This petition has been filed against the orders of the Additional
Sessions Judge, Pondicherry, passed in Crl.R.P.No.1 of 2001, dismissing the
revision, filed against the orders passed in Crl.M.P.No.1803 of 2001 in
C.C.No.338 of 2000, on the file of the Judicial Magistrate-I, Pondicherry, who
had dismissed the application for discharge filed by the petitioner herein,
against the prosecution of offences under Section 211, 500 and 506(2) IPC.
2.Since the original petition itself, filed by the petitioner, was
against the cognizance taken by the Magistrate in relation to the private
complaint filed by the respondent herein and the same having been dismissed,
against which a revision was filed before the Court of Sessions, which had
also confirmed the orders of the learned Magistrate, this Court could have
easily disposed of the matter by stating that in terms of 399(3) a petition in
the nature of a second revision is not maintainable, as two courts have
already gone into the preliminary objection taken by the petitioner and
dismissed those applications. However, it is seen that in order to get away
from the bar under Section 399(3) IPC, this petition has been filed under
Section 482 Cr.P.C, which amply establishes the fact that what cannot be
directly done is sought to be indirectly done by invoking Section 482 Cr.P.C.
3.Nevertheless, since the counsel persisted in his argument stating
that the Magistrate had taken cognizance on the private complaint, which is in
flagrant violation of laws and this is one of the exceptional cases, where the
inherent powers of the High Court has to be invoked to rectify such mistakes,
I consider it necessary to go into the facts of the case.
4. It may not be very relevant to go into the facts of the case,
suffice to state for the purpose of disposing of this application that the
petitioner had earlier given a complaint to the Inspector General of Police,
Pondicherry on 21.8.2000, against the respondent herein alleging that the
respondent has forged his signatures and impersonated him in the District
Registrar's Office at Pondicherry and thereby executed five gift Settlement
Deeds in his favour. The said matter was referred by the Inspector General of
Police to the CID of Police, Pondicherry, who summoned the respondent and
conducted an enquiry, which is pending. In addition to this complaint, the
petitioner had also given false message before the private TV Channel called
Sky Sat, which has telecasted the same in Pondicherry on 24.8.2000, 26.8.2000
and 27.8.2000 and thereby the petitioner is said to have wilfully given a
false complaint to the police, thereby committed offences under Section 211
IPC as well as under Section 500 IPC, defaming the respondent through his
message in the media, which are false to his knowledge and wantonly made.
Hence the respondent herein had filed a private complaint before the Court of
Sub Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Pondicherry on 06.09.2000, who after
taking sworn statement and examining witnesses under Section 200 Cr.P.C had
taken cognizance of the complaint under Section 211, 500 and 506 (2) IPC.
5.It is against this complaint that the petitioner had filed an
application under Section 245 Cr.P.C, before the concerned Magistrate to
discharge him of the offences. The substantial grounds raised by him were two
in number; firstly being that the learned Magistrate erred in taking
cognizance for of an offence under Section 211 IPC, since according to the
learned counsel, it is only on the basis of a complaint by the Court,
cognizance could be taken in view of Section 195(1)( b) and secondly, the
Magistrate cannot take cognizance of an offence under Section 500 IPC, since a
complaint to the police is absolutely privileged. However, the learned
Magistrate dismissed the said application, against which the petitioner filed
a revision before the Court of Sessions, which, after considering the
elaborate contentions advanced by both parties, dismissed the revision,
holding that the Magistrate was perfectly justified in taking cognizance of
offences under Section 211, 500 IPC and 506 (2) IPC.
6.Here again in this petition also, the petitioner has raised the same
points. The learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the learned
Magistrate erred in taking cognizance of an offence under Section 211 IPC, in
view of the clear bar enshrined in Section 195(i)(b) Cr.P.C. This ground has
merely to be stated to be dismissed, since Section 195(i)(b) would apply only
when there was a proceeding in the Court, since the language of the Section is
abundantly clear, which reads as follows:
Prosecution for contempt of lawful authority of public servants for
offences against public justice and for offences relating to documents given
in evidence:
(1)No Court shall take cognizance
(a) ......
(b) (i) of any offence punishable under any of the following sections
of IPC, namely, sections 193 to 196(both inclusive, 199, 200, 205 to 211 (both
inclusive) and 228, when such offence is alleged to have been committed in, or
in relation to, any proceeding in any Court -
except on the complaint in writing of that Court, or of some other Court to
which that Court is subordinate.
7.Therefore, it is clear from the above that a complaint of a Court is
necessary, only if and when the offence is committed in any proceedings before
the Court, but it does not take away the right of an individual to file a
complaint under this offence, if the subject matter has not come to the Court
at all. The learned counsel for the petitioner then gave up this argument and
made an alternate argument stating that the complaint given by the petitioner
to the police, though at a later stage, was referred on the ground that it was
civil in nature, the concerned officer has not given any finding that the
complaint was false. In other words, the learned counsel would submit that
the complaint was pending investigation at the time of the present complaint
being filed by the respondent before the Court and the petitioner's complaint
to the police has not reached the finality and that at any rate it has not
been found to be false. In the absence of the consequences of the
investigation and in the absence of any clear finding that it is false, a
complaint for an offence under Section 211 IPC is not made out.
8.In support of his argument advanced above, the learned counsel cited
a number of decisions of various Courts. In my opinion, I do not think that
any of them would have any relevance to the present facts and the points
raised before this Court. However, I would like to refer to the decisions
stated by the counsel for the petitioner.
9.The first of the decision relied on by the learned counsel is the
judgment of the Kerala High Court reported in Ahmed Kutty Vs. State of Kerala
(AIR 1963 Kerala 152), wherein it has been stated that the mere statements of
facts or communications of suspicions cannot amount to institution of criminal
proceedings within the meaning of Section 211 IPC and His Lordship has went on
to hold that the ingredient of the offence is to the effect that the
prosecution is bound to prove that the charge was wilfully false to the
knowledge of the maker of the charge. This is a case where the accused was
convicted after preliminary trial and then the learned Judge has come to the
conclusion that the prosecution was not able to prove that the statement made
by the accused to the police was not wilfully made and consequently the
accused was acquitted. But the case on hand before us is one at the stage of
dawn, wherein the state of establishing the falsity has not reached.
10.The next decision referred to by the learned counsel is the
judgment of the Nagpur High Court reported in Ganpatram Dinaram Agarwal Vs.
Mt.Rambai (AIR (37) 1950 Nagpur 20), which also relates to a complaint given
to a police and a prosecution was launched for an offence under Section 500
IPC, wherein the accused after trial was convicted. In the said case, the
accused has not referred the name of the complainant, in the First Information
Report and during the course of the investigation, he had stated that he
entertained some suspicion against the complainant and therefore, His Lordship
while appreciating evidence let in by the prosecution has come to a conclusion
that merely having a suspicion against a person cannot, in the eye of law, be
stated to falsely charging a person of having committed the offence and
therefore, had acquitted the accused in the said case.
11.The third decision referred to is the judgment reported in Abdul
Hakim Khan Chaudhuri Vs. Emperor (AIR 1932 Cal 511), which relates to a case
where a complaint had been given by the accused in the First Information
Report against the complainant for an offence under Section 211 IPC. The same
was set aside on the ground that a complaint given to a police officer
pertaining to a non cognizable offence, does not attract the provisions of
Section 211 IPC, so as to say that it does not amount to falsely charging that
person, since in a non cognizable case, the police officer has no power to
file a prosecution, which would result in institution of criminal proceedings.
12. Yet another decision cited by the learned counsel is the judgment
reported in In re Subban Samban (AIR 1944 Madras 391), wherein a complaint has
been given to a superior officer and His Lordship Justice Kuppuswami Iyer,J
had held that Section 211 IPC is not made out, since it was only a report to
his superior officer, in the discharge of his duties and that he did not sent
it with the intention to set the criminal law in motion. But in our case, it
is the intention of the complainant, who had given a report to the police
solely with a view to take action against him and initiate criminal
proceedings against him and consequently the aforesaid decision would not
apply at all.
13.The learned counsel would further rely on a decision of the Apex
Court reported in Santokh Singh Vs. Hussain and another (AIR 1973 SC 2190),
wherein Their Lordships have interpreted the language used in Section 211 IPC
namely false charges does n ean giving false evidence and in the said case, it
was a proceeding before a criminal Court and the High Court had given a
direction to the Registrar to file a complaint under Section 211 IPC because
the accused had in the said case wrongly identified a person in the
Identification parade. Therefore, their Lordships have held that a wrong
identification in the High Court would not come under the category of false
charge being made and consequently, set aside the order and in fact Their
Lordships have held that since it was a proceedings in Court and even if the
wrong identification would attract the provisions of section 211 ipc, the
Court has to decide whether there is in fact a false accusation and finally
whether it is expedient in the interest of justice on the facts and
circumstances of the present case to direct a complaint to be filed under
Section 211 IPC. Since this being a case pending in the criminal Court, I do
not think that it has any relevance to the facts of the present case before
us.
14.The next decision cited by the learned counsel is the judgment
reported in Haridas Das and another Vs. State of West Bengal and Others (1964
7 SCR 23), wherein an application was filed for contempt of Court against the
erring party. The question that arose was whether Section 211 IPC would
apply, since the person who initiated the contempt proceedings can be termed
to be a person instituting a criminal proceedings and ultimately Their
Lordships of the Supreme Court have answered the question in the affirmative
and have maintained the prosecution. This decision in no way supports the
case of the petitioner.
15.The learned counsel would also cite a decision of the Madras High
Court reported in M.Neelakantadas Vs. M.Gopinathan (1995-2-L.W. 68), a
judgment in a second appeal, wherein the plaintiff had filed a suit for
damages against the defendant for having maliciously prosecuted him. The
question that arose there was whether it was an offence under Section 211 IPC
or 182 IPC and it was held that the defendant had given a false information
without any justification and had only committed an offence under Section 182
IPC and not 211 IPC. Consequently, I feel that this decision does not support
the case of the petitioner.
16.The learned counsel would further cite a decision reported in
Empress of India Vs. Abdul Hasan (ILR 1 All. 498[1877]). But to my surprise
the said decision cited by him though not read in Court, but circulated is
directly against his arguments. In the said case one Abdul Hasan had been to
the Police station and gave a complaint against Ser Mal of having stolen
certain surgical instruments. After investigation was over it was found that
Ser Mal has not committed the offence. Hence a complaint under Section 211
IPC was instituted against him and ultimately after the trial he was convicted
for two years imprisonment, against which he had filed an appeal and the
learned Sessions Judge had acquitted him holding that the charge of false
complaint could not be sustained because the Magistrate had not entered in to
the charge of theft and in support of it His Lordship in the said judgment has
relied upon the decision reported in The Queen Vs. Subbanna Gaundan (1 Mad.
HCR 30). But then it was found that the said case referred in that decision
was the resultant of a criminal trial pending before the concerned Magistrate.
But in the case cited supra, there was no trial pending on that date before
any criminal Court and consequently, the High Court had held that the
acquittal was wrong and ultimately maintained the conviction and sentence
passed by the Magistrate against Abdul Hasan.
17.After the elaborate arguments advanced by the learned counsel and
after going through all the decisions cited by him, in my view, I am not in
agreement with his contention that Section 195(1)(b) can ever come to his
rescue and he fairly gave up the point during his argument, since there was no
proceedings before any Court, which would authorise only that Court to give a
complaint.
18.The next argument is also not equally appealable to me, since he
was not able to support his argument with any authorities that before a Court
could take cognizance of an offence under Section 211 IPC, the investigation
should have reached the finality or that a complaint to a police officer under
Section 500 IPC is also absolutely privileged, they would come under the
exception.
19.As against this, there is a direct decision which deals with this
point and if I say so with certain amount of force that the decision of the
Apex Court reported in M.L.Seti Vs. R.P.Kapur (AIR 1967 SC 52 8), is directly
on the point and I need not refer to any other decision at all, since in my
opinion it applies in all fours. In the said case before the Apex court, on
10.12.1958 the appellant (who was later tried for an offence under Section 211
IPC) had filed a complaint before the Inspector General of Police, Chandigarh
against R.P.Kappor charging them with commission of offence punishable under
Section 420, 114 and 120-B IPC. On 11.4.1959, when the matter was still under
investigation, the respondent (the accused in the police complaint) filed a
complaint in the Court of Judicial Magistrate I Class, Chandigarh against the
appellant for an offence under Section 211 IPC among other offences. However
the Supreme Court accepted that a complaint to the police would attract the
provisions of Section 211 IPC. But they went into the question as to whether
the cognizance taken by the Magistrate before the conclusion of the
investigation was right or wrong. That appears to be the question put forward
before this Court in the present case also. Since it is not the case of the
petitioner that an offence under Section 211 IPC has not been made out or
disputed.
20.The contention is relevant only to the fact that neither the
police, nor the Court have given a finding that it is a false complaint. Can
the Magistrate then take cognizance of a complaint on a private complaint ?
The identical point has been answered at Paragraph 9 of the decision of the
Apex Court cited supra, wherein their Lordships have said that the important
aspect that has to be kept in view is that the point of time at which the
legality of the cognizance taken has to be judged, is the time when cognizance
is taken under Section 190 Cr.P.C, which applies to try such cases.
21.The only restriction placed for the Magistrate to take cognizance
of such an offence under Section 211 IPC is in view of Section 195(1 )(b) of
Cr.P.C and that restriction comes into operation only when there is a
proceeding in the Court, but when there is no proceeding at all before any
Court, the Magistrate is perfectly justified in taking cognizance of the
offence, even though the matter is pending investigation.
22.One of the main contention raised on behalf of the appellant in the
case cited supra was that can a private person file a complaint under Section
211 IPC when the First Information Report is under investigation, relating to
a cognizable offence and according to the learned counsel who appeared on
behalf of the appellant in the said case, even after the conclusion of the
investigation and even after the matter has been referred, the referred report
will have to be accepted by the Magistrate and when he accepts the order of
the referred notice, it amounts to a Judicial Order and consequently, it is
only the Court that is empowered to give a complaint. But however, Their
Lordships of the Apex Court have stated in the said case that since cognizance
had already been taken, while the matter was pending investigation and the
matter had not reached its finality on the police filing a report under
Section 173 Cr.P.C and the Magistrate acting in his judicial capacity, the
cognizance already taken by the Magistrate is not illegal and consequently has
upheld it. In my opinion, the said decision squarely applies to the facts of
this case, wherein admittedly a matter was under investigation and the
Judicial Magistrate has taken cognizance of the matter before any judicial
order has been passed and consequently, I am not in agreement with the points
raised by the petitioner.
23.At this juncture, I would like to add that as far as the
complainant is concerned, he does not get his right only on the police officer
or the court giving a finding that the complaint is false but in my opinion,
the cause of action arises at the time and on the day when he comes to know
(to his knowledge) that the complaint is false and this does not depend upon
any other forum giving a finding that it is false. Therefore, in such
circumstances, the complainant gets a vested right, the moment he becomes
aware that a false complaint has been given against him and he need not
necessarily wait till the police officer or the court gives a finding that the
complaint is false.
24. The other contention raised by the learned counsel was that if
such a restriction has been allowed in every complaint pending before the
police officers, the respective accused in the said complaint would file a
complaint before the Court of the concerned Magistrate for an offence under
Section 211 IPC and it would lead to an anamolous position. As a matter of
fact, the same argument was even found advanced in M.L.Seti's case before the
Apex Court, wherein Their Lordships have held that it is unnecessary to
interpret the law in such a way so as to necessarily avoid such a situation.
There appears to be no defect, if both the cases are simultaneously taken and
tried together in the same Court, one after the other and the Apex Court had
repelled the argument. In view of the said observation by the Apex court, I
am not in agreement put forward by the learned counsel.
25.The last of the contention raised by the learned counsel is that a
complaint to the police is absolutely privileged and an offence under Section
500 IPC would not be made out. I am not in agreement with the argument
advanced by the learned counsel, since the Madras High Court in 1. Usha
Adelin, 2. Son Jayarajan, 3.Russel, 4.Lakshmanan & 5.Mariadoss Vs.
Sathiadoss (1990 LW CRL 320), wherein His Lordship Justice Arunachalam has
elaborately gone into the question and has held that the complaint given to
the police officer would at best come under the exceptions and it is only in
the Court of the trial, the exceptions has to be pleaded and there is no
absolute privilege as far as the complaint given to the police officer, but is
only a qualified privilege and consequently, there is no merit in this
argument.
26. For the foregoing reasons, I feel that the learned Magistrate is
perfectly justified in taking cognizance of the case and this petition
accordingly, deserves to be dismissed and is dismissed. Consequently,
connected Crl.M.P is closed.
csh
22-10-2002
Index:Yes
Internet:Yes
To
1.The Judicial Magistrate
Pondicherry.
2.The Additional Sessions Judge
Pondicherry.