Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • 0. 21, Rules 11 and 32 and 38 of the Civil P. C.,
  • O. 21, Rule 37, C. P. C.
  • sub-rule (1)
  • sub-rule (3),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • 0. 21, Rules 11 and 32 and 38 of the Civil P. C.,
  • O. 21, Rule 37, C. P. C.
  • sub-rule (1)
  • sub-rule (3),
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from a civil revision petition filed by the second defendant (the revision petitioner / judgment-debtor) challenging an order dated 25-1-1982 in R.E.P. No. 195 of 1981 (filed in O.S. 201 of 1981) made by the learned District Munsif, Mettur Dam. The impugned order had directed arrest of the revision petitioner for recovery of Rs. 3,876.40 (decree amount and costs) and recorded that no counter had been filed and no payment had been made. The docket contains earlier endorsements including:

  • 14-10-1981: further proceedings stayed; conditional order; stay till 23-10-1981 (with mention of re-posting to 31-10-1981).
  • 31-10-1981: conditional order passed; counter and payment of Rs. 400/- by 5-12-1981 (notation indicating adjournments and extensions).

The lower Court had, on 23-1-1982, ordered that the counter and payment of Rs. 400/- were to be made on 25-1-1982. On 25-1-1982 the learned District Munsif pronounced the impugned order which, as recorded in the order, read in part: "No counter. No payment. Respondent called absent. Set ex parte. Means proved by affidavit. Arrest by 22-2-1982 6atta in 3 days."

The revision petitioner contended that a counter was in fact filed on 25-1-1982 (bearing a date seal and serial number) and that his late appearance was neither wanton nor willful; accordingly, he sought revision under S.115, Civil Procedure Code (C.P.C.). The respondent (plaintiff-decree-holder) opposed revision, relying on Order 21 rules and the procedures contained in the Civil Procedure Code governing arrest in execution.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order of the learned District Munsif dated 25-1-1982 in R.E.P. No. 195 of 1981 in O.S. 201 of 1981 is revisable under Section 115, Civil P. C.?
  2. Whether the absence of the revision petitioner at the time the petition was called on 25-1-1982 justified the pronouncement of an order of arrest?

Arguments of the Parties

Revision Petitioner's Arguments

  • The revision petitioner (second defendant / judgment-debtor) relied on the decision in Jolly George - Verghese v. Bank of Cochin and the subsequent decision of this Court in Anuma Gounder v. Pormusami, and on observations of the Supreme Court, to contend that the impugned order was revisable under S.115, C.P.C.
  • It was submitted that the petition in the lower Court had been the subject of an appeal and a stay application; the revision petitioner later attended court but belatedly, and that such belated appearance was neither wanton nor willful.
  • The revision petitioner pointed to docket endorsements and to the fact that a counter was ready and was in fact filed on 25-1-1982 (bearing a date seal and serial number), but the lower Court nevertheless recorded "No counter" and ordered arrest on the same day; on this basis the order was said to be revisable.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent (plaintiff-decree-holder) argued that R.E.P. 195 of 1981 was filed under Order 21, Rules 11, 32 and 38 of the Civil P.C., and that the provisions of Order 21, Rule 37 and Rule 40 (C.P.C.) regulate execution by arrest and detention and afford sufficient opportunity to the judgment-debtor even after arrest.
  • The respondent contended that, in light of these procedural provisions, the impugned order was not revisable under Section 115, C.P.C., and that the facts before the lower Court were distinguishable from the circumstances considered in Jolly George.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jolly George - Verghese v. Bank of Cochin Referred to for the Supreme Court's observations regarding the law on arrest in execution proceedings and the limited circumstances in which arrest may be ordered. The Court treated those observations as relevant authority supporting the proposition that an order of arrest is an extreme consequence and should not be made unless there is adequate proof of refusal to comply with a decree despite possession of means; those considerations weighed in favor of revision.
Anuma Gounder v. Pormusami Recognized as a decision of this Court which followed the approach in Jolly George. The decision was cited as having followed Jolly George and thus as supporting the view that the lower Court's arrest order could be revisable; it formed part of the authorities relied upon by the revision petitioner and noted by the Court in its analysis.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by first identifying the precise question for consideration: whether the District Munsif's order dated 25-1-1982 is revisable under Section 115, C.P.C. The Court accepted as a fact that the revision petitioner was not physically present in Court when the impugned order was pronounced, and it recited the lower Court's order in full as recorded: "No counter. No payment. Respondent called absent. Set ex parte. Means proved by affidavit. Arrest by 22-2-1982 6atta in 3 days."

The Court examined the respondent's reliance on Order 21, Rule 37 and Rule 40 (C.P.C.). It reproduced the text of Rule 37, which prescribes notice in execution by arrest proceedings (with a proviso permitting omission of notice where the Court is satisfied that the judgment-debtor is likely to abscond), and Rule 40, which sets out the procedure when a judgment-debtor appears or is brought before the Court (hearing of the decree-holder, opportunity to the judgment-debtor to show cause, interim detention or security, and, on conclusion of inquiry, the making of an order for detention subject to other provisions of the Code).

The Court acknowledged the respondent's submission that Order 21 procedures afford opportunities to the judgment-debtor even after arrest and that consequently the impugned order was not amenable to revision under Section 115. However, the Court analyzed the substantive fairness of directing arrest in the circumstances:

  • The Court emphasized that an order for arrest is an "extreme consequence" which ought to be resorted to only where there is adequate proof of refusal to comply with the decree despite the judgment-debtor having sufficient means to satisfy it.
  • The Court noted that counsel for the revision petitioner was present before the lower Court on the day the petition was called (even though the order does not record any representation) and that a counter bearing a date seal of 25-1-1982 and a serial number (S. No. 315) was placed on the lower Court's file and thus shows the counter had been filed on that date.
  • Given that the counter had been filed on the same day and representation by counsel was a live possibility, the Court held that the lower Court could and should have heard representation instead of pronouncing an arrest order on the same day; the principle of audi alteram partem (opportunity to be heard / representation) was relevant in evaluating the legality of the order.

On these bases, the Court concluded that the impugned order of arrest was not "quite in accordance with law" and was thereby revisable under Section 115. The presence of the date-sealed counter and the fact of possible representation were determinative factual points for revisability in the Court's reasoning.

Holding and Implications

Holding: REVISION ALLOWED

Direct consequences ordered by the Court:

  • The civil revision petition is allowed.
  • The learned District Munsif, Mettur Dam is directed to restore R.E.P. No. 195 of 1981 on his file and to dispose of it formally after taking into consideration the contentions raised in the counter which bears the date seal 25-1-1982.
  • Under the circumstances, the Court made no order as to costs.

Implications beyond the parties: The opinion does not articulate any broader legal implications or purport to lay down a new precedent; it addresses the revisability of the impugned order on the specific facts before the Court and directs the lower Court to reconsider the matter in light of the filed counter and representation issues.

    Iyyam Perumal v. Chinna Gounder

    1. It is contended an behalf of the revision petitioner/second defendant judgment-debtor, referring to the decision in Jolly George- Verghese v. Bank of Cochin, , which has been followed by this Court in the decision rendered by Balasubrabmanyan, J. in Anuma Gounder v. Pormusami, and bearing in mind ft observation of the Supreme Court as well as the decision arrived at by this Court, when the grievance of the revision petitioner is dealt with, certainly it would be seen that the order now impugned is revisable under Sec. 115, C. P. C. It is further contended that the order pronounced by the lower Court on 25-1-1982 in R.E.P. 195 of 1981 in 0. S. 201 of 1981, on the file of the learned- District Munsif, Mettur Dam, the petition filed by the respondent herein plaintiff-decree-holder under 0. 21, Rules 11 and 32 and 38 of the Civil P. C., for arrest of the revision petitioner herein for recovery of Rs. 3,876-40 being the decree amount and costs, is certainly revisable, because, on the day of hearing of the said petition, the revision petitioner herein went late to the Court and the said belated appearance of the revision petitioner hereinbefore the lower Court was neither wanton nor willful. In this regard, the learned counsel for the visional petitioner would also point out the following endorsement incorporated in the docket of the petition, R. E. P. 195 of 1981, on 14-10-1981, as well as on 31-10-1991.

    (14-10-1981: - Further proceedings stayed. Application ordered in 1. A. 362 of 1981 in A. S. 184 of 1981 of District Court, Salem. Conditional order passed. Stay till 23-101981 (on 23-10-1981) the Presiding Officer was on leave and re posted to 31-10-1981).

    31-10-1981 :- Conditional order passed L R. 2 served. Mr. K. M. N. for respondents. Counter and payment of Rs.400/- by 5-12-1981."

    It is contended by learned counsel for the revision petition

    " that whom an appeal has been preferred to the District Court and that the same had been pending and when an order of stay of execution was also obtained, it is not quite in accordance with the law that the learned District Munsif had ordered arrest of the, revision petitioner herein by 22-2-1982, observing that there was no counter filled and that no payment was made as per the order of the learned District Munsif dated 31-10-1981, especially when the revision petitioner herein was not present at the time when the petition was called. To substantiate their contention, the learned counsel for the revision petitioner would point out the contents of the counter filed by the revision petition"
    on the very same date of the impugned order It is pointed out by the learned counsel for the revision petitioner that the, counter was ready to be Med even o4 25-1-19&2, viz., the date of adjournment of the petition for counter and it was filed in the office of the learned District Munsif, who had delivered the order for arrest on the very same day. In this view, the order becomes revisable, is the submission made by the learned counsel for the revision petitioner herein.

    2. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent herein would vehemently contend that the respondent herein filed R. E. P. 195 of 1981 under O. 21, Rr. 11 and 32 and 38 with the said O, 21 and in this regard when the provisions of O.21, R. 37 as well as O. 21, R. 40, Civil P. C. are gone through, it will be clear that even after arrest, there would be sufficient opportunity to the revision petitioner herein to put forth his case and as such, the impugned order cannot be revised under the provisions of S. 115, Civil P. C. The point for consideration is: Whether the order of the learned District Munsif dated 25-1-1982 in R. E. P. No. 195 of 1981 in 0. S. 201 of 1981 is revisable under S. 115. Civil P. C.?

    3. It admits of no doubt that the revision petitioner herein was not present in Court on the date on which the order was pronounced viz., 25-1-1982. On that day, the revision petitioner herein had been given an opportunity to file the counter to the said petition, R. E. P. 195 of 1981. He was also directed to pay Rs. 400/- by 5-12-1981 on 31-10-1981, and there was extension of time for the said purpose on several dates subsequently. Finally on 23-1-1982, it was ordered by the learned District Munsif that the counter and payment of Rs. 400/- had to be made on 25-1-1982. when the revision petitioner was not present in Court. The order under revision had been pronounced by the lower Court, which runs as follows-

    "No counter. No payment. Respondent called absent. Set ex parte. Means proved by affidavit. Arrest by 22-2-1982 6atta in 3 days."

    The learned counsel for the respondent herein would contend that O. 21, Rule 37, C. P. C. provides as follows "(1) Notwithstanding anything in these rules, where an application is for the execution of a decree for the payment of money by the arrest and detention in the civil Prison of a judgment-debtor who is liable to be arrested in pursuance of the application, the Court shall, instead of issuing a warrant his arrest, issue a notice calling upon him to appear before the Court on a day' to be specified in the notice and show cause why he should not be committed to the civil prison:

    Provided that such notice 'shall not' be necessary if the Court is satisfied by affidavit, or otherwise, that, with the object or effect of delaying the execution of the decree, the judgment debtor is likely to abscond or leave the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court;

    (2) Where appearance is not made in obedience to the notice, the Court shell, if the decree-holder so requires, issue a warrant for the arrest of the judgment-debtor." As such, the impugned order is not available. He would also point out the, provisions of 0. 21, R. 40 which runs as follows -

    (1) When a judgment-debtor appears before the Court in obedience, to notice issued under Rule 37, or is brought before the Court after being arrested in execution of a decree for the payment of money the Court shall proceed to hear the decree-holder and take all such evidence as may be produced by him in support of his application for execution; and shall then give the judgment debtor an opportunity of showing cause why he should not be committed to the civil prison;

    (2) Pending the, conclusion of the inquiry under sub-rule (1) the Court may, in its discretion, order the judgment-debtor to be detained in the custody of an officer of the Court or release him on his furnishing security to the satisfaction of the Court for his appearance when required.

    (3) Upon the conclusion of the inquiry under sub-rule (1) the Court may, subject to the provisions of S. 51 and to the other provisions of this Code, make an order for the detention of the judgment-debtor in the civil prison and shall in the event cause him to be arrested if he is not a1ready under arrest.

    Provided that, in order to give the-judgment-debtor an opportunity of satisfying the decree, the Court may, before making the order of detention, leave the, judgment debtor in the custody of an officer of the Court for a specified. period not exceeding fifteen days or release him on his furnishing security to the satisfaction of the Court for his appearance at the expiration of the specified period if the decree be not -sooner satisfied.

    (4) A judgment-debtor released under this rule may he- re-arrested, (5) When the Court does not make an order of - detention under sub-rule (3), it shall disallow the application and, if the judgment-debtor is under arrest, direct his release,"

    On the other hand, the learned counsel for the revision petitioner would contend that it is no doubt that Rs. 400/- which was directed to be paid to the respondent herein by the lower Court as per its order date 25-1-1982, yet it is not as if that the same would afford' a sufficient ground for arrest especially in view of the observations made by the Supreme Court in Jolly George Varglicse v. Bank of Cochin, the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent would submit that the circumstances, which were prevailing when the order of arrest was made by the lower Court are different and distinguishable. The only question that confronts this Court is, whether the "absence of the revision petitioner at the time when the petition was called on 25-1-1982, would justify a pronouncement of the order of arrest. Even at the outset it is to be stated that the order of arrest made under the circumstances is not quite in accordance with law. The direction for arrest is an extreme consequence that can be resorted to if, there is adequate proof of refusal to comply with a decree in spite of the fact that the judgment debtor is possessed of sufficient means to satisfy the same. Unless this aspect is adverted to, certainly an order of arrest cannot be made.

    In this view, when a counter had been filed on the very same date of the order under revision was pronounced by the lower Court would justify that though the revision petitioner herein was not present at the time when he was called in Court though he was represented by a counsel before the said Court yet, the lower Court could have just passed over for any representation to be made out behalf of the learned counsel appearing for the judgment debtor revision petitioner herein on that day and there after after hearing the representation made by the learned counsel he could have made an order, which, of course, would at least justify the basic principle of representation viz audi alteram partem. Though in the preamble portion it is, stated that the counsel set for the revision petitioner herein was represented, yet no representation was, said to have been made by him is incorporated in the order in question, nor is it seen that the learned counsel for the revision. Petitioner herein was not present at the time when the petition was called. Under these circumstances, the date seat found on the counter filed by the revision petitioner herein in R. E, P. 195 of 1981, before the lower Court alone comes to our Perusal only to the limited scope of seeing the date of the filing of the said counter especially when it is incorporated in the order under revision that there was no counter filed. The counter might not have been filed as and when the order was pronounced but, the date seal on the counter, which bears the date 25-1-1982 together with S. No. 315, clearly shows that the counter had been filed. Therefore, the order under revision becomes revisable and is hereby revised. The civil revision petition is allowed, the learned District Munsif, Mettur Dam is directed to restore the petition R. E. P. 195 of 1981 on his file and dispose of formally after taking into consideration the various contentions raised in the counter filed by the, revision petitioner herein as 25-1-1982, Under the circumstances, there is no order as to costs.

    4. Revision allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Iyyam Perumal v. Chinna Gounder
    (Jan 25, 1983)