AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, All India Indian Overseas Bank Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe Welfare Association (registered under the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, registration No. 163 dated 22.7.1978), sought a writ of declaration declaring the registration of the second respondent — All India Overseas Bank Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribe Employees' Welfare Association — as illegal and void for contravening Section 9 of the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, 1975.

The petitioner alleged that a group of employees led by one Myilvahanan, after failing in internal contests and related civil litigation (notably O.S. No. 6749 of 1999 and O.S. No. 976 of 1999), formed the second respondent association in 2000 with a name similar to the petitioner’s and secured registration from the Registrar. The petitioner had objected to that registration and the objection was pending.

The second respondent filed a counter affidavit asserting that it was the true representative body, that the petitioner had become defunct and had failed to comply with statutory filing requirements, and that the Registrar was obliged to register societies not falling within Section 9’s prohibitions. The first respondent (the District Registrar) filed a counter affidavit taking the position that the two societies had different names and locations and that registration of the second respondent was lawful.

The writ petition challenged the correctness of the second respondent’s registration on the ground of similarity of names invoking Section 9 of the Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the registration of the second respondent association, under the name "All India Overseas Bank Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribe Employees' Welfare Association", is identical with or so nearly resembles the petitioner's registered name so as to attract the bar under Section 9 of the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, 1975.
  2. Whether the pendency of civil suits between rival groups concerning internal functioning and elections of the associations bars the petitioner from seeking the writ in relation to registration under Section 9.
  3. Whether the petitioner was obliged, as a precondition, to first pursue relief before the Registrar (i.e., seek cancellation or other relief administratively) instead of approaching the High Court directly by writ.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments (as advanced by Mr. V. Prakash)

  • The names of the two associations are very similar and likely to cause confusion; omission of the word "Indian" in the second respondent’s name is not sufficient to remove similarity.
  • The second respondent was formed by disgruntled members who had failed in litigation and internal elections, and therefore its formation and registration were motivated by rivalry and self-interest.
  • The Registrar ought to have examined existing registered societies and declined registration under Section 9, which prohibits registration of a society with a name identical with or so nearly resembling an existing society.

Second Respondent’s Arguments (as advanced by Mr. M. Venkatachalapathy)

  • The names are sufficiently distinct such that there is no likelihood of confusion on a proper reading of both names.
  • The petitioner association had become defunct and had not complied with statutory filing requirements (members’ list, audited balance sheet, etc.), and thus the second respondent legitimately filled a representational void.
  • The petitioner had an effective alternative remedy under the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act and should have approached the Registrar rather than directly invoking writ jurisdiction.
  • The registration of the petitioner had been cancelled (as instructed to counsel) and the petitioner did not make proper representations to the Registrar in recent years, rendering the writ move mala fide.

First Respondent (District Registrar) — Contentions in Counter Affidavit

  • Two societies have different names and different headquarters (Chennai for petitioner, Kancheepuram for second respondent); they do not resemble each other and therefore there was no requirement to change the name.
  • The registration of the second respondent in the office of the District Registrar was lawful (registered on 19.6.2000) and not violative of Section 9.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court considered the submissions from both sides and analysed a number of threshold and substantive points arising from the petition:

  1. On the effect of pending civil suits: The court observed that pending civil suits between rival groups concerned internal matters (functioning of associations, election disputes) and did not directly address the narrow issue raised by the writ petition — the legality of the Registrar's registration of the second respondent under Section 9. Consequently, pendency of those suits did not bar the petitioner from pursuing the writ petition.
  2. On whether the petitioner had to approach the Registrar first: The court found no substance in the contention that the petitioner should have been directed back to the Registrar. The petitioner's assertion that an objection had been filed before the Registrar was not denied; moreover, the Registrar had taken a positive stand in its counter-affidavit that the registration was lawful. The court held that directing the petitioner to approach the Registrar would have been futile in those circumstances.
  3. On the core issue under Section 9: The court identified the primary question as whether the two association names are identical or so nearly resemble each other as to be barred by Section 9. The court noted that, aside from the omission of the word "Indian" in the second respondent’s name, the remaining words are the same and both associations relate to employees of the Indian Overseas Bank (there being no separate “Overseas Bank”). Given that both associations purport to represent the same class of persons (SC/ST employees of the Indian Overseas Bank), the court concluded that the similarity of names is likely to cause confusion among authorities, individuals and those dealing with the bank or its employees.
  4. On statutory interpretation of Section 9: The court referred to Explanation (c) to Section 9, observing that the statutory bar does not require exact identity of names; close resemblance is sufficient to invoke the prohibition. Applying that principle, the court concluded that the Registrar should have declined registration of the second respondent which was registered after the petitioner’s long-established registration (1978 vs. 2000).
  5. On the Registrar’s rationale about location and headquarters: The court rejected the Registrar's contention that different headquarters or registration locality justified the registration. The court emphasized that registrations under the Act operate throughout the State and a difference in location does not cure identity or close resemblance of names.
  6. On the factual background of rivalry: The court acknowledged the factual record indicating rivalry among office-bearers and that individuals had formed a rival association. While recognizing that it is open to individuals to form a different association, the court stressed the statutory duty of the Registrar to prevent registration of names that would create confusion by identity or close resemblance.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition was allowed and the registration of the second respondent association was declared illegal.

Consequences and immediate implications as stated by the court:

  • The registration of the second respondent, All India Overseas Bank Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribe Employees' Welfare Association, which was registered in 2000, is declared illegal on the ground that its name so nearly resembles the earlier registered petitioner association that it attracts the bar under Section 9 of the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, 1975.
  • The decision is confined to the legality of registration; the court expressly clarified that its order does not resolve or affect the separate internal disputes between the office-bearers, nor the civil suits concerning election of office-bearers — those matters are beyond the scope of this writ petition.
  • The court observed it remains open to employees who do not wish to join the petitioner association to form their own association, provided the name chosen is not similar or identical to the petitioner and conforms with Section 9 of the Act.
  • No costs were awarded.

The opinion does not include citations to case law precedents or articulate broader declarative statements about establishing a new legal doctrine beyond the statutory interpretation of Section 9 applied to the facts of this case.

    All India Iob Sc And St Employees' Welfare Association v. District Registrar

    1. All India Indian Overseas Bank Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe Welfare Association, the petitioner herein, seeks for the issue of a writ of declaration declaring the registration by the first respondent of the second respondent under the name of All India Overseas Bank Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe Employees' Welfare Association as illegal and void and being violative of Section 9 of the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, 1975.

    2. The petitioner submits that it was duly registered under the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, vide registration No. 163, dated 22.7.1978 The Secretary of the petitioner Association states that motivated by self-interest, a group of a few employees led by one Myilvahanan attempted to thwart the legitimate activities of the petitioner Association by initiating litigation against the holding of election etc. The application filed by the said individuals were dismissed and the said individuals being unable to secure any support within the Association, the said individuals and few others floated a new body by name All India Overseas Bank Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes Employees' Welfare Association. The petitioner had objected to the similarity in the name and recognition being accorded to the new body by the Registrar of Societies. Their objection was still pending.

    3. Eariler, O.S No. 6749 of 1999 on the file of the District Munsif, Kancheepuram, was filed by the said Mayilvahanan purporting to be the General Secretary of the petitioner Association and he sought for an order of restraint as against the President P. Rajalingam and the General Secretary claiming that they had been removed from the petitioner Association, and the injunction application filed by the said Myilvahanan was dismissed on 7.12.1999 It is further stated that thereafter the said Myilvahanan set up five other individuals and filed a suit in O.S No. 976 of 1999. Several interlocutory reliefs were prayed for restraining the defendant (the petitioner herein) from operating the bank accounts etc. All the interlocutory applications were dismissed on 24.12.1999 It is further stated that the second respondent was interested only in furthering the selfish interests of a few individuals and that the said Association does not enjoy much support from the employees. The affidavit in support of the writ petition also contains certain other details of various controversies between the rival groups. The dispute appears to have arisen with reference to the visit of the Parliamentary Committee to Pondicherry to hear the grievances of SC/ST employees in the public sector and grievance of the petitioner appears to be that they were not intimated by the management. The said allegations are not directly relevant for the dispute which has been raised in this writ petition. In this writ petition, the correctness or otherwise of the registration of the second respondent Association, is questioned on the ground that the said Association bears similar name as that of the petitioner.

    4. In the counter filed by the second respondent-Association, it is stated that they are the true representatives of the SC/ST employees of the Bank. The petitioner-Association though it was originally formed for the purpose of serving SC/ST employees, however, it was not functioning properly and instead there was in fight between the office bearers fighting for the office. Therefore, it necessitated the establishment of a real association to strive for the welfare of the SC & ST employees working in the Indian Overseas Bank. The second respondent Association was registered under the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, 1975 on 24.1.2000 The petitioner Association though it was started in 1978 was not catering to the needs of the members. It is further stated that the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act is very categorical and enjoins a duty on the Registrar to register societies which do not fall within the categories mentioned under Section 9 of the Act. So far as the allegation of similarity in the name was concerned, there was no similarity or identity and therefore, the writ petition was liable to be dismissed. The petitioner Association had not complied with the statutory requirements and had committed default in not submitting the members' list, audited balance sheet and other relevant records which were required to be filed periodically and thus the petitioner Association has become defunct. The second respondent Association was functioning in a full-fledged manner and was functioning in a better way. It is further contended by the second respondent that the petitioner has got effective alternative remedy under the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act and hence writ petition was liable to be dismissed. It is further contended that the name of the petitioner Association is All India Indian Overseas Bank SC/ST Employees' Welfare Association whereas the name of the second respondent is “All India Overseas Bank Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribe Employees' Welfare Association”. Therefore, there is no similarity much less identical. The petitioner has also not made any representation to the Registrar for all these years. Therefore, the entire move of the petitioner was mala fide and motivated.

    5. A separate counter affidavit has been filed on behalf of the first respondent contending that the petitioner was registered on 22.7.1978 at Chennai and the second respondent Society was registered in the office of the District Registrar on 19.6.2000 Two societies have two different names and location and they are not similar either in names or in location. They do not resemble each other. Therefore, there was no necessity to change its name. Two societies are located at different Headquarters and having different names and there will be no confusion in any manner.

    6. Mr. V. Prakash appearing for the petitioner-Association contends that the similarity of the names of both the Associations are very close and identical and the same is bound to result in confusion. He would further submit that the very floating of the second respondent Association was due to the rivalry between the members of the petitioner Association. The second respondent Association was floated by disgruntled elements and as they were not successful in the Civil Suit which was filed by them in the matter of the election to the office-bearers. The first respondent ought to have considered the objection raised by the petitioner and should have considered as to whether there was any other association in the Book of Register resembling the name of the applicant before the first respondent. Learned counsel also refers to Section 9 of the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, 1975. The said provision mandates that no society shall be registered in a name which, in the opinion of the Registrar, is undesirable. Explanation Section 9 also includes that any association identical with or so nearly resembles, the name by which a society in existence is previously registered, shall not be registered by the Registrar. Though the word “Indian” is omitted in the name of the second respondent Association, the similarity is so close and identical and it is bound to result in confusion.

    7. Mr. M. Venkatachalapathy, learned Senior Counsel for the second respondent Association, contends that there is absolutely no confusion in the name as could be seen on a perusal of names of both the petitioner Association and the respondent Association. Learned Senior Counsel further contends that the petitioner Association has become defunct and not functioning as on date, and he was also instructed to state that the registration of the petitioner Association has been cancelled. The petitioner has also approached this Court without giving any representation to the Registrar and without seeking for cancellation of the registration of the second respondent in a manner known to law and in terms of the provisions of the Act. The petitioner cannot be permitted to approach this Court directly without making a proper application before the Registrar.

    8. I have considered the submissions of both sides. Though it is true that there are certain Civil Suits pending between the parties and filed by both sides as against each other, the prayer in the suits as well as the interlocutory relief claimed thereon pertain to issues which do not directly concern the prayer made in this writ petition, namely, the issue of registration of the second respondent and the objections thereto, as would arise under Section 9 of the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act. In those suits, individuals have sought for relief in the matter of the functioning of the respective Association and the election of the office-bearers of the respective Association. Therefore, the contention that the pendency of the Civil Suit would bar the petitioner from pursing the relief in this writ petition, cannot be sustained.

    9. I do not also find any substance in the objection that the petitioner should have approached the Registrar before he had approached this Court for seeking writ of declaration. The fact that the petitioner had filed objection before the Registrar as claimed in the petition, has not been denied. Further, it is seen from the counter-affidavit filed by the first respondent, the District Registrar, Kancheepuram, has taken a positive stand to the effect that there was no similarity between the two Societies and that the registration of the second respondent Association was legal and that there was no violation of Section 9 of the Act. Therefore, it would be futile and purposeless to suggest that the petitioner should be directed to approach the Registrar.

    10. The main and only issue which arises for consideration in this writ petition is as to whether the names of both the Association are identical and similar so as to attract the bar under Section 9 of the Act. Except that the word “Indian” is omitted in the name of the second respondent Association, in all other respects the same words have been used by the second respondent Association. It is pertinent to note that the association relates to the Indian Overseas Bank and there is no bank known as “Overseas Bank”. There is also no dispute over the fact that the Association seeks to represent the members of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes employees of the I.O.B It is not as though the second respondent Association has been established with reference to some other Bank. Therefore, any authority or individual having access to or dealings with the bank or the employees' Association is bound to be confused by the names adopted by both the Associations. The rival facts also disclose that the management itself has been sponsoring one association or the other and there is controversy as to whether the petitioner Association or the second respondent Association is the true representative of the employees belonging to the Indian Overseas Bank. It is true that the employees of the same Bank can have two or more Associations as long as they conform to the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act or the Regulations relating to the employees of the Indian Overseas Bank. But in order to avoid confusion, the Act itself envisages, a bar on registration of an Association if the names are identical with or so nearly resembles the Society which has been previously registered. In the present case, there is no dispute over the fact that the petitioner Association had been registered earlier on 22.7.1978 itself and that the rival second respondent Association came to be registered only in the year 2000. Therefore, the Registrar ought to have declined the registration of the second respondent Association having regard to the bar contained under Section 9 of the Act. I am unable to sustain the contention of learned Senior counsel for the second respondent that there is no similarity in the names of both the Associations for reasons already stated above. A perusal of the Explanation (c) to Section 9 itself indicates that in order to attract bar under Section 9, it is not necessary that the names should be exactly identical. It is sufficient that even if the names resemble each other closely similar to a Society which has already been registered.

    11. The facts relating to the circumstances under which the second respondent came to be registered also disclose that there is rivalry between the office bearers of the petitioner Association resulting in a group of individuals forming a different Association. There is no dispute over the fact that it is open to any individual to constitute and register a different association if they cannot get along well with the existing Association. But before the name of the new Society is registered it is the bounden duty of the Registrar to see that the name of the new Society to be registered does not create any confusion by identity or similarity of the name.

    12. The reasons contained in the counter affidavit of the first respondent, cannot also be sustained. The first respondent had taken the stand as if the location of the Association would make any difference. The said reason cannot be sustained. The registration is operative through out the State and therefore, the fact that the petitioner Society was registered at Chennai and that the second respondent Society has been registered at Kancheepuram, cannot justify registration of societies on identical or similar names. The further contention that both the Associations have different Headquarters, is also not a justification for ignoring the bar under Section 9 of the Act. The provisions of the Act and registrations thereunder are applicable and operative throughout the State.

    13. In the result, the petitioner is entitled to succeed and the registration of the second respondent Association is declared as illegal. It is however, made clear that the relief granted in this writ petition has nothing to do with the rivalry between the office-bearers of the petitioner Association and the second respondent Association. The disputes relating to the election of the office-bearers and the Civil Suits between themselves are totally beyond the scope of this writ petition. It is also open to the employees who are not inclined to be the members of the petitioner Association to form their own Association subject to the name of the said Association not being similar or identical to the petitioner Association and is in conformity with Section 9 of the Act. With the above observation, the writ petition is allowed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    All India Iob Sc And St Employees' Welfare Association v. District Registrar
    (Jan 23, 2004)