AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sec. 132-A of the Tamil Nadu District Municipalities Act, 1920 (hereinafter referred to as the Act),
  • Clause (b) of sub section (2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sec. 132-A of the Tamil Nadu District Municipalities Act, 1920 (hereinafter referred to as the Act),
  • Clause (b) of sub section (2)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal against the order dated 15-9-1994 passed by the learned single Judge in W.P. No. 16260 of 1994. The petitioner, Pudukottai Municipality Tax Payers' Sangam, sought quashing of Notification No. NaKa.E2/8240/94 dated 19-7-1994, which was published in the newspaper "Daily Thanthi" (the opinion records publication dates of 21-7-1994 in one paragraph and 27-7-1994 in another). The Notification provided that a resident of Pudukottai seeking water-supply pipe connection must deposit Rs. 2,000 if the connection was for domestic purposes, Rs. 4,000 if for factory purposes, and Rs. 6,000 if for a commercial complex.

The petitioner's contention was that under Section 132-A of the Tamil Nadu District Municipalities Act, 1920 (the Act), the municipal council may demand security deposit only by virtue of by-laws framed under the Act, and that the existing by-laws of Pudukottai Municipality do not provide for such security deposits. The Municipality acknowledged that amended by-laws proposing the security deposits had been prepared and submitted to the State Government but had not yet been approved or published; the Municipality nevertheless sought to require deposits pending that approval.

The appeal was admitted and heard for final disposal. The single Judge had upheld the Municipality's actions on the basis that the water-supply scheme was assisted by the World Bank and that funds (and interest obligations) required the Municipality to raise deposits; the Division Bench, presided by K.A. Swamy, CJ, considered and reversed that view.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in the absence of an operative by-law under Section 132-A (and related provisions) of the Tamil Nadu District Municipalities Act, 1920, the Municipality is entitled to demand security deposits from residents seeking water-supply connections.
  2. Whether a Notification that invites residents to apply for water-supply connections subject to payment of specified security deposits during the period when amended by-laws are pending approval is valid and enforceable.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Section 132-A of the Act contemplates that matters relating to payment for water supplied are to be regulated by by-laws; unless by-laws prescribe security deposits, the Municipality has no authority to demand such deposits.
  • The existing by-laws of Pudukottai Municipality do not provide for security deposits; therefore the Notification demanding deposits is invalid.

Municipality's Arguments

  • The Municipality submitted proposed amendments to the by-laws fixing the security deposits; these proposed by-laws have been submitted to the State Government but are not yet approved.
  • The Notification (dated 19-7-1994) did not strictly insist that residents must make the security deposit; it invited applications for connection with the stated deposit amounts pending approval, leaving the matter to residents' discretion.
  • The learned single Judge relied on the Municipality's submission that the water-supply scheme was undertaken with World Bank assistance and that funds (including interest obligations) were required to implement the scheme, supporting the Municipality's insistence on deposits during the interregnum.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the statutory scheme of the Act, particularly Section 132-A and related provisions (Sections 131, 132, 306, and Section 310(1) and (2)). It noted:

  • Section 132-A prescribes that payment for water supplied under Sections 131 and 132 shall be made on such basis, at such times, and on such conditions as may be laid down in by-laws made by the municipal council; subsections delineate permissible subjects of by-laws (e.g., maximum free allowance, rates, charge based on number of taps).
  • Although Section 132-A does not explicitly mention "security deposit," a municipal council can be presumed to have the power to ensure payment (which could include demanding security deposits), but that power can be validly exercised only when by-laws authorizing such demand are in force.
  • Section 310(1) provides that no by-law, cancellation, or alteration has effect until approved and confirmed by the State Government; Section 310(2) provides that a confirmed by-law is to be published in the district gazette in English and comes into operation three months after such publication. Thus, a proposed amendment does not become operative merely by submission to the State Government.
  • Because the amended by-laws had not been approved, confirmed, and published as required, there was, as of the time of the opinion, no operative by-law empowering the Pudukottai Municipality to insist on security deposits.
  • The Municipality's contention that the Notification did not "insist" on deposits was rejected as impractical: the court observed that the Municipality would not entertain applications for water-supply connection unless accompanied by the necessary security deposit, thereby effectively compelling residents to pay despite the absence of operative by-laws. Given that water is a necessity, it is unreasonable to expect residents to defer seeking connection until by-laws became operative; this coercive effect rendered the insistence invalid.
  • The court disagreed with the learned single Judge's view that the Municipality's financial needs (including World Bank assistance and interest payments) justified demanding deposits in the absence of operative by-laws.
  • The court nonetheless held that once the amended by-laws are duly confirmed by the State Government, published in the district gazette, and come into operation, residents who have obtained water-supply connections would be liable to make the security deposit as prescribed in those by-laws, irrespective of whether the connection had been given prior to the coming into operation of the amended by-laws.

Holding and Implications

Writ Appeal (W.A. No. 1208 of 1994) allowed; the order dated 15-9-1994 of the learned single Judge in W.P. No. 16260 of 1994 is set aside; the Writ Petition is allowed to the extent indicated.

Immediate effect on the parties:

  • The Notification issued by Pudukottai Municipality bearing No. Na.Ka.E2/8240/94 dated 19-7-1994 and published in "Daily Thanthi" (dated in the record as 21-7-1994 and 27-7-1994 in different paragraphs) is quashed insofar as it requires residents to make security deposits for seeking water-supply connections while the amended by-laws are not yet operative.
  • Once the amended by-laws are confirmed by the State Government, published in the district gazette, and come into operation, all persons who have obtained water-supply connections will be liable to make the security deposit as prescribed by those by-laws, even if their connections were given before the by-laws came into force.
  • There will be no order as to costs in the facts and circumstances of the case.

Broader implications: The decision confines the Municipality's power to demand security deposits to situations where the requisite by-laws are validly in force; it does not purport to lay down any broader precedent beyond the statutory interpretation and the direct effect on the parties in this case.

    Pudukottai Municipality Tax Payers' v. The Commr., Pudukottai Municipality

    K.A Swamy, CJ.

    At the stage of admission, the respondent Municipality was notified and, accordingly, it is represented through a learned counsel. As the appeal lies in a narrow compass, it is admitted and heard for final disposal.

    2. This appeal is preferred against the order dated 15-9-1994, passed by the learned single Judge in W.P No. 16260 of 1994. The petitioner - Pudukottai Municipality Tax Payers' Sangam has sought for quashing the Notification bearing No. NaKa.E2/8240/94 dated 19-7-1994, published in ‘Daily Thanthi’ newspaper dated 21-7-1994. According to the terms of the said Notification, a resident of Pudukottai, who wants to have water supply pipe connection, shall deposit a sum of Rs. 2000/-, if the connection is for domestic purpose, Rs. 4,000/- if the connection is for factory purpose and Rs. 6,000/- if the connection is for commercial complex. The contention of the petitioner is that as per Sec. 132-A of the Tamil Nadu District Municipalities Act, 1920 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’), unless the by-laws are framed, prescribing the amount of security deposit to be made by the consumers, of water, the Municipality is not entitled to demand security deposit, that as no such by-law has been framed, it is not open to the Pudukottai Municipality to demand security deposit from the consumers. It is not disputed before us that the by-laws framed by the Pudukottai Municipality do not provide for making security deposit for giving water supply connection. Of course, it is submitted by learned counsel appearing for the Municipality, that the by-laws are proposed to be amended and, according to the proposed amendment, the aforesaid security deposits for various categories of consumers are fixed for giving water-supply connection. But those by-laws, which have been submitted to the State Government, have not yet been approved as such, the same have not come into force. It is submitted that though the by-laws would come into force as and when the State Government approves them and are published in the Gazette, the security deposit is demanded during the interregnum.

    3. Sub-section (1) of Sec. 132-A of the Act specifically provides that “for all water supplied under section 131 or under section 132, payment shall be made on such basis, at such times, and on such conditions as may be laid down in the by-laws made by the Council and shall be recoverable in the same manner as the property-tax.” Clause (a) of Sub-section (2) further provides that the by-laws may in cases of supply for domestic consumption and use, lay down the maximum free allowance to be made and the rates of charge to be levied in respect of water supplied in excess of such allowance.” Clause (b) of sub section (2) further provides that the by-laws may “in cases of supply whether for domestic consumption and use or for other purposes, or any class of such cases, lay down that the charge for water supplied shall be based on the number of the taps allowed, irrespective of the quantity of water consumed.”

    4. Though the provisions contained in Sec. 132-A of the Act do not specifically mention about the security deposit, as the municipal Council has to ensure payment of the water bills promptly made according to the water consumed, we can presume that such a power vests in the Municipal Council under section 132-A of the Act to demand security deposit, but such power cannot be exercised unless by-laws are framed. Sec. 131 and Sec. 132, which are referred to in Sec. 132-A of the Act, relate to private water supply for consumption and domestic use and powers of executive authority to enforce provision of water-supply and power of executive authority to supply water for non-domestic purposes respectively. Sec. 306 of the Act relates to power of Council to make by-laws on the subjects mentioned therein. Sec. 310(1) of the Act provides that “no by-laws or cancellation or alteration of a by-law shall have effect until the same shall have been approved and confirmed by the State Government.” Sub-section (2) thereof provides that “any by-law cancellation or alteration of a by-law when it shall have been duly confirmed shall be published in district gazette in English and shall come into operation three months after it have been so published.” Therefore, it is clear, that even though amendment to the existing by-laws may be in process, but the amended by-law cannot become operative until the same approved is by the State Government, and published in the district gazette in English and three months time expires after it have been so published. Thus, as on today, there is no by-law operating, which empowers the Pudukottai Municipality to insist for making security deposit.

    5. It is further pointed out by learned counsel for Municipality, that the Notification dated 19-7-1994, which is sought to be quashed by the petitioner, also does not insist that residents of Pudukottai Municipality seeking water-supply connection must make a security deposit. It only states that those who want to have the water-supply connection pending approval of the amended by-laws and publication of the same in the gazette, may make an application for water-supply connection with the amount of security deposit as stated in the Notification. Therefore, it is left to the discretion of the residents of the Municipality. It is not possible to appreciate this contention as it is not in dispute that application for water-supply connection will not be entertained by the municipality unless the same is accompanied by the necessary security deposit. Water is a necessity. Therefore, one must necessarily seek for water supply connection. In a city or town one cannot live without a proper water supply. Therefore, it is preposterous to expect a resident within the Municipal limits to postpone to have, or not to seek for, water supply connection until the bye-laws come into operation. In other words, it is nothing but compelling them to make security deposits and seek water supply connection. Such of law as the bye-laws as on today do not provide for it. Therefore, without the proposed amendment to the bye-law becoming operative the insistence of the Municipality to make security deposit cannot be approved as valid and lawful.

    5-A We are of the view that once the amended by-law comes into operation residents of Pudukottai who have obtained the water-supply connection from the Municipality would be liable to make the security deposit as prescribed in the amended bye-law whether such connection has been given prior to the coming into operation of the by-laws. As such the Municipality would not be put to any loss by giving water supply connection pending the confirmation of the proposed amendment to the bye-laws without insisting for security deposit made by every consumer of water supplied by the Municipality after the amended bye-law becomes operative irrespective of whether the water supply connection was given earlier to coming into force of the amended bye-law.

    6. Learned single Judge, however, has taken a view that the Municipality has undertaken the water-supply scheme with the assistance of the world Bank and it has to pay interest on the amount borrowed and also that the funds are required to implement the scheme. Since amendment to the bye-laws is under process the Municipality cannot be held to have acted without the authority of law in insisting for security deposit. In the light of the provisions contained in Sec. 132-A and Sec. 310 (1) and (2) of the Act, we find it difficult to agree with the view of the learned single Judge.

    7. For the reasons stated above, the Writ Appeal (W.A No. 1208 of 1994) is allowed. The order dated 15-9-1994 passed by the learned single Judge in W.P 16260 of 1994 is set aside. The Writ Petition 16260 of 1994 is allowed in the following terms:

    The Notification issued by the Pudukottai Municipality bearing No. Na.Ka.E2/8240/94 dated 19-7-1994 published in ‘Daily Thanthi’ newspaper, dated 27.7.1994 in so far as it requires the residents of Pudukottai Municipality to make security deposit for seeking water-supply connection from the Municipality is quashed. It is, however, made clear that once the amended by-laws are confirmed by the State Government and the same are published in the district gazette, and come into operation, all those who have obtained water-supply connection from the Municipality would be liable to make the security deposit as prescribed in the amended bye-laws, irrespective of the fact that such connections have been given earlier to the coming into operation of the amended by-laws. In the facts and circumstances of the case, there will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pudukottai Municipality Tax Payers' v. The Commr., Pudukottai Municipality
    (Oct 17, 1994)