AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • rule 6(c)(i) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Rules, 1959 (hereinafter referred
  • section 34 of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959,
  • rule 9(f) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Rules, 1963.
  • rule 6(c)(i) of the Rules.2.
  • rule 6(c)(i) of the Rules
  • rule 5(1)(g)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • rule 6(c)(i) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Rules, 1959 (hereinafter referred
  • section 34 of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959,
  • rule 9(f) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Rules, 1963.
  • rule 6(c)(i) of the Rules.2.
  • rule 6(c)(i) of the Rules
  • rule 5(1)(g)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Delivered by Ratnam, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant is a dealer in blue-metal jelly who sold material obtained from its quarry. For the assessment year 1974-75 the appellant reported a total turnover of Rs. 9,67,244.31 in its monthly A-2 returns and claimed an exemption/deduction in respect of transport charges amounting to Rs. 2,09,168.56.

The assessing authority, after calling for accounts, refixed the total and taxable turnover at Rs. 10,15,711, rejecting the appellant's claim under rule 6(c)(i) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Rules, 1959 on the ground that blue-metal was delivered at the buyer's site and the sale price included prior-incurred transport charges.

The appellant appealed to the Appellate Assistant Commissioner, producing books of account and affidavits from customers asserting that supply price and transport charges were separately agreed and charged. The departmental representative verified records and reported confirmation of the appellant's oral contracts. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner found an agreement establishing separate, specified transport charges and deducted those charges, refixing total and taxable turnovers at Rs. 9,82,505 and Rs. 7,73,236 respectively.

Acting suo motu under section 34 of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, the Board of Revenue proposed to restore inclusion of transport charges amounting to Rs. 2,13,454 and called for the appellant's objections. The Board relied upon an order book it stated the dealer maintained and applied an earlier Madras High Court decision (Rajasthan Trading Corporation) to conclude the contract was a consolidated one for delivery at site inclusive of transport charges; consequently it included Rs. 2,13,454 in taxable turnover.

The appellant challenged the Board's order before this Court. The Court reviewed the documentary materials (affidavits, bill books, invoices, a specimen bill dated 30th April 1974) and the parties' legal submissions and rendered the judgment summarized below.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, for the assessment year in question, the transport charges collected by the appellant can be deducted from taxable turnover under rule 6(c)(i) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Rules, 1959 — i.e., whether the transport charge formed part of the price of goods sold or represented a separate bargain charged independently.
  2. Whether the Board of Revenue, exercising suo motu revisional powers under section 34 of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, was correct in restoring the inclusion of transport charges in the appellant's taxable turnover.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant submitted that normally blue-metal was delivered ex-quarry; when delivery at site was requested, the cost of blue-metal and the transport charges were specified and charged separately, and therefore rule 6(c)(i) allowed deduction of transport charges from taxable turnover.
  • The appellant produced affidavits from buyers asserting separate payment for transport charges and relied on specimen bills and invoices showing transport charged and shown separately (i.e., not included in price of goods).
  • Reliance was placed by the appellant on several decisions including Gordon Woodroffe & Co. v. State of Tamil Nadu; R. Balakrishna Brick Works v. State of Tamil Nadu; Ramco Cement Distribution Co. v. State of Tamil Nadu; and Vadivel Mudaliar & Sons v. State of Tamil Nadu.

Respondent / Board of Revenue's Arguments

  • The learned Additional Government Pleader argued the transaction was a composite one (a single contract) for supply of blue-metal by delivery at the buyer's site, and thus transport charges formed part of the price and could not be excluded under rule 6(c)(i).
  • The Board relied on the dealer's order book to show that sale was complete upon delivery at the site at a particular per-unit rate inclusive of transport, and invoked the Madras High Court decision in State of Tamil Nadu v. Rajasthan Trading Corporation (T.C No. 306 of 1971) to support inclusion of transport charges.
  • The respondent also relied on judgments such as Tungabhadra Industries Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer (11 STC 827 (SC)), Dyer Meakin Breweries Ltd. v. State of Kerala (26 STC 248 (SC)), and State of Tamil Nadu v. Parry & Company (38 STC 122) to resist the deduction claimed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gordon Woodroffe and Company (Madras) Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Tamil Nadu, [1979] 44 STC 485 Cited by the appellant in support of the claim for deduction of transport charges. The Court noted the appellant relied on this authority but stated it was not necessary to elaborate upon the cases relied on by the appellant in view of the factual findings. The Court did not expressly base its decision on this case in the written reasoning.
R. Balakrishna Brick Works v. The State Of Tamil Nadu, [1982] 49 STC 251 Cited by the appellant in support of the deduction claim. As with other appellant-cited authorities, the Court observed these were relied on but did not find it necessary to elaborate on them given the factual evaluation; the decision turned on facts and rule 6(c)(i) application.
Ramco Cement Distribution Company (P.) Ltd. v. State of Tamil Nadu, [1982] 51 STC 171 Cited by the appellant in support of its position. The Court did not specifically analyze or adopt this authority in its reasoning, indicating factual findings made the detailed discussion of these cases unnecessary.
Vadivel Mudaliar and Sons v. State of Tamil Nadu, [1983] 52 STC 189 Cited by the appellant in support of the deduction claim. The Court recorded reliance by the appellant but did not elaborate on this precedent in its judgment; the outcome was reached on the documentary facts and rule 6(c)(i) requirements.
State of Tamil Nadu by the Deputy Commissioner (C.T), Madras Division, Madras-6 v. Rajasthan Trading Corporation, Madras-17 (T.C No. 306 of 1971) dated 25th March, 1976 (Madras High Court) Relied upon by the Board to support that transport charges were part of the price for delivery at site and therefore includible in taxable turnover. The Court distinguished this decision on the facts: in the Rajasthan Trading Corporation case the contract was held to be for delivery at site at an inclusive rate. In the present case, the Court found documentary evidence of two separate bargains; therefore the Rajasthan decision did not support the Board's addition.
Tungabhadra Industries Ltd., Kurnool v. Commercial Tax Officer, Kurnool, [1960] 11 STC 827 (SC) Relied on by the respondent; concerned exemption claimed for freight that had been separately charged but was held to be included in price and later deducted. The Court explained Tungabhadra was inapplicable because in that case railway freight had been included in the price and later deducted; in the present case the transport charges were shown and charged separately and not included in price.
Dyer Meakin Breweries Ltd. v. State Of Kerala, [1970] 26 STC 248 (SC) Relied on by the respondent; held that freight/handling for transport from factory to warehouse were pre-sale/incidental charges and not deductible under applicable rule. The Court found this authority inapplicable: in Dyer Meakin the charges were pre-sale/incidental (to make goods available at place of sale), whereas here the Court found two independent bargains showing transport was a separate post-sale supply charged independently.
State of Tamil Nadu v. Parry & Company (Madras), [1976] 38 STC 122 Relied on by the respondent; held that dissection of price into separate heads would not permit deduction if bargain was for payment at a particular inclusive price unless evidence showed freight was not intended to be included. The Court found Parry & Co. inapplicable on the facts because, in the present case, the bill books and invoices disclosed two independent bargains and transport charges were shown separately and not included in price.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by first determining the actual terms of the contracts between the appellant and its customers. It relied on documentary evidence placed before the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and the Board: affidavits from customers, specimen bill books and invoices, and in particular a specimen bill dated 30th April 1974.

Key factual findings from the documents (as applied by the Court):

  • The specimen bill dated 30th April 1974 showed an instance of delivery ex-quarry where no transport charge was shown — indicating that delivery ex-quarry at the quoted price was a normal form of bargain.
  • The invoice book evidenced a consistent pattern: when delivery at site was effected, the cost of blue-metal was indicated separately and sales tax was collected only on the value of the blue-metal; transport charges were charged and indicated in the bill as a separate item and were not included in the price of the goods.
  • The transport charges varied by transaction depending on the distance to be covered, supporting the view that they were separately negotiated/post-sale contractual elements rather than constitutive parts of a single inclusive price.

On these factual findings the Court concluded that each transaction involving delivery at the buyer's site comprised two bargains: (a) supply of blue-metal at a specific price (on which sales tax was collected), and (b) an independent contract for transport to the site charged separately. Given this factual position, the Court held that the requirements of rule 6(c)(i) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Rules, 1959 were satisfied, entitling the appellant to deduct the separately charged transport amounts from taxable turnover.

The Court then considered the authorities cited by the respondent. It explained why the respondent's relied-upon precedents did not apply to the facts here:

  • Tungabhadra — freight there had been included in the price and later deducted; therefore rule (analogous) required the charge be separately shown and not included in price. That factual situation differed from the present case where charges were shown separately.
  • Dyer Meakin Breweries — involved pre-sale/incipient transport charges to make goods available at the place of sale (thus not deductible). Here, by contrast, the Court found post-sale independent bargains for transport, not pre-sale charges.
  • Parry & Company — the principle required evidence that freight was not intended to be included in the bargain; in the present case the Court found direct documentary evidence of two separate bargains showing that freight/transport was not included in the price.
  • The Madras High Court decision in Rajasthan Trading Corporation — which the Board applied — was distinguished: in that case the contract was held to be for delivery at site at an inclusive per-unit rate; whereas here the bill books and invoices showed the transport component was billed separately and not part of the goods' price.

Because the Court's decision turned on the documentary and factual matrix demonstrating separate bargains, it did not find it necessary to elaborate on the cases cited by the appellant; the Court's ruling followed from direct analysis of the bills, invoices and affidavits.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed. The Court held that the appellant is entitled to a deduction of transport charges amounting to Rs. 2,13,454 under rule 6(c)(i) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Rules, 1959. The order of the Board of Revenue is set aside and the order of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner is restored.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The appellant's taxable turnover is reduced by the separately charged transport amount of Rs. 2,13,454; the Appellate Assistant Commissioner's figures are restored. The Court awarded costs: Rs. 250 counsel's fee.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion resolves the dispute on the specific factual record (invoices, bills and affidavits) and indicates that where documentary evidence establishes two independent bargains — one for goods and a separate one for transport shown and charged independently — the transport charges may be deducted under rule 6(c)(i). The Court did not state that it was laying down a new general rule beyond application to the facts before it.

Note: This summary is based exclusively on the contents of the provided opinion and does not add information beyond what the opinion itself states.

    Rajasthan Trading Corporation v. Commissioner, Board Of Revenue (Commercial Taxes), Madras

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Ratnam, J.:— The appellant is a dealer in blue-metal jelly. In the course of its business, it sold blue-metal jelly obtained from its quarry. For the assessment year 1974-75, the appellant reported in its monthly A-2 returns a total turnover of Rs. 9,67,244.31 out of which exemption was claimed in respect of a turnover for Rs. 2,09,168.56 by the appellant as transport charges. The assessing authority called for the accounts and refixed the total as well as the taxable turnover at Rs. 10,15,711. In doing so, the assessing authority negatived the claim for deduction of the transport charges made by the appellant under rule 6(c)(i) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Rules, 1959 (hereinafter referred to as the Rules), on the ground that the blue-metal was delivered by the appellant at the site of the buyer and the sale price included transport charges incurred prior, to sale, and therefore could not be deducted under rule 6(c)(i) of the Rules.

    2. The inclusion of the transport charges in the taxable turnover was objected to by the appellant in its appeal before the Appellate Assistant Commissioner, before whom the appellant produced its books of account as well as affidavits obtained from persons to whom the appellant had supplied the blue-metal to the effect that the customers had agreed to pay separately and independently for the supply of blue-metal and the charges for transport.

    3. With reference to this claim of the appellant, the departmental representative was asked to verify the records produced and he submitted a report that the appellant had confirmed by the production of the affidavits the oral contract entered into by the appellant with its customers for the supply of blue-metal. Taking this and the other materials into account, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner was of the view that the agreement between the appellant and the buyer for the supply of blue-metal at a fixed cost and the payment of transport charges specified separately had been established even by the bills produced by the appellant, and therefore, the transport charges collected separately should be deducted in ascertaining the taxable turnover. Ultimately, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner refixed the total and taxable turnovers at Rs. 9,82, 505 and Rs. 7,73, 236 respectively.

    4. Exercising suo motu revisional powers under section 34 of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, the Board of Revenue proposed to restore the turnover relating to transport charges amounting to Rs. 2,13, 454 and called for the objections of the appellant in this regard. In answer to this, the appellant maintained that there were two distinct and separate contracts entered into between the appellant and the buyers of blue-metal and that the blue-metal had to be supplied at a fixed price and that the transport charges specified had also to be paid separately and that there was no consolidated contract for the sale of blue-metal at the site. Apart from placing reliance upon the affidavits given by the buyers to the effect that the transport charges were charged for and paid separately, the appellant also contended that there was a post-sale agreement for payment of transport charges which varied from transaction to transaction depending upon the place of the buyer. The Board relied upon an order book stated to have been maintained by the dealer and concluded that the sale was complete when the goods were delivered at the site of the buyer and this would show that the contract was a consolidated one for the supply of blue-metal at the site inclusive of the price of materials and transport charges, and therefore, the affidavits relied on by the appellant and the other materials could not be relied upon. In addition, the Board proceeded to apply the decision in State of Tamil Nadu, by the Deputy Commissioner (C.T), Madras Division, Madras-6 v. Rajasthan Trading Corporation, Madras-17 [T.C No. 306 of 1971 dated 25th March, 1976 (Madras High Court) in relation to the appellant for the assessment year 1966-67] to hold that the transport charges should also be included in the taxable turnover. In the result, a sum of Rs. 2,13,454 being the transport charges received by the appellant and was included in the taxable turnover of the appellant, the correctness of which is disputed in this appeal.

    5. Before this Court, the learned counsel for the appellant contended that normally the blue-metal ordered for by the buyers used to be delivered exquarry and if a buyer desired to have delivery at site, then the cost of the blue-metal supplied and the transport charges were specified and charged for separately without including it in the price of the goods sold, and therefore in this case rule 6(c)(i) of the Rules stood attracted enabling the appellant to claim a deduction of the transport charges. Reliance in this connection was also placed on the decisions in Gordon Woodroffe and Company (Madras) Private Limited v. State of Tamil Nadu, [1979] 44 STC 485, R. Balakrishna Brick Works v. The State Of Tamil Nadu, [1982] 49 STC 251, Ramco Cement Distribution Company (P.) Ltd. v. State of Tamil Nadu, [1982] 51 STC 171 and Vadivel Mudaliar and Sons v. State of Tamil Nadu, [1983] 52 STC 189.

    6. On the other hand, the learned Additional Government Pleader contended that really there are no two separate and independent bargains, but that the transaction is a composite one for the supply of blue-metal by delivery at the site, and therefore, no exclusion of the turnover referable to transport charges can be availed of by the appellant under rule 6(c)(i) of the Rules. Strong reliance was also placed on the judgment in State of Tamil Nadu by the Deputy Commissioner (C.T), Madras Division, Madras-6 v. Rajasthan Trading Corporation, Madras-17 (T.C No. 306 of 1971 dated 25th March, 1976—Madras High Court) and Tungabhadra Industries Ltd., Kurnool v. Commercial Tax Officer, Kurnool, [1960] 11 STC 827 (SC), Dyer Meakin Breweries Ltd. v. State Of Kerala, [1970] 26 STC 248 (SC), and State of Tamil Nadu v. Parry & Company (Madras), [1976] 38 STC 122.

    7. Before considering the claim of the appellant to the deduction of transport charges from its total turnover, it is necessary to ascertain the actual terms of the contract between the appellant and its customers. Earlier, a reference has been made to the filing of a series of affidavits by the appellant before the Appellate Assistant Commissioner. Apart from it, specimen copies of the bill books and the invoices had also been made available and there is no dispute regarding this. It only remains to scrutinise, these materials to ascertain the precise terms of the contract between the parties. We proceed to examine the specimen of a bill dated 30th April, 1974. It is seen therefrom that the delivery of the blue-metal was ex-quarry and no transport charge has been separately shown. That means that the bargain between the parties was only for the supply of blue-metal ex-quarry and the appellant had also collected sales tax on the value of the blue-metal. This is an instance of delivery of blue-metal by the appellant ex-quarry where no transport charges have at all been included. In fact, in the explanation submitted before the Board, the appellant had given numerous instances of delivery of blue-metal ex-quarry. But the Board had not referred to any of them. It is also seen from the invoice book that in case the delivery of the blue-metal has to be effected at site, the cost of the blue-metal is separately indicated in the bill and sales tax is also collected by the appellant only on the value of the blue-metal supplied and with reference to the transport charges, it is charged for and indicated in the bill by the appellant without its being included in the price of the goods sold. In other words, the pattern of the transactions as disclosed by the invoices in this case would establish that with reference to the supply of blue-metal by the appellant, normally the delivery is ex-quarry, but that in the event of the customer requiring delivery at the site, an independent bargain has been, entered into by the appellant to deliver the blue-metal at the site of the customer on the payment of transport charges, which, however, varied depending upon the distance to be covered. A careful scrutiny of the bills and the invoices relating to the delivery at the site reveals that with reference to the supply of one unit of blue-metal there are two bargains, namely, the supply of blue-metal at a particular rate in respect of which sales tax is collected by the appellant from the customer and an independent bargain with reference to the transport charges not included in the price of the blue-metal but shown separately as a distinct item. On the materials placed before us, we are of the view that in this case the requirements of rule 6(c)(i) of the Rules are fully satisfied and the appellant is, therefore, entitled to a deduction of the transport charges to the tune of Rs. 2,13,454.

    8. It only remains to refer to the decisions relied on by the learned Additional Government Pleader since, on an examination of the materials in support of the case of the appellant, we have held that two independent bargains relating to the supply of blue-metal and the transport thereof to the site, if so desired by the customer, are made out in each transaction of sale where the delivery is at the site of the buyer. In Tungabhadra Industries Ltd., Kurnool v. Commercial Tax Officer, Kurnool, [1960] 11 STC 827 (SC), exemption was claimed in respect of freight on the ground that it had been separately charged for. This was rejected by all the authorities as well as the High Court. While dealing with the claim for exemption, the Supreme Court pointed out that factually the railway freight had been included in the price and had been later deducted, and therefore, it would be outside the terms of rule 5(1)(g) which required that in order to enable a dealer to claim the deduction, it should be charged for separately and not included in the price of the goods sold. Such is not the case here, and therefore, this decision cannot be of any assistance to the State. The principle of the decision in Dyer Meakin Breweries Ltd. v. State Of Kerala, [1970] 26 STC 248 (SC) is also, in our opinion, inapplicable, as in that case the exemption was claimed in respect of freight and handling charges for the transport of goods from the factories to the warehouse at Ernakulam. The Supreme Court held that these expenses were really in the nature of pre-sale charges or charges incidental to the sale for transporting the goods from the factories to the warehouse of the company at Ernakulam, and therefore, such expenditure for making the goods available to the intending customers at the place of sale would not be covered by rule 9(f) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Rules, 1963. Earlier, we have found that in this case the nature of the transactions revealed by the bills and the invoices disclose a twin bargain, one for the supply of blue-metal at a price with reference to which sales tax had also been collected by the appellant and the other for payment of transport charges not forming part of the price of the goods but separately shown for delivery of the blue-metal at the place of the customer, if so desired. This factual position would also render the decision in Dyer Meakin Breweries Ltd. v. State Of Kerala, [1970] 26 STC 248 (SC), inapplicable to the present case. The decision in State of Tamil Nadu v. Parry & Company (Madras), [1976] 38 STC 122 proceeded on the basis that there should be evidence to show that freight was not intended to be included in the price in the bargain between the dealer and the purchaser and that if the bargain between the parties was for payment at a particular price, the circumstances that the dealer had cut up the price into separate items would not enable the dealer to get deduction of the freight from the total taxable turnover. Even this decision is inapplicable in this case, where, as already seen, there are two independent and separate bargains disclosed by the bill books and the invoices and the other materials, one relating to the supply of blue-metal and the other in respect of delivery of the blue-metal at the place of the customer on payment of charges billed for separately and not included in the price. No doubt, State of Tamil Nadu, by the Deputy Commissioner (C.T), Madras Division, Madras-6 v. Rajasthan Trading Corporation, Madras-17 (T.C No. 306 of 1971 dated 25th March, 1976—Madras High Court) related to the appellant, though for the year 1966-67. But this Court had proceeded on the footing that the contract was for delivery at the site at a particular rate per unit, which was included in the price for delivery at the site and in that view it was held that the price included the transport charges and the mere dissection of the price into different heads by the appellant will not enable the appellant to deduct the transport charges as not includible in the taxable turnover. We have earlier found that the appellant had shown the transport charges separately and the price did not include the transport charges and that with reference to the supply of blue-metal to the customers two distinct and separate bargains are discernible, one relating to the supply of blue-metal at a particular price on which sales tax had also been charged for by the appellant and the other relating to the payment of charges for transport shown separately and not forming part of the price. We are, therefore, of the opinion that none of the decisions relied on by the respondent would in any manner assist in sustaining the addition made by the Board.

    9. In view of the factual situation arrived at, on a consideration of the materials placed, we do not think it necessary to elaborate upon the cases relied on by the appellant. We, therefore, hold that the appellant is entitled to a deduction of transport charges of Rs. 2,13,454. The appeal is allowed. The order of the Board is, therefore, set aside and that of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner is restored with costs. Rs. 250 counsel's fee.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajasthan Trading Corporation v. Commissioner, Board Of Revenue (Commercial Taxes), Madras
    (Aug 19, 1983)