AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 4 of Act 31 of 1978 and Section 5 and Rule 3,
  • Section 4 of the Tamil Nadu Land Acquisition Act.
  • provisions of the Tamil Nadu Act 31 of 1978,
  • sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 4
  • Section 4(2) read with Rule 3
  • sub-section (1) of Section 4
  • sub-section (2) of Section 4
  • Rule 5(11) Form IV
  • Section 4(2)
  • Section 4(1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 4 of Act 31 of 1978 and Section 5 and Rule 3,
  • Section 4 of the Tamil Nadu Land Acquisition Act.
  • provisions of the Tamil Nadu Act 31 of 1978,
  • sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 4
  • Section 4(2) read with Rule 3
  • sub-section (1) of Section 4
  • sub-section (2) of Section 4
  • Rule 5(11) Form IV
  • Section 4(2)
  • Section 4(1)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The main writ petition was taken up for final hearing by consent of both parties. On 23.01.1996 the Court passed an interim order directing the Government Pleader to produce records and granted an interim stay of dispossession until 13.02.1996. The petitioner contended that the mandatory requirement under Section 4(2) of the Tamil Nadu Act 31 of 1978 had not been complied with, and that respondents had proceeded to publish a notification under Section 4(1) in the District Gazette and later issued a notice under Section 5(1) without first issuing the show-cause notice required by Section 4(2).

The records produced in Court showed that Section 4(2) notice had not been issued to the petitioner. The respondents had proceeded to publish the 4(1) notification (Tirunelveli Kattabomman District Gazette No. 14, 3rd page dated 18.8.1995) and an award was passed in proceedings No. A.976/95, 18/95-96 dated 16.10.1995 relating to land in Survey Nos. 195/6 and 196/1 (extents 0.81.0 each). Possession was taken and pattas were issued to several persons on 30.12.1995. The writ petition was filed on 22.01.1996 (with an interim order granted the next day).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the mandatory requirements of Section 4(2) of the Tamil Nadu Act 31 of 1978 (the show-cause notice to owners/persons interested) were complied with before publishing the Section 4(1) Gazette notification.
  2. Whether notices issued under the provisions of the Central Act (or other Acts) can be treated as sufficient notice under Section 4 of the Tamil Nadu Land Acquisition Act (i.e., whether a fresh notice under the State Act was required).
  3. Whether the proceedings (notification under Section 4(1) and subsequent award under the Act) are void for failure to follow the mandatory procedure and, if so, what the consequences are for possession, pattas issued, and the right to compensation.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Section 4(2) of Tamil Nadu Act 31 of 1978 mandatory requirements were not complied with — no show-cause notice was served before the Section 4(1) Gazette notification.
  • The respondents proceeded directly to publish the Gazette notification and issued a notice under Section 5(1) without giving the petitioner the mandatory opportunity to show cause.
  • The action of the respondents in denying the petitioner an opportunity of hearing and failing to issue the Section 4(2) notice was arbitrary, against equity and conscience, and violated principles of natural justice.
  • The petitioner objected in writing on 06.10.1995; notwithstanding this, an order and award were made and compensation proceedings followed.

Respondents' / Government Pleader's Arguments

  • The respondents contended that notices issued under the provisions of the Central Act were sufficient for the purpose of notice under Section 4 of the Tamil Nadu Act and therefore no fresh notice need be issued under Act 31 of 1978.
  • The Government Pleader pointed out that possession had been taken pursuant to the award dated 16.10.1995, pattas had been issued and lands allotted on 30.12.1995, and that the writ petition was filed only on 22.01.1996 (implying delay and that third parties had acquired interests).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
W.P. No. 16934 of 1995 dated 12.12.1995 (N. Loganathan v. The Special Tahsildar, A.D.W Tiruvellore) Court deprecated the practice of treating notices under the Central Act as a substitute for the show-cause notice required by the State Act (i.e., that central notices cannot be treated as sufficient notice under Section 4 of the Tamil Nadu Act). The present Court relied on that prior observation to reject the respondents' contention that no fresh notice under the State Act was necessary, treating that prior decision as supporting the requirement of strict compliance with Section 4(2).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in the following steps, reflecting only the material in the opinion:

  1. Admission by respondents (through Government Pleader) and record production established that the procedure mandated by Tamil Nadu Act 31 of 1978 was not followed: specifically, no notice under Section 4(2) had been issued to the petitioner before publication of the Section 4(1) notification.
  2. The respondents had relied on notices under the Central Act as sufficient for the purposes of notice under the State Act; the Court rejected that approach, referring to prior judicial disapproval (N. Loganathan) of treating central notices as equivalent to the State Act's required notices.
  3. The Court set out and relied on the statutory scheme: Section 4(1) permits the District Collector to publish a Gazette notification of acquisition, but Section 4(2) mandates that before such publication the Collector or an authorized officer "shall call upon the owner or any other person... to show cause why it should not be acquired." Rule 3 further prescribes the procedure for serving the show-cause notice (individual service, registered post to last known address, service on adult male member if necessary, or affixation on outer door).
  4. The Court emphasized the expropriatory nature of the Act and that the opportunity provided by Section 4(2) (the show-cause notice) is the one and only opportunity afforded to the owner/person interested prior to Gazette publication; because the Act is expropriatory, compliance with Section 4(2) and Rule 3 must be strict.
  5. The petitioner argued that the effect of respondents' procedure was arbitrary and violative of natural justice. The Court reiterated established principles that no person should be deprived of rights without reasonable notice and opportunity to be heard and that State action must not be arbitrary, unreasonable or unfair.
  6. The respondents' argument that pattas had been issued and possession taken (and that the petitioner delayed in filing the writ) did not excuse the failure to comply with the mandatory statutory procedure. The Court held the proceedings initiated against the petitioner to be illegal and void because of the failure to comply with Section 4(2).
  7. Although the Court observed the statutory rule under Section 5 that land vests absolutely in the Government from the date of Gazette publication of a Section 4(1) notice, it treated the lack of prior compliance with Section 4(2) as fatal to the validity of the acquisition proceedings affecting the petitioner. The Court noted that because the mandatory show-cause stage was not provided, the acquisition proceedings could not stand.
  8. Given the invalidity of the award and notification, the Court concluded that possession taken and pattas issued pursuant to the illegal award conferred no benefit on those pattadars; consequently respondents were directed to hand back possession of the property to the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

Writ petition allowed; the notification under Section 4(1) and the award were quashed, and respondents were restrained from acquiring the specified land.

Direct effects and orders made by the Court (as stated in the opinion):

  • The notification under Section 4(1) published in Tirunelveli Kattabomman District Gazette No. 14, 3rd page dated 18.8.1995 is quashed (insofar as it relates to the petitioner's land).
  • The award in No. A.976/95, 18/95-96 dated 16.10.1995 relating to Survey Nos. 195/6 and 196/1 (extents 0.81.0 each) is quashed.
  • The respondents are restrained from acquiring the land in those survey numbers pursuant to the quashed 4(1) notification.
  • The respondents must hand back possession of the property to the petitioner; pattas and possession obtained pursuant to the illegal award confer no benefit and do not prevent restoration of possession.
  • The writ petition is allowed and no costs are awarded.

Broader implications: The opinion underscores strict compliance with Section 4(2) and Rule 3 of the Tamil Nadu Act 31 of 1978, rejects substitution of State-required notice by notices under a Central Act, and emphasizes protection of the right to be heard in acquisition proceedings. The opinion does not state that it is laying down a new binding precedent beyond its application in the present facts; it applies existing statutory prescription and earlier judicial disapproval of the practice relied upon by respondents.

Note: This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add information beyond that text.

    S.P Vedanayagam Petitioner v. Secretary, Government Of Tamil Nadu, Madras & Two Others S

    1. By consent of both parties, the main writ petition itself is taken up for final hearing.

    2. On 23.1.1996,I passed the following order after hearing the counsel for the petitioner:

    “It is contended by the petitioner that the mandatory requirements contemplated under Section 4(2) of the Act 31 of 1978 has not been complied with at all and the respondents have straight away proceeded with the publication in the Gazette about the acquisition and issued notice under Sec. 5(1) of the Act. The Government Pleader is directed to produce the records before this Court on the adjourned hearing date, in order to verify whether the statement made by the petitioner is correct or false. Post the Writ Petition for orders on 13.2.1996

    There will be an interim stay of dispossession till 13.2.1996 Notice.”

    3. Today, the learned Government Pleader placed the records before this Court and argued the case on the basis of the instructions received by him. Admittedly, the procedure contemplated under the Provisions of the Act 31 of 1978 has not been followed. The respondents have treated the notices issued under the provisions of the Central Act as sufficient for the purpose of notice under Section 4 of the Tamil Nadu Land Acquisition Act. Without following the procedure provided under the Act 31 of 1978, proposals were sent to the Collector, Tirunelveli. The contention raised on behalf of the respondents that no fresh notice need be issued to the land owners under Act 31 of 1978 and such a notice does not arise in this case, cannot at all be accepted. This Court in W.P No. 16934 of 1995 dated 12.12.1995 (N. Loganathan v. The Special Tahsildar, A.D.W Tiruvellore) depricated such practice. Section 4 of Act 31 of 1978 and Section 5 and Rule 3, which are relevant for the purpose of disposing of this case are extracted below:

    “Section 4: Power to acquire land —

    (1) Where the District Collector is satisfied that for the purpose of any

    Harijan Welfare Scheme, it is necessary to acquire any land, he may acquire the land by publishing in the District Gazette a notice to the effect that he has decided to acquire the land in pursuance of this section.

    (2) Before publishing a notice under sub-section (1), the District Collector or any officer authorised by the District Collector in this behalf, shall call upon the owner or any other person, who, in the opinion of the District Collector or the officer so authorised may be interested in such land, to show cause why it should not be acquired.

    3(a) The District Collector may, where he has himself called upon the owner or other person to show cause under sub-section (2), pass such orders as he may deem fit on the cause so shown;

    (b) Where any officer authorised by the District Collector has called upon the owner or other person to show cause under sub- section (2), the officer so authorised shall make a report to the District Collector containing his recommendations on the cause so shown for the decision of the District Collector. After considering such report the District Collector may pass such orders as he may deem fit.

    Section 5: Land acquired to vest in Government free from all encumbrances — When a notice under sub-section (1) of Section 4 is published in the District Gazette, the land to which the said notice relates shall; on and from the date on which the notice is so published vest absolutely in the Government free from all encumbrances.”

    Rule 3: Procedure for acquiring Land — (i) The District Collector or the Officer authorised by him in this behalf shall serve a show cause notice in Form I under sub-section (2) of Section 4 individually on the owner or on all persons interested in the land to be acquired. If the owner or any other person interested in the land resides elsewhere than where the land is situated, the show cause notice shall be sent by registered post (Acknowledgment Due) to the last known address of the owner or any other person interested.

    (ii) The District Collector, if after passing such orders as required by sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 4 is satisfied that it is necessary to acquire the land, notice in Form II to that effect shall be published in the District Gazette.”

    4. In this case, it is specifically stated that no notice under Section 4(2) of the Act, which is mandatory before 4(1) notification as Section 4(2) of the Act clearly state that before publishing a notice under Section 4(1) of the Act, the district Collector or any Officer authorised by the district Collector in this behalf, shall call upon the owner or any other person who in the opinion of the District Collector or the Officer so authorised, may be interested in such land, to show cause why it should not be acquired. It is also stated by the petitioner that he was shocked to received notice on 25.9.1995 in Form HI under Section 5(1) calling him for enquiry has not followed the mandatory provisions as contemplated in Section 4(2)of the Act. But, however, the respondents have straight away proceeded with the publication in the Gazette about the acquisition and further issued notice under Section 5(1) of the Act. The petitioner on 6.10.1995 gave a written objection to the third respondent and on 16.10.1995 the third respondent passed an order under Rule 5(11) Form IV calling the petitioner's wife to appear and receive the compensation amount. Subsequently on 16.10.1995, the third respondent in proceedings No. A/18/95-96, A976/95 passed an award. Admittedly, the respondents have not followed the mandatory provisions as contemplated under Section 4(2) of the Act. Therefore, as rightly pointed out by Mr. P.H Manoj Pandian, that the action of the respondents in denying the petitioner an opportunity of hearing and not giving a notice under Section 4(2) of the Act is arbitrary and against equity and conscience and that the action of the respondent violates all cannons of natural justice. It is well established principles of law that no person shall be deprived of any right and that no person shall be left unheard resulting in such deprivation. Every person whose rights are affected by State action, must have a reasonable notice of the case he has to meet and must have reasonable opportunity of being heard in his defence. Justice and fairness of State action is the essence of natural justice and State under the statutes and that all State action must be free from the vice of arbitrariness, unreasonableness and unfairness. As pointed out by the learned counsel for the petitioner, when the Government is dealing with the public it cannot act arbitrarily at its sweet will and pleasure. Its action must be in conformity with the standards or norms which is rational. The power of the Government must be confined and structured by rational relevant and non- discriminatory stand or norms. If there is an arbitrary exercise of power or assumption of any arbitrary power either by virtue of a statute or statutory rule or without such statute or statutory rule, the result of such exercise of power or assumption of power will be struck down as void. Therefore, I have no hesitation in setting aside the entire proceedings initiated by the respondents under Section 4(1) of the Act i.e, notification, published in Tirunelveli Kattabomman District Gazette No. 14, 3rd page dated 18.8.1995 and the award passed in No. A. 976/95, 18/95.96, dated 16.10.1995 with respect to the land in Survey No. 195/6, 196/1 to an extent of 0.81.0, 0.81.0 respectively and consequently the respondents are restrained from acquiring the land in S. No. 195/6, 196/1 to an extent of 0.81.0, 0.81.0 hectares, pursuant to the above 4(1) notification.

    5. The learned Government Pleader also produced the records before this Court. The records do not show that notice under Section 4(2) has been issued to the petitioner. At the time of hearing, the Government Pleader brought to my notice that pursuant to the award dated 16.10.1995, possession was taken and the lands were allotted and patta were issued to many persons on 30.12.1995 and that the writ petition has been filed only on 22.1.1996 and the interim order was granted on the next day. The said argument cannot be countenanced at all. As already stated the respondents have violated the mandatory provisions of the Act in acquiring the land belonging to the petitioner. It is already held that the entire proceedings initiated by the respondents in respect of the petitioner are illegal and void and therefore it is null and void. In view of the fact that pattas were issued and the pattadors had taken possession pursuant to the illegal award, it will not any benefit on them. Therefore, respondents have to handover back possession of the property to the petitioner.

    6. Under the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Act 31 of 1978, immediately on the publication of the Gazatte the land vests absolutely with the Government free from all encumbrances under Section 5. As rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for the petitioner, the vesting takes place immediately on the publication of the Gazette and not on taking possession of the land and the title to the property itself will be lost immediately on the publication of the Gazette and there is no question of any enquiry after the publication of the Gazette and before the vesting of the property. Therefore, there is absolutely no opportunity for the land owner to question the acquisition after the issue of the notice under Section 4(1) of the Act.

    7. Under the Act 31 of 1978, the one and the only opportunity given to the land owner or a person interested is on the issue of the show cause notice under Section 4(2) of the Act. The Act being expropriatory in nature and having regard to the vigour of its provisions, the opportunity to show cause why the land should not be acquired should be given, as it is a statutory requirement and the compliance thereof has therefore to be strictly adhered to.

    8. As rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for the petitioner, the show cause notice required to be issued under Section 4(2) read with Rule 3 is mandatory and therefore should strictly complied with. Rule 3 as stated already requires individual notice to be served and every attempt has to be made to serve the show cause notice individually on the owner or the person interested and if for any reason, individual notice could not be served as the person cannot be found, the service may be made on any adult male member of his family residing with him and if no such adult male member is found, notice may be served by fixing the copy on the outer door of the house in which the person therein named ordinarily dwells or carries on business.

    9. Therefore, the notification under Section 4(1) of the Act published in Tirunelveli Kattabomman District Gazette No. 14, 3rd page, dated 18.8.1995 and the award passed in No. A. 976/95, 18/95.96, dated 16.10.1995 with respect to land in Survey No. 195/6,196/1 to an extent of 0.81.0,0.81.0 are quashed. The writ petition is allowed. No costs.

    ALS/VP

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S.P Vedanayagam Petitioner v. Secretary, Government Of Tamil Nadu, Madras & Two Others S
    (Feb 13, 1996)