph
8 held that a retired government official is sensitive to delay in drawing
monetary benefits and to avoid posthumous satisfaction of the pecuniary
expectation of the superannuated public servant not unusual in government
we direct the appellant to consider promptly the claim of the petitioner in
the light of our directions and make payment of what is his due if so found
on or before April 15, 1974 . The Apex Court in paragraph 7 of the Judgment
agreed with the findings of the High Court, which reads as under,
While we agree that the High Court has been impelled by a right
judicial instinct to undo injustice to an individual, we feel that a finer
perception of the limits of judicial review would have forbidden it from going
beyond directing the Executive to reconsider and doing it on its own venturing
into an area of surmise and speculation in regard to the possibilities of
escalation in service of the appellant. Judicial expansionism, like allowing
the judicial sword to rust in its armoury where it needs to be used, can upset
the constitutional symmetry and damage the constitutional design of our
founding document.
8. (a) In so far as the award of interest for the belated payment of
retirement benefits is concerned, the Supreme Court in the decision reported
in (1987) 4 SCC 328 (O.P.Gupta v. Union of India), in paragraph 15, after
taking note of the 20 years of protracted departmental enquiry, held as
follows,
... It is clear principle of natural justice that the delinquent
officer when placed under suspension is entitled to represent that the
departmental proceedings should be concluded with reasonable diligence and
within a reasonable period of time. If such a principle were not to be
recognised, it would imply that the executive is being vested with a totally
arbitrary and unfettered power of placing its officers under disability and
distress for an indefinite duration.
In the said case, the Supreme Court awarded 12% interest in favour of the
appellant for the delayed payment of pension.
(b) In the decision reported in (1999)3 SCC 438 (Dr.Uma Agrawal v.
State of U.P.), the Apex Court quantified the interest as Rs.1.00 lakh for the
belated payment of retirement benefits.
(c) In (1985) 1 SCC 429 (State of Kerala v. M.Padmanabhan Nair)
also the Supreme Court endorsed the findings of the High Court in payment of
interest for the belated settlement of retirement benefits. Further, in
paragraph 5 of the judgment, the Court observed thus,
We are also of the view that the State Government is being rightly
saddled with a liability for the culpable neglect in the discharge of his duty
by the District Treasury Officer who delayed the issuance of the L.P.C., but
since the concerned officer had not been impleaded as a party defendant to the
suit the Court is unable to hold him liable for the decretal amount. It will,
however, be for the State Government to consider whether the erring official
should or should not be directed to compensate the Government the loss
sustained by it by his culpable lapses. Such action if taken would help
generate in the officials of the State Government a sense of duty towards the
Government under whom they serve as also a sense of accountability to members
of the public.
9. In this case, petitioner's contentions in respect of the
belated settlement of retirement benefits, are well founded. As observed
earlier, the enquiry report having been filed as early as on 10.2.1992, there
is no justification on the part of the respondents to delay the said
proceedings for over ten years. Hence I hold that the petitioner is entitled
to interest as claimed in the petition. But, the petitioner has not made any
demand to that effect. It is well settled in law that no mandamus can be
issued without a demand being made before the appropriate authority. However,
in the interest of justice, the petitioner is given four weeks time from the
date of receipt of copy of this order to make proper representation/demand
before the first respondent herein, claiming interest for the belated
settlement of retirement benefits and on such representation being made, the
first respondent is directed to dispose of the same within a period of four
weeks therefrom. The interest amount that is to be paid to the petitioner
shall be recovered from the concerned Officers, who were responsible for
causing such an undue delay of over ten years in finalising the disciplinary
proceedings.
The writ petition is ordered in the above terms. No costs.
vr
To
1. The Secretary to Government, Rural Development Department,
Fort St.George, Chennai 600 009.
2. The District Collector, Tiruvannamalai District,
Tiruvannamalai.