Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Madras Act XXIX of 1949. Cl. 2
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Madras Act XXIX of 1949. Cl. 2
Smart Summary

Comprehensive Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is a partner in a firm trading as Madras Oil Mills and Products, operating an oil mill with five expellers used to crush groundnut and produce groundnut oil and groundnut cake. The firm held a licence under the Madras Manure Dealers' Licensing Order, originally paying a fee of Rs. 10 per year since 1947. By Government Order (G.O.) No. Ms. 2435 (Food and Agriculture) dated 29 December 1950, the Madras Manure Dealers' Licensing Order, 1949 was amended to increase licence fees: Rs. 100 per expeller (oil mills), Rs. 20 per rotary/screw press, Rs. 20 for mere dealers, and Rs. 100 for manure-mixing firms (with a non-recurring Rs. 50 for each mixture marketed).

Under the amendment the petitioner's firm became liable to pay Rs. 500 (five expellers × Rs. 100). The petitioner filed an application for a writ of certiorari seeking to quash the G.O. of 29 December 1950 on constitutional and other grounds. The State filed a counter-affidavit justifying the enhancement and providing factual material concerning enforcement needs and departmental expenditure on inspectors and analysts.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the enhanced licence fee imposed by the G.O. dated 29 December 1950 is, in substance, an unreasonable licence fee amounting to a tax that the Executive cannot impose.
  2. Whether the classification and method of charging the enhanced fee (notably charging Rs. 100 per expeller) is discriminatory and inconsistent with Article 14 of the Constitution.
  3. Whether the enhanced fee constitutes an unreasonable restriction on the constitutional right to carry on business.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The enhanced rate is disproportionately high and in effect amounts to a tax, which can only be imposed by the Legislature and not by the Executive. (Affidavit paragraph 9 quoted in the opinion.)
  • The licence fee should only cover administrative costs of issuing licences and general supervision; there is virtually no control over manure dealers that would justify a high fee. The prior Rs. 10 fee was, in the petitioner's view, already effectively a tax.
  • The classification adopted by the amendment (charging by expeller, etc.) is discriminatory and violates Article 14 of the Constitution.

State's Arguments (Respondent)

  • There had been frequent public complaints of adulteration of oil cakes and other manure; amendments and enforcement measures were necessary to ensure good quality manure.
  • To enforce the amended Order, the staff of inspectors and analysts had to be strengthened. The counter-affidavit gave figures of past expenditure (a total of Rs. 43,389 for 1950–51) and an estimated additional cost for employing more staff (Rs. 56,720 under consideration).
  • The fee scale was fixed on the basis that the scale of licensing should be based on the work involved and the cost of control and inspection; oil millers supply the dealers and therefore require checks at source, justifying higher fees for expellers. The enhanced fee was also defended as insignificant compared to the cost of installing and operating an oil mill, and capacity to pay was cited as a factor.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pazundaung Bazar Co. Ltd. v. Municipal Corporation of the City of Rangoon (Privy Council) (and Municipal Corporation of Rangoon v. Pazundaung Bazar Co. Ltd.) The licence fee may reasonably cover the cost of all special services necessitated by duties and liabilities imposed on the authority in respect of supervision and regulation of private markets; licence fees are not limited to token printing costs but may include supervisory costs. The Privy Council agreed with the proposition that licence fees can cover supervisory/ regulatory costs beyond mere clerical expenses; the Court cited this authority in setting the general tests for reasonableness.
Corporation of Madras v. Spencer & Co. Licence fees are leviable as compensation for expenses of issuing licences and general regulation; there must be some relation between expenses and fees. Fees used primarily to increase revenue are unreasonable. Cited for the proposition that if fees are grossly in excess of the cost of regulation (or imposed to raise revenue), they are unreasonable; the Court relied on this principle when examining whether the enhanced fee aimed at revenue rather than cost of regulation.
Municipal Council, Kumbakonam v. Messrs. Ralli Bros. Licence fees should be commensurate with the extra cost entailed by granting licences and necessary supervision; fees should not substantially contribute to general revenues of the local body. Reiterated the principle that licence fees must relate to regulatory costs and this principle was treated as applicable in assessing the challenged fee.
Kunhambu v. Local Fund Overseer Chirakkal Licence fees should not be converted into a tax for raising revenue; they should bear a definite relation to expenses incurred by the licensing authority. Used to support the general rule that licence fees must correspond to regulatory expenses and not function as a revenue-raising tax.
Indian Sugars and Refineries Ltd. v. Municipal Council, Hospet Licence fee should relate to the cost of issuing licences and supervising the trade; special supervisory expenditure due to the character of a trade may be taken into account; apportionment among industries is acceptable so long as it is on a reasonable basis. Quoted (Wadsworth J.) to underline that while ordinary municipal services should not be used to inflate licence fees, special regulatory costs can justify higher fees; the Court considered these observations when weighing the State's justification.
Ingles v. Morf (U.S. Supreme Court) A permit fee is invalid if it bears no reasonable relation to the total cost of regulation for which it is collected. Cited as an analogous authority illustrating the international articulation of the principle that licence/permit fees must reasonably relate to regulatory cost; the court used it by way of comparison to national authorities.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in three parts: (1) stating the governing distinction between a licence fee and a tax and the legal tests developed in precedent; (2) examining the statutory order and the terms of the licence to determine the regulatory purpose of the licence; and (3) applying the principles to the material facts and evidence submitted by the State.

1. Legal principle: The court emphasized the well-established difference between a licence fee and a tax. A licence fee is part of the State's police power to regulate trades and occupations; it may include charges to cover probable expenses of regulation and supervision, but it is not intended as a vehicle for raising general revenue. Consequently, a licence fee must be reasonable and bear a relation to the costs of regulation. The court summarized and adopted the tests from the cited authorities: fees must not be grossly in excess of regulatory costs; they should bear some relation to expenses; where special services are involved, those costs may be included; and apportionment must have a rational basis.

2. Statutory and licence analysis: The challenged fee was imposed under the Madras Manure Dealers' Licensing Order, 1949 (made under S.3 of the Madras Essential Articles Control and Requisitioning (Temporary Powers) Ordinance, 1949). The order defines "dealer" (including oil millers) and prescribes requirements: licences (Cl. 3), a fee of Rs. 10 per annum previously (Cl. 4(ii)), inspection powers (Cl.10), detailed registers, monthly returns (Form II and Form III), and obligations to give facilities for inspection and sample-taking (Form II, paras. 4, 5, 8, 9).

The court observed that the Order is essentially a "dealers licence" aimed at regulating stocking and sales of manure. There is nothing in the Order that directly requires maintenance of quality standards, nor any provision imposing punishment for sale of adulterated manure. While Form II permits sampling, the Order contains no disciplinary mechanism or follow-up enforcement steps connected to quality control.

3. Application to facts: Reasoning from the statutory scope and the State's evidence, the court found several defects in the State's justification:

  • The sudden enhancement from Rs. 10 to Rs. 100 per expeller lacked a discernible connection to the regulatory scheme in the Order, which did not authorize or require the kind of quality-control regime the State purported to fund by the enhanced fee.
  • The counter-affidavit's figures (past expenditure Rs. 43,389 and estimated additional Rs. 56,720) were insufficient: the court noted missing particulars such as the total amount of fees collected from all classes of dealers and whether current collections fell short of regulatory costs. There was no averment that fees collected were less than the cost of establishment.
  • Based on material in the counter-affidavit, the court calculated that potential revenue from oil millers alone at the enhanced rates (478 oil mills with an average of 2.5 expellers producing an average fee of Rs. 250 each) would be Rs. 1,19,500, and inclusion of mills with rotaries raised the total even higher—figures that, on the face of the State's own evidence, would far exceed the stated regulatory costs. This suggested that the enhancement could not be justified as simply covering regulatory expenses.
  • The court found no rational basis for selecting the number of expellers as the unit for charging the fee. If the justification were volume of manure produced, other dealers who stock and sell greater quantities would be treated less onerously (flat Rs. 20), making the scheme irrational and discriminatory.
  • On these bases, the court concluded the enhanced fee was not a reasonable licence fee but operated to place a disproportionate burden on oil millers and therefore was unconstitutional.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court held that the enhanced fee imposed by the G.O. dated 29 December 1950 is unconstitutional and invalid. In the court's words, the enhanced fee "would amount to an unreasonable restriction on the exercise of the right to carry on business guaranteed by the Constitution" and is "discriminatory and in contravention of Art. 14 of the Constitution."

Result: The application was allowed, the rule nisi was made absolute, and the State was ordered to pay the petitioner costs of Rs. 150.

Implications: The direct effect is the quashing of the G.O. dated 29 December 1950 insofar as it enhanced licence fees as challenged, and the petitioner was awarded costs. The opinion confines its conclusions to the facts and statutory scheme before it; it does not purport to announce a broader novel legal doctrine beyond applying established principles that licence fees must bear a reasonable relation to regulatory costs and must not amount to taxation or be discriminatory under Article 14.

V.C.S

    K.C Varadachari, Partner, Madras Oil Mills And Products v. The State Of Madras, By The Secretary To The Government Of Madras, Food And Agriculture Department.

    The petitioner is a partner of a firm carrying on the business and trade of an oil miller under the name and style of Madras Oil Mills and Products. The Oil Mill owned by the firm has got five expellers which are used for crushing groundnut and producing groundnut oil and groundnut cake. The firm had been granted a licence under the Madras Manure Dealers' Licensing Order. The fee for the said licence was Rs. 10 from the year 1947. By G.O No. Ms. 2435 (Food and Agriculture) dated the 29th December 1950 an amendment was made to the Madras Manure Dealers' Licensing Order, 1949, providing for the enhancement of the licence fee, The rate so far as oil mills were concerned was fixed at Rs. 100 for each expeller and Rs. 20 for each rotary or screw press. For mere dealers in manure the licence fee was fixed at Rs. 20 and for firms engaged in manure mixing trade the licence fee was fixed at Rs. 100 with a non-recurring fee of Rs. 50 for each manure mixture marketed. In accordance with this amendment the petitioner's firm became liable to pay a sum of Rs. 500 as licence fee as there were five expellers in the Mill. The petitioner seeks to have the aforesaid G.O dated the 29th December 1950 enhancing the licence fee quashed by a Writ of Certiorari.

    The main ground on which the enhancement is impugned is that the new rate of fee is disproportionately high and virtually amounts to levy of a tax. The material allegations are contained in paragraph 9 of the affidavit which runs as follows:

    “I submit that the Government by levying such disproportionately high rate of licence fee are in fact levying a tax which can only be done by the Legislature and not by the Executive. Further the licence fee should be only to cover the cost of issuing licences and for general supervision and in this case I submit that except that the Madras Manure Dealers Order makes it obligatory for me to make returns of production and sale of oil, there is absolutely no control over the dealers in manure by the respondent and even the sum of Rs. 10 previously collected per year is in effect a tax and not a licence fee.”

    He also attacks the new amendment on the ground that the classification adopted by it is discriminatory and is inconsistent with the provisions of Art. 14 of the Constitution.

    On behalf of the State the Joint Director of Agriculture filed a counter affidavit supporting the amendment. He stated that there had been frequent complaints from the public of adulteration of oil cakes used as cattle food and manure as well as other kinds of manure and the Government have approved of certain amendments to the Madras Manure Dealers' Control Order the enforcement of which would ensure good quality in manure. To enforce these amendments it is said that the staff of inspectors and analysts for analysing manure samples had to be strengthened. A statement was given of the strength of the staff employed and the expenditure by the Government on this account during 1950 and 1951 which showed a total of Rs. 43,389. It was further stated that the question of employing additional staff for the purpose at an estimated cost of Rs. 56,720 was under the consideration of the Government. The justification for the imposition of the enhanced licence fee may be stated in the language employed in the counter affidavit which is as follows:

    “In fixing the different scales for different classes of licences what was prominently kept in view was that the scale of taxation or licence fee should be based on the work involved and cost of the control and inspection necessary. It is the millers who supply the dealers with oil cakes, and frequent checks to ensure quality are therefore necessary at the very source. It cannot therefore be contended that the imposing of licence fee is not justified by consideration relating to the interests of the general public”

    and further on,

    “When compared to the cost of installing and working an oil mill, the enhanced licence fee of Rs. 100 per expeller per annum is an in significant amount. The capacity to pay and the fact that oil mills are the source of supply of oil cakes to dealers and hence frequent checks have to be made at the source were prominently kept in view in proposing the enhancement of licence fees.”

    It is now well established that there is a fundamental difference between a tax and a licence fee. The issue of licences to regulate particular branches of business or specified trades or occupations and other matters is part of what in American constitutional law is called “the police power” of the State. For the grant of a licence a fee may be charged to cover probable expenses which may have to be incurred for the regulation of the particular trade or business or calling in respect of which the licence is required. The licence fee is not intended to raise revenues for the general purpose of the authority levying the fee. For such purposes the levy should be in the shape of a tax. The licence fee must be reasonable, whereas a tax need not be.

    Courts have often dealt with the question whether a particular licence fee is reasonable or not. Though, ultimately the decision in each case must depend upon the particular facts of that case, certain general tests have been formulated to decide whether a particular fee is reasonable in the circumstances. In laying down these general principles Courts have always kept in view the essential difference between a licence fee and a tax, namely, that in the case of a licence fee imposition is intended to reimburse the authority in any amount expended by it in respect of the particular business or matter which is intended to be regulated, whereas a tax is the recognised method of raising revenues for general purposes. It is useful to refer to some of the decided cases on the point, and we shall begin with the ruling of the Privy Council in Pazundaung Bazar Co. Ltd. v. Municipal Corporation of the City of Rangoon(1). That was given on an appeal from the judgment of the Rangoon High Court reported in Municipal Corporation of Rangoon v. Pazundaung Bazar Co. Ltd.(2). Under the City of Rangoon Municipal Act the Corporation had power to charge licence fees for private markets. The question was whether the licence fee imposed was unreasonable. Heald Offg. C.J rejected the contention of the owners of the private markets who were protesting against the levy that the only charges recoverable by way of licence fees were the cost of the papers on which the licences and receipts were printed together with the costs of printing and writing thereon and the cost of such inspection as was directly connected with the licences themselves. He held (and Mya Bu J. concurred with him) that the licence fee may reasonably cover the cost of all special services necessitated by the duties and liabilities imposed on the corporation in respect of the supervision and regulation of private markets. The Privy Council agreed with this statement of the law.

    In Corporation of Madras v. Spencer & Co. this Court held that a licence fee imposed by the Corporation of Madras for storing spirits was unreasonable because the imposition was not with a view to pay for the expenses in connection with the licences but was obviously done to increase the revenue of the Corporation from liquor. The learned Judges accepted the view of the trial Judge, Beasley J. (as he then was) that licence fees were leviable as compensation to the Corporation for the expenses incurred in the issue of licences and the general regulation of the trades and other occupations which were licenced and that there must be some relation between these expenses and the amount of fees leviable. In the case before them they found on the evidence which had been adduced that the expenses of supervising the places where foreign liquor was stored were practically nil. Reilly J. enunciated two general principles which may be useful to determine whether licence fees can be held to be reasonable or not, namely,

    “If we accept the proposition that the power of charging licence fees cannot be used for taxation, then we must say that as a whole the fees charged by the Corporation must not be very much in excess of what the duties cast upon them and their staff in connection with the licences cost them. There is the cost of issuing the licences; there is the cost of inspecting the premises to see whether they are suitable for the purpose proposed; and there is the subsequent cost of inspecting the premises to see that they are being used properly and that the conditions and restrictions imposed by the Commissioner are observed. But, roughly speaking, if the fees are charged at so high a rate that as a whole they bring in very much more than the cost of these operations to the corporation, then I think we can rightly say that they are unreasonable. There is another principle. Although it is almost impossible for the Corporation itself to ascertain, when they are issuing a number of licences to persons engaged in different trades and occupations, exactly what it the cost of any particular licence or of licences for persons engaged in particular trades or occupations—and certainly we could not attempt anything of that sort—yet, surely it would be unreasonable if they so fixed the fees that the whole cost incurred by them in connection with all the licences or a grossly disproportionately part of it was imposed on one particular trades or a few particular trades. These principles, I think, may be of help in ascertaining whether a particular fee is reasonable or not.”

    Of course it is not for a Court to minutely assess and fix what in its opinion is the proper fee. All that the Court can do is to hold whether a particular fee is reasonable or not.

    Practically the same principles were reiterated in a subsequent decision of of this Court in the Municipal Council, Kumbakonam v. Messrs. Ralli Bros. It was held that the licence fee should be commensurate with the extra cost entailed by granting the licences and exercising such supervision as was necessary to see that its terms were complied with. But the fees should not be so assessed as substantially to contribute to the general revenues of the local body.

    The decisions above cited were all discussed in Kunhambu v. Local Fund Overseer Chirakkal(3) in which it was again laid down that the licence fee should not be converted into a tax for the purpose of raising revenue and the licence fee should bear a definite and well recognised relation to the expenses incurred by the licensing authority.

    The decision in Indian Sugars and Refineries Ltd. v. Municipal Council, Hospet(4) relied upon by the learned Advocate General does not lay down any different principle. The following observations of Wadsworth J. are apposite:

    “It is, we think, wall settled that a licence fee for carrying on a particular trade or industry should not be regarded as a form of taxation the extent of which is to be governed purely by revenue considerations. The licence fee should bear as nearly as possible a relation to the cost of issuing the licence and the cost of supervising the trade or of any special measures rendered necessary by the character of that trade. We doubt whether the Municipality would be justified in increasing the licence fee chargeable upon a particular industry merely by reason of the cost of ordinary municipal services to which that industry is entitled by virtue of its position as a tax payer in the municipality. But if the industry involves special sanitary precautions, a special supervising agency or such like expenditure, it is we think, reasonable to take this expenditure into account in fixing the amount of the fee. When a supervision agency is necessary for a number of industries, it will always be difficult to say how the est is to be apportioned and, so long as the apportionment is to be made on a reasonable basis, it is not for the Courts to interfere with the way in which it has bean achieved.”

    Substantially similar principles have been laid down by the Supreme Court of the United States. It is sufficient to cite one instance, namely, the decision in Ingles v. Morf in which a permit fee was held to be invalid because it bore no reasonable relation to the total cost of regulation to defray which it was collected.

    Bearing these principles in mind, let us examine the facts of the present case. The licence fee in question is imposed under the Madras Manure Dealers' Licensing Order 1949. That order was made by the Government of Madras in exercise of the powers conferred by S. 3 of the Madras Essential Articles Control and Requisitioning (Temporary Powers) Ordinance, 1949 and in supersession of the Madras Manure Dealers' Licensing Order, 1947. It may be mentioned that the said Ordinance has now been replaced by Madras Act XXIX of 1949. Cl. 2 of this order defines a dealer as

    “Oil miller or a person who sells manure in quantities of not less than one maund at a time.”

    “‘Oil miller’ means any person owning or having in his possession or under his control, an oil mill run by power or hand presses but does not include a person owning or having in his possession or under his control a wooden or stone chekku.”

    Cl. 3 enacts that no person shall on and after 6th December 1949 carry on business as a dealer in manure in the Province of Madras except under and in accordance with a licence issued in that behalf by a licensing authority. A fee of Rs. 10 per annum is payable in advance with every application for a licence [Cl. 4 (ii)]. Cls. 6, 7, 8 and 9 deal with issue of and refusal to issue licences to applicants. Cl. 10 runs thus:

    “Any officer authorised by the Director may enter upon and inspect any premises in which he has reason to believe that the sale or storage for sale or distribution of manure is taking place contrary to the provisions of this order or any order made thereunder.”

    Form II set out in the schedule contains the terms and conditions of the licence the following of which are important:

    “3. The licensee shall not store manure in any place other than that specified in paragraph 2, except with the approval of the licensing authority.

    4. The licensee shall maintain a register of daily accounts showing correctly all transations in manure in his possession or control. It shall show:

    (a) the opening stock on each day,

    (b) the quantities sold, delivered or received each day, showing the place of origin, that is, the name of oil miller or factory or other consignor from whom received;

    (c) the quantities sold, delivered or otherwise disposed of on each day showing the places of destination and the names of the consignees; and

    (d) the closing stock on each day.

    5. The licensee shall submit to the licensing authority so as to reach him not later than the 10th of each month, a true return m form III set out in the schedule to the Madras Manure Dealer' Licensing Order, 1949, of the stocks, receipts, deliveries and balance during the preceding month.……..

    8. The licensee shall give ail facilities at all reasonable times to any officer authorised by the Director; f Agriculture, Madras for the inspection of his accounts and stocks wheresover they may be kept and for taking samples of such manures for examination.

    9. The licensee shall comply with any directions that may be given to him by the Director of Agriculture, Madras, or any officer authorised by him in regard to the sale or storage for sale or distribution of manure.”

    There is provision for a contravention of any of the conditions of the licence.

    It will be noticed from the provisions of the Order as well as the licence that the licence in question is what may be called a “dealers licence”. No doubt a “dealer” is defined as including an oil miller, but even in respect of him the order relates only to transactions of sale and distribution. There is nothing in the order which directly or indirectly provides for anything other than the regulation of the sale of manure. In Form II, i.e, the licence form, there is one term which makes it incumbent on the licensee to give all facilities to an officer authorised by the Director of Agriculture to take samples of manures for examination. But there is nothing in the order or in the licence which imposes any punishment on a person selling adulterated or bad type of manure. Nor is there anything to indicate as to what is to happen after the officer of the Agriculture Department takes samples of manures for examination. The supervision and regulation contemplated by the Order are confined to the stocking and sale of manure and do not relate to the maintenance of any quality. It is apparently because of this fact that in the Order itself a flat rate of Rs. 10 per annum is prescribed for every licence.

    If Rs. 10 was considered to be proper and adequate fee from 1947 onwards, what then is the justification for a sudden enhancement in 1955 from Rs. 10 to Rs. 100 per expeller? The statement set out in paragraph 6 of the counter affidavit filed on behalf of the State relates to the staff of the Inspectors of Fertilisers and Chemical Analysts' section of Agriculture department of the Government. Presumably the staff is engaged in checking and analysing samples of fertilisers and other things. But there is nothing in the order to indicate that the licence required from the dealers is for the purpose of ensuring the proper quality of manure being sold. There is not even a provision which makes a sale of adulterated or unwholesome manure punishable.

    We are not impressed with the figures set out in the counter affidavit. Many material particulars are found wanting as regards this aspect of the matter. The costs of the establishment has been given but we have no information as to the total amount being collected as licence fees from the various classes of dealers dealt with by the order. There is no averment that the total of fee collected is much less than the costs of establishment. On the other hand, on the information supplied to us in the counter affidavit it is clear that the total fees at the enhanced rate which can be collected from the oil millers alone, completely leaving out of account the other classes of dealers, would far exceed the cost of establishment. There are 478 oil mills which have expellers and the average number of expellers per mill is 2.5, that is to say, on an average each oil mill would be liable to pay a licence fee of Rs. 250, the total fee for 478 oil mills having expellers would be Rs. 1,19,500. Besides there are mills having rotaries or screw presses. These number 687. The average number of rotaries per mill is 3,6, and the enhanced rate is at Rs. 20 per each rotary. If the amount calculated at this rate is added to the amount of fee which can be collected from the expeller mills, the figure reached is disproportionately high in comparison with the expenditure incurred by the Government even according to their statement in the counter-affidavit.

    It is impossible to discover any rational basis for adopting the expeller as a unit for charging licence fee. If it is said that the more the number of expellers it would mean more manure produced and sold, then it can be very properly asked, what about the other dealers who may actually stock and sell much more than what any oil miller may be able to produce and sell? Such dealers have to pay only at a flat rate of Rs. 20. The enhancement in the case of oil millers only would in that event be clearly discriminatory and would offend the provisions of Art. 14 of the Constitution.

    We must therefore hold that the enhanced fee imposed by the amendment in 1950 is unconstitutional and therefore invalid because the fee would amount to an unreasonable restriction on the exercise of the right to carry on business guaranteed by the Constitution and also because the fee is discriminatory and in contravention of Art. 14 of the Constitution. The application is allowed and the rule nisi is made absolute. The State will pay the petitioner the costs of this application Rs. 150.

    V.C.S

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K.C Varadachari, Par... v. The State Of Madras,...
    (Feb 22, 1952)