Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub-section 2 of Section 9A.13.
  • Sub-section 2 of Section 9A
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub-section 2 of Section 9A.13.
  • Sub-section 2 of Section 9A
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion addresses an application for interim relief and appointment of a Court Receiver in a suit challenging the sale and transfer of a suit property. The suit property is part of the estate of Vensimal Kalachand Harjani, whose will defendant No. 1 purportedly used to sell the property to defendant Nos. 2 and 3. The plaintiff filed a suit for injunction against further alienation and creation of third party rights after a similar relief was refused in a testamentary petition. The plaintiff’s initial urgent ad interim relief application was refused by this Court on 23.10.2013. The defendants filed an affidavit-in-reply raising the issue of limitation, which was framed as a preliminary jurisdictional issue under Section 9A of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). The suit proceeded with directions for evidence and appointment of a Commissioner to record cross-examination.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Court can grant interim relief pending the determination of the preliminary issue of jurisdiction under Section 9A(2) of the CPC.
  2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to interim relief despite the delay (laches) in approaching the Court and refusal of similar reliefs in the testamentary petition.
  3. The scope and applicability of Section 9A(2) CPC regarding interim reliefs pending jurisdictional determination and limitation issues.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff sought appointment of a Court Receiver and injunction against defendants to deposit amounts collected with interest.
  • The plaintiff argued for urgent ad interim reliefs pending suit, relying on Section 9A(2) CPC to obtain interim protection despite the pending jurisdictional issue.
  • The plaintiff contended that changed circumstances, including defendants issuing letters of attornment and carrying out construction work, justified interim relief.
  • It was argued that the Court could grant interim relief under Section 9A(2) even without hearing the Notice of Motion, as no further application was made.

Defendants' Arguments

  • Defendants raised the issue of limitation as a jurisdictional bar under Section 9A CPC.
  • They contended that the plaintiff’s delay and laches in seeking relief barred the grant of interim reliefs.
  • Defendants argued that any application for interim relief after refusal would require fresh application supported by additional facts, which was not done.
  • It was emphasized that the Court cannot hear the Notice of Motion in entirety while deciding interim relief under Section 9A(2).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Notice of Motion No. 748 of 2012 dated 17.07.2012 (Single Judge, Bombay High Court) Section 9A(2) CPC - Court’s power to grant interim relief pending determination of jurisdictional issues; prevention of abuse of legal process. The Court relied on this judgment to explain that interim reliefs can be granted pending the preliminary issue and that such reliefs require changed circumstances or renewal of application. The judgment clarified that the Court is not powerless and that limitation issues require evidence and time to decide.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the scope of Section 9A(2) CPC, which empowers the Court to grant interim relief pending the determination of preliminary jurisdictional issues, including limitation. It emphasized that the application for interim relief was already before the Court as the Notice of Motion and that no separate application for interim relief under Section 9A(2) was necessary. However, the power to grant such relief is discretionary and depends on the facts and circumstances of each case.

The Court noted that the plaintiff’s delay of over two and a half years in approaching the Court after refusal of relief in the testamentary petition constituted laches, which weighs against granting interim relief. The Court also observed that additional facts supporting interim relief were not placed on record by the plaintiff.

The Court clarified that interim relief under Section 9A(2) cannot entail hearing the entire Notice of Motion but must be based on glaring facts showing irretrievable loss if relief is denied. The plaintiff’s contentions of changed circumstances, such as issuance of letters of attornment and ongoing construction, did not justify interim relief pending the suit or the preliminary issue.

Further, the Court explained that while interim relief may be granted in some cases to prevent abuse of process or irreparable harm, such relief is not automatic and requires a proper application with supporting facts, especially after an initial refusal on merits.

Holding and Implications

The application of the plaintiff for interim relief pending the Notice of Motion is disallowed.

The Court’s decision directly affects the parties by denying interim protection to the plaintiff pending trial and preliminary jurisdictional determination. The plaintiff is directed to prosecute the suit expeditiously. No new legal precedent is established beyond the existing interpretation of Section 9A(2) CPC and the principles of laches and interim relief.

    Prem Bhagwandas Harjani v. Naraindas Vensimal Harjani

    ORDER

    1. This Notice of Motion has been taken out for the appointment of Court Receiver and the usual injunctions as also for directing the defendants to deposit the amounts collected and received by them in respect of the suit property with interest @ 18% p.a thereon in a suit for declaration challenging the sale and transfer of the suit property by defendant No. 1 to defendant Nos. 2 & 3 as invalid and for the consequential relief of injunction in respect of its alienation, further sale and creation of third party rights.

    2. The suit property is the subject matter of a Testamentary Petition being the estate of one Vensimal Kalachand Harjani under whose will defendant No. 1 purported to sell the suit property. The petition for probate is stated to have been filed by defendant No. 1, 42 years after his death. The plaintiff sought the relief of injunction against further alienation in the testamentary suit. The relief came to be refused under the order dated 05.01.2011 of this Court in its T & I jurisdiction upon the ground that the property was sold in the year 2010. The plaintiff thereafter filed this suit for the grant of the injunction upon the same facts on 14.08.2013 The plaintiff applied for what was called “urgent ad interim reliefs” on 23.10.2013 in the aforesaid Notice of Motion taken out on 17.10.2013

    3. This Court by its order dated 23.10.2013 refused ad interim relief. The Court recorded that the same reliefs were sought from the Testamentary Court and which were rejected on the ground that the property had been sold in the year 2010 and that the Notice of Motion was not maintainable before the Testamentary Court. This Court further recorded that except for stating that the plaintiff is a 66 years old lady and was unwell, no reason as to why this Court was not approached in the last more than 2 ½ years is given. The Court, therefore, held that the plaintiff was not entitled to any urgent ad interim relief without giving an opportunity to the defendants to file their affidavit-in-reply. The defendants were directed to file their affidavit-in-reply. The Notice of Motion was adjourned.

    4. The Defendants have filed their affidavit-in-reply. Defendant Nos. 2 & 3 have taken up the issue of limitation. The issue has to be tried as the jurisdictional issue under section 9a of the cpc. The issue has been framed and directions for filing the oral and documentary evidence of the plaintiff has been passed on 04.04.2014 by this Court. The suit came to be adjourned for considering the admissibility of the documents of the plaintiff. Admissibility of the documents has been considered. The affidavit of evidence of the plaintiff has been accepted on record. The Commissioner has been appointed to record the cross-examination of the parties.

    5. The plaintiff presses for interim relief under section 9a(2) of the cpc. Section 9A(2) runs thus:

    9A 2). Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), at the hearing of any such application, the Court may grant such interim relief as it may consider necessary, pending determination by it of the preliminary issue as to the jurisdiction. - maharashtra act (65 of 1977) (w.e.f 19.12.1977).

    6. The application taken out by the plaintiff by way of the above Notice of Motion is itself for interim relief in the suit. The plaintiff applied for what is popularly known on the original side of the Bombay High Court as ad interim reliefs. These are the reliefs of an urgent nature granted pending the disposal of the Notice of Motion which is an application for interim reliefs. The preliminary issue has to be decided pending such Notice of Motion which is the application for interim reliefs. Section 9A came to be enacted specifically so that the application for interim relief, which takes up a lot of judicial time, would not be considered until the Court satisfies itself that it has the jurisdiction to decide the suit. This would include the Court's jurisdiction if the suit is not barred by the law of limitation also. Since the Notice of Motion cannot be decided before the decision of the preliminary issue of jurisdiction under Section 9A, the Court may grant such interim relief as it may consider necessary pending the decision under preliminary issue.

    7. The grant of such interim relief pending the preliminary issue is, therefore, dependent upon the Court. Sub-section 2 of Section 9A does not call for an application by the plaintiff. That application for interim relief is already made. It is in that application that the issue of jurisdiction can be raised. Once raised it is that issue which has to be decided. Pending that decision if the Court by itself considers it necessary that some interim reliefs be granted, which would be on the facts and circumstances of each case, the Court is certainly empowered to grant.

    8. Mr. Tamboly on behalf of the plaintiff would argue that the Court could so decide only if an application is made and the plaintiff is entitled to make an application upon certain additional facts. No further application for the grant of any interim relief is made. Additional facts are also not brought out on affidavit yet. The very first application for interim relief itself is pending. The urgent ad interim relief sought is refused. If the plaintiff has to be heard on the facts of the case, including additional facts, it would require hearing the above Notice of Motion itself which the Court cannot do. Hence the Court must grant interim relief, if any, under Sub-section 2 of Section 9A only if it could be granted without hearing the Notice of Motion.

    9. It may be that in a given case the plaintiff who applies for ad interim relief is not heard on the application because the defendant seeks to file an affidavit-in-reply which is allowed. In the affidavit-in-reply the defendant raises the issue of jurisdiction/limitation. The issue would be required to be framed, tried and decided. This would take up some time. In such a case the Court would be empowered to grant some interim reliefs (popularly called ad interim reliefs on the original side of the Bombay High Court) in favour of the plaintiff even though otherwise the Notice of Motion would be kept pending. This would only be an equitable discretionary order. It would not entail the hearing of the Notice of Motion itself. It would be granted as deemed necessary by the Court.

    10. In a suit such as this when the plaintiff sought the similar relief in a testamentary petition and sued 2 ½ years thereafter and moved for ad interim reliefs another 2 ½ months thereafter, the grant of not only ad interim but interim reliefs would elude the plaintiff. Laches would be one of the aspects on merits to be considered which has already been considered by this Court in this suit under its order dated 23.10.2013 Consideration of the facts of the case or even additional facts (which are yet not on record) would entail this Court to sit in appeal against the order dated 23.10.2013 which this Court cannot do.

    11. Counsel on behalf of the plaintiff states that this is an application for interim relief upon changed circumstances. He contends that the defendants have issued letters of attornment to the tenants. The Notice of Motion was for injunction against creation of third party rights as also against carrying on any construction or development work. The defendants have not been injuncted. The application for ad interim relief has been refused. Consequently the defendants have been carrying on construction and development work. In so doing the defendants may issue various letters, execute various documents and do various acts including the issue of letters of attornment. Such further acts cannot give a cause to the plaintiff to apply for interim relief pending the determination of the preliminary issue or even pending the suit.

    12. Consequently it would be appropriate for the plaintiff to prosecute the suit for the determination of the preliminary issue as expeditiously as possible. Of course, if the defendants seek to delay the hearing of the issue of limitation after raising the plea themselves, the plaintiff may seek appropriate direction from the Court. This is not one matter which would require or necessitate an order under Sub-section 2 of Section 9A.

    13. Counsel on behalf of the plaintiff has drawn my attention to the judgment of the Single Judge of this Court in Notice of Motion No. 748 of 2012 dated 17.07.2012 considering section 9a(2) of the cpc. The Court has held in para 8 of the order that it is not powerless for considering the applications for grant of reliefs during the pendency and decision of the preliminary issue regarding the jurisdiction. It is also observed by the Court in the aforesaid para that the provisions of section 9a of the cpc which was legislated to prevent abuse of legal process was itself widely misused by the defendants to prevent grant of interim reliefs to the plaintiff. It is also observed that limitation being a mixed question of law in fact would require evidence to be led which would take a good deal of time. It is, therefore, held in para 7 of the order that the Court was not powerless to consider an application for interim relief during the pendency of application for grant of interim relief itself. Consequently it is observed in para 7 of the judgment that the subsequent application for orders during the pendency of Notice of Motion for interim reliefs during the pendency of the suit can be considered.

    It is further observed in para 8 of the judgment that merely because an application for ad interim relief is not pressed at an earlier stage or for some reasons not granted at an earlier stage neither the party would be precluded from renewing its request nor the Court would be precluded from considering the same in the given facts and circumstances of the each case.

    However there is a rider to the aforesaid entitlement and grant. The Court would have to consider whether the application for interim relief is made on the same facts and circumstances and the Court would be required to take into consideration the change in the circumstances. No hard and fast rule can be laid down.

    14. This is indeed in consonance with Section 9A(2). Some reliefs to a deserving plaintiff would always be granted by the Court as necessitated or as deemed fit and proper. Such power is inherent in each Court. It is argued on behalf of the plaintiff that the expression “not pressed” and “not granted” show that in any case when the reliefs are pressed and not granted also, as in this case, the relief can be pressed and considered on merits. A reading of this judgment does not show that pending the Section 9A issue, all Notices of Motion can be heard to consider the grant or otherwise of interim reliefs. The judgment also does not entitle each plaintiff to such relief. Mr. Madon on behalf of defendant Nos. 1 to 3 rightly contended that an application in that behalf is required to be made for renewal of the request of the grant of interim relief. That application may be in the nature of an affidavit. When the ad interim relief is refused on the ground of laches, the plaintiff must show further facts upon affidavit which the defendant would be entitled to contest. In such a case, therefore, an interim relief can be granted pending the disposal of the preliminary issue only upon changed circumstances. If, however, the ad interim relief has not been considered by the Court at all even though an application in that behalf is made because the defendant has sought time to file affidavit-in-reply under which the preliminary issue is raised, the Court may grant interim relief on the same application upon the renewal of the request of granting such relief. The order of this Court dated 17.07.2012 must be read in the light of two entirely different facts and circumstances in which the same application can be renewed or a subsequent application can be made upon changed circumstances.

    15. In any event such an application cannot entail the hearing of the Notice of Motion in its entirety. It must only show the Court a glaring fact which would irretrievably cause loss to the plaintiff if the relief is not granted.

    16. In view of the above, the application of the plaintiff for interim relief pending the Notice of Motion cannot be granted and is disallowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Prem Bhagwandas Harjani v. Naraindas Vensimal Harjani
    (May 2, 2014)