Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner (the employer) reprimanded an employee who responded abusively. The employer suspended the worker and delivered a memorandum of charges. The petitioner invited the second respondent (a Union) to have its secretary present at the enquiry; the secretary later declined, saying it was a matter of domestic concern. The Union then contacted the Labour Officer following the worker's complaint that he had not been given employment. The matter proceeded to the Government and two questions were referred to the Labour Court. The petitioner did not appear before the Labour Court, which made an ex parte award dated 31-10-1962 directing reinstatement of the worker and awarding back wages from the date of non-employment.

The petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 226 in December 1963 seeking certiorari to quash the Labour Court's order. In his affidavit the petitioner said he was unaware of the date of the final hearing and had expected a fresh notice after attending the penultimate hearing. The Union's counter affidavit stated that the petitioner failed to participate during conciliation and in response to notices from the Labour Officer and the Labour Court, and that no counter-statement was filed by the management. The Labour Court's ex parte award was thus defended as rightly passed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the reference to the Labour Court was proper when the dispute began as an individual dispute arising out of the conduct of a single employee (i.e., whether the matter had assumed the character of an industrial dispute).
  2. Whether the second respondent-Union could represent the worker and legitimately take the matter before the Labour Officer and the Labour Court.
  3. Whether suspension of the worker amounted to non-employment and could give rise to an industrial dispute and therefore be subject to adjudication.
  4. Whether an ex parte award against the employer, arising from the employer's non-appearance, could be challenged where the employer claims lack of notice or absence for other reasons.
  5. Whether reinstatement (and back wages) was an appropriate remedy in the circumstances, including where the employer may have engaged other workers after the dismissal or non-employment.
  6. Whether the Labour Court erred in making the award effective from an earlier date (retrospective operation) and whether such an operation contravened statutory provisions concerning enforceability.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Employer's) Arguments

  • This was essentially an individual dispute arising out of the conduct of an employee, not a dispute about terms of service; therefore the reference to the Labour Court was improper.
  • The second respondent-Union could not represent the worker in this matter.
  • No victimisation or unfair labour practice was alleged or proved; consequently reinstatement was not justified.
  • The worker was only suspended pending enquiry, not dismissed or non-employed; suspension was not a punishment and thus not properly the subject of adjudication as in this case.
  • The petitioner asserted he was not aware of the date of the final hearing and had expected further notice, which explained his non-appearance before the Labour Court.

Second Respondent-Union's Arguments (as stated in counter affidavit)

  • The Union stated that the matter was taken to the Labour Officer through conciliation proceedings and that the Labour Officer issued several notices to the petitioner which the petitioner did not answer.
  • When the matter reached the Labour Court, the Labour Court also issued several notices to the petitioner without eliciting a reply, and the management did not file any counter-statement in response to the Labour Court's notice.
  • Accordingly, the Union contended the ex parte award was rightly passed and that the petitioner was at fault for deliberately failing to participate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bombay Union of Journalists v. The Hindu, Bombay (AIR 1963 SC 318) An individual dispute between an employer and a single employee may become an industrial dispute if it is taken up by the Union or an appreciable number of workmen; the test is whether, at the date of reference, the dispute was supported by the Union or an appreciable number of workmen. The Court applied this test and found it satisfied because the Union represented all seven employees and had taken up the matter before the Labour Officer; therefore the reference to the Labour Court was proper.
Employers, Express Newspapers Ltd., Madras v. Labour Court, Andhra Pradesh (1962-2 Andh WR 226; AIR 1963 Andh Pra 223) Supportive authority to the principle that an individual dispute may assume industrial character when backed by a Union or appreciable number of workers. The Court cited this decision as being to a similar effect and used it to reinforce the conclusion that the dispute had become industrial in character.
M.L. Bose & Co. (P) Ltd. v. Its Employees (AIR 1961 SC 1198; 1961-2 Lab LJ 107) Even where an employer has subsequently engaged a fresh set of employees after dismissal, that fact is not necessarily a defence to reinstatement; in wrongful or illegal dismissal cases the worker is entitled to claim reinstatement and reinstatement may be appropriate in proper cases. The Court relied on this authority to hold that reinstatement was an appropriate consequence of the Labour Court's findings and that reinstatement follows "almost automatically" from such findings.
Bangalore Woollen, Cotton and Silk Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of Mysore (AIR 1958 Mys 85) A tribunal has jurisdiction to give its award retrospective operation; however, enforceability of the award is governed by the statute and may commence only as provided by law. The Court used this authority to explain that the Labour Court could make its award effective from an earlier date and that such a direction does not necessarily offend statutory provisions regarding enforceability.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded through the contested points in the following manner, applying the facts presented and cited authorities without introducing new factual findings beyond the record:

  1. On the nature of the dispute: The Court held that suspension constitutes non-employment and that any act of the employer involving non-employment or violation of terms of service can give rise to an industrial dispute. The Court rejected the submission that absence of prior disputes or absence of an allegation of victimisation prevents a reference. The decisive test was whether the dispute, by the date of the reference, was taken up by the Union or supported by an appreciable number of workmen. Because the Union represented all seven employees and had actively taken up the matter before the Labour Officer, the Court concluded the dispute had assumed the character of an industrial dispute and the reference was proper (relying on Bombay Union of Journalists and similar authority).
  2. On the propriety of the ex parte award: The Court noted that the petitioner failed to participate in conciliation proceedings before the Labour Officer and failed to appear or file any counter-statement before the Labour Court despite notices. While the Court accepted that non-participation does not by itself preclude challenging legal errors, it emphasized that factual issues which a competent tribunal can decide in the absence of a party cannot be re-litigated in the Article 226 petition. Given the petitioner's non-appearance and failure to present his case, the Court found no basis to overturn the ex parte award on those grounds.
  3. On the merits of the Tribunal's factual conclusion: The Court examined the material before the Labour Court and held the Tribunal was justified in concluding the employer was not justified in refusing to employ the worker. The Court emphasized that the employer had not proceeded with or completed disciplinary steps after delivering a memorandum of charges and had not presented its side before the Labour Officer. On that factual footing, the Tribunal's conclusion was held to be properly drawn from the evidence.
  4. On reinstatement as remedy: The Court referred to M.L. Bose & Co. and held that reinstatement is an available and appropriate remedy in wrongful or illegal dismissal/non-employment cases, even where the employer has taken on other employees later. The Court stated that reinstatement follows almost automatically from the Labour Court's factual findings in this case.
  5. On retrospective operation of the award and enforceability: The petitioner argued the Labour Court erred by directing the award to come into force from the date of publication; learned counsel said enforceability attaches only after the statutory one-month period. The Court distinguished "operation" (i.e., making an award effective from an earlier date) from "enforceability" (which depends upon the statute). Relying on Bangalore Woollen, the Court held a tribunal may give retrospective operation to its award and that the Labour Court's direction did not offend the statutory provisions governing enforceability.
  6. Overall result of analysis: Having considered the procedural defaults by the petitioner, the factual material before the Tribunal, and applicable authorities, the Court found none of the petitioner's contentions to be sound and dismissed the petition while ordering no costs.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The petition is dismissed.

Implications:

  • The Labour Court's ex parte award of 31-10-1962 directing reinstatement of the worker and awarding back wages remains unimpeached by this writ petition.
  • The Court affirmed that suspension can amount to non-employment and may give rise to an industrial dispute when the dispute is supported by a Union or an appreciable number of workmen; the second respondent-Union's involvement rendered the reference proper on the facts of this case.
  • The Court endorsed that reinstatement is an appropriate remedy in wrongful or illegal dismissal/non-employment cases (as discussed with reference to M.L. Bose & Co.), and that a tribunal may make an award operative retrospectively though enforceability depends on statutory provisions.
  • No costs were awarded to either party in the circumstances of this petition.
  • Broader legal consequences beyond the direct effect on the parties are not discussed in the opinion; the decision resolves the petition by dismissing it and leaves the Labour Court's order in place.

Disposition recorded in the opinion: "Petition dismissed" (with no order as to costs).

    B. Kalyanasundaram, Proprietor, B.N Press, Madras 2 v. Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Madras And Another

    1. The petitioner, the employer, had occasion to reprimand one of his employees. The employee turned abusive. The employer placed the worker under suspension and gave a memorandum of charges to him. Thereafter, the petitioner addressed the second respondent-Union asking the secretary of the Union to be present at the enquiry into the charge. The secretary did not reply immediately but sometime later declined to be present stating that it was a matter of domestic concern. In the meantime, apparently, on the complaint of the worker that he had not been given employment, the Union contacted the Labour Officer. Finally, the matter reached the Government and two questions were referred for adjudication to the Labour court. Before the Labour court, however, the petitioner did not appear. There was an ex parte award directing the reinstatement of the worker and awarding back wages to him from the date of his non-employment. This order was passed on 31-10-1962.

    2. The petitioner has come to this court with the petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution in December 1963 and seeks the issue of a writ of certiorari to quash the order of the Labour Court. It is suggested in the affidavit accompanying the petition that the petitioner was not aware of the date of the hearing, and that though he attended the penultimate hearing, he was under the impression that he would receive a fresh notice with regard to the next hearing. This is given as the reason why he was not present on the date of the final hearing. It is unnecessary to refer to various grounds set out in the affidavit accompanying the petition. It will be sufficient to deal with the grounds as have been pressed before me in the course of the arguments in the writ petition. In the counter affidavit filed on behalf of the Union, it has been asserted that though the matter was brought before the Labour Officer by way of conciliation proceedings and the labour officer issued several notices to the petitioner, the petitioner did not care to appear and put forward whatever he had to say in connection with the enquiry before the Labour Officer. It is also stated that when the matter reached the Labour Court, the Labour Court issued several notices to the petitioner but could elicit no reply. It is further stated that the management did not file any counter statement at all in response to the notice issued by the Labour Court. It is accordingly contended that the award was rightly passed ex parte and that the petitioner has only himself to blame for deliberately failing to participate in the enquiry. It is claimed that the order of the Labour Court does no I. suffer from any invalidity which justifies interference therewith.

    3. One of the contentions advanced by Mr. Venkataraman, learned counsel for the petitioner, is that this is really an individual dispute arising out of the conduct of an employee, that it does not relate to the terms of service, that no victimisation or unfair labour practice was alleged and that being so the very reference itself is improper. It is further contended that the second respondent-Union cannot represent the worker. It is urged that the Labour Court has not found that there is victimisation and that in the circumstances the order reinstating the worker is not justified. It is contended also that the worker was suspended pending the enquiry, that it was not a case of non-employment at all and that his suspension not being in the nature of punishment inflicted upon the worker, it could not be brought for adjudication as in the present case.

    4. In so far as the last point is concerned, whether or not suspension was a measure of punishment I am really unable to see how an industrial dispute cannot arise out of such a direction made by the management, Even suspension amounts to non-employment of a worker and in relation to such non-employment alleged to be devoid of valid reasons, a dispute can be raised. So long as the dispute does not remain an individual dispute but assumes the form of an industrial dispute in which the general body of the workers display an interest, then, it cannot be said that a reference would not be proper. In this case, it is not denied by learned counsel on behalf of the management that all the seven employees are members of the second respondent Union and when the second respondent-Union took up the matter before the Labour Officer for conciliation, it obviously, offered clear indication that the Union represented the body of the workers in sponsoring the cause of the employee. Though a dispute may start as an individual dispute, it assumes the form of an industrial dispute by the backing which the dispute receives from other employees of that concern or by a Union in which such employees are members. In this case there is no doubt that this was the position and the contention that there was only an individual dispute which remained as such right through cannot possibly be accepted.

    5. This has been fully explained in the decision of the Supreme Court in Bombay Union of Journalists v. The Hindu Bombay, AIR 1963 SC 318. There Lordships have pointed out that a dispute between an employer and a single employee cannot per se be an industrial dispute but it may become one if it is taken up by the Union or a number of workmen. They also say that in each case in ascertaining whether an individual dispute has acquired the character of an industrial dispute, the test is whether at the date of the reference, the dispute was taken up or supported by the Union of the workmen of the employer against whom the dispute is raised by an individual workman or by an appreciable number of workmen. The test is fully satisfied in the present case for the Union represents all the workers employed by this particular management. To a similar effect is the decision in Employers, Express Newspapers Ltd., Madras v. Labour Court, Andhra Pradesh, 1962-2 Andh WR 226 : (AIR 1963 Andh Pra 223). It is unnecessary to refer to details of this decision.

    6. That there was no earlier dispute and that no victimisation was alleged or proved are matters which are not germane to the question raised before me. I am really unable to follow the precise scope of the argument that there can be no reference in so far as the direction of reinstatement is concerned unless victimisation is alleged. In order to acquire the character of an industrial dispute, it is not always necessary that an allegation of victimisation should form the foundation of the charge. Any act of the employer which involves non-employment of a worker or violation of the terms of; service upon which he is employed can give rise to an industrial dispute. Victimisation is no doubt alleged in proper cases but it is not a necessary incident to each and every industrial dispute which an employee raises against the employer.

    7. Several allegations of fact have been made in the affidavit accompanying the petition and the petitioner seeks to justify his claim, that his failure to appear before the Labour Court during the conciliation proceedings or before the Labour Court leading to the ex parte award against him cannot conclude the question against him. I agree that the mere fact that he did not participate in that enquiry does not prevent him from raising such questions; as would involve either an error of law apparent on the face of the record or error or jurisdiction in the award of the Tribunal. He cannot certainly be permitted at this stage to canvass questions of fact which can validly be decided even in the absence of the party, by the Tribunal competent to decide such issues.

    8. Coming to the question whether the Tribunal was right in its finding that the employer was not justified in refusing to employ the worker, it appears to me that upon the facts presented to the Tribunal it was justified in coming to the conclusion as it did. Mr. Ramaswami, learned counsel for the second respondent Union points out that though the petitioner-management purported to deliver a memorandum of charge to the employee, the management took no steps whatsoever to proceed further with the charges and decide whether the employee was to be dealt with or not in the domestic forum. The employer took shelter apparently under the plea that the worker had approached the Union and the Union had contacted the Labour Officer. But the fact remains that the employer did not choose to put forward his contention or his side of the case even before the Labour Officer. In those circumstances, there is no merit in the contention that the Tribunal did not appreciate the evidence properly in coming to the conclusion that the employer was not justified in dealing with the employee and placing him under suspension.

    9. On the question of reinstatement, which has been ordered by the Labour Court, the Supreme Court has held in M.L Bose and, Co. (P) Ltd. v. Its Employees, 1961-2 Lab LJ 107 : (AIR 1961 SC 1198), that even in, extreme cases where the employer has, subsequent to the dismissal of the workmen, entertained a fresh set of employees it is no answer in denial or the relief of reinstatement to the dismissed employees in proper cases. They observe that however much the Court may sympathise with the difficulties arising from such a position, in the case of wrongful or illegal dismissal the worker is entitled to claim reinstatement. It does not appear from the decisions bearing on the point that it is only in cases where unfair labour practice or victimisation is alleged or proved that reinstatement can generally be ordered. Upon the findings recorded by the Labour Court, the direction for reinstatement flows almost automatically.

    10. It is lastly contended that the Labour Court has given retrospective operation to its award, and has in fact directed that the award will come into force on the date of its publication which is opposed to the provisions of the Act. According to learned counsel, an award becomes enforceable only on the expiry of one month after the date of the publication of the award. The direction that the award will come into force from the date of the publication is attacked as erroneous in law. It seems to me that this contention is not correct.

    11. It is open to the Labour Court to make the award effective even from an anterior date. But the enforceability of the award depends upon the provisions of the statute. The distinction between the operation of the award and its enforceability has been brought out in more than one decision. In Bangalore Woollen, Cotton and Silk Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of Mysore, AIR 1958 Mys 85, the learned Judges of the Mysore High Court have held that the Tribunal has jurisdiction to give its award retrospective operation. But the enforceability of the award is from the date as provided in the statute. The observation of the Labour Court in the instant case that the award will come into force from the date of the publication does not really offend the relevant provision in the statute.

    12. It seems to me that none of the contentions pressed on behalf of the petitioner is sound. The petition is dismissed, but in the circumstances there will be no order as to costs.

    KI/SG/R.G.D

    13. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    B. Kalyanasundaram, ... v. Presiding Officer, L...
    (Apr 6, 1965)