Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provision of Order 38, Rule 5 of C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 46C of C.P.C7.
  • Order 21, Rule 46A of C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 46B of C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 46 of C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 46 C.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provision of Order 38, Rule 5 of C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 46C of C.P.C7.
  • Order 21, Rule 46A of C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 46B of C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 46 of C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 46 C.P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is the second defendant and a garnishee in O.S 294/85 before the Sub-Court, Madurai. The first respondent filed the suit for recovery of Rs. 17,555.28 from the second respondent. Pending the suit, the first respondent obtained an order of attachment of Rs. 22,000 due from the second respondent, which was held by the petitioner. The petitioner did not appear in response to the garnishee notice, resulting in the attachment order being made absolute on 29.8.86. The petitioner was directed to deposit the attached amount in Court by order dated 23.12.86 but failed to comply. After the suit was decreed, the first respondent filed E.P 80/88 seeking direction for the petitioner to deposit the decree amount from the attached funds. The Executing Court dismissed the petition on 1.12.89, holding that without an attachment order under Order 21, Rule 46 C.P.C and notice under Order 21, Rule 46A C.P.C, the petitioner could not be directed to deposit the amount. The first respondent appealed in C.M.A 44/90, and the District Court allowed the appeal on 23.8.91, directing the petitioner to deposit the decree amount. The petitioner challenged this order by filing the present revision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an order directing the garnishee (petitioner) to deposit the decree amount under Order 21, Rule 46B of the Civil Procedure Code (C.P.C) can be passed without issuing notice to the garnishee as contemplated under Order 21, Rule 46A of C.P.C.
  2. Whether the attachment order made pending the suit under Order 38, Rule 5 of C.P.C negates the necessity of a fresh attachment order under Order 21, Rule 46 of C.P.C and the requirement of notice under Order 21, Rule 46A before directing the garnishee to deposit the amount.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • An order to deposit the amount under Order 21, Rule 46B C.P.C requires prior issuance of notice under Order 21, Rule 46A C.P.C.
  • The lower appellate court erred in assuming the decree amount was available with the petitioner simply because the petitioner did not respond to the attachment notice during the suit.
  • The petitioner contended that the procedure mandated by the Rules requires notice under Rule 46A before directing deposit, and thus the appellate court's order should be set aside.

First Respondent’s Arguments

  • Once an order of attachment is made pending the suit, there is no requirement to issue a fresh notice under Order 21, Rule 46A C.P.C.
  • The Court is empowered under Order 21, Rule 46B C.P.C to direct the garnishee to deposit the amount without issuing fresh notice.
  • The revision filed by the petitioner should be dismissed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Executive Engineer T.C Division, K.S.E Board v. J.H Sharma (AIR 1988 Kerala 285) Necessity of notice under Order 21, Rule 46A C.P.C before garnishee is directed to deposit under Rule 46B; procedure for garnishee objections under Rule 46C The Court relied on this precedent to hold that despite an order of attachment pending the suit, notice under Rule 46A is necessary before directing deposit under Rule 46B, and objections by the garnishee must be considered under Rule 46C.
Alsidass Kaverlal v. J. Hiriya Gowder (1960 II MLJ 561) Effect of prohibitory order issued by Court barring payment to judgment debtor by garnishee only for amounts payable up to date of attachment The Court cited this case to emphasize that the garnishee must be given an opportunity to raise objections during execution proceedings if the amount to the extent of the decree debt is not available, reinforcing the need for notice under Rule 46A.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the statutory provisions governing attachment before judgment under Order 38, Rule 5 C.P.C and the execution procedure under Order 21, Rules 46 to 46C C.P.C. It held that an order of attachment pending the suit continues until lifted, and no fresh attachment order under Order 21, Rule 46 is necessary for execution. However, the Court emphasized that the procedural scheme mandates issuance of notice to the garnishee under Order 21, Rule 46A before the Court can direct the garnishee to deposit the amount under Rule 46B. This notice provides the garnishee an opportunity to show cause or raise objections, which the Court must consider under Rule 46C. The Court relied on the Kerala High Court decision in Executive Engineer T.C Division, K.S.E Board v. J.H Sharma, which clarified this procedural requirement and the necessity of allowing garnishee objections. The Court further cited Alsidass Kaverlal v. J. Hiriya Gowder to highlight that the attachment order only bars payments up to the date of attachment, and the garnishee must be permitted to contest the availability of funds during execution. Since no notice under Rule 46A was served on the petitioner, the Court found the lower appellate court’s order directing deposit without following these procedural safeguards to be unsustainable. However, considering the prolonged litigation, the Court decided not to remand for fresh notice but instead set aside the appellate order and restored the execution petition for fresh disposal with directions to the Executing Court to hear both parties on merits and in accordance with law.

Holding and Implications

The Court set aside the order of the lower Appellate Court in C.M.A 44/90 and restored the execution petition E.P 80/88 for fresh disposal.

The Executing Court is directed to hear the objections filed by the petitioner and dispose of the execution petition on merits and in accordance with law, ensuring compliance with the procedural requirements under Order 21, Rules 46A to 46C of the C.P.C. This decision affects the parties by requiring the execution proceedings to be conducted with proper notice and opportunity for the garnishee to be heard, but does not establish any new precedent beyond the existing legal framework.

    Madurai City Municipal Corporation v. N. Baskara Pandian

    The petitioner is the second defendant in O.S 294/85 on the file of the Sub-Court, Madurai who is only a garnishee. The first respondent filed the said suit for recovery of a sum of Rs. 17,555-28 from the second respondent herein. Pending the suit, the first respondent obtained an order of attachment of a sum of Rs. 22,000/- due to the second respondent herein, lying in the hands of the petitioner. In the garnishee application, notice was ordered to the petitioner. Since the petitioner did not represent, the order of attachment was made absolute on 29.8.86 Subsequently the petitioner was directed to deposit the amount in Court by order dated 23.12.86 which was not complied with. Thereafter the suit was decreed and the first respondent tiled E.P 80/88 seeking a direction, directing the petitioner herein to deposit the decree amount from out of the attached amount, lying with the petitioner. The said petition was dismissed by the Executing Court on the ground that without an order of attachment under Order 21, Rule 46 C.P.C and without issuing notice under Order 21, Rule 46A of C.P.C the petitioner herein cannot be directed to deposit the amount. The Executing Court dismissed the said E.P by order dated 1.12.89 As against the same, the first respondent herein filed an appeal in C.M.A 44/90 on the file of District Court, Madurai. The First Additional Judge, by his order dated 23.8.91 has allowed the appeal and directed the petitioner to deposit the decree amount into Court. Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner preferred this revision.

    2. Mrs. P. Bhagayalakshmi, the learned counsel for the petitioner contended that an order directing the petitioner to deposit the amount under Order 21, Rule 46B of C.P.C can be passed after issue of notice to the garnishee, as contemplated under Order 21, Rule 46A of C.P.C The lower appellate court has proceeded on an assumption that the decree amount is available with the petitioner herein, since the petitioner did not respond to the notices issued in respect of the order of attachment pending the suit. Even though an order of attachment was made pending the suit, the Rules require the notice to be issued under Order 21, Rule 46A of C.P.C before ever the garnishee is directed to deposit the amount. Hence the order of the lower appellate court is liable to be set aside.

    3. Mr. Srinivasan, the learned counsel for the first respondent contended that once an order of attachment is made pending the suit, there is no need to issue a fresh notice under Order 21, Rule 46A of C.P.C The Court is empowered under Order 21, Rule 46B of C.P.C to direct the garnishee to deposit the amount and hence the revision is liable to be dismissed.

    4. I carefully considered the contention of both the counsel. The undisputed facts are that the first respondent filed the suit against the second respondent and obtained an order of attachment pending the suit in respect of the amount lying with petitioner-garnishee. The garnishee did not respond to the notices sent by the Court in the said proceeding. The suit has been decreed and the execution is levied.

    5. The attachment before judgment is governed by the provision of Order 38, Rule 5 of C.P.C Once the order of attachment is made pending the suit, that attachment would continue till the same is raised. Hence mere is no need for the decree holder to seek for fresh order of attachment under Order 21, Rule 46 of C.P.C The attachment is deemed to be in effect and as such the decree holder can proceed against the attached property.

    6. The short question is whether the notice is necessary. The learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the judgment reported in Executive Engineer T.C Division, K.S.E Board v. J.H Sharma (AIR 1988 Kerala 285) wherein a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court, in an identical case, has held as follows:

    “It has to be noticed that R. 46 does not contain any provision enabling the garnishee to raise any objection though it gives opportunity to the garnishee to subject himself to the order by making payment into Court. The next step is provided by R. 46A. He has to be given notice either to pay the amount into Court or to show cause why he should not do so. According to R. 46B, where he fails to pay the amount in Court and also fails to appear and show cause in answer to the notice, the Court may order him to comply with the terms of the notice and on such order execution may issue as though such order were a decree against him. This is the consequence of his failure to respond in terms of the notice under R. 46B. Where he appears and disputes his liability R. 46C requires that the court should decide the question as if it were an issue in a suit and upon the determination of such issue the Court should pass such order as it deems fit. The Court may uphold the contention raised by the garnishee of reject his contention and pass appropriate orders. Such an order is appealable under R. 46H. Thus the scheme of the rules contemplates a specific opportunity being given to the garnishee to show cause why he should not pay the amount into court. If he raises an objection the court has a duty to consider the objection and pass appropriate orders. The rules do not require him to raise an objection sua motu before receiving a show cause notice under R. 46 A. The fact that he did not suo motu file an objection when the attachment was effected before judgment does not take away his right under the above rules to raise an objection.”

    From the above judgment, it is very clear that in spite of the order of attachment pending the suit, the notice under Order 21, Rule 46A of C.P.C is necessary. In case if the garnishee fails to respond to the notice under Order 21, Rule 46A of C.P.C then only the Court is empowered to pass an order under Order 21, Rule 46B of C.P.C But when the garnishee appears and puts forth their objections, the Court has to enquire as to the dispute raised by the garnishee, as contemplated under Order 21, Rule 46C of C.P.C

    7. As held in Alsidass Kaverlal v. J. Hiriya Gowder (1960 II MLJ 561) the prohibitory order issued by the Court will operate to bar the payment to the judgment debtor by the garnishee of all the amounts payable as upto the date of attachment alone. The order will not operate in respect of further earnings of the judgment debtor beyond that date. In such circumstance, it is absolutely necessary that the garnishee should be given an opportunity at the time of execution proceedings to put forth their objections in case if the amount to the extent of the decree debt is not available with them. Since admittedly no notice was served to the petitioner, as contemplated under Order 21, Rule 46A of C.P.C the order of the lower Appellate Court is liable to be set aside.

    8. Since already the matter has been dragged on considerably, I am of the view that it is unnecessary for the lower court to issue notice and follow the formalities. Since the parties are before this court, I set aside the order of the lower Appellate Court in C.M.A 44/90 and restore the E.P 80/88 on the file of the Sub-Court, Madurai for fresh disposal. The petitioner has already filed the objections before the lower Appellate Court. The Executing Court is directed to hear both parties and dispose of the E.P on merits and in accordance with law.

    KA/RR/VCS

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Madurai City Municipal Corporation v. N. Baskara Pandian
    (Feb 4, 1998)