Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of section 75 and Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XXVI, Rule 9, Civil Procedure Code.9.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of section 75 and Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XXVI, Rule 9, Civil Procedure Code.9.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner-plaintiff filed Regular Civil Suit No. 513 of 2007 seeking declaration and restoration of possession after removing the respondent-defendant's encroachment on the suit land. The plaintiff claimed ancestral ownership of the land identified as City Survey No. 1894 and alleged that the defendant was residing in a room on this land without returning it despite assurances. The defendant denied the plaintiff's ownership, contending that lands bearing Survey Nos. 315B and 317B/1 were allotted to his ancestors from the Vaidu Nomadic Tribe and that the house he occupied was registered as City Survey No. 1895. The defendant filed a counter-claim asserting possession and ownership of the disputed property and sought injunction against interference.

During the suit, both parties filed applications for temporary injunctions; the plaintiff's was rejected while the defendant's was allowed. Appeals against these orders were dismissed, and a writ petition filed by the petitioner was disposed of. Subsequently, the petitioner filed an application for appointment of the City Survey Officer as Court Commissioner to assist in determining the correct survey number of the construction, which was rejected by the trial court. The petitioner challenged this rejection by filing the present petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appointment of a Court Commissioner (specifically the City Survey Officer) under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure is appropriate for determining the actual position of the disputed construction on City Survey Nos. 1894 or 1895.
  2. Whether the trial court erred in rejecting the application for appointment of a Court Commissioner to aid in demarcation and investigation of the disputed land.
  3. The applicability and correct interpretation of section 75 and Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure in the context of disputed land encroachment cases.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The key issue is whether the respondent’s construction is on City Survey No. 1894 or 1895.
  • The appointment of the Taluka Inspector of Land Records as Court Commissioner was necessary to facilitate a factual determination of the dispute.
  • The petitioner relied on various precedents emphasizing the necessity of a Court Commissioner in encroachment and demarcation disputes.
  • The petitioner contended that previous judgments, including one by Khanwilkar, J., and the petitioner’s own prior case, were per incurium for not properly considering section 75 and Order XXVI, Rule 9 CPC and the Apex Court’s ruling in Haryana Waqf Board v. Shanti Sarup.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The learned trial Judge correctly rejected the application as it was aimed at collecting evidence in support of the plaintiff’s case, which did not warrant interference.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Haryana Waqf Board v. Shanti Sarup, (2008) 8 SCC 671 Appointment of Local Commissioner under Order XXVI, Rule 9 CPC for demarcation of disputed land The Apex Court held that in land demarcation disputes, appointing a Local Commissioner is appropriate; the High Court erred in dismissing the application summarily. This precedent was pivotal in allowing the petitioner’s application.
Tajmulhussain Mulla Mumtaz Hussain v. Satish Bhanudas Chavan, 1994 (1) Mh.L.J 664 Necessity of expert assistance in boundary disputes involving alleged encroachment Reinforced the principle that courts require expert assistance (such as a Commissioner) to decide boundary disputes effectively, supporting the petitioner’s request.
Ushabai w/o Sharadchandra Bannore v. Wasudeo s/o Baliramji Mehare, 2003 Mh.L.J 594 Requirement of accurate maps and appointment of Commissioner to prepare agreed maps in encroachment disputes Supported the need for a Court Commissioner to prepare reliable maps to avoid meaningless decrees and repeated litigation.
Ramchandra Bhikaji Jagtap v. Dudharam Langniji Padvekar, 2004 (1) Mh.L.J 278 Related to procedural aspects of land disputes and measurements Referenced as part of jurisprudence supporting appointment of Commissioners in land disputes.
Kashinath Ramkrishna Chopade v. Purushottam Tulshiram Tekade, 2005 (4) Mh.L.J 471 Essentiality of appointing City Surveyor for joint measurement under Order XXVI, Rule 9 CPC Emphasized that appointment of City Surveyor or Cadastral Surveyor is absolutely necessary for just decision in encroachment cases; this principle was adopted by the Court.
Yeshwant Bhaduji Ghuse v. Vithobaji Laxman Ladekar, 2010 (3) Mh.L.J 956 Reliance on prior judgments for appointment of Commissioner and accuracy of maps Used to bolster the argument for the necessity of a Court Commissioner in land disputes, despite not citing the Apex Court judgment.
Vij Kamagar Sahakari Patsanstha Ltd. v. Ramkrushna Dhondiram Thorat, 2009 (1) Bom.C.R 880 Related to procedural and evidentiary aspects in civil disputes Referenced in support of procedural correctness and appointment of Commissioners.
Sanjay s/o Namdeo Khandare v. Sahebrao s/o Kachru Khandare, 2001 (2) Mh.L.J 959 Appointment of Commissioner not permissible for collecting evidence of actual possession The Court distinguished this precedent, holding that the Commissioner appointment in the present case was for demarcation, not mere evidence collection, thus not applicable here.
Pandurang Nandlal Chandak v. Sandip Mukundrao Pensalwar, 2009 (2) Mh.L.J 487 Appointment of Commissioner under Order XXVI, Rule 9 CPC The Court held this precedent as per incurium for not considering the Apex Court’s ruling in Haryana Waqf Board and relevant provisions of CPC, thus not binding.
Girish Vasantrao Bhoyar v. Nimbaji Warluji Bambal, 2009 (4) Mh.L.J 371 Desirability of measurement in encroachment disputes Supported the proposition that measurement by a Court Commissioner is desirable to determine encroachment, aiding the Court’s decision.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court recognized the core dispute as the precise location of the respondent’s construction—whether it stands on City Survey No. 1894 (claimed by the petitioner) or No. 1895 (claimed by the respondent). The Court noted that although ancillary title issues existed, the parties did not contest each other’s entitlement to the respective survey numbers.

The Court examined the applicability of Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which permits appointment of a Local Commissioner for local investigation in disputes involving land demarcation. The Apex Court’s decision in Haryana Waqf Board v. Shanti Sarup was pivotal, establishing that in cases of disputed land boundaries, appointing a Local Commissioner to investigate and demarcate the land is appropriate and assists the Court in reaching a just conclusion.

The Court reviewed various High Court precedents that consistently held the appointment of a Court Commissioner (often a City Survey Officer or Cadastral Surveyor) is necessary and beneficial in encroachment disputes to prepare accurate maps and measurements. It further observed that such appointment does not prejudice either party, as aggrieved parties may cross-examine the Commissioner and challenge the report.

The Court distinguished the precedent where appointment was refused because the Commissioner’s role was limited to evidence collection of possession, which differs from the present case focused on demarcation and measurement.

Given the objections by respondents to independent measurement and the centrality of the demarcation issue, the Court concluded that appointment of a Court Commissioner would assist in ascertaining the facts and facilitate a just decision.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the writ petition, quashing and setting aside the impugned order dated 7th July 2009 that rejected the application for appointment of the Court Commissioner. The application for appointment of the City Survey Officer as Court Commissioner in Regular Civil Suit No. 513 of 2007 was allowed.

The direct effect is that the Court Commissioner will be appointed to conduct local investigation and measurement of the disputed land, aiding the trial court in resolving the encroachment dispute. The Court emphasized that the Commissioner’s report is not conclusive and parties retain the right to cross-examine and challenge it.

No new precedent was established beyond affirming the applicability of existing legal principles as laid down by the Apex Court and High Court judgments regarding the appointment of Commissioners in land demarcation disputes.

There was no order as to costs in the matter.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Kolhapuri Bandu Lakade v. Yallappa Chinappa Lakade, Since Deceased Through. Pooja Poojariy, Lakade And Others

    1. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard by consent.

    2. The petitioner challenges the order dated 7th July, 2009 passed by the learned 8th Joint Civil Judge, Senior Division, Pune below Exhibit 35 in Regular Civil Suit No. 513 of 2007, thereby rejecting the application filed by the present petitioner for appointment of Court Commissioner.

    3. The facts in brief giving rise to the present Petition are as under:

    The petitioner-plaintiff has filed the Suit, being Regular Civil Suit No. 513 of 2007, for declaration and restoration of possession after removing the encroachment of the respondent-defendant. The plaintiff in the plaint has contended that the suit land is owned by the plaintiff from the period of his ancestors; that the said land has been given City Survey No. 1894; that the plaintiff has constructed two rooms on the said land and the room admeasuring 20 ft. × 10 ft. on the northern side was given to the respondent-defendant for residing therein for certain time without any consideration. It is contended that though the defendant had assured the plaintiff that after making alternate arrangement he will return the said room, he was refusing to do so for last 10 to 12 years. In this premise, the plaintiff has prayed for the reliefs as claimed hereinabove. The Suit of the plaintiff is resisted by the defendant. It has been contended by the defendant that the lands bearing Survey No. 315B and Survey No. 317B/1 were given by the British Government in the year 1911 to the persons belonging to Vaidu Nomadic Tribe. It was contended that for the sake of convenience, the land was given in the name of ancestors Shankar Laxman Pawar and as such the name of said Shankar Laxman Pawar and his brothers and sisters were recorded in the 7/12 Extract. The contention of the plaintiff, that he was the owner of the land was denied by the defendant. It is the contention of the defendant that the house in which he is residing has been owned by him since the period of his ancestors. It is the contention of the defendant that in the records, the said house has been registered as City Survey No. 1895. The defendant has also filed a counter-claim for a declaration that the property, as stated in the counter-claim, was the property in possession of the defendant, from the period of his ancestors. A declaration was prayed in the counter-claim that the plaintiff had no relation with the house on which the defendant was residing and further for an injunction restraining the plaintiff from disturbing the peaceful possession of the defendant.

    4. During the pendency of the Suit, two applications came to be filed for temporary injunction; one by the plaintiff and the other by the original defendant. The application of the plaintiff was rejected and that of the defendant was allowed. Being aggrieved thereby, an Appeal was carried before the learned District Judge. The same was also dismissed. Being aggrieved thereby, the petitioner approached this Court by way of Writ Petition No. 1440 of 2009. The said Petition was disposed of by the order dated 6th March, 2009. Thereafter, the application below Exhibit 35 in Regular Civil Suit No. 513 of 2007 came to be filed for appointment of the City Survey Officer, Pune as “Court Commissioner”. The same was rejected and hence the present Petition.

    5. Mr. Godbole, the learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner, submits that the issue involved in the present Petition is as to whether the construction of the respondent-defendant is on City Survey No. 1894 or City Survey No. 1895. The appointment of the Taluka Inspector of Land Records as a “Court Commissioner” was necessary inasmuch as the report of the said Commissioner would facilitate the Court for finding out an actual position. Mr. Godbole submitted that the issue involved in the present Petition is the issue involved in various matters and, therefore, has taken me through various pronouncements on the issue. The learned Counsel has relied on the judgments of the learned Single Judges of this Court, namely, by M.S Vaidya, J., in the case of Tajmulhussain Mulla Mumtaz Hussain…Applicant; v. Satish Bhanudas Chavan…., reported in 1994 (1) Mh.L.J 664 : 1994 (3) Bom.C.R 317, various judgments delivered by S.T Kharche, J., in the cases of Ushabai w/o Sharadchandra Bannore v. Wasudeo s/o Baliramji Mehare, reported in 2003 Mh.L.J, 594, Ramchandra Bhikaji Jagtap v. Dudharam Langniji Padvekar, Dead, Thru L.Rs, reported in 2004 (1) Mh.L.J 278 : 2003 B.C.I 659, and Kashinath Ramkrishna Chopade v. Purushottam Tulshiram Tekade, reported in 2005 (4) Mh.L.J 471 : 2005 (6) Bom.C.R XXVI 7, by A.P Bhangale, J., in the case of Yeshwant Bhaduji Ghuse… v. Vithobaji Laxman Ladekar…., reported in 2010 (3) Mh.L.J 956, by S.B Deshmukh, J., in the case of Vij Kamagar Sahakari Patsanstha Ltd. v. Ramkrushna Dhondiram Thorat, reported in 2009 (1) Bom.C.R 880, and the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Haryana Waqf Board v. Shanti Sarup, reported in (2008) 8 SCC 671.

    6. The learned Counsel further submitted that the view taken by the learned Single Judge of this Court, namely, Khanwilkar, J., in the case of Sanjay s/o Namdeo Khandare v. Sahebrao s/o Kachru Khandare, reported in 2001 (2) Mh.L.J 959 : 2001 (1) Bom.C.R 800, is per incurium since it does not take into consideration the provisions of section 75 and Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure in correct perspective. He further submits that the view taken by me in the case of Pandurang Nandlal Chandak v. Sandip Mukundrao Pensalwar, reported in 2009 (2) Mh.L.J 487, is also per incurium, inasmuch as the same does not take into consideration the provisions of section 75 and Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure in correct perspective and also does not notice the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Haryana Waqf Board cited supra, which is prior to the decision in Pandurang's case, cited supra.

    7. As against this, Mr. Rahul Kashid, the learned Counsel appearing for the respondents, on the contrary submits that the learned trial Judge has rightly rejected the application, inasmuch as it was in the nature of collecting evidence in support of the case of the plaintiff and, therefore, no interference could be warranted.

    8. Though various judgments of various learned Single Judges of this Court including my judgment have been pointed out by Mr. Godbole. I do not think that a reference to those judgments would be necessary in view of the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Haryana Waqf Board cited supra. In the said case a Suit was filed by the Punjab Waqf Board for declaration and injunction. The suit of the plaintiff claiming that the defendants had encroached in suit property was dismissed by the trial Court on the ground that the Board had failed to prove that the respondents have encroached upon the land belonging to the said Board. The Appeal preferred there against was dismissed by the Appellate Court. The Second Appeal filed before the High Court was dismissed summarily on the ground that the Second Appeal stood concluded by the concurrent findings of facts. In this background, the Apex Court observed thus:

    “3. The dispute that was raised by the parties before the Court was whether the respondent had encroached upon any land belonging to the appellant Board. Therefore, it cannot be in dispute that the dispute was in respect of the encroachment of the suit land.

    4. Admittedly, in this case, an application was filed under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure which was rejected by the trial Court but in view of the fact that it was a case of demarcation of the disputed land, it was appropriate for the Court to direct the investigation by appointing a Local Commissioner under Order XXVI, Rule 9, Civil Procedure Code.”

    9. Observing as aforesaid, the Apex Court set aside the judgment and order of the High Court and while setting aside the same, the Apex Court observed that the High Court ought to have considered whether in view of the nature of dispute, the Local Commissioner should be appointed for the purpose of demarcation in respect of suit land. As such the matter was remitted back to the High Court for deciding it in the light of the observations made by the Apex Court.

    10. The learned Single Judge of this Court, F.M Reis, J., in the case of Girish Vasantrao Bhoyar v. Nimbaji Warluji Bambal, reported in 2009 (4) Mh.L.J 371, has held that in order to determine whether there is an encroachment, it is always desirable to get the measurements of the land encroached upon. Another learned Single Judge of this Court, A.P Bhangale, J., in the case of Yeshwant Bhaduji Ghuse… v. Vithobaji Laxman Ladekar…., reported in 2010 (3) Mh.L.J 956, though has not noticed the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Haryana Waqf Board cited supra, but relying on the earlier judgment of this Court delivered by S.T Kharche, J., in the case of Ushabai w/o Sharadchandra Bannore cited supra, has observed thus:

    “8. In Ushabai Sharadchandra v. Wasudeo, reported in 2004 (2) Mh.L.J 594, this Court has held that the maps or plans made for the purpose of any cause must be proved to be accurate. The onus of proving that such a map is accurate lies on the party who produces it. The maps must be proved by the person who has prepared them. In case of dispute of an encroachment or dimension of a site, the first essential is to get an agreed map and if the parties cannot agree on one, a Commissioner must be appointed to prepare the same. In the absence of such a map, the decree is probably meaningless and execution means virtually starting the case overall again.”

    11. Even prior to the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Haryana Waqf Board cited supra, the learned Single Judge of this Court, M.S Vaidya, J., in the case of Tajmulhussain cited supra has observed thus:

    “9 ………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

    In a suit, in which the cause of action is founded on the alleged encroachment of a particular land and in which the determination of the boundary line between the two adjoining properties is the only issue, the Court could hardly decide such a matter on its own without any dependable expert assistance.”

    12. The learned Single Judge has further observed that:

    “10. It may be noted here that making of such an order for appointment of the Commissioner would not have prejudiced the interest of either of the parties, because it was only in that eventuality, that it was possible for the Court to arrive at a proper conclusion. If at all any party was aggrieved by the report given by the Commissioner so appointed by the Court, an opportunity would have become available to that party to cross-examine the Commissioner and to point out how his conclusions were not correct. The party, who was not aggrieved could also prove how his conclusions were correct.”

    13. Another learned Single Judge of this Court, namely, S.T Kharche, J., in the case of Kashinath Ramkrishna Chopade cited supra has observed thus;

    “13. In view of the aforesaid legal position, it appears to be absolutely necessary that the City Surveyor ought to have been appointed when the question arises as to whether any encroachment has been made or not. The appointment of City Surveyor or Cadastral Surveyor for taking joint measurement of the property owned by the plaintiff and defendant for the purpose of local investigation under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure not only become relevant but appears to be absolutely essential for the just decision of the case.”

    14. It can thus clearly be seen that the Apex Court in the case of Haryana Waqf Board cited supra in unequivocal terms has held that in the case of demarcation of disputed lands, it is appropriate for the Court to direct the investigation by appointing a Local Commissioner as provided under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The other learned Judges of this Court, namely, M.S Vaidya, J., S.T Kharche, J., A.P Bhangale, J., F.M Reis, J., have also held that in case of dispute of encroachment of a site, an appointment of Court Commissioner who could be City Survey Officer or Cadastral Surveyor for taking joint measurement of the property owned by the plaintiff and defendant for the purpose of local investigation under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure would be necessary for the just decision of the case. It has also been held by this Court that merely because a Court Commissioner is appointed, it will not prejudice the interest of either of the parties. It has been held that if any of the parties is aggrieved by the report of the Court Commissioner, an opportunity would be available to that party to cross examine the Court Commissioner and to point out as to how his conclusions were not correct. It has further been observed that the party who was not aggrieved would also prove how his conclusions are correct.

    15. Insofar as judgment delivered by the learned Single Judge of this Court, namely, Khanwilkar, J., in the case of Sanjay Namdeo Khandare cited supra is concerned, in the said matter the appointment of the Commissioner, who was sought to be appointed, was for the purpose of finding out as to who was in actual possession of the suit land. In that view of the matter, it appears that the learned Judge has held that the Court Commissioner cannot be appointed for collecting the evidence.

    16. Insofar as my judgment in the case of Pandurang Nandlal Chandak cited supra is concerned, it is clear from the said judgment that the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Haryana Waqf Board cited supra was not brought to my notice, nor was it noticed by me while delivering the said judgment. It can further be seen that the judgment of the learned Single Judge of this Court, namely, M.S Vaidya, J., in the case of Tajmulhussain cited supra was also not noticed by me. In any case, now in view of the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Haryana Waqf Board cited supra, the view taken by me in the case of Pandurang Nandlal Chandak cited supra will have to be held as per incurium.

    17. Insofar as the facts in the present case are concerned, undisputedly, one of the main areas of dispute between the parties is as to whether the construction is on City Survey No. 1894 or City Survey No. 1895. It is the contention of the petitioner that the construction is on City Survey No. 1894, whereas it is the contention of the original defendant that it is on City Survey No. 1895, which according to him is in his possession from the period of his ancestors. No doubt that there are other ancillary issues regarding the title of the property also. However, insofar as claim of the plaintiff regarding the entitlement of defendant to City Survey No. 1895 is concerned, the same is not contested by the plaintiff. At the same time, insofar as the entitlement of the plaintiff to City Survey No. 1894 is concerned, the same is not contested by the defendants.

    18. One more fact that needs to be taken into consideration is that though the petitioner had applied for getting the measurement done through the City Survey Officer, the same could (sic: not) be done as the defendants-respondents had objected to the measurement being carried out by the City Survey Officer on the ground of pendency of the Regular Civil Suit No. 513 of 2007 between the parties.

    19. In that view of the matter, to find out as to whether the defendants have, in fact, encroached upon the City Survey No. 1894 or not, I find that the appointment of Court Commissioner would assist the Court in arriving at the just decision. Needless to state that, as has been consistently observed, the report of the Court Commissioner would not be conclusive and if any of the parties are aggrieved by the same, such a party would always be entitled to cross-examine the Court Commissioner, so as to challenge the veracity of the report.

    20. In that view of the matter, the Writ Petition succeeds. The impugned order dated 7th July, 2009 passed by the learned 8th Joint Civil Judge, Senior Division, Pune below Exhibit 35 in Regular Civil Suit No. 513 of 2007 is quashed and set aside. The application filed by the petitioner-plaintiff below Exhibit 35 in Regular Civil Suit No. 513 of 2007 for appointment of City Survey Officer as “Court Commissioner” is allowed.

    21. In the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.

    Petition allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kolhapuri Bandu Lakade v. Yallappa Chinappa La...
    (Mar 14, 2011)