AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — R. O. Nos. 68 & 58 of 1953

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion deals with two references (R. O. No. 68 of 1953 and R. O. No. 58 of 1953) presented to the Court under Section 66(2) of the Income-tax Act. The references arise from assessments and appeals under the Excess Profits Tax Act relating to the business activities of a Hindu undivided family headed by Arunachala Nadar and later transactions following a family partition.

Key factual events (as stated in the opinion):

  • Arunachala Nadar was the kartha of a Hindu undivided family consisting of himself and ten sons. Four sons (Ayyamperumal, Ratnasabapathi, Dorairaj and Rajamanickam) were adults in 1942; six sons by a second wife were minors.
  • The family carried on businesses (grocery and oil mills) at Virudhunagar, a grocery at Tuticorin, oil mills at Madurai, and commission grocery business at Bombay.
  • The accounting year ended 27-1-1942. On that date four adult sons separated and a partition effective from the close of the accounting year (27-1-1942) was effected. The family properties were divided into two halves: Arunachala and his minor sons took Virudhunagar and Madurai; the divided adult sons took Tuticorin and Bombay. A family partition release deed was executed on 10-3-1942 evidencing the arrangement.
  • Three of the adult sons began business as "V. N. M. A. Ayyamperumal Nadar and Bros." on 28-1-1942; the fourth adult son also commenced business separately on the same day. Arunachala commenced fresh accounts for the accounting year starting 28-1-1942, treating prior business as discontinued.
  • Arunachala wrote to the Income-tax Officer on 14-10-1942 (notifying the separation and new businesses) and later, on 10-8-1943, requested assessment forms under Section 25-A so that he could be assessed separately (claiming the family business had stopped on 14th Thai Vishnu / 28-1-1942). An order under Section 25-A recognizing the partition was passed by the Income-tax Officer in October 1945.
  • For the chargeable accounting period 28-1-1942 to 7-2-1943, the Excess Profits Tax Officer assessed Arunachala's business income at Rs. 62,568, allowed standard profit deduction Rs. 37,179 and determined excess profits of Rs. 25,329. A claim by Arunachala to set off an earlier deficiency of Rs. 42,479 (from 1-9-1939 to 27-1-1942) was disallowed on the ground that there was a change in the persons carrying on the business.
  • The departmental view disallowing the carry-forward of the prior deficiency was upheld by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and by the Appellate Tribunal, and the matter was referred under Section 66(2) for determination whether there was a change in persons carrying on the business within Section 8(1) of the Excess Profits Tax Act.
  • Separately (R. O. No. 58 of 1953), after the 1942 partition Arunachala and his undivided minor sons carried on business at Virudhunagar and Madurai; Arunachala also started a rice/paddy business at Kumbakonam with an employee Sadagopa Pillai in charge. For the accounting year 28-1-1942 to 8-2-1943 Arunachala was assessed on income from Virudhunagar, Madurai and Kumbakonam.
  • For the subsequent year of account (commenced 8-2-1943, ended 6-2-1944) partnership deeds dated 10-1-1944 recited that two partnerships had been constituted on 8-2-1943 (one for Madurai, admitting Ratnaswami as partner; one for Kumbakonam, admitting Sadagopa Pillai as partner). Each new partner was said to have contributed Rs. 1,500 as a one-fourth share and to be entitled to one-fourth of profits.
  • The departmental authorities applied Section 10-A(1) of the Excess Profits Tax Act and held the two partnerships were constituted mainly to avoid or reduce excess profits tax liability. The Tribunal upheld that view; the question was referred under Section 66(2) whether there was material to justify that finding.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and circumstances of the case (R. O. No. 68 of 1953), there was a "change in the persons carrying on the business" within the meaning of Section 8(1) of the Excess Profits Tax Act.
  2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case (R. O. No. 58 of 1953), there was material to justify the Tribunal's finding that the main purpose in constituting the two firms was avoidance or reduction of liability to excess profits within the meaning of Section 10-A of the Excess Profits Tax Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments (summarized)

  • In R. O. No. 68 of 1953 the assessee contended that the Hindu undivided family continued to exist after the events of 27-1-1942. The separation of four adult sons did not necessarily terminate the existence of the remaining undivided family, and the remaining members (Arunachala and his minor sons) could continue as a joint Hindu family. Counsel relied on Rangaswami Naidu v. Sundararajulu Naidu and other authorities to support that legal possibility.
  • The assessee asserted that the family partition was bona fide and that he believed he would be able to set off the earlier deficiency against later profits; this belief was said to support the bona fides of subsequent arrangements (relevant to R. O. No. 58 as well).
  • In R. O. No. 58 the assessee argued the partnerships (admitting Ratnaswami and Sadagopa Pillai) were formed for legitimate business reasons — to give incentives and because Arunachala (being over 60) could not personally go to Madurai or Kumbakonam — rather than primarily to avoid excess profits tax.

Revenue's / Respondent's Arguments (summarized)

  • In R. O. No. 68 the revenue contended that, despite possible legal theories permitting the old family to continue, the facts and Arunachala's own conduct (including invocation of Section 25-A and commencement of fresh accounts and a new business from 28-1-1942) established that the old juristic entity (the Hindu undivided family that had been the assessee up to 1942-43) had been terminated. The departmental authorities had therefore rightly accepted a new juristic entity for assessment and held that there was a change in the persons carrying on the business within Section 8(1) of the Excess Profits Tax Act.
  • In R. O. No. 58 the revenue relied on factual indicators that the partnerships were mainly for tax avoidance: the partnership deeds were drawn late (10-1-1944) but recited an earlier effective date (8-2-1943), the new partners contributed only modest sums (Rs. 1,500 each) while entire finance came from the assessee, Arunachala remained in full control, the businesses were effectively branches with headquarters at Virudhunagar, and inter-branch transactions were channelled through Virudhunagar accounts. The departmental authorities and Tribunal found these facts supported the conclusion that the dominant purpose was avoidance or reduction of excess profits tax under Section 10-A(1).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rangaswami Naidu v. Sundararajulu Naidu, 31 Mad LJ 472; AIR 1917 Mad 722 Propositions that (1) separation of one member does not necessarily cause separation of the remaining members; (2) the father can separate one or more sons (second proposition noted as not applicable to these facts). The Court acknowledged these propositions as demonstrating the legal possibility that a residual undivided family might continue after some members separate, but observed that the decisive question was the factual continuation of the juristic entity for assessment purposes. The precedent did not compel acceptance of continuity on the facts of this case.
Palni Ammal v. Muthuvenkatachala Moniagar, ILR 48 Mad 254; AIR 1925 PC 49 Authority relating to Hindu family law and questions of division/status (referenced by counsel for the assessee). Cited by the assessee to support the contention of possible continuation of family status; the Court referred to it but did not rely upon it to alter its factual conclusion that the juristic entity had ceased for tax assessment purposes.
Martand v. Radhabai, AIR 1931 Bom 97 Authority relating to Hindu family law (cited by the assessee). Referenced by counsel for the assessee; the Court noted the citation but reached its conclusion on the basis of the facts and applicable tax provisions rather than as a direct application of this case.
Sundar Singh Majithia v. Commissioner of Income-tax, 1942-10 ITR 457; AIR 1942 PC 57 Interpretation of Section 25-A of the Income-tax Act: "It (Section 25-A) has no reference at all to any case in which the Hindu undivided family remains in existence at the time of the assessment." The Court relied on this Privy Council observation to support the proposition that Section 25-A recognises cessation of the old joint family as a prerequisite — i.e., Section 25-A cannot apply where the old family remains in existence at assessment; recognition under Section 25-A indicates the old juristic entity had ceased for tax purposes.
Unreported judgment: R. C. No. 57 of 1952 (Mad) (recorded propositions) Summarised propositions relating to Section 10-A inquiries: burden on department to prove main purpose, timing alone not conclusive, relationships not conclusive, incidental advantages insufficient — the motive must be the main purpose. The Court cited these propositions as established principles to be applied when assessing whether transactions (such as creating partnerships) were mainly for avoidance of excess profits tax. The Court then considered whether the Tribunal's conclusion violated any of these principles and found it did not on the facts of this case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

R. O. No. 68 of 1953 (Change in persons carrying on the business under Section 8(1))

The Court framed the core question as whether there was a "change in the persons carrying on the business" within Section 8(1) of the Excess Profits Tax Act. The analysis proceeded as follows:

  1. Factual focus: The Court emphasized that the legal issue turned on the factual question whether the juristic entity (the Hindu undivided family that had been assessed up to 1942-43) continued to exist for assessment purposes after 27-1-1942.
  2. Significance of parties' conduct: The Court gave weight to Arunachala's own conduct — he treated the business as discontinued at the end of the accounting year 27-1-1942, commenced fresh accounts from 28-1-1942, notified the tax authorities of the separation and later (10-8-1943) invoked Section 25-A claiming separate assessment. The Court held that invoking Section 25-A and attaining recognition under it constituted a clear indication of Arunachala's intention to terminate the old juristic entity for income-tax purposes.
  3. Statutory and precedential framework: The Court observed that Section 25-A requires that the joint family as such must have ceased to exist for an order under Section 25-A to be made. The Privy Council decision in Sundar Singh Majithia was cited to show Section 25-A does not address a case where the undivided family remains in existence at the time of assessment.
  4. Legal fiction under Section 8(1): The Court noted that Section 8(1) of the Excess Profits Tax Act enacts a legal fiction deeming the business carried on after any change in the persons carrying on it to be a new business. Given Arunachala's conduct and the Section 25-A recognition, the departmental authorities were justified in regarding the post-28-1-1942 business as being carried on by a different juristic person (a new Hindu undivided family consisting of Arunachala and the minor sons).
  5. Conclusion on this point: On the facts the Court concluded there had been a change in the persons carrying on the business within the meaning of Section 8(1), and therefore the carry-forward of the earlier deficiency was not available to the new juristic entity.

R. O. No. 58 of 1953 (Section 10-A — partnerships formed to avoid excess profits tax)

The Court treated the second question as essentially factual and confined its review to the material before the Tribunal. Its analytical steps were:

  1. Identify the material facts relied upon by departmental authorities and the Tribunal: the partnership deeds were executed on 10-1-1944 but recited an effective date of 8-2-1943 (near the end of the year of account), the partners contributed modest capital (Rs. 1,500 each), the assessee provided the entire finance, Arunachala retained control, the Madurai and Kumbakonam activities functioned as branches with headquarters at Virudhunagar, inter-branch transactions were routed through Virudhunagar accounts, and the profits were ascertainable when the deeds were drawn.
  2. Consider the Tribunal's finding: the Tribunal observed the partnerships were "only nominal" and that the assessee remained in full control. The Court clarified that the Tribunal did not necessarily hold the partnerships fictitious in the sense of non-existent, but that the Tribunal found the main purpose of constituting them to be avoidance or reduction of excess profits tax.
  3. Apply legal standards: The Court reiterated established principles (from its own unreported judgment) — timing alone is not conclusive, burden is on the department to prove main purpose, relationships alone are not conclusive, incidental benefits are insufficient, and the avoidance motive must be the main purpose. The Court then considered whether the Tribunal's conclusion transgressed these principles.
  4. Conclusion on this point: Given the array of factual indicators pointing to tax-motivated restructuring (timing of deeds, capital contributions, control, accounting treatment, and financing), the Court held there was material to sustain the Tribunal's finding that the main purpose in constituting the two firms was the avoidance or reduction of excess profits tax within Section 10-A(1). The Court refused to overturn the factual conclusion of the Tribunal.

Holding and Implications

Holdings

The Court answered both referred questions in the affirmative and against the assessee:

  • R. O. No. 68 of 1953 — There was a change in the persons carrying on the business within the meaning of Section 8(1) of the Excess Profits Tax Act. The assessment and the rejection of the claim to carry forward the earlier deficiency were upheld. The assessee was ordered to pay the costs of the reference; counsel's fee Rs. 250.
  • R. O. No. 58 of 1953 — There was material to justify the finding that the main purpose in constituting the two firms was avoidance or reduction of liability to excess profits tax within the meaning of Section 10-A(1) of the Excess Profits Tax Act. The Tribunal's conclusion was sustained. The assessee was ordered to pay the costs of the reference; counsel's fee Rs. 250.

Implications

Direct consequences as expressed in the opinion:

  • The departmental and Tribunal findings in both matters were affirmed, resulting in the disallowance of the claim to set off earlier deficiency in R. O. No. 68 and in the upholding of the application of Section 10-A in R. O. No. 58.
  • Costs were awarded against the assessee in both references (including counsel's fees of Rs. 250 for each reference).

Broader precedential or doctrinal implications:

The Court applied existing principles and authorities (including the Privy Council decision in Sundar Singh Majithia) to emphasise that recognition under Section 25-A signifies cessation of the old joint family juristic entity for assessment purposes, and that the legal fiction in Section 8(1) operates where there is a change in the persons carrying on the business. The opinion did not purport to lay down a new rule of law beyond applying established principles to the particular facts; the decision turned on facts and accepted factual findings of the Tribunal.

    V.N.M Arunachala Nadar v. The Commissioner Of Excess Profits Tax, Madras.

    1. We consider it desirable to dispose of the questions, which constitute the subject-matter of these two references by a single order, though, of course, each set of questions has to be answered with reference to the circumstances under which they arise. We shall deal first with R. O. No. 68 of 1953.

    2. R. O. No. 68 of 1953 : The question that was referred under Section 66 (2) of the Income-tax Act ran :

    "Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case, there was a change in the persons carrying on the business within the meaning of Section 8(1) of the Excess Profits Tax Act."

    Arunachala Nadar was the kartha of the Hindu undivided family which consisted of himself and his ten sons. Pour of these sons, Ayyamperumal, Ratnasabapathi, Dorairaj and Rajamanickam, were Arunachala's sons by his first wife. All of them were adults in 1942. The six sons by the second wife were still minors. It was this Hindu undivided family that was the assessee upto the assessment year 1942-43. The assessee family had its headquarters at Virudhunagar. It carried on its business at the following places:

    1. Grocery and two oil mills at Virudhunagar

    2. Grocery at Tuticorin;

    3. Oil mills at Madurai, and

    4. Commission business in grocery at Bombay. There were three other items with which we need not now concern ourselves.

    3. The accounting year of the assessee family ended on 27-1-1942. The four adult sons of Arunachala separated themselves from the family and they were also divided inter se. Arunachala remained joint in status. A partition was effected with effect from the close of the accounting year on 27-1-1942. For purposes of that partition, the members of the family were treated as forming two groups; the four adult sons, though divided 'inter se', formed one group; Arunachala and his undivided minor sons formed the other group. The properties of the family were divided into two halves, each group taking one half. Arunachala's group took over the business at Virudhunagar and at Madurai; the divided adult sons took over the businesses at Tuticorin and at Bombay. This arrangement was evidenced by a document executed on 10-3-1942, which was styled a family partition release deed.

    4. Three of the adult sons, Ayyamperumal, Ratnasabapathi and Doraira], commenced a separate business under the name and style of "V. N. M. A. Ayyamperumal Nadar and Bros.", on 28-1-1942. On the same day, the other undivided son, Rajamanickani also commenced a separate business of his own. Arunachala Nadar in his turn started with a fresh set of accounts for the accounting year commencing 28-1-1942, treating the business that he had done upto that date as having been closed or discontinued.

    5. On 14-10-1942 Arunachala wrote to the Income-tax officer, Virudhunagar in the following terms:

    "Prom the family business carried on at Virudhunagar, Tuticorin, Bombay, Madras and Rangoon in the name of V. N M. Arunachala Nadar, my four sons (1) V. N. M. A. Ayyamperumal, (2) V. N. M. A. Ratnasabapathi (3) V. N. M. A, Dorairaj and (4) V. N. M. A. Rajamanickam, nave gone out after 14th Thai Vishnu, and with effect from 15th That Vishnu (28-1-1942), (1) V. N. M. A. Ayyamperumal Nadar, (2) V. N. M. A. Ratnasabapathi Nadar, and (3) 'V. N. M. A. Dorairaj Nadar carry on business as partners in the style of "
    V. N. M. A. Ayyamperumai Nadar and brothers. Viru-dhunagar, Tuticorin and Bombay; V. N. M. A. Rajamanickam Nadar is carrying on business at Virudhunagar.

    I hereby inform you that after 15th Thai Vishnu, only the business, in the name of V. N.

    M. Arunachala Nadar at Virudhunagar and Madura belongs to me."

    6. When in the usual course Arunachalam, as the kartha of the Hindu undivided family, in which status he had all along been assessed, was asked to submit his return for the assessment year 1943-44, Arunachala's reply dated 10-8-1943 was as follows:

    "I have received a form for preparing and submitting the return of income for assessing me for the year 1943-44. The form has been sent on the basis of the same family that existed upto 1942-43, The family business was stopped on the 14th Thai Vishu and my sons V, N. M A. Ayyampera-mal Nadar, V. N. M. A, Ratnasabapathi Nadar, V. N. M. A. Dorairaj Nadar and V. N. M. A. Rajamanickam Nadar have gone out of my family and from the 15th Thai Vishu (28-1-1942) parties 1, 2 and 3 abovenamed have started a business in partnership in the name of "V. N. M. A. Ayyampuru-mal Nadar and Brothers" and the fourth party V. N. M. A. Rajamanickam Nadar is carrying on business individually. This information has been submitted along with the return for 1942-43, and I have also separately filed a petition before you on 14-10-1942. While this is so, whereas I should have received a return in my separate capacity, I have received a return in the character of the family. I am, therefore, returning this form. I pray that as per Section 25-A separate forms may be sent to me and my sons individually." This letter dated 10-8-1943 was apparently treated by the Income-tax Officer as an application under Section 25-A of the Act; and in October 1945 the Income-tax Officer passed the required order under Section 25-A of the Act recognising the partition that had been effected on 27-1-1942.

    7. One other event may be recorded at this stage. After the partition in January 1942, Arunachala started a new line of business in paddy and rice at Kumbakonam, with one Sadagopa Pillai as his employee in charge of that business at Kumbakonam. For the chargeable accounting period from 28-1-1942 to 7-2-1943, the Excess Profits Tax Officer assessed Arunachala's business income at Rs. 62568. He deducted therefrom Rs. 37179 as the standard profit proportionate to the period of 12-11/28 months and determined the quantum of excess Profits at Rs. 25329.

    If there had been no partition on 27-1-1942, and the Hindu undivided family of Arunachala and his ten sons had continued to be the assessee, it would have been entitled to take into account the deficiency in profits to the extent of Rs. 42479 during the period 1-9-1939 to 27-1-1942. Arunachala claimed that despite the arrangement in the family on 27-1-1942, evidenced by the document of 19-8-1942, Arunachala was entitled to claim that this deficiency should be taken into account in assessing his liability to excess profits tax for the chargeable accounting period 28-1-1942 to 7-2-1943. That claim was disallowed. The Excess Profits Tax Officer, recorded:

    .......I reject the assessee's contention that the old family of V. N. M. Arunachala Nadar which existed prior to 27-1-1942 continued to exist and therefore the deficiency of profits relating to that family should be brought forward and set off against the profits of the business of the new family of V. N. M. Arunachala Nadar which came into existence on 27-1-1942. Since there has been a change in the persons carrying on the business, the business started on 28-1-1942 will be regarded as a new business which is not entitled to claim the deficiencies of the old business which came to an end on 27-1-1942.

    That view was upheld by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and on further appeal by the Appellate Tribunal.

    8. The question of law that was referred to this Court under Section 66(2) raises the issue, whether there was a change in the persons carrying on the business within the meaning of Section 8(1) of the Excess Profits Tax Act.

    9. The contention of the learned counsel for the assessee was that the Hindu undivided family, which had been the assessee down to the assessment year 1942-43, continued in existence despite the partition arrangements of 27-1-1942. The result of these arrangements, the learned counsel contended, was that four of the coparceners divided themselves from the family leaving the rest of the family to continue as a Hindu undivided family. The learned counsel referred to Rangaswami Naidu v. Sundararajulu Naidu, 31 Mad LJ 472 : (AIR 1917 Mad 722 (2) ) (A). The learned Judges laid down two propositions: (1) it was not the law that the separation of one member is necessarily a separation of the remaining, members, and that if the latter desired to remain or become a Joint Hindu family, they can only do so by an agreement to reunite, subject to the limitations of a Hindu regarding that status; (2) under the Hindu law, the father has power to separate one or more of his sons from himself, in which case there is no presumption of division between the father and his other sons. The second proposition will not apply to the facts of this case.

    It was not a case of the father Arunachala exercising his right to separate one or more of his sons from the family. It was a case of an adult coparcener exercising his right to become divided in status from the other members of his family. It was on the first proposition the learned counsel for the assessee relied fn support of his contention that the Hindu undivided family, of which Arunachala was the kartha, continued to exist even after 27-1-1942, when four of his sons separated themselves. Learned counsel also relied on Palni Ammal v. Muthuvenkatachala Moniagar, ILR 48 Mad 254: (AIR 1925 PC 49) (B) and Martand v. Radhabai, AIR 1931 Bom 97 CC).

    10. The undivided family in the case before us consisted of a father and his sons with the father as the kartha. That was the position down to 27-1-1942. We are not, however, concerned in this case with the legal possibility of Arunachala and his undivided minor sons continuing as members of a Hindu undivided family after 27-1-1941, when four of his adult sons became divided in status from the rest of the family and also inter se. Factually, did the Hindu undivided family continue its existence after 27-1-1942 for purpose of assessment to income-tax is the real question for determination.

    11. Learned counsel for the respondent urged that, though it was open to Arunachala, as the kartha of the family, to continue the old family after 27-1-1942, minus the four sons who had separated, or to terminate the existence of the old family on 27-1-42, the evidence based on Arunachala's conduct itself clearly established that he chose to terminate the existence of the Hindu undivided family, which, as a juristic entity recognised by the Indian Income-tax Act for purposes of assessment, was the assessee. That termination was on 27-1-1842, The Juristic entity that Arunachala offered for assessment subsequent to 28-1-1942 was not the old family minus its divided members, but a new Hindu undivided family which consisted of Arunachala and his minor sons.

    It was that new juristic entity which the in- come-tax authorities recognised for assessment after the order passed wider Section 25-A of the Act. That was the assesses after 28-1-1943, and it was the income from the business of that assessee that had to be assessed to excess profits tax. As a person includes a Hindu undivided family within the meaning of the Income-tax Act and the EXCESS Profits Tax Act, there was a change in the persons carrying on the business on 28-1-1942, within the meaning of Section 8(1) of the Excess Profits Tax Act

    -- such was the contention of the learned counsel for the respondent.

    12. In this case, it was Arunachala himself that invoked the provisions of Section 25-A of the Income-tax Act by his letter dated 10-8-1943. He specifically claimed that he was entitled to be assessed in a separate capacity, which could only mean a capacity separate from that, on the basis of which he had been assessed down to the assessment year 1942-43. That Arunachala discontinued the business that he had carried on upto 27-1-1942 and started a fresh one from 28-1-1942 he himself made clear. Of course, discontinuance of the business and starting a business afresh may not affect the jural position of the assessee, or whether the family as such that had continued down to 27-1-1942 continued even after that date.

    By invoking Section 25-A and by successfully in-yoking it, Arunachala gave a clear indication of his intention to terminate the existence of the old juristic entity, the Hindu undivided family of which he had been the kartha, the juristic entity for purposes of income-tax assessment. Factually, Arunachala himself sought the termination of the existence of that juristic entity, and he achiev-ed it, if that be the position, taken in conjunction with the fact it was a new business that he commenced on 28-1-1942, though it was the same line of business, the departmental authorities were fully justified in holding that there was a change in the persons carrying on the business within the meaning of Section 8 (1) of the Excess Profits Tax Act.

    13. It seems clear to us that before there can be an order under Section 25-A of the Income-tax Act, a joint family as such must have ceased to exist. That another and differently constituted joint family, whatever be the legal basis for the subsequent joint 'family, came into existence immediately afterwards, would not alter the fact, that the old joint family as such ceased, and that was what had to be recognised under Section 25-A of the Income-tax Act.' In Sundar Singh Majithia v. Commissioner of Income-tax, 1942-10 ITR 457 at p. 464: (AIR 1942 PC 57 at p. 60) (D) in discussing the scope of Section 25-A of the Income-tax Act, their Lord-

    ships of the Privy Council observed:

    "It (Section 25-A) has no reference at all to any case in which the Hindu undivided family remains in existence at the time of the assessment."
    Their Lordships observed further:

    14. Learned counsel for the department was thus well-founded in his contention, that after the disruption of the Hindu undivided family, by whatever means that disruption was brought about, unless the requirements of Section 25-A were satisfied, the members of his family, though divided in status under this personal law, are deemed for purposes of income-tax under the Income-tax Act to continue to retain a fictional undivided status with the resulting Juristic personality as a Hindu undivided family. That legal fiction is retained only for purposes of the income-tax.

    If the Hindu undivided family, as such a fictional legal entity, disappears, and that disappearance is caused by a positive act of that family itself--and that can be the only basis on which recognition of the cesser of the legal existence of the legal entity can be achieved under Section 25-A--it will no longer be permissible to invoke the principle of the personal law applicable to the assessee and claim that for purposes of income-tax, the undivided family continued to exist even after the order passed under Section 25-A of the Act.

    15. There is one other, factor to be noticed. Section 8(1) of the Excess Profits Tax Act enacts a legal fiction, that the business carried on after the date of any change in the persons carrying on that business, shall be deemed to be a new business. As a fact, in this case, Arunachala, as we have already pointed out above, made it clear that. It was a new business that he commenced as the kartha of the Hindu undivided family as it stood on 28-1-1942 from and after 28-1-1942.

    16. As we said, what had primarily to be decided in this case by the departmental authorities was whether the assessee, the Hindu undivided family that had been assessed in that status down to 1942-43, continued in existence for the purpose of an assessment in the assessment year 1943-44. The view taken by the Tribunal on that question is in our opinion, correct.

    16. The question referred to us in R. O. No. 68 of 1953 has to be answered in the affirmative and against the assessee. The assessee will pay the costs of this reference. Counsel's fee Rs. 250.

    17. R. O. No. 58 of 1953: We have set out earlier, in discussing the question that arose for determination in R. O. No, 68 of 1953, the circumstances under which a partition was effected in the family of Arunachala Nadar with effect from 27-1-1942. After that arrangement, Arunachala and his six undivided sons by his second wife constituted a Hindu undivided family. It carried on business at Virudhunagar and at Madurai. After 28-1-1942, Arunachala commenced a fresh line of business in rice and paddy at Kumbakonam with Sadagopa Filial, a paid employee, in charge of that business. The business at Madurai--oil mills--was in charge of Ratnaswami, a nephew of Arunachala, even before 37-1-1942, and Ratnaswami continued to be in charge of that business on and after 28-1-1942. The head office, of these lines of business was at Virudhunagar. For the accounting year 28-1-1942 to 8-2-1943, Arunachala was assessed to tax on the income of the business carried on at all these places, Virudhunagar, Madurai and Kumbakonam.

    18. The claim of the assesses was that in the next year of account which commenced on 8-2-1943, separate partnerships were formed, one to carry on the business at Madurai and another to carry on the business at Kumbakonam. Ratnaswami was taken in as a partner to carry on the business at Madurai, and Sadagopa - Pillai was taken in as a partner to carry on the business at Kumbakonam. The partnership deeds were drawn up on 10-1-1944. The year of account which commenced on 8-2-1943 came to an end on 6-2-1944. The deeds, however, recited that the partnerships had been formed on 8-2-1943 itself. The deeds were virtually in identical terms. Ratnaswami and Sadagopa Pillai each contributed Rs. 1500 as a fourth share of the capital, and each of them was entitled under the terms of the deeds of the partnership to a fourth share in the profits.

    19. The departmental authorities applied the provisions of Section 10-A(1) of the Excess Profits Tax Act and held that these two partnerships were brought about for the main purpose of avoidance or reduction of liability to excess profits tax a further appeal to the tribunal failed, and the tribunal agreed with the findings of the departmental authorities.

    20. The question referred to this Court under Section 66(2) of the Income-tax Act ran:

    "Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case there is any material to justify the finding of the tribunal that the main purpose in constituting the two firms was the avoidance or reduction of liability to excess profits within the meaning of Section 10-A of the Excess Profits Tax Act."

    If there is material to sustain the conclusion of the tribunal, that should suffice to answer the question in the affirmative and against the assessee. The quantum or sufficiency of that evidence may not be a matter for investigation in proceedings under Section 66 of the Act.

    21. No doubt, the tribunal observed that the circumstances which it noticed and the terms of the partnership

    "clearly indicated that the partnership were only nominal and that the assessee was in full control as before"
    . But that cannot really be considered to mean that the Tribunal was of the view, that the partnerships themselves were fictitious. If the partnerships were fictitious, there was no need to resort to the provisions of Section 10-A of the Excess Profits Tax Act.

    22. The Tribunal accepted the findings of the Excess Profits Tax Officer. The assessee pleaded that because his adult sons had left him and because he was himself old, over 60, he had to take in is former employees, Ratnaswami and Sadagopa Pillai, as partners, to give them an incentive to improve the business. Arunachala's claim was that he could not himself go over to Madurai or Kumbakonam. It should be remembered that Arunachala commenced the business at Kumbakonam after the partition in the family on 27-1-1942. Obviously the prospect of what he called old age did not deter him from embarking on a new line of business. That the departmental authorities and the tribunal declined to attach any importance to the age factor does not vitiate their conclusion, even were it permissible to examine the soundness of the conclusion.

    23. The contention of the learned counsel for the assessee was that the tribunal was wrong in attaching the importance it did to the possibility of the assessee having to pay heavy excess profits tax. The tribunal recorded:

    When the partnerships were created, heavy excess profits tax liability was staring the asses-see in its face. It is idle to contend that there was some deficiency of the old Hindu undivided family, prior to partition, which was available to him. He could not bona fide have had any such idea as the assessee himself had claimed partition wad proceedings under Section 25-A were taken at his instance and it was held that the original family had completely disrupted.

    24. Learned counsel for the assessee urged that the very fact, that the legal effect of the division in the old family constituted the subject matter of the reference in R. O. No. 68 of 1953, which we have disposed of, would show that the assessee all along bona fide believed that in the relevant accounting period 1943-44, he would be entitled to set off the deficiency in the business which the assessee had carried on as the kaitha of the joint family of himself and of his ten sons. Even ignoring this factor there was certainly ample-material on which the authorities and the tribunal could come to the conclusion, that the main purpose of forming the partnerships was the avoidance or reduction of liability to excess profits tax even with reference to year of account itself,

    25. The E. P. T. Officer pointed that the deeds of partnership were drawn up towards the end of the year of account on 10-1-1944 at a time when the profits of the business were fairly ascertain-able. The entire finance required for the business in Madurai and Kumbakonam was contributed only by the assessee. Arunachala was in complete control of the business at Madurai and at Kumbakonam. In fact, both were looked upon as branches of the business that Arunaehala carried on, with the headquarters at Virudhunagar.

    All the transactions between Madurai and Kumbakonam were passed only through the accounts of the Virudhunagar office. The books in Madurai had no folio for the Kumbakonam business and all the transactions between Madurai and Kumbakonam were recorded in the folio for Virudhunagar in the Madurai books. The assessee submitted to the assessment of income-tax of the income from all the three businesses only at Virudh-nagar'. These were the factors taken into account by the departmental authorities and by the tribunal; and one cannot say that on this material the Tribunal could not have reached the conclusion that the main purpose in forming the partnerships was avoidance or reduction of liability to excess profits tax.

    26. Since the question at issue depends for its determination really on the facts found in this case, it may not be necessary to embark upon a discussion of the case law on the subject. After discussing some of the cases, we recorded in our unreported judgment in R. C. No. 57 of 1952 (Mad) (E), that the following propositions may be taken as clearly established:

    1. The mere fact that a new business was started at a time when by such starting there would be a reduction of liability is not by itself proof that it was started with the main object of avoiding the excess profits liability within the meaning of Section 10-A. In other words, the point of time when these businesses are started or a transaction takes place does not by 'itself furnish a proof that the transaction was effected with a sinister motive.

    2. The burden is on the department to prove that this was the main purpose with which the transaction was effected.

    3. The relationship between the parties to the transaction is not by itself conclusive to prove that the motive of the actors in that transaction was the avoidance of liability.

    4. It is not sufficient if this was an incidental advantage which might have accrued to an assessee; it must be the main motive to compass which the transaction was brought about.

    27. None of those principles was violated by the conclusion reached by the tribunal on the material placed before it, that the main purpose of the assesses in forming the partnership in the year of account 1943-44 was the avoidance or reduction of the liability to excess profits tax even with reference to that very year. There was, of course, also the future years to be taken into account in gathering what was the motive, the main purpose, of the assesses in bringing about the transactions in question, the two partnerships.

    28. We answer the question in the affirmative and against the assessee. As the assessee had failed, he will pay the costs of this reference. Counsel's fee Rs. 250.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    V.N.M Arunachala Nadar v. The Commissioner Of Excess Profits Tax, Madras.
    (Sep 17, 1956)