Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal was preferred by petitioners Kanniammal and Subbulu Reddy against an award dated 22-9-1981 in M.O.P. No. 371 of 1980 from the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (Addl. Sub Judge II), Chengalpattu. The petitioners claimed compensation under Section 110-A of the Motor Vehicles Act for the death of their son Ramesh, who died in a lorry accident on 13-7-1980 while travelling in lorry APC 8569. The appellants alleged the lorry had been driven rashly and negligently and sought Rs. 40,000 by way of compensation.

The respondents (the 1st respondent as owner of the lorry and the 2nd respondent as the insurer) denied rashness/negligence and contended the deceased was an unauthorised traveller; they also challenged aspects of age, occupation and heirship. The Tribunal framed two points for consideration: (1) whether the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the lorry, and (2) to what relief, if any, the petitioners were entitled. The Tribunal found that the accident was caused by rash and negligent driving by the driver (RW1) but nevertheless dismissed the petitioners' claim and awarded no compensation. The present opinion is the appellate court's consideration of that Tribunal award.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the lorry of the first respondent.
  2. To what relief, if any, the petitioners are entitled.
  3. Whether the owner of the vehicle is vicariously liable for the tortious act of the driver.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The Tribunal did not properly appreciate the evidence and its award is erroneous.
  • The Tribunal, having held that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving by the driver (RW1), erred in rejecting the appellants' claim for compensation.
  • The owners' and driver's versions were contradictory and ought to have led the Tribunal to reject the respondents' case.
  • The Tribunal failed to follow precedent decisions (G Dhyanand v. Zaamni Bi and New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Shakuben), and the extra premium shown on the policy ought to have been taken into account per the ratio in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Shakuben.
  • The appellants relied on a later decision (United India Insurance Co., Trichy v. Dhanalakshmi and Ors.) and on Rule 261 of the Motor Vehicles Rules to contend that the claim fell within the policy coverage, including non-fare paying passengers.

2nd Respondent (Insurance Company) — Arguments

  • If an unauthorised person is given a lift in a goods vehicle and is injured or killed, between the insurance company and the employer/owner the insurance company is not liable but the owner may be liable to pay compensation (as argued by the insurer's counsel).
  • The insurer pointed out that the driver had not authorised the deceased to board the lorry and that the deceased carried two chairs; evidence suggested payment for the lift (PW2 paid Rs. 3 and stated the deceased paid fare), supporting the respondents' case that travel was unauthorised.

1st Respondent (Owner) — Arguments

  • The owner denied authorising the driver (RW1) to take any passenger in the goods vehicle.
  • There was no evidence of tacit permission by the owner for anyone to travel in the goods vehicle; the owner had not been examined but his counter-affidavit denied authorisation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
G Dhyanand v. Zaamni Bi (1982 ACJ 399) Appellants contended that the Tribunal had not followed this decision (precise principle not detailed in the opinion text). The appellants relied on this decision; the court noted the reliance but confirmed the Tribunal's findings and dismissed the claim (the opinion does not record that the court applied the decision to alter the outcome).
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Shakuben (1986 ACJ 778) Invoked by appellants regarding the ratio on treating an extra premium and on policy coverage (appellants argued the extra premium of Rs. 18.75 should be considered). The appellants relied on this decision and asked the court to consider the extra premium; the court recorded the reliance but ultimately upheld the Tribunal's dismissal and did not award compensation (the opinion does not indicate application of the precedent to grant relief).
United India Insurance Co., Trichy v. Dhanalakshmi and 5 Ors. (C.M.A. No.122 of 1982 dated 31-8-1987) Appellants relied on this Court's decision to contend that the appellants' claim fell under Rule 261 of the Motor Vehicles Rules. The appellants relied on the judgment to argue coverage for the claim; the court noted the reliance but, based on its analysis of the facts and authorisation, dismissed the appeal and did not award compensation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first reviewed the testimonial and documentary evidence accepted by the Tribunal, including evidence from PW1 (the 2nd petitioner Subbulu Reddy), PW2 (Munuswamy), RW1 (Venkatarama Reddy, the driver), and documentary exhibits (school certificate, higher secondary certificate, transfer certificate, certified copy of charge sheet, and true copy of the insurance policy).

On the central factual question of how the deceased came to be travelling in the lorry, the evidence was inconsistent: the driver (RW1) said the deceased had asked to be taken to Madras bus but the driver refused; PW1 testified the deceased got permission from the cleaner; PW2 said the deceased boarded at about 6 p.m. and that both PW2 and the deceased were allowed to travel in the lorry along with their luggage. The Tribunal found the driver's version false and concluded the deceased and PW2 had been allowed to travel in the lorry and that the deceased should have been given a lift for consideration.

The Tribunal also found the accident was caused by the rash and negligent driving of the lorry by RW1; the appellate court confirmed this finding of negligence.

The court then turned to vicarious liability and policy coverage: it analysed whether the owner is vicariously liable for the driver's tort. The owner had denied authorising the driver to take any passenger. The court reasoned that a goods vehicle is intended for transporting goods and that only the crew (including the cleaner) is ordinarily permitted to travel with the load; giving a lift to private passengers in a goods vehicle was held to be outside the scope of the driver's employment. The court found no evidence of owner authorisation — neither express nor tacit — permitting passengers in the goods vehicle.

On the basis that the deceased was travelling unauthorisedly (and the finding that the deceased ought to have paid for the lift), the court concluded the owner and the insurer could not be held liable under vicarious liability principles and under the terms of the policy as argued in the record.

The court also addressed whether the driver himself could be made liable. The court concluded that the deceased's act of entering the lorry as an unauthorised passenger was an illegal act which invited the risk of death; accordingly, the court held that the driver could not be made liable either.

Although the court proceeded to compute quantum by applying a multiplier of 20 (for an 18-year-old deceased, assumed earning potential and contribution), resulting in a calculated compensatory figure of Rs. 32,000 after deductions, the court expressly ruled that no person (owner, insurer or driver) could be held liable to pay that amount given the factual findings on authorisation and illegality of the deceased's act.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed; no compensation is awarded to the appellants.

Implications:

  • The court affirmed the Tribunal's finding that the accident was caused by the rash and negligent driving of the driver (RW1) but nonetheless held that the appellants were not entitled to compensation because the deceased travelled as an unauthorised passenger in a goods vehicle.
  • On the question of vicarious liability, the court held that neither the owner nor the insurer could be made liable because there was no authorisation (express or tacit) for the deceased to travel in the goods vehicle.
  • The court also found that the driver could not be held liable because the deceased's unauthorised entry into the lorry was an illegal act that invited the risk — consequently, no person was made liable to pay compensation.
  • The court calculated a compensatory amount (Rs. 32,000) based on assumed future earnings and a multiplier, but explicitly ruled that this amount could not be directed to be paid by any party under the facts of this case.
  • There is no discussion in the opinion of any broader legal innovation or new precedent being established; the decision's direct effect is to dismiss the appeal and to leave the parties without an award. The court made no order as to costs.

This summary is prepared exclusively from the text of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond what the opinion expressly states.

    Kanniammal And Anr. v. Prabhakar And Anr.

    1. This Appeal coming on for bearing on Thursday the 24th day of September 1987 and Thursday the 22nd day of October, 1987 upon perusing the petition of Appeal, the order of the Lower Court, and the material papers in the case, and upon hearing the arguments of Mr. G. Desappan, Advocate for the Appellants and of Mr. P.N. Prakash, Advocate for the 1st respondent and of Mr. V.R. Gopalan, Advocate for the 2nd respondent, and having stood over for consideration till this day, the Court made the following order.

    2. This is an appeal preferred by the petitioners Kanniammal and Subbulu Reddy against the award dated 22-9-1981 in M.O.P. No. 371 of 1980 on the file of the learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, (Addl. Sub Judge II), Chengalpattu.

    3. The case of the appellants before the Tribunal in short is as follows : The deceased Ramesh was the son of the appellants. The deceased was travelling in the lorry APC 8569 on 13-7-1980, accompanying the goods transported. Near Pallipet the said lorry was driven in a rash and negligent manner and caused the accident. As a result of the same., the deceased Ramesh died. The deceased boy was aged about 18 years and was hale and healthy. He had passed P.U.C. and was trying to get a seat in Degree classes. He was a bright student. The 1st respondent being the owner of the vehicle and the 2nd respondent being the Insurer of the same are vicariously and statutorily liable to compensate the petitioners. Hence the appellants filed the petition under Section 110-A of the Motor Vehicles Act praying to pass an award of Rs. 40,000/- being the compensation amount on account of the death of the petitioners' son Ramesh in the Motor Vehicle accident on 13-7-1980.

    4. The respondents 1 and 2 filed separate counters denying rashness or negligence on the part of the driver of the vehicle of the 1st respondent. They would further contend that the deceased was an unauthorised traveller. The lorry was driven very slowly and cautiously by its driver, while the lorry was about to pass a curve, another lorry loaded with hay was seen coming from the opposite direction with terrific speed. There was no space at all for the lorry of the 1st respondent to pass through and the driver in his attempt to avoid the collision between the 1st respondent's lorry and the lorry on the opposite side, swerved to the right since the lorry from the opposite direction was occupying the entire road on the left and hence the lorry of the 1st respondent capsized. Further the age of the deceased, his occupation and the heir ship of the petitioners are denied.

    5. On these allegations and contentions, the Tribunal has framed the following points for consideration.

    (1) Whether the accident has taken place due to the rash and negligent driving of the lorry of the first respondent.

    (2) To what relief if any, the petitioners are entitled?

    6. On a consideration of the oral evidence of the 2nd petitioner Subbulu Reddy as PW 1 and Munuswamy, PW 2 as well as the evidence of Venkatarama Reddy, RW 1 and the documentary evidence, namely Ex. A-1 S.S.L.C. Book relating to the deceased Change Ramesh; Ex. A-2 Higher Secondary Course Certificate of Change Ramesh; Ex. A-3 dated 9-7-1980, Transfer Certificate; and Ex. A-4 dated 29-11-1980 certified copy of Charge Sheet against the lorry driver APC 8569 by the Inspector of Police, Tiruttani as well as Ex. B-1 True Copy of Policy in the name of Thur Venkatesan Chetty No. 13605/24/1/100800, the Tribunal found on point No. 1 that the accident bad taken place only due to the rash and negligent driving of the lorry by RW 1 and on point No. 2, the Tribunal held that the petitioners will not be entitled to any compensation and dismissed the claim petition. Hence, the appeal.

    7. It is contended by Mr. S. Desappan, learned Counsel for the appellants that the Tribunal had not properly appreciated the evidence and as such the award is wrong. It is further contended that the Tribunal having held that the accident had taken place only due to rash and negligent driving of the lorry by RW 1, erred in rejecting the claim of the appellants herein. According to the learned Counsel for the appellants, the Tribunal ought to have rejected the case of the respondents in view of the contradictory versions given by the owner of the lorry, and the driver of the lorry. It is also contended that the decision in G Dhyanand v. Zaamni Bi 1982 ACJ 399 and the decision in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Shakuben 1986 ACJ 778 were not followed by the Tribunal. It is also pointed out that so far as the extra premium paid in the instant case is concerned, namely Rs. 18.75 as per Ex. B-1, that ought to have been taken into consideration in the light of the ratio decidendi in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Shakuben 1986 ACJ 778 Learned Counsel for the appellants also relied on the judgment in C.M.A. No. 122 of 1982 dated 31st August, 1987, United India Insurance Co., Trichy. v. Dhanalakshmi and 5 Ors. (supra) rendered by this Court in support of his contention that the Tribunal having held that the accident has taken place only due to the rash and negligent driving of the lorry by RW 1, erred in rejecting the claim of the appellants herein and that the claim made by the appellants herein squarely comes under Rule 261 of the Motor Vehicles Rules. According to him under Ex. P-1 policy the risk is covered even with respect to non-fare paying passengers.

    8. Mr. V.R. Gopalan, learned Counsel for the Insurance Company submitted that if a driver of a goods vehicle unauthorised gives lift to a person and the said person sustains injury on account of accident, then as between the Insurance Company and the employer, the Insurance Company is not liable, but the owner of the vehicle is liable to pay the compensation. In the instant case, it is pointed out by the learned Counsel for the Insuranee Company that the driver of the vehicle had not authorised the deceased to get into the lorry. What is more, it is pointed out that the deceased was carrying two chairs along with him in the said lorry during the time of the occurrence. It is also pointed out that PW 2 who was also travelling along with the deceased in the lorry at the time of the accident carrying coconut thatches in the said lorry had paid a sum of Rs. 3/- for giving a life to him. PW 2 specifically states that the deceased also paid fare for travelling in the lorry. But the case of the appellants is that the deceased was travelling in the lorry APC 8569 on 13-7-1980 accompanying the goods transported.

    9. Now I shall go through the evidence as to how the appellants' son happened to travel in the lorry of question at the time of the accident; According to PW 2, the deceased boy got into the lorry at about 6 p.m. at Medium village to go to his village Ekambarakuppam. The lorry which was involved in the accident was carrying two granite stones, each weighing four tones. The cleaner of the lorry was seated on the load. RW1 the driver of the lorry would state that he stopped the lorry for filling water in the radiator about 3 miles away from Pallipattu and the deceased boy at that place wanted to get into the lorry to go to Madras bus, but he refused. According to PW 1, the deceased boy got into the lorry by getting permission from the cleaner of the lorry. But the Tribunal had rightly held that this contention of the driver is false and came to the conclusion that PW 2 and the deceased Ramesh had been allowed to travel in the lorry along with their luggages. From the above evidence, the Tribunal proceeded to hold that the deceased should have been given a lift for consideration. The Tribunal had also held that the accident had occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the vehicle, by RW 1. I confirm this finding of the Tribunal.

    10. The next question is whether the owner is vicariously liable for the tortious act of the driver.

    11. In this case, the owner has been given notice and on his behalf Mr. P.N. Prakash, learned Counsel appeared. According to him, the owner of the lorry in question had not authorised the driver RW 1 to take any passenger in the vehicle. A careful scrutiny of the evidence available on record shows that the deceased did pay some amount towards his travel in the lorry in question along with his two wooden chairs. I find that giving a lift to a person or two persons in a goods vehicle by the driver is outside the scope of his employment. The goods vehicle is only intended for transporting goods and as such it is only the crew including the cleaner can travel in the lorry during the transit of the goods. In the instant case, though the owner of the vehicle had not been examined, yet it is relevant to note in this connection the specific contention of the first respondent in his counter that be had not authorised the driver of the lorry to take any one as a passenger. There is nothing on record to show that there was even tacit permission on the part of the owner authorising the driver to take any person as a passenger in the goods vehicle. Thus the irresistible conclusion that can be arrived at on the basis of the evidence on record in this case , is that the deceased Ramesh was taken in the lorry unauthorisedly by the driver as a passenger and as such the claim of the appellants cannot be upheld. Further there is nothing on record to snow that the deceased was travelling in the lorry APC 8569 on 13-7-1987, accompanying the goods transported. Under the circumstances, neither the owner of the lorry in question nor the Insurance Company can be made liable. So the Tribunal is correct in having dismissed the claim petition finding that the appellants are not entitled to an y compensation.

    12. Coming to the quantum, let us use the multiplier of 20. The deceased was aged 18 years at the time of his death as disclosed from the evidence. He would have lived at least unto 55 years. He was hale and healthy. He had passed P.U.C. The deceased could have easily earned Rs. 300/- per mensem. It is true that there is no evidence to show that the deceased was employed at the time of his death. But in future he would certainly get a job. Taking Rs. 300/- as his monthly income, he would have contributed to his family at least Rs. 200/- per mensem. Calculating on this basis, the total amount comes to Rs. 48,000/-. Deducting one-third for this lump sum payment, the balance comes to Rs. 32,000/-. In case of the appellants are entitle to compensation, they would be entitled to Rs. 32,000 as compensation.

    13. In the instant case, we have ruled out the liability on the part of the owner of the vehicle as well as the Insurance Company. Whether the driver can be made liable is the question which confronts this Court. This Court is of the view that even the driver in the instant case is not liable because it has not been proved that the deceased travelled in the lorry authorisedly. In the instant case, the driver had not been allowed to take any passenger. The driver had been prohibited from taking any person in the lorry in question. Under the circumstances, entering into the lorry either with the knowledge of the driver or without his knowledge and with the consent of the cleaner as a passenger is illegal, exterior causal non-orltor action. It is by the very illegal act of the deceased, namely entering into the lorry as a passenger, that he had invited his death. Therefore nobody can be blammed. Under the circumstances, even the driver of the lorry cannot be mulcted with the liability. Therefore the amount arrived at as compensation cannot be directed to be given by anyone to the appellants herein.

    14. In the result, the appeal is dismissed, but under the circumstances, there is no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kanniammal And Anr. v. Prabhakar And Anr.
    (Oct 13, 1987)