Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of S3 of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972
  • S. 3 (1) (b) (ii) of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972,
  • provisions of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972,
  • S. 3 of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972,
  • provisions of Tamil Nadu Act 21
  • Nadu Act 21 of 1972
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of S3 of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972
  • S. 3 (1) (b) (ii) of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972,
  • provisions of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972,
  • S. 3 of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972,
  • provisions of Tamil Nadu Act 21
  • Nadu Act 21 of 1972
Smart Summary

Concise Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Two suits (O.S. Nos. 522 of 1970 and 72 of 1970) were filed in the Court of the District Munsif, Madurai, by plaintiffs seeking recovery of arrears of rent from Karuppanan Ambalam in respect of two separate parcels of land (2 acres 12 cents and 2 acres 18 cents). The leases required payment of rent at the rate of 16 bags of paddy (48 Madras measures per bag) in each case for faslis 1378 and 1379. The trial court held that the rent payable was 16 bags of paddy in each case and decreed the suit for the value (Rs. 1,280 in each case).

The defendant Karuppanan Ambalam appealed, died during pendency, and his legal representatives were substituted. During the appeals, the tenants filed I.A. Nos. 564 and 565 of 1973 invoking the provisions of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972 (enacted after the suits but before disposal of the appeals) seeking to avail themselves of the Act by depositing the current rent for fasli 1381 so as to have earlier arrears deemed discharged. The deposit made was Rs. 678 in each case (claimed to represent the value of 12 bags), whereas the rent fixed earlier by a civil suit (O.S. No. 18 of 1969) had been 16 bags whose market value was Rs. 1,280.

The III Additional Subordinate Judge, Madurai, considered (1) whether the suits were liable to be dismissed on the deposit for fasli 1381 and (2) whether plaintiffs were entitled to the amounts claimed; he decided both questions against the tenants. The appeals before this court challenge that decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the tenant had complied with the provisions of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972 (particularly S. 3) such that arrears of rent for earlier faslis would be deemed discharged by deposit of the current rent for fasli 1381.
  2. Whether the deposit made (value claimed to represent 12 bags, amounting to Rs. 678) satisfied the statutory requirement of depositing the whole current rent (as fixed earlier at 16 bags / Rs. 1,280) within the period specified by the Act.
  3. Whether, given a bona fide dispute as to the amount to be deposited, the court was bound to grant further time to the tenant to make up any deficiency in deposit under S. 3 of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972.
  4. Whether suits for arrears should be dismissed on the basis of the deposit made under the statute.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Tenant's) Arguments

  • The provisions of S. 3 of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972 apply and, because there was a bona fide dispute as to the quantum to be deposited, the court was obliged to grant further time to make up the deficiency in deposit.
  • The tenants relied on the statutory mechanism in S. 3 to have earlier arrears wiped out by depositing the current rent (or its market value) for fasli 1381.

Respondents' (Plaintiffs') Arguments

  • The rent had already been fixed at 16 bags of paddy by an earlier civil suit (O.S. No. 18 of 1969) and that fixation had become final; therefore the tenant could not claim benefit under the Act after failing to deposit the entire current rent within the period stipulated by the Act.
  • The deposit made (claimed equivalent to 12 kalams/bags) did not represent the market value of the current rent and was much less than the proper rent; accordingly the tenants had not complied with the provisions of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sommadanna Gounder v. Mysore Mission by its power agent, Rev. Father Uthiram, 1977 1 M.L.J. 38 = 89 L.W. 635 Held that where there was a dispute as to the quantum of rent and the quantum had to be determined, the time taken for determination of the amount due could be excluded in calculating the six-month period prescribed by S. 3 of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972 (thus permitting additional time for depositing any shortfall). The court distinguished this precedent as inapplicable: in the present case the rent had already been fixed by a civil court decree (O.S. No. 18 of 1969) and that fixation was final, so there was no analogous period required for determining the quantum that could be excluded. Therefore the principle in the precedent did not assist the tenant here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's reasoning follows a statutory and factual analysis based on the text and purpose of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972, particularly S. 3, and the established facts about the prior fixation of rent:

  1. Purpose and operation of the Act: The Act was enacted to relieve cultivating tenants of arrears payable and outstanding on 30 June 1971, provided the tenant paid or deposited the whole of the rent due for the fasli year 1 July 1971 to 30 June 1972 (the "current rent") either before publication or within six months after publication (S. 3(1)(a)). Payment in kind could alternatively be satisfied by deposit of market value on the date of deposit (S. 3(1)(b)).
  2. Procedure under S. 3: The court or competent authority before which the deposit is made must issue notice to the landlord and after a summary enquiry determine whether the deposited amount represents the correct current rent. If a further sum is found to be due, the court directs the tenant to deposit that sum within the six-month period; if the tenant complies (or no further sum is due), the tenant is deemed to have paid the current rent and earlier arrears are discharged.
  3. Application to facts: It is undisputed that the tenant deposited Rs. 678 (claimed to be value of 12 bags) with the Authorised Officer and the plaintiffs withdrew that amount. The civil court had earlier fixed the rent at 16 bags of paddy (value Rs. 1,280). The deposit was therefore substantially lower than the rent as fixed by the prior decree. The lower appellate court concluded that the tenant had not deposited the entire current rent as contemplated by S. 3.
  4. Distinguishing precedent: The appellant relied on Sommadanna Gounder (where the court allowed exclusion of time taken to determine the correct quantum). The present court held that the precedent turned on facts where the quantum itself required determination; in contrast, here the civil court had already fixed the rent and that fixation was final. Consequently, there was no appreciable period of adjudication pending that could be excluded from the six-month statutory period.
  5. Conclusion from statutory construction and facts: Because the statutory concession under S. 3 is conditional on payment of the whole current rent within the six-month period, and the tenant failed to deposit the entire amount (as earlier fixed), that concession could not be extended. The omission to deposit the full current rent was therefore fatal to the tenant's claim that earlier arrears were wiped out.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeals are dismissed. The court concluded that the tenants did not comply with S. 3 of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972 because they failed to deposit the entire current rent as previously fixed by a decree; hence the earlier arrears were not wiped out and the suits for arrears were rightly decreed by the courts below.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The tenants remain liable for the arrears as decreed; the deposits made did not operate to discharge those arrears because they fell short of the amount required by S. 3 in light of the prior judicial fixation of rent.
  • Procedure and statutory limits: The decision emphasizes that the statutory relief under S. 3 is conditional and time-bound; where the rent has been conclusively fixed by a prior decree, the tenant must deposit the whole amount as fixed within the statutory period to avail the benefit. The court declined to extend or exclude time in those circumstances.
  • Costs and precedent: The appeals were dismissed with no order as to costs. The court distinguished the cited precedent and did not treat this judgment as extending that precedent; no broader rule altering the temporal limit in S. 3 was established beyond the application to the present facts.

This summary is based exclusively on the information contained in the provided opinion and does not add any facts or inferences beyond that text.

    K. Periaswamy Ambalam v. Pichayammal And Others.

    1. These two appeals arise out of appeals from two suits O.S Nos. 522 of 1970 and and 72 of 1970 respectively in the Court of the District Munsif, Madurai. The suits were filed for recovery of arrears of rent from one Karuppanan Ambalam in respect of 2 ac. 12 cents and 2 ac. 18 cents of land belonging to the plaintiffs and leased to the said Karuppanan Ambalam at the rate of 16 bags of paddy of 48 Madras measures in each case. The suits related to the arrears of rent for faslis 1378 and 1379. Karuppanan Ambalam contended that the rent was only 12 bags of paddy 48 Madras measures in each case, and when he paid the rent for faslis 1378 and 1379, the plaintiffs refused to receive (he same giving false hopes to him that the amount may be settled and adjusted in the sale transaction negotiated between the parties. The trial Court held that the rent payable was 16 bags of paddy and decreed the suit for the value thereof, namely, Rs. 1,280 in each.

    2. Karuppanan Ambalam filed two appeals and he died during the pendency of those appeals, and his legal representatives have been brought on record. During the pendency of the appeals I.A Nos. 564 and 565 of 1973 were filed taking advantage of the provisions of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972, which came to be enacted subsequent to the disposal of the suits and before the disposal of the appeals. The attempt of the tenants was to deposit the arrears of rent for fasli 1381, so that the earlier rent could be taken to have been wiped out in accordance with the provisions of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972. The plaintiffs contended that the deposit of the value of 12 kalams of paddy in each case was not proper so as to discharge the arrears and that the proper rent was 16 kalams of paddy in each of the cases. According to the plaintiffs, the value of the paddy deposited by the tenants did not represent the market value and was much less. It was, therefore, contended that the tenants had not complied with the provisions of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972, so that the plaintiffs were entitled to a decree as prayed for in the suit.

    3. The III Additional Subordinate Judge, Madurai, who heard the appeals, went into two questions. One was whether the suits were liable to be dismissed on the deposit of the rent for fasli 1381, and the second was whether the plaintiffs were entitled to the amount claimed by them in the suits. On both these points he decided against the tenants, and that is how the matter comes in appeal before this court.

    4. The learned counsel for the appellant contended that this is a case in which the provisions of S3 of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972 would apply, that in this case, there is a bona fide dispute at to the amount to be deposited and that in such a case, the Court was bound to grant further time for making up the deficiency in deposit. For the respondents, the submission was that this is a ease in which the actual rent had already been fixed under a decree as between the parties, against which there was no appeal, and that this is not a case in which the tenant would be entitled to any benefit under the provisions of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972, after he had failed to deposit the entire rent for fasli 1381, within the period stipulated under the Act.

    5. The only question that arises for consideration is whether the tenant had complied with the provisions of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972, so that the arrears of rent due for the earlier faslis would stand wiped out. Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972 was passed for providing relief to cultivating tenants in respect of arrears of rent. Due to default in the payment of arrears of rent, landlords have taken action against cultivating tenants for eviction as well as for recovery of arrears of rent, It was considered that in the interests of the general public, cultivating tenants should, at the time when the Act was enacted, be spared the distractions and expenditure involved in such action, in order that the maximum possible advantage may result to the State in the matter of production of food crops. It was, therefore, considered necessary, as part of agrarian reforms, to give relief to cultivating tenants from the burden of discharging arrears of rent on condition of payment of the current lent to landlords.

    6. This Act was published in the Fort St. George Gazette on 11th August, 1972. S. 3 (1) which is the only material provision reads as follows—

    “3. Relief in payment of arrears of rent:—(1) (a) All arrears of rent payable by a cultivating tenant to the landlord and outstanding on 30th June, 1971 (hereinafter referred to as arrears of rent), shall be deemed to be discharged; whether or not a decree or order has been obtained therefor, if such cultivating tenant—

    (i) has before the date of the publication of this Act paid to the landlord or deposited in the court or before the competent authority, to the accounts of the landlord; or (ii) pays or deposits in the manner specified in Cl.(b) within six months from the date of the publication of this Act; or (iii) is deemed to have paid or deposited under this Act;

    the whole of the rent due for the fasli year commencing on the 1st July, 197), and ending with 30th June, 1972 (hereinafter referred to as the current rent).

    (b) A cultivating tenant may—(i) pay to the landlord the current rent, or (ii) deposit in the court of before the competent authority, to the account of the landlord, the current rent or if the rent be payable in kind, its market value on the date of deposit;

    (c) The Court in which, or the competent authority before which, the deposit is made, shall cause notice of the deposit to be issued to the landlord and determine, after a summary enquiry, whether the amount deposited represents the correct amount of the current rent due from the cultivating tenant. If the court or competent authority finds that any further sum is due, it shall direct the cultivating tenant to deposit the further sum within the period specified in Cl.(a) (ii). If the Court or competent authority adjudges that no further sum is due or if the cultivating tenant deposits within the time referred to above such further sum as is ordered by the court or competent authority, the cultivating tenant shall be deemed to have paid the current rent for the purposes of this Act.”

    It may be seen from the above provision that arrears of rent payable by a cultivating tenant to a landlord and outstanding on 30th June, 1971, is deemed to be discharged, if the tenant had paid before the date of the publication of the Act to the landlord or deposited in court to the account of the landlord the whole of the rent due for the fasli commencing from 1st July, 1971, and ending with 30th June, 1972. Even in a case where the tenant had not paid the current rent before the publication of the Act or deposited the rent before the said publication, he was given time to pay the rent within six months from the date of the publication of the Act. The six months time would expire by 10th February, 1973. The court or competent authority, before which the deposit is made, has to give notice of the deposit to the landlord and determine, after a summary enquiry, whether the amount deposited represents the correct amount of the current rent due from the cultivating tenant. If the court or the competent authority found that any further sum was due, then, it has to direct the cultivating tenant to deposit the further sum within the period specified in Cl.(ii) of sub-S (1)(a) of S. 3. If the court or the competent authority found that no further sum was due or if the cultivating tenant deposited the further sum found to be due within the period specified in Cl.(a)(ii), then the cultivating tenant is deemed to have paid the current rent for the purposes of the Act, so that the earlier rent in arrears would stand discharged or wiped out. There is no dispute about the fact that the tenant deposited the rent for fasli 1381 before the Authorised Officer, and the plaintiffs had withdrawn the amount. The amount so deposited was Rs. 678. As mentioned earlier, there was dispute as to the quantum of rent payable by the tenant to the landlords in those cases. The quantum was fixed under O.S No. 18 of 1969 and the rent fixed in the said suit was 16 bags of paddy each containing 48 Madras measures. The tenant was, therefore obliged to pay the landlord 16 bags of paddy in each of these cases, while in I.A Nos. 564 and 565 of 1973 he stated that he had deposited the value of only 12 bags of paddy. The market value of the 16 bags of paddy was Rs. 1,280, and at the deposit, was only Rs. 678 in each of these cases, the court below came to the conclusion that the tenant had not deposited the entire rent as contemplated by S. 3 of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972, Prima facie, there appears to be no error in the Judgment of the lower appellate court.

    7. The learned counsel for appellant, however, drew my attention to a decision of this Court in Sommadanna Gounder v. Mysore Mission by its power agent. Rev. Father Uthiram . 1977 1 M.L.J 38=89 L.W 635,. That was a case which came to this Court in a petition to revise the order of the Authorised Officer by which the Authorised Officer had dismissed an application by a tenant filed for a declaration under S. 3 (1) (b) (ii) of Tamil Nadu Act 21 of 1972, that he had discharged the entire arrears due to the landlord by reason of the deposit of the current rent. The deposit in that case was made on 9th February, 1973 with an application for declaration that the entire arrears had been wiped out by reason of such deposit. The landlord disputed the correctness of the amount deposited and contended that the rent payable for each fasli was Rs. 360 and not Rs. 310. The Authorised Officer enquired into this matter, and ultimately accepted the contention of the landlord and held that the rent payable was Rs. 360. Finding that only a sum of Rs. 300 had been deposited and taking the view that he had no authority under the provisions of the Act to extend the time for depositing the balance amount, he dismissed the application. It was against that order that the revision petition came to be filed in this Court. The learned Judge held that that was a case in which the time taken for paying the additional amount could be excluded in calculating the period of six months.

    8. I consider that this decision has no application to the facts of the present case. In that case, there was a dispute as to the quantum of the rent payable to the landlord. The quantum had to be determined and on such determination, some excess was found to be due to the landlord. The question was whether the tenant was entitled to any further time for payment of the excess amount. It is on these facts that the court held that the time taken for determination of the amount due could be excluded. As pointed out earlier, in this case, the civil court had fixed the rent and the fixation had become final. The tenant had only to deposit the rent so fixed. There is no possibility of any time being taken for the determination of the rent by any authority so as to justify its exclusion as in the case cited. The omission to deposit the entire rent on these facts is fatal to the tenant's claim for deeming the earlier rent in arrears to have been wiped out. The concession given to the tenant is conditional on his paying the entire rent for fasli 1381, within the period of six months. If he did not comply with the condition, the statutory concession cannot be extended to him. In this view, it is unnecessary to go into the question raised during the arguments whether the time limit fixed in S. 3 (1)(b) is unalterable without there being any scope for extending the time limit or excluding any time taken in other proceedings. The arrears here are not wiped out. The suit for arrears were rightly decreed,

    9. The appeals are dismissed with no order as to costs. vcs

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K. Periaswamy Ambalam v. Pichayammal And Others.
    (Apr 9, 1979)