AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 5 of the Limitation Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 5 of the Limitation Act,

    Angappa Gounder And Others v. Rajavelu Gounder And Another

    1. This Second Appeal raises an interesting question of law about the principle of res judicata. The only question that falls far determination is that when two suits involving substantialy the same issue are disposed of under a common judgment, (sic) whether the non-filing of an appeal against the judgment and decree in one suit, will operate as res judicata when the decision in the other suit alone is challenged in the appeal.

    2. Though in my opinion, the Supreme Court has laid down that the principle of res judicata will be attracted in such cases, vide, Koshal Pal and others v. Mohanlal and others . A.I.R 1976 S.C 688. followed by Balasubrahmanyan J. in K. Khaja Mohideen v. Mohideen Batcha . 92 L.W 28. and Lononkutty v. Thoman and another . A.I.R 1976 S.C 1645. learned counsel for the respondents sought to distinguish these rulings on the ground that the above principle will not be applicable to cases where the two suits were disposed of under a common judgment. Incidentally, learned counsel claimed support to his above contention from the following obervations of the Supreme Court in Narbari and others v. Shankar and others.4

    “It is now well settled that where there has been one trial, one finding, and one decision, there need not be two appeals even though two decrees may have been drawn up. As has been observed by Tek Chand J. Mt. Lachhmi v. Mt. Bhulli in his learned Judgment in mentioned above, the determining factoris not the decree but the matter in controversy As he puts it later in his judgment, the estoppel is not created by the deeree but it can only be created by the judgment. The question of res judicata arises only when there are two suits. Even when there are two suits, it has been held that a decision given simultaneously cannot be a decision in the former suit. When there is only one suit the question of res judicata does not arise at all and in the present case, both the decrees are in the same case and based on the same judgment, and the matter decided concerns the entire suit. As such, there is no question of the application of the principle of res judicata. The same judgment cannot remain effective just because it was appealed against with a different number or a copy of it was attached to a different appeal. The two decrees in substance are one. Besides, the High Court was wrong in not giving to the appellants the benefit of S. 5 of the Limitation Act, because there was conflict of decisions regarding this question not only in the High Court of the State but also among the different High Courts in India.” (underlining by me).

    and the decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in K. A. Natesa Chettiar v. Krishniah Chetty and another. Hence is it, I am persuaded to render a detailed judgment.

    3. The facts relevant for the discussion are as hereunder. The appellants before me are the defendants is O.S No. 874 of 1970, District Munsif's Court, Tindivanam. The respondents, the two plaintiff's therein came forward with the above suit for declaration of their title to the six items of properties and for permanent injunction against the appellants from interfering with the former's possession and enjoyment of the said property. The defence taken by the first appellant and adopted by the other appellants is that the respondents are not absolute owners, that the first appellant alone is entitled to 4/5th share while the plaintiffs to 1/5th share and that therefore, the relief for injunction cannot be maintained.

    4. Not satisfied with such defence in O.S No. 874 of 1970, the first appellant before me, brought another suit O.S No. 154 of 1972, on the file of the same Court against the two respondents herein and another, for a partition and separate possession of his 4/5th share in the very same six items of properties in respect of which the respondents claimed absolute title and injunction in the other suit O.S No. 874 of 1970.

    5. These two suits were disposed of under a common judgment by the trial Court; it held that the two respondents are entitled to declaration of their title only in respect of items 4 and 5 in their suit OS. No. 874 of 1970 and dismissed the suit in respect of other items. In the other suit O.S No. 154 of 1972, it granted a decree in favour of the first appellant (the sole plaintiff in O.S No, 154 of 1972), for partition and separate possession in the suit properties other than item No. 4, declaring the first appellant's share as 13/24.

    6. The respondents alone preferred appeal A.S No. 411 of 1975, Sub-Court, Cuddalore only against the judgment and decree in O.S No. 874 of 1970 (that is their suit) and did not file any appeal against the judgment and decree in the other suit O.S No. 154 of 1972.

    7. The first appellate Court negatived the plea of res judicata stressed on behalf of the respondents before it (the appellants herein) and also reversed the decision of the trial Court in O.S No. 874 of 1970 and decreed that suit as prayed for by the appellants before it (the respondents herein).

    8. According to Mr. R.S Venkatachari, learned counsel for the appellants, on the principle laid down by the Supreme Court in Koshal Pal and others v. Mohan Lal and others followed in K. Khaja Mohideen v. K. Mohideen Batcha and in Lonan Kutty v. Thoman and others . A.I.R 1976 S.C 1645. the appeal A.S No. 411 of 1975 is barred under the principle of res judicata in so far as the respondents had allowed the decision in the other suit O.S No. 154 of 1972 to become final. He fairly conceded that the first appellant did not have the benefit of the above Supreme Court decisions and that of this Court, as well. Be that as it may, I find the learned counsel is well founded in his contention, in view of the authoritative pronouncement of the law by the Supreme Court in Lonankutty v. Thoman and another:

    “Respondents did not file any further appeal against the decree passed by the District Court in the appeals arising out of their suit. They filed a second appeal in the High Court only as against the decree passed by the District Court in A.S No. 66 of 1978 which arose out of the decree passed by the trial Court in the appellant's suit. Thus the decision of the District Court rendered in the appeal arising out of the respondent's suit became final and conclusive. That decision, not having been appealed against could not be reopened in the second appeal arising out of the appellant's suit. The issue whether respondents had the easementary right to the flow of water through the appellant's land for fishing purposes was directly and substantially in issue in the respondent's suit. That issue was heard and finally decided by the District Court in a proceeding between the same parties and the decision was rendered before the High Court decided the second appeal. The decision of the District Court was given in an appeal arising out of a suit which though instituted subsequently, stood finally decided before the High Court disposed of the second appeal. The decision was therefore one in a “former suit” within the meaning of S. 2, Explanation 1, C.P.C Accordingly, the High Court was in error in deciding an issue which was heard and finally decided in a “former suit'’ and was therefore barred by res judicata.

    9. The above principle governs the present case. For, so long as the decree in O.S No. 154 of 1972 declaring that the appellants herein are entitled to 13/24th share in five items of properties, was allowed to become final because the respondents herein had not filed any appeal, it follows that such decision in O.S No. 154 of 1972 is one made in a ‘former suit’ within the meaning of S. 11, Explanation I, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, when the first appellate Court came to deal with A.S No. 411 of 1975 against O.S No. 874 of 1970. It cannot be disputed that the issues involved in both the suits O.S No. 874 of 1970 and O.S No. 154 of 1972 are substantially the same. To the same effect is the decision reported in Koshal Pal and others v. Mohan Lal and others. It is to be noticed that the dissenting judgment of Untwalia, J. did not turn on the principle upheld by the majority and reiterated in the later decision of the Supreme Court in Lonankutty v. Thoman and another. Indeed, Untwalia, J. was also in the Bench which rendered the later decision.

    10. There remains to be considered the por-tionparticularly the one underlined by me, relied on by the learned Counsel for the respondents in Narbari and others v. Shankar and others. The short facts in that case are that against the decision in a suit, two first appeals came to be filed by two sets of the defendants to that action as each of them felt aggrieved; consequently, two decrees came to be prepared by the first appellate Court though the two appeals were disposed of under a common judgment. Further, though two second appeals were presented by the aggrieved party in the High Court, one came to be dismissed, as it was filed out of time, and as the application under S. 5 of the Limitation Act was dismissed. Eventually, one appeal alone was entertained by the High Court. In that context, it was contended that the dismissal of one of the second appeals would operate as res judicata so far as the other second appeal was concerned. Such a contention found favour with the High Court. But, the Supreme Court held as extracted at the outset. It cannot, therefore, be taken that the ratio laid down therein is as urged by the learned counsel for the respondents, more so, in view of the authoritative pronouncement in Lonankutty v. Thoman and another.

    11. As regards the decision of Andhra Pradesh High Court referred to supra, it is enough to remark that the same can be no longer good law in the face of the Supreme Court decision in Lonankutty v. Thoman and another.

    12. The result, is, the second appeal succeeds. Consequently, the judgment and decree in A.S 411 of 1975 are set aside and the decision of the trial Court in O.S No. 874 of 1970 is restored. In the above circumstances, I make no order as to costs.

    vcs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Angappa Gounder And Others v. Rajavelu Gounder And Another
    (Feb 6, 1981)