This Chamber Summons is taken out by the Plaintiff for deletion of
Nutech Engineers & Power Systems Ltd. as Defendant No. 5 to the suit and
implead the Respondents - Nutech Engineering Technologies Ltd. and Nutech
Enterprises - as Defendant Nos. 5 and 5A in the Suit.
2 The Plaintiff is a private company promoted for acquiring
commercial premises in the city of Mumbai. Defendant Nos. 2 and 3, who are
sat 2/9 chs (l) 45-2014.doc
related to the promoter of the Plaintiff company, are promoters of Defendant No.
1. Defendant No. 2 was also a director of the Plaintiff. It is the Plaintiff's case that
Defendant Nos. 2 and 3 defrauded the Plaintiff and siphoned off its funds. The
Suit is for recovery of a sum of about Rs. 13.58 crores which is claimed to have
been illegally and fraudulently siphoned away by Defendant Nos. 2 and 3 in
collusion with various entities who are arraigned as other Defendants to the Suit.
The Suit is based on forensic accounting studies by an accountant identifying
transfer of funds from the Plaintiff's account by Defendant Nos. 2 and 3 in favour
of the entities joined as Defendants. It is the case of the Plaintiff that these
accounting studies revealed an entity "Nutech Engineers" to whom funds to the
tune of Rs. 70 Lacs were unauthorisedly transferred. The Plaintiff came across
during its search the existence of a company by the name of "Nutech Engineers
and Power Systems Ltd." and bona fide believed that company to be the
transferee identified as "Nutech Engineers" and arraigned it as Defendant No. 5
to the Suit. When Defendant Nos. 2, 3, 6 and 7 filed their Written Statement, the
Plaintiff realized that the transferee entities were Nutech Engineering
Technologies Ltd. and Nutech Engineers (a proprietorship) and not Nutech
Engineers and Power Systems Ltd. The Plaintiff, thereupon, filed Chamber
Summons No. 938 of 2011 for impleadment of the correct entities. That Chamber
Summons was withdrawn with liberty to file a fresh Chamber Summons, when it
was revealed in a reply to that Chamber Summons that the proprietor of Nutech
Engineers had changed in the meanwhile and it was now known as Nutech
Enterprises. The present Chamber Summons is filed in pursuance of that liberty
for impleading the company - Nutech Engineering Technologies Ltd. and the
proprietorship - Nutech Enterprises.
submitted by the Defendants that the trial of the Suit has already commenced
with the issues having been framed and no amendment is permissible unless the
case falls within the proviso to Rule 17 of Order VI of the Code of Civil Procedure.
The Defendants submit that the case does not fall under the proviso. They also
submit that the suit against the proposed Defendants is barred by the law of
limitation and in the premises, the amendment cannot be allowed.
On the first question, namely, the commencement of trial, a Division
Bench of an Court in the case of Mahadeo Maruti Bhanje Vs. Balaji Shivaji
Pathade1, after an extensive review of authorities on the point, held that the trial
in a civil suit commences from the date of filing of affidavits in lieu of examination
in chief of the witnesses and the proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil
Procedure comes into play only after the stage of filing of such affidavits.
Evidently, that has not happened in this case. There is, thus, no question of
applicability of the proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 in the present case. The learned
Counsel for the Defendants relied upon several judgments of the Supreme Court
as well as our court to contend that the trial of the suit actually commences with
the framing of issues and not with the filing of the affidavits of evidence. I refuse
to be drawn into this discussion. After all the Division Bench of our court in
Mahadeo Maruti Bhanje (supra) has, after an extensive review of all authorities
including the ones cited by the Defendants, come to a conclusion that the trial
commences with filing of affidavits of evidence and that judgment is binding on
1 2012 (5) Bom.C.R. 777
sat 4/9 chs (l) 45-2014.doc
me.
5 The second question is : whether in the facts of the case, the proposed
amendment ought to be allowed. Under Order 1 Rule 10 the court may at any
stage of the proceedings order that the name of any party improperly joined to be
struck out and the name of any person who ought to have been joined to be
added. In the present case, the Plaintiff claims to have improperly added Nutech
Engineers & Power Systems Ltd. as Defendant No. 5 instead of Nutech
Engineering Technologies Ltd. and Nutech Enterprises who were the real
transferees of the alleged illegally siphoned off funds and therefore, ought to have
been joined. There is obviously power in the court to grant the amendment
proposed on that basis.
6 The Plaintiff's claim in the suit is, as noted above, inter alia for
unauthorized transfers of funds by Defendant Nos. 2 and 3 from the account of
the Plaintiff to the accounts of third parties, who were claimed as close business
associates of Defendant Nos. 2 and 3. It is the Plaintiff's case that none of the
promoters and directors of the Plaintiff except Defendant No. 2 was aware of this
fraud and siphoning off of funds. The Plaintiff had appointed an accountant to
conduct forensic accounting studies which identified the transferred funds. It was
revealed from these studies that payments to the tune of Rs. 70 Lac were
transferred to an entity with the name "Nutech Engineers". The Plaintiff was not
aware of the details of this entity. Defendant Nos. 2 and 3 were not furnishing any
information about "Nutech Engineers". Search in the records of the Registrar of
Companies revealed the existence of "Nutech Engineers and Power System Ltd."
sat 5/9 chs (l) 45-2014.doc
The Plaintiff verily believed the entity "Nutech Engineers" to be this "Nutech
Engineers and Power Systems Ltd." The Plaintiff actually corresponded with M/s
Nutech Engineers and Power System Ltd. in this behalf. In its reply, M/s Nutech
Engineers and Power Systems Ltd. simply denied having received any amount
and claimed that it "was yet to understand the amount shown in the tabular
statement when it was realized through which same". The Plaintiff, in the
premises, proceeded to file the Suit impleading inter alia M/s Nutech Engineers
and Power Systems Ltd. After the Suit was filed and summons was served,
Defendant No. 5, Nutech Engineers and Power Systems Ltd., did not appear.
When Written Statement was filed by Defendant Nos. 2, 3, 6 and 7, it was
revealed therein that payments from the Plaintiff's account were actually made to
entities with the names 'Nutech Engineering Technologies Ltd.' and 'Nutech
Engineers' (which had since been taken over by Nutech Enterprises) and not to
"Nutech Engineers and Power Systems Ltd." and that the former entities along
with Defendant No. 4 belonged to one B. N. Khurana, who was claimed as a
close associate of Defendant Nos. 2 and 3. The Plaintiff thereafter caused
another search taken at the Registrar of Companies and ascertained the
existence of M/s Nutech Engineering Technologies Ltd. By way of abundant
caution, the Plaintiff also called upon the advocates of Defendant Nos. 2, 3, 6 and
7 to confirm whether 'Nutech Engineers' and 'Nutech Engineering Technologies
Ltd.' were the same entity and if not, to furnish further particulars of 'Nutech
Engineers'. All these facts clearly show an error on the part of the Plaintiff about
the entity 'Nutech Engineers'. A statement of Punjab National Bank addressed to
the police (which is relied upon by the Defendants themselves) shows 'Nutech
Engineers' and the limited company 'Nutech Engineering Technologies Ltd.' being
sat 6/9 chs (l) 45-2014.doc
the payees holding the same account number, namely, '26614777/8'. This is
definitely a source of some confusion concerning the entity 'Nutech Engineers' -
whether the same was or was not a limited company. The mistake, which was
revealed after Written Statement was filed by the Defendants, is now sought to be
corrected.
7 The object of the rule contained in Order 1 Rule 10 is to save
honest and bona fide claimants from being non-suited and discourage contests
on technical pleas. A mistake made foolishly or carelessly but honestly may well
be within this rule. After all, whether under Order 1 Rule 10 or under Order 6 Rule
17, the dominant purpose of allowing an amendment is to minimize the litigation
and determine the real controversy between the parties to a Suit. Any error or
mistake, as long as the same is not fraudulent or motivated by bad faith, should
not non-suit a party.
8 In that view of the matter, there could be no objection to allowing
the amendment and deleting the existing Defendant No. 5 (who is improperly
added) and joining the proposed Defendant Nos. 5 and 5A (who ought to have
been added) to the Suit.
9 That still leaves one question open: Is the Suit against the new
Defendants barred by limitation. Ordinarily, under Section 21 of the Limitation Act,
where a new defendant is substituted or added, the suit as regards him shall be
deemed to have been instituted when he was so made a party. For this purpose
the material date is the date of the application for impleadment and not the date
sat 7/9 chs (l) 45-2014.doc
on which the party is actually brought on record. Ordinarily therefore, the date of
joinder would be the date of the application for joinder. It is claimed by the
Defendants that on the date of the application for joinder the suit is barred by
limitation against the proposed Defendants. In answer, it is submitted by the
Plaintiff that this is not a case of a new impleadment but correction of a
misdescription originally contained in the plaint. Alternatively, it is submitted that
the omission to include the proposed Defendants was due to a mistake made in
good faith. In the premises, it is claimed that the suit should be deemed to have
been instituted against the newly added Defendants on the date of the
presentation of the plaint itself.
10 Proviso to Section 21(1) of the Limitation Act permits the court to
treat the suit as having been instituted on any earlier date (i.e. earlier to the date
of application for joinder) on being satisfied that the omission to include the
proposed defendant was due to a mistake made in good faith. The question that
needs to be examined in the present case is whether, either due to a bona fide
error in description or any other mistake made in good faith, as claimed by the
Plaintiff, the proposed Defendants were not actually included originally in the suit
herein.
11 This question is different from the one to be considered for the case
of joinder under Order 1 Rule 10. Whereas under Order 1 Rule 10 the question is
whether there is lack of good faith in the application for new joinder, under the
proviso to Section 21 the question is whether there is good faith in the earlier
non-joinder. The Plaintiff must show that despite exercise of good faith, a mistake
sat 8/9 chs (l) 45-2014.doc
was made by not joining the correct defendant. In other words, despite exercise
of due diligence, the Plaintiff could not find out who the correct defendant ought to
be. Both the Plaintiff and the Defendants have relied upon various documents
which throw light on the aspect of due diligence or otherwise on the part of the
Plaintiff in omitting to implead the correct defendants. The matter obviously
requires to be proved at the trial by leading of evidence. That question cannot be
decided, or at any rate, need not be decided, at this stage, since it would involve
leading of extensive evidence. Subject to the plea of limitation being kept open,
the proposed Defendants can always be added.
12 The Supreme Court in the case of Ragu Thilak D. John Vs. S.
Rayappan2 observed as follows:
"If the aforesaid test is applied in the instant case, the
amendment sought could not be declined. The dominant
purpose of allowing the amendment is to minimise the litigation.
The plea that the relief sought by way of amendment was barred
by time is arguable in the circumstances of the case, as is
evident from the perusal of averments made in paras 8(a) to 8(f)
of the plaint which were sought to be incorporated by way of
amendment. We feel that in the circumstances of the case the
plea of limitation being disputed could be made a subject-matter
of the issue after allowing the amendment prayed for."
This dictum was affirmed by the Supreme Court later in the case
Baldev Singh Vs. Manohar Singh 3. The dictum can aptly be applied to the facts
of the present case.
to the plea of limitation against the newly added Defendants, to be agitated in the
trial of the suit. There shall be no order as to costs. Amendment to be carried out
within a period of four weeks from today.
(S.C. Gupte, J.)