AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2011 BHC 10454
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2011 BHC 10454
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an oral judgment delivered by Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, J., disposing of a petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution. The petition challenges the legality of orders passed by the Commissioner of Customs (Import) on 15 February 2011 and 7 April 2011 that granted provisional release of seized goods under Section 110 of the Customs Act 1962, subject to specified conditions.

Relevant factual and procedural points recorded in the opinion:

  • The Petitioners imported nine cranes between 17 November 2005 and 6 April 2010; bills of entry were lodged and these consignments were assessed and cleared.
  • On 10 November 2010 the cranes were seized by Customs authorities.
  • On 15 February 2011 an order under Section 110A permitted provisional clearance of the goods subject to conditions, namely: (i) payment of differential duty of Rs. 1,32,17,036/- with interest of Rs. 62,41,705/- (calculated till 28.02.2011); (ii) furnishing a bank guarantee for 20% of the ascertained CIF value (i.e., Rs. 7,30,44,625/-); (iii) furnishing a bond for the ascertained CIF value (same amount); (iv) legal undertaking to produce the crane for inspection when required; and (v) legal undertaking not to dispose of the crane without prior intimation to the department.
  • By letters dated 21 March 2011 the Petitioners informed Customs that two cranes had already been released on payment of differential duty and sought modification to allow bank guarantees of a nationalized bank and reduction of the guarantee from 20% to 10% of the enhanced CIF value. By a letter dated 7 April 2011 the Deputy Commissioner permitted clearance of the seized cranes one at a time.
  • The Respondents filed an affidavit in reply stating that investigations revealed imports of 90 cranes since October 2005 involving alleged duty evasion of approximately Rs. 10.82 crores, undervaluation, suppression of freight, retracted admissions and other evidence suggesting under-declaration. A notice to show cause under Section 28 read with Section 124 was indicated as forthcoming.
  • The petition was taken up and finally disposed of by consent on the same day as the rule was issued.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the orders of the Commissioner of Customs (Import) dated 15 February 2011 and 7 April 2011 granting provisional release of seized goods under Section 110/110A of the Customs Act 1962 are legal and justified.
  2. Whether the provisional release of goods under Section 110A can, as a matter of principle, be restricted to the furnishing of a bond alone (as urged by the Petitioners relying on Navshakti Industries), or whether the adjudicating authority may require additional security/conditions including bank guarantees.
  3. Whether the conditions imposed (in particular payment of differential duty and interest, and a bank guarantee representing 20% of the ascertained CIF value) were excessive and should be modified (including the Petitioners' request to reduce the bank guarantee requirement to 10%).
  4. Whether the Petitioners have an absolute right to release of goods under Section 110(2) of the Customs Act (in light of prior authority Jayant Hansraj Shah).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • At the current stage no notice to show cause had been issued and adjudication was yet to take place.
  • Under Section 110A the release of seized goods pending adjudication is by bond with such security and conditions as the adjudicating authority may require; the object is not to cripple the importer.
  • The conditions imposed were argued to be excessively harsh. Since the bills of entry were assessed between 2005 and 2010 and the goods were cleared on payment of duty, the Petitioners contended the authority should have required only a bond for the differential duty (relying on Navshakti Industries and Vodafone Essar South Ltd.).
  • The Petitioners sought modification to permit bank guarantees from a nationalized bank and a reduction of the bank guarantee requirement from 20% to 10% of the enhanced CIF value.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The Respondents relied on the affidavit in reply detailing the investigation which disclosed substantial material indicating undervaluation, suppression of freight and other irregularities in relation to imports of numerous cranes.
  • The department proposed to issue a notice to show cause under Section 28 read with Section 124 given the material in the investigation.
  • On the basis of the revealed material, the Respondents submitted that the impugned provisional release order securing the interest of the Revenue (including requiring security) was not faultable.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Navshakti Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs, 2011 267 E.L.T 483 (Del) Accepted in that case that provisional release was ordered subject to payment of differential duty, execution of a bank guarantee (25% in that case) and a bond; the Delhi High Court in that factual context referred to Customs (Provisional Duty Assessment) Regulations, 1963 (Regulation 2) to frame the conditions. The Court distinguished Navshakti as fact-specific and declined to treat it as laying down a universal rule that provisional release under Section 110A must be allowed only against a bond. The Court held that Section 110A permits the adjudicating authority to require such security and conditions as it deems fit, and the Customs (Provisional Duty Assessment) Regulations operate in a different field (provisional assessment under Section 18), so they could not be mechanically applied to Section 110A cases.
Vodafone Essar South Ltd. v. Union of India, 2009 237 E.L.T 35 (Bom) In that Division Bench decision (concerning the same Petitioners) the court held that where bills of entry had been duly assessed and goods cleared in accordance with an order of the Commissioner (Appeals), the Customs authorities could not have seized the goods until such assessment was set aside. The Court noted Vodafone Essar but found the present facts different: the investigation disclosed material suggesting undervaluation and suppression, and therefore the requirement of security by the Commissioner could not be faulted in the circumstances of the present case.
Jayant Hansraj Shah v. Union of India, 2008 229 E.L.T 339 (Bom) Held that Section 110(2) operates only where no provisional order has been passed for release of seized goods and where no notice under Section 124(a) for confiscation is issued; i.e., Section 110(2) is not an absolute right to immediate return where provisional orders exist. The Petitioners did not assert an absolute right under Section 110(2) in view of this authority; the Court cited the principle to explain why Section 110(2) did not mandate release in the present circumstances.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds by reference to the statutory scheme and the material disclosed during the investigation. The reasoning as recorded in the opinion is as follows:

  1. Statutory framework:
    • Section 110(1) empowers seizure of goods believed to be liable to confiscation; Section 110(2) provides that if no notice under Section 124(a) is issued within six months of seizure, the goods shall be returned.
    • Section 110A permits release of goods seized under Section 110, pending adjudication, on taking a bond with such security and conditions as the adjudicating authority may require.
    • Section 17 deals with assessment of duty and Section 18 with provisional assessment; the Customs (Provisional Duty Assessment) Regulations, 1963 implement the provisional assessment regime under Section 18 and are therefore intended for a distinct situation.
    • Section 28 provides for recovery of duties not levied or short levied; cases involving undervaluation and suppression of freight would ordinarily be governed by Section 28 procedures.
  2. On the Petitioners' reliance on Navshakti: The Court found that Navshakti must be read in its factual context. Navshakti involved provisional assessment/regulation-based considerations and was not intended to create a universal rule limiting the adjudicating authority under Section 110A to require only a bond. The Court emphasized that it would be inappropriate to curtail the discretion given by Section 110A by importing the mechanics of the provisional assessment regulations, which operate in a different field (Section 18).
  3. Application to facts: The affidavit in reply disclosed substantial material from ongoing investigations — including alleged understatement of value, suppression of freight, admissions (some retracted), supplier records, shipping agent's letter evidencing payment of freight, and allegations of unofficial payments. Given this material and the likelihood of proceedings under Section 28 and Section 124, the Court held that the Commissioner’s requirement for security to protect Revenue's interest was not impermissible.
  4. Proportionality and modification: While upholding the power of the adjudicating authority to demand security and impose conditions under Section 110A, the Court sought to balance protection of Revenue with not unduly crippling the importer's business. On that basis, the Court modified the conditions of provisional release to require bank guarantees from a nationalized bank (with specified amounts and reductions to reflect amounts already paid/cleared) and maintained other undertaking requirements.
  5. Practical directions: The Court ordered specific substitutions and modifications to the conditions originally imposed on 15 February 2011 and upheld the remaining conditions, while permitting the bank guarantees to be furnished in relation to each clearance of cranes (one at a time) and directed that such bank guarantees be kept alive during pendency of adjudication.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition was disposed of. The Court upheld the Commissioner of Customs' power to impose security and conditions under Section 110A in the circumstances of this case but modified certain conditions to protect the Petitioners from unduly onerous measures while securing Revenue's interest. The precise modifications ordered are set out below.

Direct consequences ordered by the Court (as stated in the opinion):

  • Condition (1) in the communication dated 15 February 2011 (payment of differential duty of Rs. 1,32,17,036/- with interest Rs. 62,41,705/-) is substituted by a direction that the Petitioners shall furnish a bank guarantee of Rs. 1,32,17,036/-, after giving due credit for the amount of duty paid in respect of the two cranes already cleared against duty payment.
  • Condition (2) is modified: the Petitioners are required to furnish a bank guarantee representing 10% of the ascertained CIF value of Rs. 7,30,44,625/- (after giving due credit for the value of the two cranes already cleared).
  • The bank guarantees must be from a nationalized bank, be furnished to the satisfaction of the Commissioner of Customs (Import), be kept alive during the pendency of adjudication, and may be furnished against each clearance (per the 7 April 2011 letter permitting one-at-a-time clearance).
  • The Petitioners shall furnish a bond for the amount of interest and for the balance representing 10% of the ascertained CIF value.
  • Conditions (3), (4) and (5) originally set out in the 15 February 2011 order (bond for CIF value, undertaking to produce cranes for inspection, undertaking not to dispose without intimation) are maintained.

Broader implications addressed by the Court (as expressly stated in the opinion):

  • The Court clarified that the Delhi High Court's decision in Navshakti Industries is fact-specific and does not establish a universal rule limiting Section 110A to release only against a bond. Section 110A confers discretion on the adjudicating authority to demand security and impose conditions as appropriate to the circumstances.
  • The order is tailored to the facts and evidence produced in this investigation; the Court did not purport to lay down a general rule beyond distinguishing the cited precedents.

Disposition: The Petition is accordingly disposed of in the terms indicated above.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Apollo Cranes Pvt. Ltd. And Another Petitioners v. Union Of India And Others S

    ORAL JUDGMENT (PER DR. D.Y CHANDRACHUD, J.) :

    1. Rule, by consent returnable forthwith. With the consent of Counsel and at their request the Petition is taken up for hearing and final disposal.

    2. The Petitioners question in these proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution, the legality of orders passed by the Commissioner of Customs (Import) on 15 February 2011 and 7 April 2011 granting provisional release of goods seized under Section 110 of the Customs Act 1962 subject to the following conditions :

    1. “Payment of differential duty of Rs. 1,32,17,036/- in full along with the interest thereon amounting to Rs. 62,41,705/- (calculated till 28.02.2011).

    2. Furnishing of Bank Guarantee for 20% of the ascertained CIF value i.e Rs. 7,30,44,625/-.

    3. Furnishing of a bond for the ascertained CIF value i.e Rs. 7,30,44,625/-.

    4. Legal undertaking to produce the crane in question for inspection, whenever required till adjudication of the case, and

    5. Legal undertaking not to dispose of the crane without prior intimation to the department.”

    3. The Petitioners imported nine cranes between 17 November 2005 and 6 April 2010 in respect of which bills of entry were lodged and which were assessed. On 10 November 2010 the cranes were seized by the Customs authorities. On 15 February 2011 an order for the provisional release of the goods was passed under Section 110A permitting clearance subject to (i) payment of differential duty - together with interest; (ii) the furnishing of a bank guarantee representing 20% of the ascertained CIF value; (iii) the furnishing of a bond; and (iv) an undertaking to produce the cranes for inspection and not to dispose of the cranes without prior intimation. On 21 March 2011 the Petitioners addressed letters to the Commissioner of Customs stating that two cranes had already been released on the payment of differential duty. However, the Petitioners stated that they were ready to secure the revenue by furnishing bank guarantees of a nationalized bank and hence, the direction for making a deposit be modified accordingly. The Petitioners also stated that the direction to furnish a bank guarantee representing 20% of the enhanced value may be reduced to an amount representing 10% of the enhanced CIF value. By a letter dated 7 April 2011 the Deputy Commissioner of Customs has granted the request made by the Petitioners for clearance of the seized cranes one at a time, as sought.

    4. An affidavit in reply has been filed in these proceedings in which it has been submitted that in the present case the investigations are in progress involving the import of 90 cranes by the Petitioners from October 2005 involving a duty evasion of approximately Rs. 10.82 Crores. The affidavit sets out that the investigations have thus far revealed that the Petitioners had suppressed the freight component which forms part of the CIF value for determining duty liability and there was an undervaluation in the declared price of the cranes. The case of the Respondents is that this was admitted in a statement made by the Managing Director of the Petitioner which was subsequently retracted. However, the statements of the Customs House Agent handling the clearance of cargo are to the effect that the value of the cranes has been understated. Similarly the statements of the buyers of the cranes imported by the Petitioners have admitted to payments having been made in cash over and above the invoice value. In respect of 11 cranes imported by the Petitioners, the private records of one of the suppliers indicated that the price declared to the Customs authorities was 1/3rd of the actual price. A letter of the Shipping Agent is stated to have admitted receipt of U.S $ 542,184 towards freight, though the invoices indicated the price as CIF and the bill of lading had an endorsement of freight pre-paid. The affidavit also states that there has been an admission by the Petitioners about payments of the differential amounts of the value of the cranes as also freight to overseas parties through unofficial channels.

    5. On behalf of the Petitioners, it has been submitted that at the present stage, even a notice to show cause has not been issued and an adjudication is to take place. Section 110A contemplates the release of the goods seized pending an order of the adjudicating authority on the owner furnishing a bond, with such security and conditions as the adjudicating authority may require. Learned counsel submitted that the object of an order for provisional release of goods seized cannot be to cripple the business of the importer. Hence, it was submitted that the conditions which are imposed are extremely harsh. Moreover, it was urged that in the present case the bills of entry were duly assessed between 2005 and 2010 and clearance was granted against the payment of duty. Hence, it was urged that the authority ought to have only required the Petitioners to furnish a bond for the differential duty, particularly having regard to the judgment of the Delhi High Court in Navshakti Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs 2011 267 E.L.T 483 Del. and of a Division Bench of this Court in Vodafone Essar South Ltd. v. Union of India 2009 237 E.L.T 35 Bom. On the other hand, Counsel appearing on behalf of the Respondents has extensively relied on the affidavit in reply which has been filed. Learned counsel submitted that in the present case the department would be issuing a notice to show cause under Section 28 of the Customs Act 1962 read with Section 124. Having regard to the material which has been revealed during the course of the investigation, the impugned order which secures the interest of the Revenue cannot, it was urged, be faulted.

    6. Sub section (1) of Section 110 empowers the proper officer to seize goods which he has reason to believe are liable to confiscation under the provisions of the Act. sub section (2) of Section 110 postulates that where any goods are seized under sub section (1) and no notice in respect thereof is given under clause (a) of Section 124 within six months of the seizure of the goods, the goods shall be returned to the person from whose possession they were seized. The Petitioners have not asserted an absolute right for the release of the goods under sub section (2) of Section 110 in view of the judgment of the Division Bench in Jayant Hansraj Shah v. Union of India 2008 229 E.L.T 339 Bom. The Division Bench has held that it is only in a case where no provisional order has been passed for the release of seized goods and if no notice is issued under Section 124(a) for confiscation that Section 110(2) would come into operation. Be that as it may, Section 110A provides that any goods seized under Section 110 may, pending an order of the adjudicating authority, be released to the owner on taking a bond from him in the proper form with such security and conditions as the adjudicating authority may require. The object of Section 110A is to protect the interests of the Revenue while at the same time allowing provisional release of goods pending the decision of the adjudicating authority.

    7. The submission of the Petitioners, which relies on the judgment of the Delhi High Court in Navshakti Industries that the goods should be provisionally released in the present case only against the furnishing of a bond cannot be accepted. It cannot be asserted as a universal rule that there is any entitlement on the part of an importer to seek provisional release only against a bond. The plain terms of Section 110A contemplate the taking of a bond from the importer with such security and conditions as the adjudicating authority may require. In Navshakti Industries, the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court dealt with a case where certain goods were seized on the ground that they were being diverted for purposes other than newsprint. The importer was directed to pay the differential duty and to execute a bank guarantee representing 25% of the seizure value together with a bond. The Delhi High Court noted that no specific guidelines are available in regard to the exercise of the power under Section 110A. In the facts of that case, the High Court adverted to the provisions of Regulation 2 of the Customs (Provisional Duty Assessment) Regulations 1963. Regulation 2 dealt with a situation where on account of any of the grounds specified in sub section (1) of Section 18 the proper officer is not able to make a final assessment of duty. In that case, the officer is required to make an estimate of the duty most likely to be levied. If the importer or the exporter executes a bond in an amount equivalent to the difference between the duty that may be finally assessed and the provisional duty and deposits with the proper officer such sum not exceeding 20% of the provisional duty as the officer may direct, the Regulation permits the officer to assess the duty on the goods provisionally at an amount equivalent to the provisional duty.

    8. We find merit in the submission which has been urged on behalf of the Respondents that the judgment of the Delhi High Court must be read in the context of the facts as they appear in that case and cannot be regarded as laying down a principle of universal application. Section 17 of the Act provides for assessment of duty, while Section 18 makes provisions for a provisional assessment of duty. A provisional assessment of duty is contemplated (a) where the importer or exporter is unable to make a self assessment and makes a request in writing to the proper officer for assessment; or (b) where the proper officer deems it necessary to subject any imported or exported goods to a chemical or other test; or (c) where the importer or exporter has furnished full information or documents but the proper officer deems it fit to make a further enquiry; or (d) where necessary documents have not been produced or information has not been furnished and the proper officer deems it necessary to make further enquiry. The Customs (Provisional Duty Assessment) Regulations 1963 are intended to effectuate the power to make a provisional assessment under Section 18. Cases such as the present on the other hand would be governed by Section 28 where a provision has been made for the recovery of duties which have not been levied or which have been short levied or erroneously refunded. Section 110 provides for the seizure of goods. Section 110A provides for the provisional release of the goods pending an adjudication by the adjudicating authority. The effect of Section 110A is to confer jurisdiction upon the adjudicating authority to permit the release of goods, pending an adjudication subject to the owner of the goods furnishing a bond together with such security and conditions as the authority may deem fit to impose. In our view, it would not be either appropriate or proper to restrict or curtail the power of the adjudicating authority to demand security or to impose conditions by confining the exercise of that power along the lines of the conditions imposed in the Customs (Provisional Duty Assessment) Regulations 1963. Those Regulations operate in a different field.

    9. In the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in Vodafone Essar there was an order of the Commissioner (Appeals) in the case of the very Petitioners in regard to the classification of the goods. The bills of entry filed by the Petitioners were duly assessed and the goods were cleared on the payment of duty. In this background, the Division Bench held that till the assessment was set aside, the Customs authorities could not have seized the goods assessed particularly when the goods were assessed in accordance with the order passed by the Commissioner (Appeals).

    10. In the present case, the affidavit in reply contains a detailed disclosure of the material which is made available during the course of investigation. Undoubtedly, a notice to show cause is still to be issued to the Petitioners and an adjudication is to take place. At the same time, having regard to the material which has been disclosed during the course of the investigation, the order of the Commissioner of Customs (Import) requiring the Petitioners to furnish security cannot be faulted insofar as the requirement of security is concerned. At the same time, we are of the view that while it would be necessary to protect the interest of the Revenue, this object could be subserved by directing the Petitioners to furnish a bank guarantee of a nationalized bank. Accordingly, we direct that Condition (1) in the communication dated 15 February 2011 shall stand substituted by a direction that the Petitioner shall furnish a bank guarantee of Rs. 1,32,17,036/- after giving due credit for the amount of duty paid in respect of the two cranes which have already been cleared against the payment of duty. Condition (2) shall stand modified by requiring the Petitioners to furnish a bank guarantee representing 10% of the ascertained CIF value of Rs. 7,30,44,625/- after giving due credit in respect of the value of two cranes of which clearance has already been granted. In terms of the letter issued by the Deputy Commissioner of Customs on 7 April 2011 the Petitioners have been permitted to clear the seized cranes one at a time. The aforesaid bank guarantees shall be of a nationalized bank and shall be furnished to the satisfaction of the Commissioner of Customs (Import) and shall be kept alive during the pendency of the adjudication proceedings. The bank guarantees would consequently be permitted to be furnished against each clearance to be made by the Petitioners. The Petitioners shall furnish a bond for the amount of interest and for the balance representing 10% of the ascertained CIF value. Conditions (3), (4) and (5) set out in the order dated 15 February 2011 are maintained.

    The Petition is accordingly disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Apollo Cranes Pvt. Ltd. And Another Petitioners v. Union Of India And Others S
    (Jul 25, 2011)