Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 244 of the Cr PC of 1895, (corresponding to Section 254 of the Code of 1973),
  • Sub-Section (7) of Section 251(a) of the Cr PC, 1898 and analogous to Section 242(3)
  • provisions contained in Sections 69, 70 and 71 of the Cr PC, 1898,
  • Section 4(1)(b) of the Tamil Nadu Prohibition Act,
  • Sub-Sec. (6) of Section 251-A of the Cr PC, 1898,
  • provisions.9. Section 258 of the Cr PC, 1973,
  • Code of Criminal Procedure is Section 311.
  • justice.16. Section 510 of the Cr PC 1898,
  • Section 62, Section 63 or Section 64,
  • Sub-Section (1) of Section 254,
  • Sub-Section (2) of Section 254
  • Sub-Section (2) of Section 242,
  • SECTION 34 POLICE ACT
  • provision in Section 242(2)
  • Section 252 or Section 253,
  • Sub-Section (3) of Sec. 242
  • defence.8. Section 255(1)
  • Section 242(2) or 254(2)
  • matter.5. Section 255(1)
  • Section 174 I.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 244 of the Cr PC of 1895, (corresponding to Section 254 of the Code of 1973),
  • Sub-Section (7) of Section 251(a) of the Cr PC, 1898 and analogous to Section 242(3)
  • provisions contained in Sections 69, 70 and 71 of the Cr PC, 1898,
  • Section 4(1)(b) of the Tamil Nadu Prohibition Act,
  • Sub-Sec. (6) of Section 251-A of the Cr PC, 1898,
  • provisions.9. Section 258 of the Cr PC, 1973,
  • Code of Criminal Procedure is Section 311.
  • justice.16. Section 510 of the Cr PC 1898,
  • Section 62, Section 63 or Section 64,
  • Sub-Section (1) of Section 254,
  • Sub-Section (2) of Section 254
  • Sub-Section (2) of Section 242,
  • SECTION 34 POLICE ACT
  • provision in Section 242(2)
  • Section 252 or Section 253,
  • Sub-Section (3) of Sec. 242
  • defence.8. Section 255(1)
  • Section 242(2) or 254(2)
  • matter.5. Section 255(1)
  • Section 174 I.P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

These appeals were preferred by the State (represented by the learned Public Prosecutor) against orders of the Judicial Second Class Magistrate, Namakkal, who had acquitted the respondent-accused in each case of an offence punishable under Section 4(1)(b) of the Tamil Nadu Prohibition Act. The matter was referred to a Full Bench because it involved a question of law of public importance and there were divergent views among various High Courts.

In the underlying cases (summons cases) the Magistrate acquitted the accused under Section 255(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) on the ground that, although summons had been issued and the cases had been posted for hearings on various dates, the prosecution witnesses were not produced on any hearing date. The Magistrate had given notice that the case would be disposed of without examining the witnesses if they were not produced; the prosecution did not let in any evidence and therefore the Magistrate found that the prosecution had no evidence to let.

The Full Bench was asked to decide two questions of law referred to it. The appeals challenged the acquittals on the ground that a Magistrate cannot acquit under Section 255(1) when he has not taken the evidence referred to in Section 254 of the CrPC.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether under Section 255(1) of the CrPC a Magistrate can acquit the accused if the prosecution fails to apply for the issue of summons to any witness and does not produce the witness for several hearings and does not serve summons on the witnesses despite having been granted sufficient opportunity to serve the summons or to produce the witnesses.
  2. Whether a Magistrate can acquit the accused under Section 248(1) of the CrPC if the prosecution does not apply for the issue of summons to any of the witnesses and does not produce the witness for several hearings and does not serve the summons on the witnesses despite having been granted sufficient opportunities to serve the summons on the witnesses or to produce the witnesses.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The State contended that the Magistrate could not lawfully acquit the accused under Section 255(1) of the CrPC when he had not taken the evidence referred to in Section 254 of the CrPC. In short, an acquittal under Section 255(1) is impermissible where the court has not taken the prosecution evidence contemplated by Section 254.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent/accused legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Orissa v. Sibcharan Singh, AIR 1962 Orissa 157 The word "produced" in provisions analogous to Section 242(3) cannot be given a restricted meaning to saddle the prosecution alone; a duty is also cast upon the courts to enforce attendance of witnesses by Code processes. The Court relied on this to support the proposition that courts are not powerless when parties fail to produce evidence and have a duty to enforce attendance of witnesses.
State v. Nandkishore, AIR 1967 Raj 228 "Produced" includes bringing witnesses forward by the prosecution or through court process; the court has a duty to arrive at truth by lawful means. Used to emphasise the court's duty to secure witnesses and to exercise powers (including inherent powers) when prosecution fails to produce witnesses.
State of Madhya Pradesh v. Kaluthawar, 1972 Cri LJ 1639 The prosecution (police) has a duty to arrange production of its witnesses; where prosecution is negligent the court may conclude lack of seriousness and may record acquittal under the applicable provision when there is no evidence. Referred to as an example where court upheld acquittal when prosecution showed remissness; the Court considered it an extreme case in support of the proposition that prosecuting agency must be diligent.
State v. Kaliram Nandlal, AIR 1968 Punj 87 Authority for the proposition that acquittal for non-production of prosecution witnesses was improper (one among several similar decisions). Cited among authorities stressing the duty of the court to summon and enforce attendance of witnesses rather than treat non-production as automatically requiring acquittal.
State of Mysore v. Ramu, 1973 Mad LJ (Crl.) 116 (1973 Cri LJ 1257) Decision holding acquittal for non-production of witnesses improper; emphasises court's duty. Placed among cases supporting the court's duty to secure and examine witnesses and not saddle entire responsibility on prosecution.
State of Mysore v. Kalilulla Ahmed Sheriff, AIR 1971 Mys 60 Finding an accused "not guilty" implies the court applied its mind to the merits after recording evidence. Referenced in discussion on whether acquittal implies merits-based decision after evidence; Court said it could not wholly subscribe to the view that acquittal must always follow such an exercise of mind.
Kanduri Misra v. Sahadev Kunda, (1962) 2 Cri LJ 295 Authority emphasising court's duty to summon witnesses and enforce attendance. Used to support the proposition that courts must not remain passive when prosecution fails to produce witnesses.
State of Mysore v. Somala, 1972 Mad LJ (Cri) 476 (1972 Cri LJ 1478) Decision holding acquittal for non-production of witnesses improper where court fails in its duty. Cited in support of the view that the Magistrate's duty includes ensuring witnesses are produced; not all acquittals on such grounds are proper.
State of Mysore v. Shanta, 1972 Mad LJ (Cri) 589 Another authority in the group holding acquittal improper when court did not discharge duty to secure witnesses. Reinforced the view of judicial responsibility to facilitate production of prosecution evidence.
State v. Nagappa, 1973 Cri LJ 548 (Mad) Authority included among those holding acquittal improper where court has not used powers to enforce attendance. Used to support the duty of the court to secure attendance and examine witnesses.
Public Prosecutor v. M. Sambangi Mudaliar, ILR (1965) 1 Mad 418 : AIR 1965 Mad 31 In warrant cases where charge was framed under the old Section 251A, an important duty was laid on the court to exercise powers for examination of witnesses irrespective of complainant's laches. Referred to as precedent emphasising the court's obligation to use available powers to examine witnesses for just decision.
State of Kerala v. Kunhiaraman, 1964 Mad LJ (Cri) 330 Authority cited among decisions supporting that acquittal for non-production is improper when court fails in duty. Used in the compilation of cases stressing court's duty to secure evidence.
State of Mysore v. Narasimha Gowda, AIR 1965 Mys 167 Another authority cited in support of the court's duty to secure witnesses and examine them rather than acquit. Referenced to support the same proposition.
State of Gujarat v. Thakorbhai Sukhabhai, AIR 1968 Guj 15 Authority cited where acquittal on non-production was held improper. Used among other authorities to support the view that the court must ensure witnesses are examined.
State of U.P. v. Ramjani (1965 All LJ 1126) Authority cited among those upholding the court's obligation to secure and examine witnesses. Placed in the list of cases that emphasize judicial duty to secure evidence.
Lakshmiamma Kochukuttiamma v. Raman Pillai, AIR 1952 Trav-Coch 268 Authority included among cases indicating the court's duty regarding witnesses. Referenced as part of the body of case law emphasising judicial responsibility.
State v. Madhavan Nair, 1959 Mad LJ (Cri) 633 (Ker) Authority cited supporting court's duty to secure witnesses. Used to strengthen the principle that the court should not remain passive.
Emperor v. Varadarajulu Naidu, AIR 1932 Mad 25 Historic authority cited among others dealing with court's power to secure witnesses. Included in the survey of authorities supporting judicial initiative to secure evidence.
State of Kerala v. Mary (1960 Mad LJ (Cri) 378) Authority stressing court's duty in securing attendance of witnesses. Referenced in the group of cases supporting active judicial role in compelling attendance.
Kesar Singh v. State of Jammu and Kashmir, AIR 1963 J & K 23 Authority cited among those emphasising court's powers and duties regarding witnesses. Included in the Court's compilation of supporting decisions.
R.K.V Motors and Timbers Ltd. v. Regional Transport Authority, Trivandrum, AIR 1960 Ker 35 Authority cited in the collection of cases relevant to the issue of production of evidence. Referenced in the survey of precedents concerning the court's duties.
K.K. Subbier v. K.M.S. Lakshmana Iyer, AIR 1942 Mad 452 Authority cited that has been used to support the proposition that courts must apply their minds and secure witnesses where necessary. Used to show historical judicial insistence on courts ensuring a just decision by examining witnesses when essential.
State of Tripura v. Niranjan Deb Barma, 1973 Cri LJ 108 (Tripura) Authority cited among those supporting active judicial responsibility in production of evidence. Part of the group of supporting precedents.
Apren Joseph v. State of Kerala, 1972 Mad LJ (Cri) 10 (1972 Cri LJ 1162) Authority included in the set of decisions stressing the court's duties regarding witnesses. Referenced in the Court's survey of authorities.
State v. John Abraham, 1959 Mad LJ (Cri) 814 : 1961 (2) Cri LJ 92 (Ker) Held that the duty of the court is only to take evidence ready when the case is taken up; Magistrate not bound to adjourn until all witnesses mentioned in police report are examined (old Code context). Listed among decisions that supported the proposition that acquittal on non-production could be proper; the Court observed that some earlier decisions under the old Code would no longer be good law given changes in the 1973 Code.
State v. Lakshmanan, 1966 All LJ 342 Held that if witnesses were not present and no one appeared for prosecution to request assistance, Magistrate could lawfully close the case and acquit. Cited as authority where acquittal was held permissible; included in the group of contrary decisions the Bench reviewed.
Smt. Jyotirmoyee Bose v. Birendra Nath Prodhan, AIR 1960 Cal 263 In old Section 251-A contexts, the Magistrate was not enjoined to compel attendance of any witness unless applied for; the Magistrate in such a trial is not compelled to proceed as in warrant cases (old Code context). Placed among earlier decisions that supported acquittal for non-production; the Court noted differences in the earlier legal regime and the present Code.
State v. Ramlal, 1961 (2) Cri LJ 331 (All) Observed that the procedure under Section 251-A (old Code) did not provide for summoning prosecution witnesses on application and thus Magistrate not bound to summon; court should expect police to be prepared to produce witnesses. Referred to as an old-code decision supportive of acquittal in certain circumstances; the Full Bench noted that changes in 1973 Code alter the applicability of such decisions.
State of Gujarat v. Bava Bhadya, (1962) 2 Cri LJ 537 Where charge is framed in a warrant case on police report and prosecution failed to produce witnesses and failed to serve summonses properly, and there was no evidence before the Magistrate, the Magistrate can acquit under the then-applicable provision. Referred to as authority supporting acquittal when prosecution failed and did not make full endeavour to serve summonses; Court considered such decisions in distinguishing contexts and facts.
State of Karnataka v. Subramania Setti, 1980 Mad LJ 138 (1980 Cri LJ NOC 129) Distinction turns on whether there was remissness and want of diligence on part of prosecuting agency; where prosecution was remiss, Magistrate could be justified in refusing adjournment and acquitting. Used to illustrate that the real distinction in conflicting decisions is factual diligence of the prosecution; the Court applied this factual inquiry in framing its answer.
Poban Chandra Majumdar v. Dulal Ghosh, AIR 1965 Cal 382 Where summons were issued to prosecution witnesses but court after adjournments took no steps to procure attendance and then acquitted, such acquittal was unwarranted. Employed to support the proposition that courts must actively use powers to procure witnesses and should not acquit where court itself failed to exercise those powers.
State of Bihar v. Polomistry, AIR 1964 Pat 351 Where prosecutor relies on court's agency to secure attendance of prosecution witnesses, it is duty of Magistrate to take necessary measures to compel attendance; responsibility does not lie solely on prosecutor. Quoted to emphasise that when prosecution applies to the court for its assistance the court has an obligation to act to secure witnesses.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Full Bench proceeded by first examining the relevant statutory provisions in the Code of Criminal Procedure (1973). The Court set out Sections 254 and 255(1) (summons cases) and the corresponding provisions for warrant cases (Sections 240–243, 248) and noted the differences and duties imposed thereby.

Key statutory observations:

  • Section 254(1) enjoins the Magistrate to hear the prosecution and take all evidence produced in support of the prosecution and to hear the accused and take evidence produced in his defence. Section 254(2) permits the prosecution or accused, on application, to seek summons to witnesses; the words "may if he thinks fit" indicate judicial discretion and require the Magistrate to apply his mind before issuing summons.
  • Section 255(1) empowers the Magistrate, after taking the evidence referred to in Section 254 and such further evidence as he may cause to be produced of his own motion, to record an order of acquittal if he finds the accused not guilty.
  • For warrant cases instituted on police report, Sections 240–243 impose duties on the Magistrate to consider the police report, frame charge where appropriate, and take evidence; Section 242(2) provides for issuing summons to prosecution witnesses on application.

The Court then analysed precedents. It accepted the holdings in a number of High Court decisions (e.g., Orissa and Rajasthan High Court decisions) that the word "produced" cannot be construed to place the entire burden on the prosecution and that a duty is cast on the court to enforce attendance of witnesses by processes provided in the Code. The Court referred to the Code's provisions conferring powers on the court (Section 311 corresponding to old Section 510) to summon or examine persons suo motu where their evidence appears essential to a just decision.

The Bench next set out the procedural mechanisms available to secure service and attendance of witnesses (Sections 62–65, 69) — service by police or court officer, substituted service, affixture, and service by registered post — and observed that these provisions, including the newer Section 69 (service by registered post), can be used where normal service fails. The Bench noted there are no State rules under Section 62 in the instant context, but that there is no bar to service by an officer of the court.

Synthesising statutory text and precedent, the Court concluded:

  1. If the prosecution makes an application for issue of summons to its witnesses under Sections 242(2) or 254(2), it is the duty of the court to issue summons and to secure witnesses by exercising all powers given under the CrPC (including coercive processes where appropriate).
  2. If the court has discharged its duty to summon and to use its powers to secure attendance, and despite that the witnesses cannot be secured and the prosecution, through pronounced negligence or recalcitrance, fails to produce the witnesses after sufficient time and opportunities, the court, being left with no other alternative, would be justified in acquitting the accused for want of evidence to prove the prosecution case — under Section 248 (warrant cases on police report) or under Section 255(1) (summons cases).

The Court explicitly stated that several earlier decisions rendered under the old Code (prior to the 1973 amendments) which took a different view would no longer be good law to the extent they are inconsistent with the present statutory provisions (noting that the present Code makes express provision for issuance of summons on application).

Turning to the appeals before it, the Court noted the offences had been prosecuted nearly four years earlier and that the prosecution, despite notices, had not attempted to produce witnesses and had been non-cooperative. The Bench observed that the acquittals in these cases were not proper inasmuch as the Magistrate had not discharged the duty as outlined by the Full Bench, but, taking into account the length of time that had elapsed, the Court declined to interfere with the acquittals and dismissed the appeals.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Full Bench answered the two referred questions in the following terms: if the prosecution makes an application for the issue of summons to its witnesses (under Sections 242(2) or 254(2)) the court must issue summons and use all appropriate powers to secure attendance; if, after the court has discharged this duty, the witnesses cannot be secured and the prosecution, through pronounced negligence or recalcitrance, fails to produce the witnesses despite sufficient opportunities, the Magistrate is justified in acquitting the accused for want of evidence — under Section 248 in warrant cases and under Section 255(1) in summons cases.

The Full Bench, however, in the present appeals, observed that although the acquittals were not proper (because the Magistrate had not discharged the duties indicated by the Bench), it would not interfere with the acquittals at this late stage. Accordingly, the appeals by the State were dismissed.

APPEALS DISMISSED.

Direct Consequences for the Parties

  • The acquittals granted by the Judicial Second Class Magistrate in favour of the respondent-accused stand; the State's appeals are dismissed.
  • The Court expressed that the acquittals were improvident because the Magistrate had not performed the duties that the Full Bench has articulated, but the delay in prosecution led the Court to refrain from disturbing the acquittals.

Wider Implications Noted by the Court

The Full Bench clarified the respective duties of the prosecution and the Magistrate under the Code (1973): the prosecution must produce its evidence and, where it requires court assistance, must apply for summons; the Magistrate must, on such application, issue summons and employ procedural powers to secure attendance of witnesses; if despite these efforts the prosecution remains negligent and witnesses are not produced, acquittal for want of evidence may be justified. The Court noted that certain older precedents under the pre-1973 regime would no longer be good law to the extent inconsistent with these observations.

The opinion does not state that a new binding precedent is being created beyond the Full Bench's answers to the referred questions; the direct operative effect in these appeals is that the appeals are dismissed and the earlier acquittals remain undisturbed.

    The State v. Veerappan And Others

    The Judgement of the Court was delivered by

    Paul, J.:— These appeals which have been preferred by the State represented by the learned. Public Prosecutor against the orders of the learned Judicial Second Class Magistrate of Namakkal acquitting the respondent-accused in each case of an offence punishable under Section 4(1)(b) of the Tamil Nadu Prohibition Act are before us, inasmuch as on a reference by one of us, before whom the appeals originally came up for hearing, the matter has been placed before this Full Bench since the matter involved a question of law of public importance, in regard to which question of law there have been divergent views of various High Courts.

    2. Of the two questions which have been referred to this Full Bench, the first one, namely, whether under Section 255(1) of the Cr PC, a Magistrate can acquit the accused if the prosecution fails to apply for the issue of summons to any witness and does not produce the witness for several hearings and does not serve summons on the witnesses despite having been granted sufficient opportunity to serve the summons or to produce the witnesses, is the one that directly arises for determination in these appeals. The second question which arises for determination by us incidentally is whether a Magistrate can acquit the accused under Section 248(1) of the Cr PC, if the prosecution does not apply for the issue of summons to any of the witnesses and does not produce the witness for several hearings and does not serve the summons on the witnesses despite having been granted sufficient opportunities to serve the summons on the witnesses or to produce the witnesses. In all these appeals, the learned Magistrate acquitted the accused under Section 255(1) of the Cr PC, on the ground that even though the cases had been posted for hearing on various dates and summons had been issued to the witnesses for all the hearings, the witnesses were not produced on any of the hearing dates and in spite of a notice issued that the case would be disposed of without examining the witnesses if they are not produced the prosecution did not choose to let in any evidence and as such the Magistrate found that the prosecution had no evidence to let

    3. Section 81 of the Cr PC 1861, the Magistrate to issue a warrant.

    4. We shall first examine the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1973, which have relevance to this matter.

    5. Section 255(1) of the Cr PC, under which the accused have been acquitted in these cases states as follows:—

    “If the Magistrate, upon taking the evidence referred to in Section 254 and such further evidence, if any, as he may, of his own motion, cause to be produced, finds the accused not guilty, he shall record an order of acquittal”.

    6. Section 254 of the Cr PC, states as follows:—

    “(1) If the Magistrate does not convict the accused under Section 252 or Section 253, the Magistrate shall proceed to hear the prosecution and take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution, and also to hear the accused and take all such evidence as he produces in his difference.

    (2) The Magistrate may if he thinks fit, on the application of the prosecution or the accused, issue a summons to any witness directing him to attend or to produce any document or other thing.

    (3) The Magistrate may, before summoning any witness on such application, require that the reasonable expenses of the witness incurred in attending for the purposes of the trial be deposited in court.

    7. It will be noticed that under Sub-Section (1) of Section 254, the Magistrate is enjoined to hear the prosecution and take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution and also to hear the accused and take all such evidence as he produces in his defence. It was to be noted that under that Sub-Section a duty is cast on the prosecution to produce its evidence and likewise on the accused to produce evidence in his defence, Sub-Section (2) of Section 254 makes provision for the prosecution or the accused to seek the assistance of the court in producing its of his evidence by applying for issue of summons to any witness directing him to attend or to produce any document or other thing. It may also be noted that this Sub-Section gives a discretion to the Magistrate to so issue summons on the application of the prosecution or the accused by using the words the Magistrate may if he thinks fit’. Thus an emphasis is placed by Section 254 on the duty of the prosecution or the accused to produce all evidence in support of its case or his defence.

    8. Section 255(1) makes provision for the Magistrate upon taking the evidence referred to in Section 254 to take such further evidence, if any, as he may of his own motion cause to be produced. Under Section 255(1) a Magistrate can record an order of acquittal if he finds the accused not guilty upon taking the evidence referred to in Section 254 and such further evidence, if any, as he may of his own motion cause to be produced. Section 244 of the Cr PC of 1895, (corresponding to Section 254 of the Code of 1973), as it was in force before the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1973 came into effect, also contained similar provisions.

    9. Section 258 of the Cr PC, 1973, which is analogous to Section 249 of the Cr PC of 1898, reads as follows:—

    “In any summons case instituted otherwise than upon complaint, a Magistrate of the first class or, with the previous sanction of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, any other Judicial Magistrate, may for reasons to be recorded by him, stop the proceedings at any stage without pronouncing any judgement and where such stoppage of proceedings is made after the evidence of the principal witnesses has been recorded, pronounce a judgement of acquittal, and in any other case release the accused, and such release shall have the effect of discharge.”

    10. In all the cases now before us, the Magistrate could have very well resorted to this Section. But, instead, he has acquitted the accused under Section 255(1) of the Cr PC and it is this acquittal which has been challenged by the State in. these appeals on the ground that the Magistrate cannot acquit the accused under Section 255(1) of the Cr PC, when he has not taken the evidence referred to in Section 254 of the Cr PC.

    11. We shall also now examine the provisions relating to the trial of warrant cases instituted on a police report. We might note here that the cases now before us are summons cases, but in order to answer the question No. 2, referred to us in the reference, it is necessary to examine the position regarding the trial of warrant cases instituted on a police report, for those provisions also help to throw light on the first question which has been referred, to us and which relates to summons cases. Under Section 240, if upon consideration of the Police report and the documents sent with it under Section 173, and examination of the accused, if any, as the Magistrate thinks necessary and after giving the prosecution and the accused an opportunity of being heard, the Magistrate is of opinion that there is ground for presuming that the accused has committed an offence triable under Chapter XIX which such Magistrate is competent to try and which in his opinion could be adequately punished by him, he shall frame in writing a charge against the accused. Under Section 242 of the Cr PC, if the accused refuses to plead or do not plead, or claims to be tried or the Magistrate does not convict the accused under Section 241, on his plea of guilt the Magistrate should fix a date for examination of the witnesses and the Magistrate may on the application of the prosecution issue summons to any of its witnesses directing him to attend or to produce any document or other thing and on the date so fixed the Magistrate shall proceed to take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution. Section 243 states that the accused shall then be called upon to enter upon his defence and produce his evidence, and if the accused puts in any written statement, the Magistrate shall file it with the record, and if the accused after he has entered upon his defence, applies to the Magistrate to issue any process for compelling the attendance of any witness for the purpose of examination or cross-examination or the production of the document or other things, the Magistrate shall issue such process unless he considers that such application should be refused on the ground that it is made for the purpose of vexation or delay or for defeating the ends of justice and such grounds shall be recorded by him in writing.

    12. It might be noted that as in Section 254 of the Cr PC, relating to the trial of summons cases, the Magistrate even in warrant cases instituted on a police report is enjoined by Sub-Section (3) of Sec. 242 to take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution and a provision has been made in Sub-Section (2) of Section 242, for the issue of summons to any witness directing him to attend or produce any document or other thing on the application of the prosecution. It may, however, be noted that while under Section 254(2) the Magistrate ‘may if he thinks fit’ issue such summons under Section 242, the Magistrate ‘may issue’ such summons. Apparently, the words ‘if he thinks fit’ have been included in Section 254(2) in summons cases in order to give the Magistrate the power to refuse to issue such summons if he thinks it proper to do so. The words ‘if he thinks fit’ in Sub-Section (2) of Section 254, further indicate that the Magistrate has to apply his mind when an application is made by the prosecution or the accused to issue such summons. Therefore, even in regard to warrant cases instituted on police report a duty is cast on the Magistrate to take all evidence that may be produced by the prosecution as well as a duty to facilitate the production of evidence by the prosecution, by issuing summons to witnesses on the application of the prosecution and likewise a duty has also been cast on the prosecution to produce all evidence in support of its case. Since both in Section 254(1) as well as in Section 242(3), the words as may be produced in support of the prosecution have been used it is necessary for us to examine the connotation of the words ‘as may be produced’.

    13. In State of Orissa v. Sibcharan Singh, AIR 1962 Orissa 157, it has been observed as follows : (Head-note):—

    “The word ‘produced’ in Sub-Section (7) of Section 251(a) of the Cr PC, 1898 and analogous to Section 242(3) cannot be given any restricted meaning as to saddle the prosecution with the entire responsibility of producing the evidence. A duty also is cast upon the courts for enforcing attendance of witnesses by the process provided in the Code of Criminal Procedure. The courts are not therefore absolutely powerless when the parties fail to produce evidence relevant in a Case”.

    14. In State v. Nandkishore, AIR 1967 Raj 228, it has been observed as follows (Head-note):

    “The word ‘produced’ in Sub-Sec. (9) includes the bringing forward of the witnesses by the prosecution at its own instance or through the process of the court whom it desires to examine at trial. Besides in the administration of criminal justice a duty is cast upon the court to arrive at the truth by all lawful means though the primary responsibility of prosecuting cognisable offence is on the executive authorities”.

    15. We are in respectful agreement with the aforesaid observations of the Orissa and the Rajasthan High Courts. The Rajasthan High Court went on to point out that the Magistrate should not feel himself helpless in such situations and should exercise his inherent powers under Section 540 to summon such witnesses as he thinks necessary for the ends of justice. If the prosecution by its negligence or otherwise fails to discharge its responsibility in producing witnesses, it is incumbent on the court to examine such witnesses as it considers necessary in the ends of justice.

    16. Section 510 of the Cr PC 1898, states as follow:—

    “Any Court may at any stage of enquiry, trial or other proceeding under this Code summon any person as a witness or examine any person in attendance, though not summoned as a witness, or recall and re-examine any person already examined and the court shall summon and examine or recall and examine any such person if his evidence appears to it essential to the just decision of the case”.

    17. The analogous and corresponding provision in the present Code of Criminal Procedure is Section 311. Thus the court cannot absolve itself of its responsibility to summon and examine all witnesses whose evidence appears to it to be essential to a just decision of the case, merely because the prosecution does not produce such witnesses owing to its negligence or otherwise. It being clear that it is the duty of the Magistrate to issue summons and secure the presence of witnesses and examine them, when the prosecution seeks the court's assistance by means of an application, the Court is further obliged in discharge of its duty to arrive at the truth by all lawful means in furtherance of the administration of criminal justice to suo motu take all steps to secure the presence of witnesses where evidence appears to it to be essential to a just decision of the case.

    18. We shall now proceed to indicate the powers which the Magistrate could exercise and the steps he could take under the Code of Criminal Procedure is the matter of securing the presence of witnesses. Section 62 of the Cr PC, reads as follows:—

    “(1) Every summons shall be served by a police officer or subject to such rules as the State Government may make in this behalf, by an officer of the court issuing it or other public servant”, Section 64 states “where the person summoned cannot by the exercise of due diligence be found, the summons may be served by leaving one of the duplicates for him with some adult male member of his family residing with him and the person with whom the summons is so left shall if so required by the serving officer sign a receipt therefor on the back of the other duplicate”.

    19. Section 65 of the Cr PC, states—

    “If service cannot by the exercise of due diligence be effected as provided in Section 62, Section 63 or Section 64, the serving officer shall affix one of the duplicates of the summons to some conspicuous part of the house of homestead in which the person summoned ordinarily resides and thereupon the court after making such enquiries as it thinks fit may either declare that the summons has been duly served or order fresh service in such manner as it considers proper”.

    20. Section 69 which makes provision for service of summons on witnesses by post reads as follows—

    “(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in the preceding Sections of this Chapter, a court issuing a summons to a witness may in addition to and simultaneously with the issue of fresh summons direct a copy of the summons to be served by registered post addressed to the witness at the place where he ordinarily resides or carries on business or personally works for gain.

    (2) Where an acknowledgment purporting to be signed by the witness or an endorsement purporting to be made by a postal employee that the witness refused to take delivery of the summons has been received the court issuing the summons may declare that the summons has been duly served”.

    21. This provision is a new one incorporated in the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1973, and was not in the old Code of Criminal Procedure. This provision, in our experience, has not been resorted to by any Magistrate as far as we know. Of course, it is not practicable to adopt this procedure in every case, for it would result in heavy expenditure to the State. Nevertheless. where summons issued has not been served on the witness by a police officer under Section 62, repeatedly, the Magistrate may resort to this provision of issuing the summons and sending it by registered post to the witness. Of course, if after due service, the witness does not appear before the Court, the Court should issue coercive processes for securing the presence of the witness before the court. In suitable cases, or in cases of chronic or persistent failure to appear in response to the summons, a complaint can be laid under Section 174 I.P.C Then again, the explanation (2) in Section 309 of the Cr PC, also can be made use of in suitable cases by the Magistrate, for that explanation states the terms on which an adjournment or postponement may be granted include in appropriate cases the payment of costs by the prosecution or accused. We might also note here that no rules have been framed by the State Government under Section 62 of the Cr PC. Therefore, as it is, there appears to us to be no bar to the serving of summons by an officer of the court or other public servant.

    22. The next question that would arise is whether even after having recourse to the above provisions, the Magistrate is not able to secure the presence of the witnesses and the prosecution on its part, even after having been given several opportunities, fails to serve the summons on the witnesses or to produce them, the Magistrate would be justified in acquitting the accused either under Section 255(1) of the Cr PC, in summons cases or under Section 248(1) of the Cr PC in warrant cases.

    23. In State of Madh. Pra. v. Kaluthawar, 1972 Cri LJ 1639, a Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court observed as follows—

    “It was the duty of the prosecution to make necessary arrangements for the production of its witnesses……. The Police must always remember that it has got a duty to the court and they cannot just send a challan and think that the rest will be done by the court. When nobody appeared in the court to inform what the reason was for nonappearance of the witnesses, the court could legitimately come to the conclusion that the police was not very serious in prosecuting the offence which was a minor one. Under Section 245, the Magistrate can record an order of acquittal if there is no evidence to hold the accused guilty. If the prosecution did not take proper steps to produce the witnesses, or ask the court to give them time to do the same, or to issue fresh summons, the court was not bound to fix another date. The police has a duty towards the citizen. When the accused is brought before the court and the prosecuting department does not take any steps it will be an abuse of the process of the court to continue the trial. Bringing a person before the court accusing him of some offence is a serious matter and however petty the offence may be, the prosecuting department, must do its duty towards the accused as well as the court. When once the accused is challaned there is no privilege given to the police to remain absent”.

    24. In that case the accused was prosecuted under Section 34 of the Police Act. The case was to be tried according to the procedure prescribed in the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, for the trial of summons cases, that is, under Section 244 of the Cr PC of 1898. The case was posted to a particular date for recording evidence and earlier at the instance of the prosecution summons had been issued to the prosecution witnesses, but on the date of hearing the witnesses did not turn up and the learned Magistrate forthwith passed an order of acquittal, aggrieved by which an appeal against acquittal was preferred by the State which appeal was eventually dismissed by the Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court with the above observations. That was an extreme case.

    25. There are quite a number of decisions in which it had been held that an acquittal of the accused on the failure of the prosecution to produce the witnesses is not legal. (Vide State v. Kaliram Nandlal, AIR 1968 Punj 87, the State of Mysore v. Ramu, 1973 Mad LJ (Crl.) 116 : (1973 Cri LJ 1257) (Mys); State of Mysore v. Kalilulla Ahmed Sheriff, AIR 1971 Mys 60; Kanduri Misra v. Sahadev Kunda, (1962) 2 Cri LJ 295; State of Orissa v. Sibcharan Singh, (1962) 2 Cri LJ 200 : (AIR 1962 Orissa 157); State of Mysore v. Somala, 1972 Mad LJ (Cri) 476 : (1972 Cri LJ 1478) (Mys); State of Mysore v. Shanta, 1972 Mad LJ (Cri) 589 (Mys); State v. Nagappa, 1973 Cri LJ 548 (Mad); Public Prosecutor v. M. Sambangi Mudaliar, 1964 Mad WN (Cri) 136 : (AIR 1965 Mad 31); State of Kerala v. Kunhiaraman, 1964 Mad LJ (Cri) 330 (Ker); State of Mysore v. Narasimha Gowda, AIR 1965 Mys 167; State of Gujarat v. Thakorbhai Sukhabhai, AIR 1968 Guj 15, State Of U.P… v. Ramjani…Accused…., 1965 All LJ 1126; Lakshmiamma Kochukuttiamma v. Raman Pillai, AIR 1952 Trav-Co 268; State v. Madhavan Nair, 1959 Mad LJ (Cri) 633 (Ker); Emperor v. Varadarajulu Naidu, AIR 1932 Mad 25 (2); State Of Kerala…* v. Mary…., 1960 Mad LJ (Cri) 378 (Ker); Kesar Singh v. State of Jammu and Kashmir, 1963-1 Cri LJ 765 : (AIR 1963 J and K 23); R.K.V Motors and Timbers Ltd. v. Regional Transport Authority, Trivandrum, AIR 1960 Ker 35; K.K. Subbier v. K.M.S. Lakshmana Iyer, 1942 Mad WN (Cri) 64 : (AIR 1942 Mad 452 (1)); State of Tripura v. Niranjan Deb Barma, 1973 Cri LJ 108 (Tripura); Apren Joseph v. State of Kerala, 1972 Mad LJ (Cri) 10 : (1972 Cri LJ 1162) (Ker). As against these decisions, there are the following decisions in which it has been held that acquittal on the ground of non-production of witnesses by the prosecution was proper.

    26. State v. John Abraham, 1959 Mad LJ (Cri) 814 : (1961 (2) Cri LJ 92 (1) (Ker)) State v. Lakshmanan, 1966 All LJ 342; Smt. Jyotirmoyee Bose v. Birendra Nath Prodhan, AIR 1960 Cal 263; State v. Ramlal, 1961 (2) Cri LJ 331 (All).

    27. In the first mentioned case, State v. John Abraham, 1959 Mad LJ (Cri) 814. (1961 (2) Cri LJ 92 (1) (Ker)), the case was one of theft and when the case came up for the prosecution to adduce evidence, the prosecution filed a report stating that the witnesses had refused to execute kychits and seeking orders, but there was no prayer to issue process for compelling the attendance of witnesses. The learned single Judge of the Kerala High Court repelled the argument advanced on behalf of the State that under Section 251A(7) of the Cr PC 1898, the Magistrate was bound to examine all the witnesses mentioned in the police report and issue process for their appearance in case the prosecution fails to produce them and the learned Judge held that the duty of the court is only to take evidence which is ready when the case is taken up for hearing and the Magistrate is not bound to go on adjourning the case until all the witnesses mentioned in the police report are examined.

    28. In State v. Lakshmanan, 1966 All LJ 342, it was held that when the witnesses were not present and did not appear when called and there was nobody on behalf of the prosecution although the Magistrate contacted the A.P.P and also the Public Prosecutor and no request was made to the court far any assistance to procure the attendance of the witnesses, it was held that the Magistrate could not be said to have acted illegally if he closed the case and acquitted the accused.

    29. In Smt. Jyotirmoyee Bose v. Birendra Nath Prodhan, AIR 1960 Cal 263, at p. 265, a Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court observed that Sub-Sec. (6) of Section 251-A of the Cr PC, 1898, does not enjoin upon the Magistrate any duty to compel the attendance of any witness unless it was applied for and in a case tried under Section 251-A, of the Cr PC the Magistrate is not compelled as he is if the case is tried as a warrant case instituted other than on a police report, to proceed in terms of Sections 256 and 257 of the Code.

    30. In State v. Ramlal, (1961) 2 Cri LJ 331, a single Judge of the Allahabad High Court observed as follows—

    “Section 252 of the Cr PC imposes a duty upon the Magistrate to ascertain the names of the witnesses who can give evidence on the relevant points and to summon those witnesses in evidence. But, by providing an entirely new procedure, under Section 251-A of the Cr PC, 1898 in cases instituted by the police, the Legislature has deliberately departed from that procedure and in the new procedure has made no provision for summoning of the prosecution witnesses. There is therefore no authority in law for the proposition that the Public Prosecutor can make an application for summoning of prosecution witnesses and in such a case the Magistrate is bound to summon those witnesses………The whole object of the Section appears to have been that the police should be prepared to produce its witnesses when the case is called upon for hearing and it should not be permitted to take shelter behind the absence of witnesses on account of want of summons by the court”.

    31. It may be noted that in the old Code of Criminal Procedure, before the amendment of 1973, and Section 251A which dealt with the trial of warrant cases instituted on police report there was no provision whereby the Magistrate on the application of the prosecution could issue summons to any of its witnesses directing him to attend or produce any documents or other thing. In the present Code, there is such a provision in Section 242(2) in regard to the trial of warrant cases instituted on a police report and in Section 254(2) in regard to the trial of summons cases. Therefore the aforesaid four decisions would no longer be good law.

    32. In almost all the decisions in which it has been held that an acquittal of the accused on the ground that the prosecution did not produce the witnesses was improper, the courts have pointed out that the duty to summon the witnesses in the course of the trial is that of the Magistrate or the Court concerned, and that the entire responsibility of production of witnesses cannot be saddled on the prosecution and a duty is also imposed upon the Court for enforcing the attendance of witnesses by the processes provided in the Code and it is the duty of the court to issue coercive processes if in spite of summons served on the witnesses they do not appear before the court and the prosecution fails to produce the witnesses as directed. We are in respectful agreement with that view in so far as it emphasises the duty of the Magistrate or the court. In some of those decisions it has been held that finding the accused not guilty implies that the court has applied its mind to the merits of the case after recording evidence and then only has found him not guilty. (Vide State at Mysore v. Kalilullah Ahmed Sherili, AIR 1971 Mys 60 and State of Gujarat v. Thaker Bhai Sikhabai, AIR 1968 Guj 15; State of Rajasthan v. Mukhtiar Singh, (1965) Cri LJ 835 (Raj); State of Mysore v. Somala, 1972 Mad LJ (Cri) 476 : (1972 Cri LT 1478 (Mys)); K.K Subbier v. Lakshmana Iyer, 1942 Mad WN (Cri) 64 : (AIR 1942 Mad 452 (1)) and State v. Nagappa, 1973 Cri LJ 548 (Mad)). We are not however able to subscribe to that view. No doubt, there is no specific provision in either the relevant Sections of Chapter XIX which deal with the trial of warrant cases instituted on the police reports by Magistrates or Chapter XX relating to the trial of summons cases instituted on the police report, for acquitting the accused on the ground that the prosecution had not produced its evidence. Nevertheless provisions have been made in the present Code, for summons to be issued to the witnesses on the application of the prosecution and a duty is also cast on the prosecution to produce all its evidence. Thus there is a duty cast on the court on an application by the prosecution to issue summons to the witnesses and secure the presence of witnesses by exercising all the powers conferred on it by the Code for that purpose and duty is also cast on the prosecution to produce all its evidence and to seek the assistance of the court for so doing by applying to the Court for the issue of summons to the witnesses. Therefore, in our view, an acquittal of the accused merely on the ground the prosecution had not produced the witnesses would not be proper if the court had not on an application by the prosecution discharged its duty of summoning and enforcing the attendance of witnesses. We also notice that almost all the decisions which have held such an acquittal as improper dealt with cases in which the Magistrate had not discharged the aforesaid duty. We would also like to refer to a few other decisions which have a bearing on this matter. The first one is the decision in Public Prosecutor v. M. Sambangi Mudaliar, ILR (1965) 1 Mad 418 : (AIR 1985 Mad 31), to which we have already made a reference, Ramakrishnan, J. held that in warrant cases where the court had already framed a charge under Section 251A of the Cr PC against the accused an important duty was laid on it to see that all the powers available to the court for the examination of witnesses were exercised for a just decision of the case irrespective of the laches of the complainant. Therefore, this court had already emphasised the important duty laid on the court to see that all the powers available to the court for the examination of witnesses were exercised for a just decision of the case. Likewise, in Poban Chandra Majumdar v. Dulal Ghosh, AIR 1965 Cal 382 it was held that the order of acquittal was unwarranted by law when in a case instituted on a police report, the Magistrate ordered summons to be issued to the prosecution witnesses, but after certain adjournments without taking any step for procuring the attendance of witnesses to whom summonses were issued he proceeded further and after examining the accused who pleaded not guilty, passed an order of acquittal. In State of Bihar v. Polomistry, AIR 1964 Pat 351, it was observed by a single Judge of the Patna High Court as follows—

    “Where the prosecutor in a criminal trial has himself undertaken to produce the prosecution witnesses the entire responsibility for the production of the evidence in support of the prosecution case is that of the prosecutor. But when the prosecutor has taken recourse to the agency of the Court for securing the attendance of the prosecution witnesses it is undoubtedly the duty of the Magistrate to take steps for securing the attendance of the prosecution witnesses in his court. Where, therefore, in the latter case, none of the prosecution witnesses turn up in spite of the service of the summons issued by the court on them and there are no materials to indicate that there was any reasonable cause for their failure to appear, the proper course for the Magistrate is to take necessary steps to compel the attendance of the witnesses and it is wrong on his part to proceed to acquit the accused on the footing that there is no evidence against them.”

    33. It was further observed - “It is undoubtedly the duty of the Magistrate to take steps for securing the attendance of the prosecution witnesses in his court and it cannot be held that the entire responsibility for securing the attendance of prosecution witnesses lies upon the prosecutor alone. It is only where the prosecutor finds himself unable to produce the prosecution witnesses through his own agency that he relies upon the agency of the Court for securing the attendance of the prosecution witnesses; in such an event, it is the duty of the Magistrate concerned to take all such measures as may be found necessary under the law to compel the attendance of the prosecution witnesses.”

    34. On the question as to whether the Magistrate can acquit an accused at all under Section 251A(11) of the Cr PC, if the prosecution failed to produce their witnesses, a Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court observed in State of Gujarat v. Bava Bhadya, (1962) 2 Cri LJ 537 (2), as follows—

    “Where a charge is framed in a warrant case on police report, if owing to the failure of the prosecution to produce their witnesses and owing also to the failure of the prosecution to make full endeavour to serve the summonses according to the provisions contained in Sections 69, 70 and 71 of the Cr PC, 1898, there is no evidence before the Magistrate, the Magistrate can acquit the accused under Section 251A(11).”

    35. In State of Karnataka v. Subramania Setti, 1980 Mad LJ 138 : (1980 Cri LJ NOC 129), a Division Bench of the Karnataka High Court referring to the decisions in State of Mysore v. Narasimha Gawda, (1964) 2 Mys LJ 241 : (AIR 1965 Mys 167) and the State of Mysore v. Abdul Hameed Khan, (1969) 1 Mys LJ 4 : (1970 Cri LJ 112 (Mys)), observed that the real distinction between the two decisions is as to whether there was remissness and want of diligence on the part of the prosecuting agency in producing the witnesses before the Court and therefore the principle laid down in Abdul Hameed Khan's case applied to the facts of the case with which the division Bench was concerned. We may note here that Abdul Hameed Khan's case, it was found on the facts that the prosecution was not at all diligent as the non-bailable warrants issued to the witnesses had neither been served nor returned to the court by the concerned police and it was therefore held that where the prosecution was not diligent in producing its witnesses and had failed to serve the bailable warrants on the witnesses and return the same the Magistrate would be justified in refusing to grant an adjournment and to proceed to acquit the accused on the material on record. We may note here that in State of Karnataka v. Subramania Setti, 1980 MLJ 138 the Division Bench was dealing with a summons case instituted on a police report.

    36. After carefully considering all the aforesaid decisions and the views expressed therein, we are of the view that if the prosecution had made an application for the issue of summons to its witnesses either under Section 242(2) or 254(2) of the Cr PC it is the duty of the court to issue summons to the prosecution witnesses and to secure the witnesses by exercising all the powers given to it under the Code of Criminal Procedure, as already indicated by us and if still the presence of the witnesses could not be secured and the prosecution also either on account of pronounced negligence or recalcitrance does not produce the witnesses after the Court had given it sufficient time and opportunities to do so, then the Court being left with no other alternative would be justified in acquitting the accused for want of evidence to prove the prosecution case, under Section 248 of the Cr PC, in the case of warrant cases instituted on a police report and under Section 255(1) of the Cr PC in summons cases, and we answer the two questions referred to us in the above terms.

    37. Coming now to these appeals, we might note here that the offences with which the respondents-accused have been charged are offences under Section 4(1)(b) of the Tamil Nadu Prohibition Act, and those prosecutions were launched nearly four years ago.

    38. Furthermore, the prosecution had not, in spite of notices, attempted to produce the witnesses and in fact were quite non-cooperative in their attitude. In view of those circumstances, while pointing out that the acquittal of the respondents-accused in the circumstances of these cases is not proper, inasmuch as the court had not discharged its duty as indicated by us as above, we do not want to interfere with that acquittal at this length of time and hence we dismiss these appeals.

    39. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The State v. Veerappan And Others
    (Mar 24, 1980)