Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act, 1961,
  • S. 12(3) or S. 18(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act;
  • rule 149(2) of the Co-operative Societies Rules
  • S. 18(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act, 1961,
  • S. 12(3) or S. 18(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act;
  • rule 149(2) of the Co-operative Societies Rules
  • S. 18(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947,
Smart Summary

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners (Thanjavur District Co-operative Credit Societies Employees Union) filed a writ petition seeking issuance of a writ of certiorari and mandamus to quash portions of Government Order (G.O.) Ms. No. 89, Co-operation, Food and Consumer Protection Department, dated 16 May 2000 (first respondent) and to direct implementation of the recommendations of a Streamlining Committee. The petition challenged Clauses 2.03, 3.03 and 4.03 of the G.O., which modified the Committee's recommendations concerning grading of Thrift and Credit Co-operative Societies, conferral of selection and special grades on employees, and extending pay-packages/benefits to temporary (irregular) employees.

The petition arose out of background facts set out in the supporting affidavit: there are 35 Thrift and Credit Co-operative Societies with 70 employees; historically pay scales and related benefits had been addressed through settlements under Section 12(3) or Section 18(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947; the Government had constituted a Streamlining Committee which made recommendations on pay-scale, allowances and cadre-strength categorisation; the Government adopted most recommendations in G.O. Ms. No. 89 but modified or rejected certain recommendations (notably Clauses 2.03, 3.03 and 4.03); the Registrar issued a circular directing societies to enter fresh settlements based on the G.O.; the Union objected to the modifications and filed representations and the present writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Clauses 2.03, 3.03 and 4.03 of G.O. Ms. No. 89 (dated 16 May 2000), which modify recommendations of the Streamlining Committee, are illegal and liable to be quashed.
  2. Whether the grading rule for societies should require maintenance of norms for one full co-operative year (as recommended by the Committee) or for three consecutive co-operative years (as fixed by the Government in Cl. 2.03).
  3. Whether employees of the Thrift and Credit Co-operative Societies ought to receive selection grade after 10 years and special grade after 20 years, as recommended by the Streamlining Committee and as applicable to Tamil Nadu State Government employees (Cl. 3.03), despite the Government marking these recommendations "not accepted".
  4. Whether temporary/irregular employees who have rendered not less than 480 days within a continuous period of two years and perform equal work should be extended the pay package and other benefits recommended by the Streamlining Committee (Cl. 4.03), notwithstanding the Government's position that irregular appointees should not receive the revised scale until regularisation decisions are made.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Streamlining Committee's recommendations (including Clauses 2.03, 3.03 and 4.03) should be implemented: Clauses 2.03 and 3.03 were validly framed and Cl. 4.03 followed the principle of equal work, equal pay for temporary employees performing duties similar to regular employees.
  • Cl. 2.03 (grading of societies) — the Committee recommended that a society be deemed to have achieved a higher grade if prescribed norms are maintained for one full co-operative year; the Government's imposition of a three-year requirement has no basis.
  • Cl. 3.03 (selection/special grade) — the Committee recommended conferring selection grade after 10 years and special grade after 20 years, as for State Government employees; the Government rejected this without assigning a proper reason.
  • Cl. 4.03 (temporary employees) — temporary employees perform equal work and some have completed the requisite 480 days in two years; their services are irregular but not illegal and therefore they should receive equal pay as per the Committee's recommendation and as done for Primary Agricultural Co-operative Bank employees (Registrar's letter Ro. No. 15868/91 CR-1, dated 24 Feb. 1994).
  • Counsel cited Council of Scientific & Industrial Research v. K.G.S. Bhatt [1990 (1) L.L.N 10] to support arguments concerning fairness in promotion and opportunities for advancement.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Government's modification of Cl. 2.03 to require norms to be maintained consecutively for three co-operative years is a reasonable restriction and the Government has not revealed certain complaints which justified rejecting some recommendations.
  • Cl. 3.03 (selection and special grade) — the Government did not accept the Committee's recommendation (marked "not accepted") and did not assign a public reasoning for that rejection in the material cited.
  • Cl. 4.03 (temporary employees) — because the employees in question are irregular appointees, granting them the revised pay scale should await approval/decision by the head of the department (Registrar of Co-operative Societies); until Government decides on the regularisation of irregular appointments, it may be improper to allow the revised scale to irregular employees.
  • The learned Government Advocate ultimately prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Council of Scientific and Industrial Research v. K.G.S. Bhatt, [1990 (1) L.L.N 10] Principles regarding opportunity for advancement, promotions and equitable treatment in career progression; the cited passage emphasizes the need for realistic promotion opportunities and consequences of denying advancement. The case was cited and an extract was placed before the Court by the petitioner's counsel. The opinion records the citation and the excerpt; the citation was used by petitioner's counsel in support of arguments about promotions and parity, and the Court noted the citation in the course of considering the issues. (The opinion does not state a separate, detailed doctrine-based reliance beyond recording the citation and excerpt.)

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the three contested Clauses (2.03, 3.03 and 4.03) in light of the Streamlining Committee's recommendations, the G.O. modifications, the materials on record and the submissions of counsel.

Stepwise analysis as reflected in the opinion:

  1. Cl. 2.03 (grading of societies): The Streamlining Committee recommended that a society be deemed to have achieved a higher grade if the prescribed norms are maintained for one full co-operative year. The Government modified this to require norms to be maintained "consecutively and conclusively for at least 3 full co-operative years." The Court found that the Government had not assigned any valid reason for fixing a three-year term and held that the Committee's one-year period is sufficient to grant gradations to societies. Accordingly, the Court concluded that the Government could implement the Committee's recommendation without the 3-year modification.
  2. Cl. 3.03 (selection grade and special grade): The Committee recommended conferring selection grade after 10 years and special grade after 20 years, mirroring the practice for Tamil Nadu State Government employees. The Government marked this recommendation "not accepted" without providing a proper reason. The Court observed that when Government employees enjoy these grades, similarly placed co-operative sector employees (as identified by the Committee) ought to have the same standards applied. The Court therefore found that the Government should have accepted these recommendations and that the lack of rationale for rejection was not sustainable.
  3. Cl. 4.03 (temporary/irregular employees): The Committee recommended extending pay packages and other benefits to temporary employees who have served not less than 480 days within a continuous period of two years, on the basis of equal work and equal pay. The Government relied on the argument that these employees are irregular appointees and that revised scales should not be allowed until regularisation decisions are taken. The Court noted (and the petition recorded) that some comparable benefits had already been extended to Primary Agricultural Co-operative Bank employees by the Registrar's letter dated 24 February 1994. The Court also recorded that the Government did not deny the equality of work performed by temporary employees. The Court reasoned that since these temporary employees perform equal work and this was not rebutted by the Government, the Committee's recommendation for equal pay was desirable and should be accepted.
  4. Procedural and evidentiary notes: The Court observed that the Streamlining Committee had properly recommended the three clauses based on reasons and principles set out by the Committee, and that the Government either modified or refused to accept those recommendations without adequate justification as recorded in the material before the Court.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The writ petition is allowed. Specifically:

  1. G.O. Ms. No. 89, Co-operative Food and Consumer Protection Department, dated 16 May, 2000 of the Tamil Nadu Government is quashed insofar as it concerns Clauses 2.03, 3.03 and 4.03 of the recommendations.
  2. The first respondent is directed to implement the Streamlining Committee's recommendations regarding Clauses 2.03, 3.03 and 4.03.

Additional orders recorded in the opinion: No costs were awarded; W.M.P. No. 18233 of 1998 was closed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The Court's decision requires the first respondent (the Government/Registrar) to implement the Streamlining Committee's recommendations for the three Clauses, thereby restoring the Committee's one-year grading rule (Cl. 2.03), its recommendation on selection and special grades (Cl. 3.03), and its recommendation to extend pay/benefits to qualifying temporary employees (Cl. 4.03).
  • Broader implications: The opinion does not set out or announce a novel legal doctrine beyond the application of the Committee's recommendations to the facts before the Court; the judgment primarily addresses the legality of the Government's modifications and rejections of specific Committee recommendations and directs implementation. The opinion does not state that it establishes a new precedent beyond quashing the specific modifications in G.O. Ms. No. 89.

    Thanjavur District Employees Co-Operative Credit Societies Employees Union v. Secretary To Government, Co-Operation, Food And Consumer Protection Department, Chennai

    1. Petition praying to issue a writ of certiorarified mandamus to call for the records relating to the impugned G.O Ms. No. 89, Co-operation, Food and Consumer Protection Department, dated 16 May, 2000 of the first respondent and quash the Cls. 2.03, 3.03 and 4.03 modifying the recommendations of the Streamlining Committee, as illegal and against law and direct the first respondent to implement the recommendations of the Streamlining Committee and amend the G.O accordingly.

    2. In the affidavit filed in support of the writ petition, the Thanjavur District Co-operative Credit Societies Employees Union would allege that there are 35 Thrift and Credit Co-operative Societies registered under the provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act, 1961, and they have employed 70 employees only and in connection with the scale of pay and other benefits payable to them, the petitioner used to enter into a settlement either under S. 12(3) or under S. 18(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, in order to streamline the disparities in the scale of pay among employees of different co-operative societies in the same cadre and discharging similar functions and duties, the Government by G.O.O (D) No. 18, Co-operative Food and Consumer Protection Department, dated 21 January, 1999, constituted a Streamlining Committee with the Tamil Nadu Employees Co-operative Societies Federation as one of its members which made several recommendations in respect of pay-scale, allowances cadre strength categorisation, etc.; that the Government after examining the recommendations of the Committee passed G.O Ms. 89, dated 16 May, 2000 accepting most of the recommendations and modifying certain others, further, directing the Registrar of Co-operative Societies to implement the G.O to enter into a settlement under S. 12(3) or S. 18(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act; only if the employees accept and agree in the recommendations annexed to the above G.O, resulting in the Registrar issuing the circular in RC No. 20795 of 1998 VB-I, dated 29 May, 2000, directing the societies to enter a fresh settlement on the basis of the recommendations made in the above G.O, and the Union found several patent and apparent discrepancies and sent representations to consider the modifications to certain recommendations. They are:

    2.03 In the event of a society achieving the norms prescribed to a higher grade, such society shall be deemed to have achieved that higher status only if the norms prescribed to such higher grade is maintained at least for a period of one full co-operative year. The recommendations of the Committee is accepted subject to the modification that norms prescribed to such higher grade is maintained consecutively and conclusively for at least 3 full co-operative years. 3.03 Selection Grade and Special Grade Scale of Pay.— Selection Grade on completion of 10 years and Special Grade on completion of 20 years as applicable to Tamil Nadu State Government employees may be conferred: Awarding of selection grade and special grade is not accepted. 4.03 Extending the packages and other benefits to the temporary employees.— The Government may consider extending the pay package and other benefits to these employees (temporary employees) whose services have not so far been regularised for one reason or other and who have been put in a service of not less than 480 days within a continuous period of two years subject to the condition that the status of such employees will remain as it is till a decision to regularise their services are taken by the Government for in the case of employees of Primary Agricultural Co-operative Banks in Registrar's Co-operative Societies letter RC. 158681/91 CR-1, dated 24 February, 1994. Till Government take a decision on the irregular appointment made in co-operative institutions, it may not be proper to allow revised scale of pay to the irregular employees also. Hence, the wage revision is applicable only to regular employees.

    Aggrieved of the said recommendations of the Government, the petitioner has come forward to file the above writ petition.

    3. During arguments, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners-union pointing out that so far as Cl. 2.03 is concerned which pertains to grading of the society that every year a co-operative society is graded on the basis of total amount of assets, liabilities, disbursement powers etc.; that so far as the employees of the Thrift and Credit Societies are concerned, the recoveries are made from the salaries; that when certain grades decided in all other societies are done each and every year, in the thrift and credit societies it is done once m three years and not every year which has no basis; that regarding Cl. 3.03 which is concerned with the regular employees, the recommendations of the Streamlining Committee is that after attainment of 10 years of service, the selection grade and after 20 years of service, the special grade become applicable for Tamil Nadu State Government employees and this system of conferring the selection grade after 10 years and special grade after 20 years on the employees is not accepted by the Government for the employees of the petitioners society nor any valid reason assigned for such non-acceptance.

    4. At this juncture, the learned counsel would also cite the decision reported in Council of Scientific and Industrial Research v. K.G.S Bhatt, [1990 (1) L.L.N 10]. The relevant portion in Para. 9, at page 13, is extracted hereunder:

    “That then is the scope of bye-law 71(b)(ii). But that does not mean that we should interfere with the relief granted to respondent. 1. By pointing out the error that crept into the decision of the Tribunal, we need not take to its logical end which will defeat justice. Respondent 1 is not a layman. He is a highly qualified engineer. Although joined service with a diploma in Engineering be later passed Bachelor of Engineering (B.E) and also acquired M.Tech degree and one more diploma (D.P.M). He was, however, left without opportunity for promotion for about twenty years. This is indeed a sad commentary on the appellant's management. It is often said and indeed, adroitly, an organisation public or private does not ‘hire a hand’ but engages or employs a whole man. The person is recruited by an organisation not just for a job, but for a whole career. One must, therefore, be given an opportunity to advance. This is the oldest and most important feature of the free enterprise system. The opportunity for advancement is a requirement for progress of any organisation. It is an incentive for personnel development as well. Every management must provide realistic opportunities for promising employees to move upward. ‘The organisation that fails to develop a satisfactory procedure for promotion is bound to pay a severe penalty in terms of administrative costs, misallocation of personnel, low morale, and ineffectual performance, among both non-managerial employees and their supervisors.’ There cannot be any modern management much less any career planning, man-power development, management development, etc., which is not related to a system of promotions. The appellant appears to have overlooked this basic requirement of management so far as respondent 1 was concerned till N.R and A.S were introduced.”

    5. Learned counsel for the petitioner would further submit that regarding Cl. 4.03 that those persons, who are discharging similar duties of the regular employees are not getting the pay-scale; that the Streamlining Committee recommended that they should be paid equally on the basis of the equal work equal pay for which the Government would state that till they take decision on the irregular appointment made in Co-operative institutions, it may not be proper to allow revised scale or pay to the irregular employees also and therefore, the wage revision is applicable only to regular employees. He would further point out that Courts have held that their services could be regularised since certain office assistants have completed 480 days in a couple of years as per G.O Ms. No. 86, dated 12 March, 2001. Learned counsel would point out that their services are only irregular and not illegal. Learned counsel would lament that the Streamlining Committee was appointed by the Government itself, but the recommendations are not accepted by the Government and hence, the writ petition praying for the reliefs extracted supra.

    6. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents would submit that in the last Cl. 4.03, only because they are irregular appointees, it could be only by the approval of the head of the department, i.e, the Registrar of Co-operative Societies; that this procedure is not valid. Learned counsel would also point that even though the other Cl. 2.03 in granting higher grade to the Thrift and Credit Society, the Government have accepted the recommendations of the committee, but subject to the modification the norms prescribed to such higher grade is maintainedconsecutively for at least three co-operative years which is a reasonable restriction imposed by the Government. Likewise, for Cl. 3.03 pertaining to the question of granting selection grade on completion of 10 years and special grade on completion of 20 years as applicable to Tamil Nadu State Government employees. The Government should have rejected only on certain complaints, which cannot be revealed and therefore, the learned Government Advocate (writ side) would ultimately pray for dismissing the writ petition.

    7. In consideration of the pleadings by parties, having regard to the materials placed on record and upon hearing the learned counsel for both, the petitioner Employees Co-operative Societies Union has come forward with this writ petition on behalf of the members of the union, who are the employees of the Co-operative Thrift and Credit Societies seeking to implement the recommendations of the Streamlining Committee appointed by the Government itself. So far as it is concerned with Cls. 2.03, 3.03 and 4.03, thereby modifying the recommendations of the Streamlining Committee are not accepted by the Government further directing to implement the other recommendations of the streamlining committee.

    8. So far as Cl. 2.03 is concerned, the Streamlining Committee has recommended for the higher status or grade if the society achieves the norms prescribed to such higher grade is maintained for a full co-operative year, but the Government modifying the recommendations of the committee has advocated that the norms prescribed to such higher grade should be maintained consecutively and conclusively for three full co-operative years. But on the part of the Government, no valid reason has been assigned as to why it is fixing three year term for achieving the norms prescribed for the higher grade and therefore, the recommendations of the Streamlining Committee could be implemented by the Government without effecting any modification since the period of one year that is fixed for achieving the norms is sufficient to grant such gradations to the societies.

    9. Secondly, coming to Cl. 3.03 the consultative committee has clearly recommended to confer on the employees of the Thrift and Co-operative Societies that selection grade on completion of 10 years of qualifying service and special grade on completion of 20 years of qualifying service as it is applicable to the Tamil Nadu Government employees for which no proper reason has been assigned on the part of the Government and the recommendations have been blindly rejected stating not accepted. When the Government employees are enjoying such facilities, the employees working in the co-operative sector, especially in the Thrift and Co-operative Societies since being similarly placed on par with the Government employees, the Streamlining Committee has recommended to adopt standards meant for the Government employees to the employees of the co-operative societies also and therefore, the Government should have accepted these recommendations of the Streamlining Committee also.

    10. Thirdly, coming to Cl. 4.03, i.e, pay-package and other benefits to the temporary employees, whose services have not so far been regularised for one reason or other put in service not less than 480 days within a continuous period of two years and subject to certain service conditions, these facilities have already been extended to the employees of Primary Agricultural Co-operative Banks as per the Registrar Co-operative Societies' letter in Ro. No. 15868/91 CR-1, dated 24 February, 1994. The petitioner would plead for providing them also the same pay scale as it is provided for the regular employees and as recommended by the Streamlining Committee on the principle of equal work, equal pay. On the part of the Government, there is no denial of the fact that the work that is done by the temporary employees is no way less or inferior but on par with the regular employees of the employees of the primary agricultural co-operative banks, but, the Government pointing out that they are irregular appointees would refuse to accept these recommendations to provide them with equal pay.

    11. The irregularities, pointed out shows that these employees have been employed without consulting the Co-operative Department nor following some directions issued by the Registrar of Co-operative Societies and also without being forwarded through the Employment Exchange. This position is covered under rule 149(2) of the Co-operative Societies Rules wherein qualifications for appointment by direct recruitment to different class of posts are specified.

    12. On the part of the petitioners, they would argue that the Courts have held that the services could be regularised on the ground that the services are only irregular and not illegal and therefore, they cannot be paid on par with the regular appointees is a wrong policy adopted on the part of the Government, but, the point is not whether regular appointees or irregular appointees; the point that is to be given credence is whether they do the equal work as the regular employees in the same cadre, either in other co-operative sectors or in the Government or not? The answer is simple in the sense that they do the equal work as others. Since it is not rebutted on the part of the Government and therefore, when these temporary employees are doing the equal work, it is only desirable to permit them to get the equal pay and therefore, at this score also, the Government should accept the recommendations of the Streamlining Committee instead of refusing to allow the revised scale of pay to the employees of the petitioner-union on the ground that they are irregular employees.

    13. All the above three recommendations covering Cls. 2.03, 3.03 and 4.03, the streamling committee has properly recommended to the Government on valid reasons and strong principles and the Government should have only accepted those recommendations of the Streamlining Committee instead of either modifying or refusing to accept the same.

    14. For all the above discussions held, the writ petition becomes entitled to be allowed as prayed for.

    15. In result, the above writ petition is allowed:

    (i) G.O Ms. No. 89, Co-operative Food Consumer Protection Department, dated 16 May, 2000 of Tamil Nadu Government is quashed so far as it is concerned with Cls. 2.03, 3.03 and 4.03 of the recommendations.

    (ii) The first respondent is hereby directed to implement the recommendation of the Streamlining Committee regarding these three Clauses. No costs. Consequently, W.M.P No. 18233 of 1998 is closed. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Thanjavur District E... v. Secretary To Governm...
    (Feb 13, 2002)