Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowment Act, 1959,
  • S. 29 of the Hindu Religious and Charitable Act
  • provisions of S. 9-A of Madras Act IV of 1938.
  • Ryotwari) Act, XXX of 1963. S. 3
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowment Act, 1959,
  • S. 29 of the Hindu Religious and Charitable Act
  • provisions of S. 9-A of Madras Act IV of 1938.
  • Ryotwari) Act, XXX of 1963. S. 3
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The suit was for redemption of a usufructuary mortgage (the "suit hypotheca") executed on 9 May 1947 by Srinivasa Iyengar in favour of the first defendant and his wife Kaliammal for Rs. 1,000, with three years' time for redemption. Kaliammal later died (about 1963) and defendants 2 and 3 are her heirs; the fourth defendant claimed possession under defendants 2 and 3. Plaintiffs 1 and 2 sold the properties to plaintiffs 3 to 7 by a registered sale deed dated 21 January 1966; plaintiffs 3 to 7 are described in the opinion as entitled to redemption and plaintiffs 1 and 2 were joined to avoid technical objection. The plaintiffs asserted that the amount due under the mortgage was only Rs. 375 under the provisions of S. 9-A of Madras Act IV of 1938, and sued for redemption and recovery of possession.

The defendants pleaded that the suit property was a devadayam minor inam granted for chanting Sahasranamam at the Sri Prasanna Venkataramanaswami temple, that Srinivasa Iyengar was only an oozhiadar without proprietary rights, that services had ceased after his death (20 January 1950), and therefore plaintiffs 1 and 2 lacked title, locus standi and the right to redeem. The defendants further relied on the abolition and conversion scheme under the Madras Minor Inams (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act (as presented in the record) and on a Government notification dated 15 February 1965 by which the properties were said to have vested in Government; they contended that the suit was not competent and rights must be worked out under that Act.

The trial court decreed the suit for redemption, holding plaintiffs 1 and 2 had title, that mortgagees could not challenge that title, and that plaintiffs had the right to redeem; but it also held that because the plaintiffs were not agriculturists they were not entitled to certain statutory benefits and that the full Rs. 1,000 was payable before redemption. The trial court granted a decree for redemption in favour of the first plaintiff alone on payment of Rs. 1,000 and for recovery of possession, concluding that the sale to plaintiffs 3–7 was invalid.

Both sides appealed: defendants filed A.S. No. 2 of 1968 and plaintiffs filed Ap. No. 125 of 1969. The Additional Subordinate Judge heard both appeals together and dismissed them, confirming the trial court's conclusions on all points. The defendants (appellants in the second appeal) then filed the second appeal which is the subject of the present opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the rights in the suit hypotheca (a minor inam) survive the operation of the Madras Minor Inams (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act such that the plaintiffs can maintain and succeed in a suit for redemption of the mortgage.
  2. Whether, in consequence of the Act and the relevant notification, the mortgagee's and mortgagor's remedies and entitlements (including the right to redeem) continue to be enforceable in the ordinary way or must be worked out exclusively under the provisions of the Act.
  3. Whether the plaintiffs had title and locus to claim redemption and possession, given the allegations of discontinuance of the service (chanting Sahasranamam) and the effect of vesting in Government under the relevant statutory scheme.
  4. Whether the courts below erred in treating the suit as a simple action for redemption without applying the statutory scheme governing minor inams and service inams.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Contentions

  • The amount due under the mortgage was only Rs. 375 as per the provisions of S. 9-A of Madras Act IV of 1938 (as pleaded by the plaintiffs).
  • Plaintiffs 3 to 7 (purchasers under the registered sale deed dated 21 January 1966) are entitled to redeem the mortgage; plaintiffs 1 and 2 were joined to avoid technical objection.

Defendants' Contentions

  • The suit hypotheca was not the absolute property of plaintiffs 1 and 2 but a devadayam minor inam granted for chanting Sahasranamam; Srinivasa Iyengar was only an oozhiadar with no proprietary rights or interests.
  • Srinivasa Iyengar died on 20 January 1950 and there was a total discontinuance of the services thereafter, which, the defendants say, caused loss of rights by forfeiture and destroyed plaintiffs' locus standi to sue for possession or redemption.
  • The sale to plaintiffs 3 to 7 was void and illegal (as per defendants' plea).
  • Minor inams have been abolished under the Madras Minor Inams (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act (the complaint refers to a version labelled XXX of 1967 in the pleadings) and, following the notification of 15 February 1965, the properties vested in Government; consequently the parties' rights were extinguished or must be determined under that Act and the suit was not competent.

Submissions Drawn to Court's Attention (Statutory Register under HR&CE Act)

  • Respondents' counsel (Mr. M.S. Venkatarama Iyer) relied on provisions of the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowment Act, 1959, particularly S. 29(1)(e), requiring a register of all endowments, title deeds and particulars of service-holders for religious institutions. The counsel submitted that the service-holder's name and particulars would be recorded under that statutory scheme and that the service-holder's right depends upon whether he was rendering the service on the notified day.
  • The appellants pointed to documentary entries (Exhibits B10 and B11) showing that the register entry relating to performance of the Sahasranamam service was vacant; appellants' counsel observed that absence of an entry might not conclusively establish non-performance (service might be performed by proxy), but that the factual question of service performance required examination in appropriate proceedings and was not to be decided in the present forum.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded principally by statutory construction of the provisions of the Madras Minor Inams (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act as those provisions affect the rights in a minor inam:

  1. The court identified S. 3 of the Act as the vesting section: on the appointed day every minor inam stands transferred to and vests in Government free of encumbrances; clause (c) provides that rights and interests created by the inamdar before the appointed day cease and determine as against the Government; clause (e) and (f) further restrict the post-notification rights of the inamdar and extinguish the inamdar's rights and obligations as such.
  2. The court then examined the statutory scheme for reallocation of rights: S. 8 (grant of ryotwari pattas) and its sub-sections, S. 9 (pattas in other cases), S. 20 (tasdik allowance to institutions) and S. 21 (service inams). The provisions of S. 21 were described in detail, including continuation of services, the option to pay an amount to discharge service conditions, the role of tasdik allowance, the consequences of failure to render service, and the declaration by prescribed officers which may terminate a service-holder's right to occupy.
  3. On this statutory matrix the court concluded that the rights of the parties in respect of the suit property were crystallized on the notified date and, thereafter, their rights and remedies had to be worked out exclusively under the statutory scheme of the Act. The court expressly stated that the plaintiffs "cannot seek to enforce their right to redeem the mortgage which has ceased to be operative on the date of the notification."
  4. The court observed that the mortgagee's remedy is to proceed against any compensation amount standing in deposit (i.e., the compensation payable under the Act) for recovery of the mortgage debt, rather than permitting ordinary redemption proceedings in the pre-Act form.
  5. The court also accepted the relevance of the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowment Act, 1959 (S. 29(1)(e)) insofar as the register required by that statute would reflect particulars of service-holders and the services to be rendered; thus, whether a service-holder was rendering service on the appointed day is a determinative question for entitlement under the minor inams statutory scheme.
  6. The court concluded that the lower courts had treated the dispute as a simple mortgage redemption action and had failed to apply the statutory scheme governing minor inams and service inams. The question whether services were being performed (including the documentary evidence in Ex. B10 and B11 showing an apparently vacant entry) concerned factual adjudication in appropriate proceedings and was not for determination in the present appeal.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The second appeal is ALLOWED.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The court held that the plaintiffs cannot enforce a conventional right of redemption of the mortgage because the statutory vesting and conversion provisions applicable to minor inams operate to change the mode of enforcement; the right to redeem the mortgage "has ceased to be operative" on the date of the notification and the parties' rights must be worked out under the Madras Minor Inams Act.
  • As to recovery of the mortgage debt, the mortgagee's remedy is directed to the compensation amount deposited (under the statutory scheme) rather than to ordinary redemption proceedings against the land itself.
  • The service-holder's rights depend on whether he was actually rendering the requisite service on the notified day; the HR&CE Act register entries are relevant evidence of that fact, but the factual question of service performance must be determined in appropriate proceedings and not in this appeal.
  • The courts below erred in treating the dispute as a straightforward suit for redemption without applying the statutory provisions governing minor inams and service inams; the appellate allowance of the second appeal reverses that approach.
  • No broader common-law or judicial precedent is stated to have been created by this decision in the opinion; the practical consequence is confined to the parties (i.e., plaintiffs cannot claim redemption as sought and must pursue their entitlements under the statutory scheme). The opinion makes no specific declaration of new legal principle beyond applying the enacted provisions to the facts before the court.

Order: There will be no order as to costs. No leave. (Signed V.C.S.)

    Periayammal And Others v. Rukmani Ammal And Others

    1. The defendants are the appellants. The suit is for redemption. The suit hypotheca belonged to one Srinivasa Iyengar, the husband of the first plaintiff and the father of the second plaintiff, who borrowed a sum of Rs. 1000 under a usufructuary mortgage dated 9th May 1947 executed in favour of the first defendant and his wife, Kaliammal, the, mother of defendants 2 and 3. The time for redemption was three years. Kaliammal died about 1963, and defendants 2 and 3 are her heirs. The fourth defendant claimed to be in possession of the mortgaged property under defendants 2 and 3. Plaintiffs 1 and 2 sold the properties to plaintiffs 3 to 7 under a registered sale deed, dated 21st January 1966 and plaintiffs 3 to 7 are entitled to redemption. Plaintiffs 1 and 2 have been joined to avoid any technical objection. According to the plaintiffs the amount due under the mortgage is only Rs. 375 as per the provisions of S. 9-A of Madras Act IV of 1938. The suit is laid for the redemption of the mortgage and for recovery of possession.

    2. The defence to the suit was that the suit hypotheca is not the absolute property of plaintiffs 1 and 2, that it is a devadayam inam granted for chanting Sahasranamam in the temple of Sri Prasanna Venkataramanaswami at Kangayam, that Srinivasa Iyengar, the husband of the first plaintiff and the father of the second plaintiff was only an oozhiadar, having no proprietary rights or interests in the inam lands, that Srinivasa Iyengar died on 20th January 1950 and that plaintiffs 1 and 2 had no right of enjoyment or title to the property as there was a total discontinuance of the services after Srinivasa Iyengar's death. The further contention of the defendants is that the plaintiffs 1 and 2 have no locus standi to maintain the suit for recovery of possession, that the rights of Srinivasa Iyengar were lost by discontinuance of services for a long number of years, that the plaintiffs had forfeited all rights to such office and could not claim to redeem the mortgage and that the sale to plaintiffs 3 to 7 is void and illegal. Their further contention is that minor inams have been abolished under the provisions of the Madras Minor Inams (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act, XXX of 1967, that pursuant to the notification dated 15th February 1965, the properties have vested in the Government, that the rights of the parties have been extinguished and that the suit is not competent. The rights of the parties are governed by the provisions of the said Act, the parties have to work out their rights under that Act and the present suit is not maintainable.

    3. The trial court decreed the suit for redemption. While doing so, it held that plaintiffs 1 and 2 had title to the suit property, that the defendants being mortgagees could not question the title of plaintiffs 1 and 2, that plaintiffs 1 and 2 had a right to redeem the mortgage and that the suit for redemption is maintainable. The trial court further held, on the question of the correct amount due under the suit mortgage, that the plaintiffs not being agriculturists, are not entitled to the benefits of the Act and that the entire amount due under the mortgage is payable before redemption. In the result the trial court gave a decree for redemption in favour of the first plaintiff alone on payment of a sum of Rs. 1000 and for recovery of possession of the hypotheca from the defendants, in view of the fact that the alienation in favour of plaintiffs 3 to 7 is invalid.

    4. The defendants filed A.S 2 of 1968 and the plaintiffs filed Ap. No. 125 of 1969 against the judgment of the trial court. Both the appeals were heard together, and the learned Additional Subordinate Judge dismissed both the appeals confirming the conclusions of the trial court on all the points. The defendants have filed this second appeal.

    5. The suit property was admittedly a minor inam covered by the provisions of the Madras Minor Inams (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act, XXX of 1963. S. 3 is the vesting Section, under which with effect on and from the appointed day every minor inam shall stand transferred to the Government and vest in them free of all encumbrances. Cl. (c) provides that all rights and interests created by the inamdar in or over his inam before the appointed day shall, as against the Government, cease and determine. Cl. (e) provides that the inamdar and any other person whose rights stand transferred under Cl. (b) or cease and determine under Cl. (e) shall be entitled only to such rights and privileges as are recognised or conferred on him by or under the Act. Cl. (f) provides that the rights and obligations of the Inamdar as such shall be extinguished. The position therefore, is that on the notified date the rights of the parties are crystallized and thereafter they have to be worked out only under the provisions of the. Act.

    6. The next relevant provision is S. 8 which provides for the grant of ryotwari pattas. Under S. 8(1) every person who is lawfully entitled to the kudiwaram in an inam land immediately before the appointed day shall be entitled to ryotwari patta in respect or the land. Sub-S.(2) deals with the properties granted as minor inam for the support or maintenance of a religious institution or for the performance of a charity or service connected therewith or of any other religious charity. Cl. (i) of S. 8(1) deals with the rights of transferees of the lands by way of sale. Cl. (ii) of S. 8(1) deals with the rights of the institution or individual rendering service; that is to say, that such individual rendering service with effect on and from the appointed day will be entitled to ryotwari patta in respect of the land. Sub-S. (5) of S8 provides that, in the case of a minor inam held immediately before the appointed day by an individual on condition of rendering service to a religious, educational or charitable institution, the grant of ryotwari patta under sub-S. (1) or (2), shall be subject to the provisions of S. 21.

    7. S. 9 deals with the grant of ryotwari patta in cases not covered by S. 8.

    8. The next relevant provision is S. 20, which provides for the payment of tasdik allowance to religious, educational or charitable institution, where the inamdar of an iruvaram minor inam is a religious, educational or charitable institution or an individual holding the inam on condition of rendering service to a religious educational or charitable institution, and the rate at which the Government shall pay to the institution every fasli year commencing from the fasli year in which the appointed day falls as tasdik allowance which shall be calculated in terms of S. 19.

    9. S. 21 deals with the service inams and it applies in respect of any minor inam which was held immediately before the appointed day by an individual, namely, the service holder, on condition of his rendering service to a religious, educational or charitable institution. Sub-S. (2) provides that the service holder shall subject to the provisions of sub-S. (3) continue to render service after the appointed day. Sub-S. (3) deals with a situation where the service holder who is entitled to a ryotwari patta under S. 8, shall have the following options, viz., (i) either to pay to the religious institution the amount specified in sub-S. (4) and on such payment the land shall be discharged from the conditions of the service, or (ii) to hold the hind and continue to render service subject to the provisions contained in sub Ss. (1), (2), (6) and (7). Sub S. (5) provides that, where the service holder has exercised his option to pay the amount specified in sub S. (4) the tasdik allowance referred to in sub. S. (6) in respect of the period subsequent to the date of the exercise of such option shall be the absolute property of the institution and the institution shall be at liberty to make such arrangements as it thinks fit for the performance of the service. Cl. (a) of sub. S. (6) provides that the institution shall pay to the service holder the tasdik allowance paid by the Government under S. 20 so long as he renders service, and under Cl. (b), if the service holder fails to render service, after due enquiry, notify such failure and then declare that the tasdik allowance payable to the institution in respect of the period subsequent to the failure shall be the absolute property of the institution, and the institution shall be at liberty to make such arrangement as it thinks fit for the performance of the service. Sub-S. (7) provides for the service holder being entitled to occupy permanently the lands in respect of which he is entitled to a patta under S. 8, subject to the payment of the assessment fixed in respect of such lands. In case the service holder fails to render service, the prescribed officer shall declare that the service holder's right to occupy the land under Cl. (a) Shall cease and determine and the institution Shall be at liberty to make such arrangements as it thinks fit for the performance of the Service and shall hold the land as its absolute property subject to the payment of the assessment fixed therefor.

    10. I have referred to these provisions in detail only for the purpose of showing that plaintiffs will have to work out their rights only under the provisions of the Act, and that they cannot seek to enforce their right to redeem the mortgage which has ceased to be operative on the date of the notification. The mortgagee will be entitled to proceed against the compensation amount in deposit for the recovery of the amount due under the mortage. The plaintiffs, however, will not be entitled to claim redemption of the mortgage and their rights lie elsewhere which they have to work out.

    11. Mr. M.S Venkatarama Iyer, the learned counsel for the respondents, drew my attention to some of the provisions of the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowment Act, 1959, in particular, to S. 29(1)(e), under which for every religious institution there shall be prepared and maintained a register in such form as the Commissioner may direct showing particulars of all other endowments of the institution and of all the title deeds and other documents. Therefore, in respect of this institution the name of the service, holder would be entered in the register in accordance with the record prepared under S. 29 of the Hindu Religious and Charitable Act and the service which the service holder is bound to render, namely, recital of Sahasranamam for the institution. Considering this provision along with the provisions of the Minor Inams Act, the position is that the service holder's right would depend upon the question whether or not he was rendering service to the institution on the notified day.

    12. The courts below have missed this significant aspect of the matter and have proceeded on the basis that the suit Is for redemption of a mortgage simpliciter. The learned counsel for the appellants drew my attention to Ex. B10 and B.11 which are particulars relating to the service rendered by the service holders in Sri Prasanna Venkataramanasami temple, Kangayam, maintained by the authorities. The particulars therein show that the entry relating to performance of Sahasranamam service if vacant, that is to say that no Sahasranamam is being chanted. On this the learned counsel comments that the service, if performed through proxy, may not be entered in the register and that, that entry will not establish that the service is not performed at all. This is a matter which has to be examined in appropriate proceedings, but, this is not the forum for determining that question.

    13. The second appeal is therefore allowed. There will be no order as to costs. No leave.

    V.C.S

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Periayammal And Others v. Rukmani Ammal And Others
    (Apr 12, 1973)