AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Z.A. Haq, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are Lecturers in various departments of Government Polytechnics in Maharashtra who were appointed on a contractual basis under a State policy introduced by a Government Resolution dated 25 July 2002 (as modified by resolutions of 2 August 2003 and 3 October 2003). Their contractual appointments were made following public advertisement and interview by Selection Committees constituted under the Government Resolution dated 2 August 2003. The petitioners worked for periods ranging from three to ten years but were not granted permanency/regularization.

The State had earlier imposed a recruitment ban (since 1998) and subsequently permitted temporary contractual appointments to fill sanctioned teaching posts in technical education to avoid adverse effects on students' education. The petitioners' contractual appointments were continued by government orders (including an order dated 26 October 2005 and subsequent communications) and certain service benefits (e.g., a technical break policy, leave, and increases in pay package) were granted by the Government. The petitioners filed the present writ petition seeking regularization/permanency of their services. The Court heard counsel for both parties, made the rule returnable forthwith, and ultimately delivered the judgment summarized here.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners, who were selected by duly constituted Selection Committees after advertisement but appointed on a contractual basis, are entitled to regularization/permanency in their posts.
  2. Whether the principle in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (denying regularization to persons appointed clandestinely or without following prescribed selection procedures) applies to the petitioners' case.
  3. Whether treating petitioners differently from similarly situated employees (notably Lecturers in Private Polytechnics who are regularized under other policies) constitutes impermissible discrimination violating Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as presented by Shri R.L. Khapre)

  • The petitioners were selected after advertisement and interview by duly constituted Selection Committees and have worked to the satisfaction of the respondents; thus they are entitled to regularization/permanency.
  • The Government has framed recruitment rules under Article 309; the State has previously regularized other categories of contractual employees (Shikshan Sevak, Gram Sevak, certain Mantralaya employees, medical/dental college lecturers, Assistant Engineers Class-II), and similar treatment must be extended to these petitioners to avoid discrimination.
  • Teachers in Private Polytechnics (appointed as Shikshan Sevak under the 27 April 2000 resolution) undergo a selection process and are regularized after contractual service; petitioners in Government Polytechnics perform the same work and have similar qualifications and therefore cannot be treated differently — reliance on Article 14 (equality) and Article 16 (equality of opportunity) was urged.

Respondents' Arguments (as presented by Shri N.W. Sambre)

  • The petitioners have no legal right to claim regularization via extraordinary writ jurisdiction because they accepted contractual employment with notice that permanency would not be conferred.
  • The respondents relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi ((2006) 4 SCC 1) to argue that regularization cannot be permitted where appointments are not made according to rules or through the Public Service Commission.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi ((2006) 4 SCC 1 : AIR 2006 SC 1806) Courts should not ordinarily grant regularization where appointments were clandestine or made without following established procedures (e.g., without advertisement or proper selection); irregular appointees should not be permitted to block regular selection processes. The Court held that Umadevi was not applicable here because the petitioners were appointed after advertisement and selection by duly constituted Committees (i.e., not clandestine/back-door appointments), so the respondents' reliance on Umadevi was rejected.
Radha Dubey v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi (Order dated 16 Aug 2010 in SLP (C) No. CC10388/2010) Appointments on contract for an uninterrupted period of ten years may amount to exploitation; the State should not impose wholly inequitable and unreasonable conditions of employment on weaker parties. The Court treated Radha Dubey as factually almost identical and used it to support the view that long continuance on contract without regularization is unfair; this supported relief in favor of petitioners.
Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Ltd. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly ((1986) 3 SCC 156 : AIR 1986 SC 1571) Article 14 requires State action to be right and reasoned; Courts can strike down unfair and unreasonable contractual terms imposed by a stronger party on a weaker party who had no bargaining power. The Court relied on this principle to conclude that when the State imposes unfair conditions (e.g., protracted contractual employment) the Court can strike them down; used to support petitioners' claim for regularization given the imbalance of bargaining power.
Delhi Transport Corporation v. D.T.C. Mazdoor Congress (1991 Supp (1) SCC 600 : AIR 1991 SC 101) Approved the principle in Central Inland Water Transport Corporation (i.e., protecting weaker parties from unfair contractual conditions imposed by the State). Used as supporting authority for the proposition that State must act reasonably and that unfair conditions may be invalidated; supports the Court's view against permitting indefinite contractual exploitation.
Union Public Service Commission v. Girish Jayanti Lal Vaghela (2006 (2) SCALE 115) Article 16 requires advertisement and selection by an expert body/committee for appointment; regular appointments generally cannot be made without such advertisement and a proper selection procedure. The Court cited this decision for the proposition that regular appointments require advertisement and fair selection; then observed that the petitioners had been appointed after advertisement and selection by a Committee, which satisfied the concerns underlying Article 16.
B.S. Minhas v. Indian Statistical Institute ((1983) 4 SCC 582 : AIR 1984 SC 363) Foundational authority on the requirement of advertisement/selection for appointments as connected to Article 16. Referred to within the discussion of the Vaghela decision to support the statement of law regarding Article 16 obligations for appointment procedures.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the matter in these main steps, relying only on material and authority cited in the opinion:

  1. Found as fact that the petitioners were appointed pursuant to the Government Resolution dated 25 July 2002 (permitting contractual appointments) and further selection arrangements under the Government Resolution dated 2 August 2003. The Selection Committee composition was detailed and included experienced/technical persons (Joint Director Technical Education, a lady representative, the Principal, a backward class representative, and subject experts).
  2. Observed the appointment process involved advertisement and interviews and that no charge was made by the respondents that the selection process involved illegality, clandestine appointments, or denial of opportunity to eligible candidates. Several candidates had applied and the petitioners were selected as suitable.
  3. Noted that the State had continued the petitioners' services beyond initial two-year contracts (for example by order dated 26 October 2005 and subsequent communications), increased their pay packages, granted leave benefits, and expressly permitted continuation after technical breaks. These actions showed the posts were sanctioned, full-time, and the Government had extracted long-term service from these employees.
  4. Considered the State's contention that whether posts should be filled on a regular or contractual basis is a policy matter. The Court held that, while policy decisions generally lie with the State, the fact that sanctioned posts were being continuously filled by long-term contractual appointees meant the State could not perpetuate a 'hire and fire' approach or treat such appointments as a temporary convenience when the effect is prolonged employment without regularization.
  5. Examined and distinguished the Supreme Court's decision in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi: in Umadevi the appointments were clandestine/irregular and deprived others of the chance to compete; the present case, however, involved appointment after advertisement and selection by a duly constituted committee, so Umadevi's rule was not applicable.
  6. Invoked the principles in Radha Dubey, Central Inland Water Transport (Brojo Nath Ganguly), and Delhi Transport Corporation decisions, which emphasize that prolonged contractual employment can amount to exploitation and that Article 14/Article 16 require equality, reasonableness and protection of weaker parties from unfair contractual terms imposed by the State. The Court found these principles supportive of petitioners' claims because the petitioners had worked uninterruptedly for substantial periods (3–10 years) and were selected by fair processes established by the Government Resolution.
  7. Addressed discrimination arguments: observed that Lecturers in Private Polytechnics (appointed as Shikshan Sevaks) are regularized after contractual terms under the 27 April 2000 policy, and that petitioners in Government Polytechnics had similar qualifications and selection procedures. The Court found no reason to differentiate between these groups when service conditions are otherwise similar.
  8. Considered the vacancy situation: even the State admitted over 5,000 teaching posts were vacant while MPSC advertisement was only for 400 posts. The Court reasoned that regularizing the petitioners would not displace candidates to be selected by MPSC because a large number of vacancies would remain.
  9. On the cumulative view of facts and authorities, held that the petitioners' long continuance on contract, selection through advertisement and committee, sanctioned nature of posts, and inequitable effect of continued contractual status justified granting relief in part.

The Court declined the respondents' request for a stay of the judgment at the hearing, noting the factual circumstances (including many petitioners being in regular service until 15-10-2013) and therefore refusing the stay request.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The writ petition is partly allowed.

Direct Orders and Consequences (as directed by the Court):

  • The respondents are directed to regularize the services and confer permanency on those petitioners who have completed three years' service with the requisite technical breaks. The respondents shall absorb such petitioners within six weeks.
  • Petitioners who were in continuous employment till 15-10-2013 shall be continued in service as regular employees.
  • The petitioners shall be entitled to regular salary from 1 November 2013, but they are not entitled to any past monetary benefits for prior services despite the regularization. However, once regularized they shall have continuity in service for all other non-monetary purposes from the date of their first appointment.
  • The respondents were directed to act on an authenticated copy of the judgment; the Court expedited certified copy (C.C) and refused the respondents' application for stay of the judgment at that stage.

Broader implications: The opinion applies established principles (Article 14/16 jurisprudence and authority on exploitative prolonged contractual employment) to circumstances where advertised appointments were followed by long-term contractual continuance. The opinion does not itself purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities to the facts before it.

Outcome

Final disposition in the opinion: Petition partly allowed.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sachin Ambadas Dawale And Others v. State Of Maharashtra And Another

    Z.A Haq, J.:— Heard Shri R.L Khapre, learned Advocate for the petitioners and Shri N.W Sambre, learned Government Pleader for respondents.

    2. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith.

    3. The petitioners are Lecturers in different departments of Government Polytechnic in the State of Maharashtra. The petitioners have been appointed as per the policy of the Government of Maharashtra incorporated in the Government Resolution dated 25th July, 2002 as modified by the Government Resolution dated 2nd August, 2003 and 3rd October, 2003. The grievance of the petitioners is that though they have been in the employment of the respondents for a period ranging from three years to ten years, they are not given permanency and the benefits of permanent appointment.

    4. The Finance Department of the Government of Maharashtra had imposed a ban on recruitment in all the departments since 1998. In view of the ban, the appointments were not made in Government and non-government aided educational institutions which adversely affected the education of the students. In 2001-2002 permission was granted to fill 50% to ⅔rd teaching posts but the posts could not be filled and in the academic year 2002-2003, 6453 teaching posts were vacant. In order to avoid the adverse effect on the education of the students, the Government of Maharashtra issued resolution dated 25th July, 2002 by which permission is granted to fill ⅔rd teaching posts in Technical and Higher-technical Education Department on temporary contractual basis.

    5. The respondents had issued Notification dated 25th August, 2003 inviting the applications from eligible candidates for the posts of Lecturers in Government Polytechnic in the State of Maharashtra. As per the notification, the appointments were to be made on contract basis for the period of two years or until the candidates nominated by the Maharashtra Public Service Commission were available.

    The Government of Maharashtra had issued the resolution dated 2nd August, 2003 constituting the Selection Committee for appointment of the Lecturers in the Government Polytechnics and the composition of the Selection Committee was as follows:—

    i) Joint Director, Technical Education Divisional Office — Chairman.

    ii) Lady representative — Member,

    iii) Principal of concerned Institute — Member Secretary,

    iv) Representative of backward classes (Engineering Graduate) — Member.

    v) Subject Experts (2) — Member.”

    6. The petitioners had submitted the applications pursuant to the Notification dated 25th August, 2003 and all the candidates who had applied for the posts, including the petitioners, were interviewed and the selections were made. At the time of the appointment, the petitioners were given a lump sum monthly pay package and their appointment was for the period of two years. The respondent No. 2-the Director of Technical Education issued the order dated 26th October, 2005 and continued the Lecturers whose names are mentioned in the order for a further period of two years till 26th October, 2007 however, with the rider that the continuation will be till the regularly selected candidates are available.

    The Lecturers who were appointed on contractual basis submitted a charter of their demands to the Government of Maharashtra, which was considered by the Government of Maharashtra and it was directed that those Lecturers will be continued in service on contractual basis after giving a technical break of 4 to 5 days, until the candidates regularly selected by the MPSC are available. Thirty days leave was also sanctioned for these contractual employees by the Government by resolution dated 18th February, 2006. The monthly salary of these contractual employees was increased from Rs. 8,000/- to 12,000/- in case of Lecturers, from Rs. 12,000/- to Rs. 16,000/- in case of Assistant Professors and from Rs. 16,400/- to Rs. 20,000/- in case of Professors.

    In due course Directorate of Technical Education had submitted the proposal on 11th August, 2008 for grant of pregnancy leave and casual leave to these contractual employees and the Government of Maharashtra by the communication dated 15th August, 2008 had rejected the said proposals. However, subsequently, by the communication dated 10th November, 2009, the Government of Maharashtra permitted the Directorate of Technical Education to continue the services of all the Lecturers appointed on contractual basis after giving a technical break of 4 to 5 days. It is in these circumstances that the petitioners are working with the respondents in the Government Polytechnic Institutions on contractual basis.

    7. The submission of the petitioners is that they have been selected by a duly constituted Selection Committee by following the procedure of issuing advertisement and inviting the applications from all the eligible candidates and they have been working to the satisfaction of the respondents and therefore, they are entitled for the regularization and/or permanency in the posts in which they are working. The petitioners have submitted that the Government of Maharashtra has framed rules in exercise of the powers conferred by the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India which are known as “Principal, Government Polytechnic, Principal, Hotel Management and Catering Technology, Head of Department in Engineering Disciplines or Workshop Superintendent (Head of Department Level) in Government Polytechnic, Head of Department in Non-Engineering Disciplines, Head of Department in Hotel Management and Catering Technology, Lecturer in Various Engineering Disciplines or System Analysts or Workshop Superintendent (lecturer level) or Controller of Examinations in Government Polytechnic or Maharashtra State Board of Technical Education, Lecturer in Various Non-engineering Disciplines, Lecturer in Hotel Management and Catering Technology in the Maharashtra Polytechnic Services in Group “A” under the Directorate of Technical Education in the Higher and Technical Education Department (Recruitment) Rules, 2008.”

    It is submitted that the Government of Maharashtra by the communication dated 29th March, 2008 had informed the Director of Education (Higher Education) that the teaching posts which fall within the purview of the MPSC and which were to be filled only on the basis of the interviews have been taken out of the purview of the MPSC and the Cabinet has granted its approval for the same. The petitioners have submitted that the Government of Maharashtra being a “Model Employer” has to treat its similarly situated employees alike and it cannot discriminate between different sets of similarly situated employees. The petitioners have submitted that the following categories of employees have been regularized by the Government of Maharashtra:—

    (i) Shikshan Sevak working in the private schools appointed on contractual basis as per the policy incorporated in the Government Resolution dated 27th April, 2000, have been regularized.

    (ii) Gram Sevak appointed on contractual basis, have been regularized.

    (iii) 3761 employees appointed in the various departments of Mantralaya, who were not selected through the procedure of Selection Board, have been regularized by the Government resolution dated 8th March, 1999.

    (iv) Lecturers working in the Government Medical Colleges and Government Dental Colleges, who were appointed on contractual basis, have been regularized by the Government resolution dated 22nd January, 2009.

    (v) Assistant Engineers class-II in the Maharashtra Engineering Services Group B appointed till 16th June, 1997, have been regularized subject to passing the oral qualifying examination conducted by the MPSC.

    The petitioners, thus, complain of discrimination by the Government of Maharashtra in the matter of regularization of the services of the petitioners.

    8. Shri Khapre, learned Advocate for the petitioners, has submitted that the Private Polytechnic Institutions in the State of Maharashtra are governed by the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977 (for short “Act of 1977”) by virtue of the definition of “School” under section 2(24) of the Act of 1977. The Teachers/Lecturers appointed in the Private Polytechnic Institutions are appointed by the School Committee as laid down in Schedule “A” of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Rules, 1981. These appointments are made after following the procedure of issuing advertisements, inviting the applications and conducting interviews by the School Committee. Learned Advocate for the petitioners has submitted that the Government of Maharashtra has issued the resolution dated 27th April, 2000 by which the “Shikshan Sevak Scheme” is introduced and as per this policy the candidates are appointed on contractual basis for a tenure of three years and after they complete the contractual term of three years, their services are regularized. Learned Advocate for the petitioners has submitted that the petitioners, who are appointed in the Government Polytechnic Institutions, cannot be given a different treatment than their counterparts appointed in the Private Polytechnic Institutions and some of which are also receiving grant-in-aid from the State Exchequer According to the petitioners, the Teachers/Lecturers working in the Private Polytechnic Institutions and the Teachers/Lecturers working in the Government Polytechnic Institutions are appointed on the basis of the same qualifications and are required to do the same work and therefore, the discrimination only regarding the regularization of their services is impermissible in law and is violative of the guarantee enshrined under Article 14 of the Constitution of India.

    9. Shri Sambre, learned Government Pleader, has submitted that the petitioners have no legal right to make the claim by invoking the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court. According to the respondents, the petitioners are contractual employees and they have accepted the employment with full knowledge that they cannot claim regularization or permanency. Learned Government Pleader has relied on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi, reported in (2006) 4 SCC 1 : AIR 2006 SC 1806 (1) and has submitted that as per the ratio of the above referred judgment, it is not possible for the respondents to confer regularization or permanency on the petitioners as the appointments of the petitioners are not according to the rules and not through the MPSC.

    10. We have considered the submissions on behalf of the petitioners and the respondents. It is undisputed that the appointments of the petitioners are as per the policy incorporated in the Government resolution dated 25th of July, 2002 in which it is laid down that the appointments will be on contractual basis and till the availability of the candidates appointed through regular selection process. However, it is important to consider that the petitioners are appointed after following the procedure of issuance of advertisement and conducting interviews by a duly constituted Selection Committee. The Selection Committee constituted as per the Government resolution dated 2nd August, 2003 comprises of highly experienced and technical persons like:

    (i) Joint Director, Technical Education Department,

    (ii) representative of women,

    (iii) Principal of the concerned institution,

    (iv) representative of backward class, and

    (v) two Experts of concerned subject.

    In view of the above facts, it cannot be said that the appointments of the petitioners are back door or illegal. It cannot be said that the petitioners are appointed arbitrarily or haphazardly or clandestinely without issuing advertisement and without giving an opportunity to all the eligible candidates to participate in the selection process. From the record it clearly appears to be an undisputed position that in response to the advertisement several candidates had participated in the selection process and it is the petitioners who were found eligible and suitable for the posts and as such were selected and appointed. It is not the case of the respondents that any illegalities took place during the selection process.

    11. We have discussed earlier, that after the tenure of two years of the appointment of the petitioners came to an end, the respondent-Government issued the resolution dated 26th October, 2005 and continued the Lecturers for the further period of two years. It is to be noted that the Government of Maharashtra has stated in the affidavit filed before this Court that it had decided to continue the services of the contractual employees after giving four to five days' break until the candidates selected through MPSC are available and that the Government of Maharashtra had decided to grant 30 days' leave to these employees and had increased monthly package of these employees. These factors show that the posts, in which these employees are appointed on contractual basis, are permanent and full time posts and the services of these employees were required by the Government of Maharashtra to discharge its “constitutional obligation” of imparting education.

    12. The contention of the State Government as to whether the posts should be filled on a regular basis or contractual basis is a policy matter and cannot be within the domain of the judicial review of this Court is without substance. The State Government is a “Model Employer” and is obliged to follow the Constitutional Scheme. It is not in dispute that after their selection, the petitioners have worked for a period between 3 years to 10 years. In this respect we may gainfully refer to the following observations of the Hon'ble Apex Court in case of Radha Dubey v. Govt, of NCT of Delhi in the order dated 16th August, 2010 in Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) No. CC10388/2010:

    “We are prima facie of the view that appointment of a person on contract basis for an uninterrupted period of ten years amounts to exploitation. The State, as a model employer in a welfare State, is not expected to take advantage of its position and impose wholly unequitable and unreasonable condition of employment on the prospective employees, who do not have the choice but to accept the appointment on terms and conditions offered by the employer. This practice seems to be contrary to the ratio of the judgments of this Court in Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Ltd. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly, (1986) 3 SCC 156 : AIR 1986 SC 1571 and Delhi Transport Corporation v. D.T.C Mazdoor Congress, 1991 Supp (1) SCC 600 : AIR 1991 SC 101.”

    It is to be noted that having observed this, the Hon'ble Apex Court in the peculiar facts of the case had directed the respondents to take the petitioners back in service by an interim order. The facts of the present case are almost identical. The Government has extracted the work from the petitioners for years together after they were found eligible and suitable in the selection process, conducted by the Selection Committees, which are constituted in pursuance to the Government Resolution.

    13. Insofar as the contention of the respondents that the petitioners were aware that their appointment was for a limited period on contract basis and as such they are not entitled to claim regularization is concerned, the said submission is also without substance. It is not in dispute that during this period i.e up to 2010 the appointments which were made, were made only through the process by which the petitioners were selected. It is not as if during the said period MPSC was also conducting the selection process simultaneously. It is not therefore as if the petitioners had choice to participate in the selection process through MPSC as well as through the Committees constituted under the said Government Resolution. The petitioners had no choice but to participate in the selection process conducted through the Committees constituted under the said Government Resolution. The Hon'ble Apex Court in case of Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Ltd. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly, (1986) 3 SCC 156 : AIR 1986 SC 1571 has observed as follows:

    “…………Article 14 of the Constitution guarantees to all persons equality before the law and the equal protection of the laws. The principle deducible from the above discussions on this part of the case in consonance with right and reason, intended to secure social and economic justice and conforms to the mandate of the great equality clause in Article 14. This principle is that the Courts will not enforce and will, when called upon to do so, strike down an unfair and unreasonable contract, or an unfair and unreasonable clause in a contract, entered into between parties who are not equal in bargaining power it will apply to situations in which the weaker party is in a position in which he can obtain goods or services or means of livelihood only upon the terms imposed by the stronger party or go without them.”

    It can, thus, be clearly seen that the Apex Court in the said case has held that Article 14 requires that the State action should be right and reasoned and intended to secure social and economic justice and to conform to the mandate of equality clause enshrined in Article 14 of the Constitution. It has been equally held that when an unfair or unreasonable condition is imposed by the State, the Court can very well strike it down. The Constitution Bench of the Apex Court in case of Delhi Transport Corporation v. D.T.C Mazdoor Congress, reported in 1991 Supp (1) SCC 600 : AIR 1991 SC 101 (1) has approved the principle laid down in the case of Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Ltd. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly (supra). In that view of the matter, we are unable to accept the contention of the State, on account of whose inaction, the appointments could not be made for a period of more than a decade. The petitioners had no choice but to participate in the selection process as per the said Government Resolution to get the employment.

    14. In the facts of the present case, the Government did not hold selection through MPSC for a period of more than 10 years and selected the Lecturers only through the selection process as provided under the said Government Resolution and the petitioners were duly selected through that process. The respondent-State has extracted the work from the petitioners for years together. Now, by efflux of time and on account of the respondent-State not holding the selection process for years together, many of the petitioners have become over-aged and would not be in a position to participate in the selection process through MPSC. It could be clearly seen that the issue before the Apex Court in case of Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (supra) was pertaining to the appointments which were made clandestinely and without advertisement and the persons were appointed without following due selection process. The facts of the present case are totally different. In the present case the petitioners have been appointed after the posts were advertised, they were selected in a selection process by Committee of Experts duly constituted as per the said Government Resolution. In that view of the matter, the law laid down by the Apex Court in the case of Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (supra) would not be applicable to the facts of the present case.

    15. The submission of the Government of Maharashtra that whether the posts should be filled in on regular basis or contractual basis is a matter of policy and falls within the domain of the Government of Maharashtra (employer), does not appeal to us. It being an admitted position that the posts, in which these employees have been appointed and continued for a considerable length of time, on contractual basis, are regular and full time posts; the appointments in these posts cannot be at the whims and fancies of the Government of Maharashtra. The State cannot adopt a policy of hire and fire or use and throw.

    16. In our view the submissions made on behalf of the respondents relying on the judgment in the case of Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (supra) would not be applicable in the facts of the present case. It is undisputed that the posts, in which the petitioners are working, are sanctioned posts. As discussed earlier, the Government of Maharashtra had issued the resolution dated 2nd August, 2003 by which the Selection Committee came to be constituted for the selection of the candidates. The respondents have not disputed that though the petitioners were initially appointed for a fixed term, they are continued in service. It is not disputed that the leave facility is made available by the resolution dated 18th February, 2006 to such employees. The respondents have stated in their affidavit that the monthly pay to these employees has been increased. It is not disputed that the petitioners are having the qualifications required for the posts in which they are working. The respondents have not disputed that the appointments for the teaching posts are taken out of the purview of the MPSC as informed by the communication dated 29th March, 2008.

    17. The submission on behalf of the respondents relying on the judgment of Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (supra) cannot be accepted in the facts of the present case. In above case, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed in paragraph 3 of the judgment that the States have resorted to irregular appointments, especially in the lower rungs of the service, without reference to the duty to ensure a proper appointment procedure through the Public Service Commission “or otherwise as per the rules adopted” and to permit these irregular appointees or those appointed on contract or on daily wages, to continue year after year, thus, keeping out those who are qualified to apply for the post concerned and depriving them of an opportunity to compete for the post. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed that Courts should desist from issuing orders preventing regular selection or recruitment at the instance of such persons and from issuing directions for continuance of those who have not secured regular appointments as per procedure established. In the present case though the petitioners are not selected through MPSC, it is undisputed that the petitioners are selected after the procedure for selection is followed and through the duly constituted Selection Committee as constituted by the Government of Maharashtra. The advertisement was issued before the petitioners were selected and all interested candidates had applied for the posts for which the petitioners are selected. Thus, it cannot be said that the petitioners have got the employment through back door entry. It cannot be said that the candidates qualified for the posts were deprived of the opportunity to compete for the selection for the posts in which the petitioners are working.

    In case of Union Public Service Commission v. Girish Jayanti Lal Vaghela, reported in 2006 (2) SCALE 115 the Hon'ble Supreme Court has laid down as follows:

    “Article 16 which finds place in Part III of the Constitution relating to fundamental rights provides that there shall be equality of opportunity for all citizens in matters relating to employment or appointment to any office under the State. The main object of Article 16 is to create a constitutional right to equality of opportunity and employment in public offices. The words “employment” or “appointment” cover not merely the initial appointment but also other attributes of service like promotion and age of superannuation etc. The appointment to any post under the State can only be made after a proper advertisement has been made inviting applications from eligible candidates and holding of selection by a body of experts or a specially constituted committee whose members are fair and impartial through a written examination or interview or some other rational criteria for judging the inter se merit of candidates who have applied in response to the advertisement made. A regular appointment to a post under the State or Union cannot be made without issuing advertisement in the prescribed manner which may in some cases include inviting applications from the employment exchange where eligible candidates get their names registered. Any regular appointment made on a post under the State or Union without issuing advertisement inviting applications from eligible candidates and without holding a proper selection where all eligible candidates get a fair chance to compete would violate the guarantee enshrined under Article 16 of the Constitution (See B.S Minhas v. Indian Statistical Institute, (1983) 4 SCC 582 : AIR 1984 SC 363).”

    The said judgment is considered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (supra).

    18. The submissions made by Shri Khapre, learned advocate for the petitioners, regarding the discrimination of the Lecturers working in the Government Polytechnics viz-a-viz Lecturers working in the Private Polytechnics is not without substance. The Lecturers who are appointed in the Private Polytechnic Institutions are selected by the School Committee which comprises of the Members of the Trust which administers the Private Polytechnic Institutions. The Committee which is constituted under the Government resolution dated 2nd August, 2003 is a broad based Committee comprising of Joint Director (Technical Education), two Subject Experts, representative of women, representative having technical knowledge, a member who belongs to backward classes and the Principal of the Polytechnic Institution concerned.

    The Lecturers who are appointed in the Private Polytechnic Institutions after selection through the School Committee are appointed on contractual basis as “Shikshan Sevak” for the period of three years as per the policy of the Government of Maharashtra incorporated in the resolution dated 27th April, 2000. It is not in dispute that the selection process through which the petitioners are selected is much less stringent than the selection process of the Private Polytechnic. We see no reason as to why the petitioners, who are otherwise eligible and qualified for the posts and who are selected by a duly constituted Selection Committee appointed by the Government of Maharashtra and who are appointed in sanctioned posts after the issuance of advertisement and following regular procedure of selection should not be treated at par with their counterparts in the Private Polytechnic Institutions. We are of the view that the petitioners cannot be discriminated viz-a-viz their counterparts working in the Private Polytechnic Institutions. We are conscious that the Lecturers working in the Government Institutions form a different class than the Lecturers working in the Private Institutions. However, when all other service conditions are similar, we are of the view that the petitioners are also entitled for the same benefits as their counterparts working in the Private Polytechnic Institutions are entitled as far as the conferment of regularization and permanency are concerned.

    19. One more fact that needs to be taken into consideration is that even according to the respondent-State there are more than 5000 teaching posts which are still vacant and the advertisement issued by the MPSC is only for 400 posts. It can, thus, be clearly seen that even after the candidates who would be selected through the selection process conducted by the MPSC are available, more than 4500 posts will be vacant. It is, therefore, clear that the petitioners' absorption would in no way affect the candidates who would now be selected through the MPSC. It is, thus, clear that the petitioners' continuation in service would not adversely affect the fundamental right guaranteed under Article 16 to the citizens. We are of the considered view that the respondent-tate having extracted the work from the petitioners for years together, the petitioners cannot be deprived of the right of regular employment particularly when their entry can neither be termed as “illegal” nor “back door”.

    20. In view of the above, the writ petition needs to be partly allowed.

    21. The writ petition is partly allowed.

    22. The respondents are directed to regularize the services of such of the petitioners and confer permanency on such petitioners who have completed three years' service with technical breaks. The respondents shall absorb the petitioners within a period of six weeks. Needless to state that the petitioners who are in continuous employment till 15-10-2013 shall be continued in service as regular employees.

    However, in the facts and circumstances of the case, we direct that the petitioners shall be entitled to regular salary from 1st November, 2013 and would not be entitled to claim any monetary benefits for the past services rendered by them in spite of their regularization. Needless to state that since the petitioners' services are regularized, they shall be entitled to the continuity in service for all other purposes except monetary purposes from the date of their first appointment.

    23. At this stage, Shri N.W Sambre, learned Government Pleader, requests for stay to this judgment. However, taking into consideration the facts and circumstances of the case and particularly the fact that most of the petitioners were in regular service till 15-10-2013, we are not inclined to consider the request as made.

    C.C is expedited.

    Respondents to act on authenticated copy of the judgment.

    Petition partly allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sachin Ambadas Dawale And Others v. State Of Maharashtra And Another
    (Oct 19, 2013)