Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2014 BHC 27200
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provision of Order XLI, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • provision of Order XX, Rule 19 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XLI, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XX, Rule 19 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • BOMBAY CIVIL COURTS ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2014 BHC 27200
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provision of Order XLI, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • provision of Order XX, Rule 19 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XLI, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XX, Rule 19 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • BOMBAY CIVIL COURTS ACT
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, the original plaintiff, filed Special Civil Suit No. 110 of 2005 seeking a declaration of ownership over the entire suit property and cancellation of a sale deed executed by defendant No. 2 (the petitioner's daughter) in favor of defendant No. 4. Both defendants filed counter-claims: defendant No. 2 claimed a one-quarter share in the property or partition thereof, while defendant No. 4 sought partition pursuant to the sale deed. The trial Court decreed the suit in favor of the plaintiff and dismissed the counter-claims by judgment dated 31-3-2007.

Defendant Nos. 2 and 4 (respondents herein) filed First Appeal No. 2155 of 2007 challenging the decree, including a specific ground contesting the dismissal of the counter-claims. After enhancement of the District Court's pecuniary jurisdiction, the appeal was transferred to the District Court, Solapur. The respondents moved an application (Exhibit 15) to amend the appeal memo to expressly pray for setting aside the trial Court's judgment and allowing the counter-claims. The trial Court allowed this amendment by order dated 23-4-2013, holding that since there was one trial, one finding, and one decision, only one appeal was necessary despite two decrees. The petitioner challenged this order by invoking the writ jurisdiction of this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellants/respondents were required to file separate appeals in respect of the decree passed in the suit and the decree passed in the counter-claims, or whether a single appeal suffices when there is one trial, one finding, and one decision.
  2. Whether the amendment allowing the appellants to incorporate specific prayers challenging dismissal of the counter-claims in the appeal memo was valid and maintainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that since separate decrees were passed in the suit and the counter-claims, the respondents were required to file two separate appeals.
  • The petitioner argued that the scope of the suit and counter-claims were different, and no single finding was recorded, necessitating separate appeals.
  • Reliance was placed on Order XLI, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which requires filing one copy of judgment if suits are tried together but two decrees are passed.
  • Order XX, Rule 19 of the Code of Civil Procedure was also invoked, which governs appeals against decrees in suits involving counter-claims, contending it implies filing separate appeals.
  • The petitioner objected to the amendment on grounds that it sought to combine three appeals into one and raised issues of limitation and jurisdiction.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents supported the impugned order allowing the amendment and maintaining a single appeal.
  • They pointed to the grounds of appeal originally filed, which included a specific challenge to dismissal of the counter-claims.
  • Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court judgment in Narhari v. Shankar (AIR 1950 SC 419) that where there is one trial, one finding, and one decision, separate appeals are not necessary even if multiple decrees are drawn.
  • They also relied on a Kerala High Court judgment (Pampara Philip v. Koorithottiyil Kinhimohammed, AIR 2007 Kerala 69) holding that a single appeal is maintainable when the suit claim is allowed and counter-claims dismissed, with composite valuation and court fees.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Narhari v. Shankar, AIR 1950 SC 419 Where there is one trial, one finding, and one decision, multiple appeals are not required even if multiple decrees are drawn. The Court applied this principle to hold that since there was one trial, one finding, and one decision regarding the suit property, a single appeal sufficed.
Pampara Philip v. Koorithottiyil Kinhimohammed, AIR 2007 Kerala 69 Where the suit claim is allowed and counter-claim dismissed, a single appeal is maintainable with composite valuation and court fees. The Court relied on this precedent to support the maintainability of a single appeal challenging both suit and counter-claims decrees.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined whether separate appeals were required for the decrees passed in the suit and counter-claims. It noted that the controversy centered on the same suit property, and the reliefs claimed by the plaintiff and defendants related to that property. The trial Court conducted one trial, rendered one judgment allowing the suit and dismissing counter-claims. The original appeal memo already challenged both decrees, including a specific ground contesting dismissal of the counter-claims.

The Court found that the amendment sought by the respondents merely added explicit prayers reflecting the existing grounds of appeal and did not introduce new challenges. The Court rejected the petitioner's reliance on provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure (Order XLI, Rule 1 and Order XX, Rule 19), interpreting them as procedural enabling provisions rather than mandates requiring separate appeals.

The Court applied the principle from Narhari v. Shankar that one appeal suffices when there is one trial, one finding, and one decision, despite multiple decrees. It also found support in the Kerala High Court judgment that a single appeal is maintainable in such circumstances with composite valuation.

Consequently, the Court held that no limitation, jurisdictional, or res judicata issues arose from maintaining one appeal. The trial Court's order allowing the amendment and holding a single appeal maintainable was not erroneous or illegal.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is dismissed.

The Court upheld the trial Court's order allowing the amendment of the appeal memo and confirmed that a single appeal is maintainable when there is one trial, one finding, and one decision, even if separate decrees are drawn in respect of the suit and counter-claims. The parties are to bear their own costs. The Court directed expedited disposal of the appeal due to the petitioner's advanced age. No new precedent was set beyond affirming the application of established principles regarding appeals involving suits and counter-claims.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Shankar Masu Dokare v. Shobha Subhash Dokare And Another

    Rule, with the consent of the learned Counsel for the parties made returnable forthwith and heard.

    2. The writ jurisdiction of this Court is invoked against the order dated 23-4-2013 passed by the learned Ad hoc District Judge-2 Solapur by which order the Application (Exhibit 15) for amendment of the Appeal being Civil Appeal No. 325 of 2012 came to be allowed and resultantly, the respondents herein were held entitled to amend the Appeal in terms of the amendment sought vide the said Application (Exhibit 15).

    3. Shorn of unnecessary details, a few facts can be stated thus:

    The petitioner herein is the original plaintiff who had filed the suit in question being Special Civil Suit No. 110 of 2005 for a declaration that the petitioner is the owner of the entire suit property, and for cancellation of the sale deed executed by the defendant No. 2 i.e the respondent No. 1 herein who is his daughter in favour of the defendant No. 4. i.e the respondent No. 2 herein. In the said suit counter-claims came to be filed by both the defendant No. 2 and the defendant No. 4. Insofar as the defendant No. 2 is concerned, she claimed a declaration that she has got ¼th share in the suit property, and in the alternative the suit property be partitioned. Insofar as the defendant No. 4 is concerned, she sought the relief of partition of the suit property pursuant to the sale deed executed by the defendant No. 2 in her favour.

    4. After going through the gamut of a trial, the suit in question came to be decreed by the trial Court in favour of the plaintiff by the judgment and order dated 31-3-2007 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Solapur. However, insofar as the counter-claims of the defendant No. 2 and the defendant No. 4 are concerned, their counter-claims came to be dismissed.

    5. Aggrieved by the decreeing of the suit by the judgment and order dated 31-3-2007 the defendant Nos. 2 and 4 i.e the respondent Nos. 1 and 2 herein filed an Appeal in this Court being First Appeal No. 2155 of 2007 challenging the said decree. In the context of the issue which arises in the present Petition, it is required to be noted that in Ground (B) of the memo of the First Appeal, the respondents/appellants have raised a challenge to the dismissal of the counterclaims. There are other grounds in the Memo of Appeal which question the findings recorded on the issues which arise on account of the counter-claims and which are concerning the defendant Nos. 2 and 4. It is not necessary to refer to the said grounds as the Ground (B) can be said to be an over imposing ground questioning the dismissal of the counter-claims.

    6. At this stage it is required to be noted that the adjudication is one and the finding recorded is in respect of the suit property by which the trial Court has held that the title vests with the plaintiff. After the pecuniary jurisdiction of the District Court was enhanced pursuant to the amendment to the Bombay Civil Courts Act, the said First Appeal No. 2155 of 2007 was transferred to the District Court, Solapur. After the transfer of the said First Appeal to the District Court, Solapur, the respondents/appellants moved the instant Application (Exhibit 15) for amendment of the Appeal memo to add paragraph (iv) after paragraph (iii). In the said paragraph (iv) by way of prayer clause (a) the appellants have prayed that the Appeal be allowed and by way of prayer clause (b) the appellants have prayed for setting aside the judgment and order dated 31-3-2007, the suit be dismissed and the counter-claims of the defendant Nos. 2 and the defendant No. 4 may be allowed with costs throughout.

    7. The said Application (Exhibit 15) was opposed to on behalf of the original plaintiff i.e the petitioner herein by filing a Reply (Exhibit 16). In the said reply, the plaintiff objected to the amendment sought on the ground that by way of amendment three Appeals were sought to be converted into one; that the issue of limitation and the issue of jurisdiction also arise in view of the amendment.

    8. The trial Court considered the said Application (Exhibit 15) and has by the impugned order dated 23-4-2013 allowed the same. Whilst allowing the said application, the trial Court held that since there was one trial, one finding and one decision in respect of the suit and the counter-claims, there need not be two Appeals even though the decrees may have been drawn up. The trial Court relied upon the judgment of the Apex Court reported in AIR 1950 SC 419 in the matter of Narhari v. Shankar. The trial Court also placed reliance on the judgment of a learned Single Judge of Kerala High Court reported in AIR 2007 Kerala 69 in the matter of Pampara Philip v. Koorithottiyil Kinhimohammed wherein the learned Single Judge has held that where a counterclaim filed by the defendants is dismissed and the plaint claim is allowed, the defendants need not file separate Appeals but a single Appeal challenging both the findings is maintainable, and that the valuation of Appeal would be on the basis of the combination of suits plus counter-claim and the Court fees would have to be paid accordingly. The Lower Appellate Court held that since the appellants have challenged the decree passed in the suit as well as the dismissal of the counter-claims, they are entitled to maintain one Appeal. As indicated above, it is the said order dated 23-4-2013 which is taken exception to by way of the above Appeal.

    9. Heard the learned counsel for the parties. The learned counsel for the petitioner Shri Surel Shah would reiterate the case of the petitioner before the Trial and would submit that since there is a decree in the suit and the decree in the counter-claims, the appellants i.e the respondents herein were required to file two Appeals. The learned counsel would contend that the scope of the suit and the scope of the counter-claim was different, there was no one finding recorded and hence the respondents were required to file two Appeals. The learned counsel sought to place reliance on Order XLI, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure which postulates filing of one copy of the judgment if the suits are tried together and two decrees are passed. The learned counsel also placed reliance on Order XX, Rule 19 of the Code of Civil Procedure where it is posited that the decree passed in a suit in which a counter-claim is filed shall be subject to the same provisions in respect of an Appeal. This provision the learned counsel for the petitioner wants to invoke so as to extend the proposition to the factum of filing of a separate Appeal in respect of the decree passed in the counter-claim.

    10. Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondents Shri Amit Borkar would support the impugned order. The learned counsel would draw my attention to the grounds of Appeal in the Appeal as originally filed wherein there is a specific ground taken as regards rejection of the counter-claims as also as regards the findings recorded by the trial Court in respect of the counter-claims of the defendant No. 2 and the defendant No. 4. The learned counsel in support of his submission that there is no warrant to file separate Appeals sought to place reliance on the judgment of the Apex Court in the Narhari (supra) as also the judgment of a learned Single Judge of the Kerala High Court in Pampara Philip's case (supra).

    11. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, I have considered the rival contentions. The question that is posed is whether the appellants were required to file separate Appeals in respect of the decree passed in the suit and in respect of the decree passed in the counter-claims. It is required to be noted that the controversy in the suit revolves around the suit property which the plaintiff claims to be his exclusive property. In view thereof, the plaintiff i.e the petitioner herein had challenged the sale deed executed by his daughter i.e the defendant No. 2 in favour of the defendant No. 4 on the ground that the defendant No. 2 did not have any right in the property so as to execute the sale deed in favour of the defendant No. 4. The defendant No. 2 in her counter-claim had sought a declaration that she has ¼th share in the property and in the alternative had prayed for partition of her said ¼th share in the said suit property. The defendant No. 4 who is the purchaser from the defendant No. 2 also sought partition of the ¼th share which she has purchased from the defendant No. 2. Hence the controversy was revolving around the suit property and it was not a case where the reliefs claimed by the plaintiff and the reliefs claimed by the defendants were different in their content vis-a-vis the suit property. It is an undisputed position that the counter-claims were tried along with the suit and a common judgment was rendered by the trial Court i.e allowing the suit and dismissing the counter-claims filed by the defendant No. 2 and the defendant No. 4. It is further required to be noted that in the Appeal as original filed the challenge has been raised to the decree by incorporating a specific ground being Ground (B) wherein the dismissal of the counter-claims is questioned. There are also other grounds in the Appeal memo wherein the findings relating to the counter-claims are challenged. Hence in the Appeal as originally filed, it can be said that the same was filed against both the decree passed in the suit as well as the counter-claims. Hence it is not as if for the first time that by the amendment a challenge to the dismissal of counter-claim is raised by the appellants. The amendment sought as can be seen was as and by way of incorporating prayer clauses (a) and (b) in the Appeal Memo i.e the Appeal be allowed and dismissal of the counter-claim be set aside. Such is not the practice followed in this Court as the Appeals filed in this Court do not contain any prayer except the grounds on which the decree is challenged. May be after the Appeal was transferred to the District Court out of abundant caution the advocate for the appellants who was appearing for them in the District Court sought to incorporate the said two prayers which appear in paragraph (vii) which is now sought to be incorporated by way of the amendment application. However, the application for inclusion of the said prayer cannot be construed in a manner to suggest that originally there was no challenge to the decree passed in the counter-claims as the challenge to the dismissal of the counter-claims is ex facie clear from the reading of Ground (B) of the grounds in the Memo of Appeal as originally filed. Hence in the instant case there is no question of issue of limitation or issue of jurisdiction, res judicata arising as the challenge in the Appeal as originally filed was composite i.e both to the decreeing of the suit and the dismissal of the counter-claims.

    12. Now coming to the judgment of the Apex Court in Narhari's case (supra), the Apex Court in paragraph 5 has observed that it is now well settled that where there has been one trial, one finding and one decision, there need not be two Appeals even though two decrees may have been drawn up. The observation of the Apex Court in Narahari's case therefore applies in all fours to the facts of the instant case wherein there was one trial, one finding and one decision as regards the property and therefore the appellants were not required to file separate Appeals. Insofar as the judgment of a learned Single Judge of the Kerala High Court in Pampara Philip's case is concerned, though the said judgment is not directly on the point as to whether one Appeal is maintainable, the appellants can draw support from the said judgment in the light of the fact that the learned Single Judge of the Kerala High Court has held that if the claim in the counter-claim is dismissed and the suit claim is allowed, then there is no warrant to file two Appeals but what is required to be done is that the valuation has to be composite i.e the valuation of the suit and counter-claim, and Court fees have to be paid accordingly. In my view, the judgment lends support to the case of the appellants inasmuch as in the instant case also the suit claim has been allowed and the counter-claims have been dismissed.

    13. Insofar as the provision of Order XLI, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure is concerned, the same can be said to be in the nature of enabling the provision which obviates the need to file separate copies of the judgment and decree. Insofar as the provision of Order XX, Rule 19 of the Code of Civil Procedure is concerned, what is posited therein cannot be extended so as to contend that there is a requirement of filing of two Appeals. There can be no dispute about the fact that the decree in the counter-claim has also to be challenged within limitation. In the instant case as indicated above the Appeal memo as originally filed contained common grounds of challenge for both the decree in the suit as well as a counter-claims. Hence as rightly observed by the trial Court no question of limitation arises. In the facts of the present case where there was one trial, one finding, filing of one Appeal cannot be said to be in contravention of any of the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure. This is not a case where the reliefs sought by way of counter-claims had nothing to do with the subject-matter of the suit or that the counter-claims were directed against some parties who are not parties to the suit or against whom the plaintiffs were not claiming reliefs. The order passed by the Lower Appellate Court therefore cannot be said to suffer from any error of jurisdiction or any other infirmity or illegality for this Court to interfere in its writ jurisdiction. The above Writ Petition is accordingly dismissed. Rule discharged with parties to bear their respective costs of the petition.

    14. In the light of the fact that the petitioner herein i.e the original plaintiff is 83 years of age, the hearing of the Appeal which is of the year 2007 is expedited and is directed to be disposed of latest by 31st March, 2015.

    Petition dismissed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shankar Masu Dokare v. Shobha Subhash Dokare And Another
    (Dec 10, 2014)