Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, landlord, filed a suit for possession under the Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 on four grounds: (i) respondents were not using the premises for residence, (ii) respondents had not paid rent since 1 April 2004, (iii) petitioner required the premises for bona fide demolition and reconstruction, and (iv) respondents were using the premises to run an eating house. The original plaint lacked detailed allegations about the bona fide requirement for demolition and reconstruction. The petitioner applied to amend the plaint to add that he had obtained plans from an architect and would offer new premises in the reconstructed building. The 5th Joint Civil Judge, Junior Division, Solapur rejected the amendment application in a laconic order stating that the "Amendment sought will change the nature of the suit." The petitioner filed the present writ petition challenging that rejection. Counsel for the parties stated that issues had been framed but recording of evidence had not commenced and no affidavits in lieu of examination-in-chief had been filed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, for the purpose of the proviso to Order 6, Rule 17 CPC, the "trial" commences on framing of issues or on the filing of an affidavit in lieu of examination-in-chief (i.e., commencement of recording of evidence).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The proposed amendment only supplied details elaborating the pleaded bona fide requirement for demolition and reconstruction and an offer of new premises; it did not introduce a new ground or change the nature of the suit.
  • The trial had not commenced because, although issues were framed, recording of evidence had not begun and no affidavits in lieu of examination-in-chief had been filed.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The trial had commenced on framing of issues; therefore the proviso to Order 6, Rule 17 CPC barred the amendment after commencement of trial.
  • Reliance was placed on Vidyabai v. Padmalatha (2009 (4) Mh.L.J (SC) 30 : (2009) 2 SCC 409 : AIR 2009 SC 1433) to support the proposition that framing of issues marks commencement of trial.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vidyabai v. Padmalatha, 2009 (4) Mh.L.J (SC) 30 : (2009) 2 SCC 409 : AIR 2009 SC 1433 Submitted to support the proposition that the trial commences on the date issues are framed (the "date of first hearing"). The court read the judgment in context and held that it was misread by respondents; the Supreme Court's statement that "the date on which the issues are framed is the date of first hearing" must be read with the subsequent sentence that filing of an affidavit in lieu of examination-in-chief would amount to commencement of proceeding. The court concluded that trial commences when an affidavit in lieu of examination-in-chief is filed, not merely on framing of issues.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The trial court's order rejecting the amendment was laconic and the High Court found the trial judge had not applied his mind. The High Court observed that the proposed amendment merely elaborated the already-pleaded ground of bona fide requirement for demolition and reconstruction and included an offer to provide alternate premises; such elaboration did not change the nature of the suit.

The court analyzed the proviso to Order 6, Rule 17 CPC, which bars amendments after commencement of trial unless the court concludes that despite due diligence the matter could not have been raised earlier. The key question was whether "trial" commences on framing of issues or upon filing of an affidavit in lieu of examination-in-chief.

The court examined Vidyabai v. Padmalatha and held that a sentence in a judgment must be read in context rather than in isolation. Although Vidyabai stated that "the date on which the issues are framed is the date of first hearing," the subsequent sentence in Vidyabai equated filing of an affidavit in lieu of examination-in-chief with commencement of proceeding. Therefore, the High Court concluded that framing of issues is the first date of hearing but the actual trial—so far as commencement for the proviso—occurs when a party files an affidavit in lieu of examination-in-chief. Because no affidavit had been filed and recording of evidence had not commenced, the proviso to Order 6, Rule 17 CPC did not bar the amendment.

Holding and Implications

Writ petition allowed; the order rejecting the amendment is set aside.

Direct effect: The petitioner is permitted to carry out the amendment of the plaint and must do so within four weeks of the writ being received by the trial Court. The opinion did not discuss broader implications beyond the direct effect on the parties.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Ajit Narsinha Talekar v. Nirmala Wamanrao Kekade And Others

    1. Rule, returnable forthwith.

    2. Mr. Kumbhakoni appears for respondent Nos. 1 to 3 and waives service.

    3. By consent taken up for hearing.

    4. By this petition, the petitioner challenges the order dated 7 August, 2009 passed by the 5th Joint Civil Judge, Junior Division, Solapur rejecting the application made by the petitioner (original plaintiff) for amendment of the plaint.

    5. The petitioner (landlord) filed a suit for possession against the respondents under the provisions of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999, inter alia, on four grounds, viz. (i) the respondents were not using the suit premises for residence, (ii) the respondents had not paid the rent from 1 April, 2004 and they were defaulters, (iii) the petitioner wanted to demolish the existing building and construct a new building thereon and as such the petitioner required the suit premises bona fide for the purpose of demolition and reconstruction, and (iv) the suit premises were given on rent for residence and the respondents were using the premises for carrying on business of running an eating house

    6. In the plaint, the petitioner had not given all the requisite details about his bona fide requirement regarding demolition and construction of a new building. He, therefore, filed an application for amendment of the plaint to incorporate the details. By the proposed amendment, he sought to plead that he had got the plans of new construction prepared from an architect. He also proposed to plead that the petitioner would offer new premises in the reconstructed building to the respondent. The application was rejected by the trial Court. Aggrieved petitioner is before this Court.

    7. The order of rejection of application is very laconic and is quoted below in verbatim.

    “Read the application and say. Heard the counsel of plaintiff. Amendment sought will change the nature of the suit. Hence application is rejected.”

    To say the least, the learned Judge does not appear to have applied his mind to the application for amendment. The petitioner had already pleaded in the original plaint that he required the suit premises for the purpose of demolition and erection of a new building thereon. All that he wanted to plead by way of an amendment was to give details about that requirement and make an offer that he was willing to offer to the respondents new premises in the reconstructed building. The details were only elaboration of the ground and cannot be said to be a new ground so as to change the nature of the suit. Consequently, the order is required to be set aside.

    8. Learned counsel for the respondents, however, submitted that the trial had commenced and, therefore, the application could not be allowed in view of proviso to Order 6, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure (for short “the Code”). Proviso to Order 6, Rule 17 reads thus:—

    “Provided that no application for amendment shall be allowed after the trial has commenced unless the Court comes to the conclusion that in spite of due diligence, the party could not have raised the matter before the commencement of trial.”

    9. No doubt, the proviso clearly says that after the commencement of the trial the application for amendment cannot be allowed except in a case where the Court comes to the conclusion that in spite of due diligence the parties could not have raised the matter before the commencement of the trial. Learned counsel for the petitioner, however, disputed that the trial had commenced. Counsel for the parties stated before me that issues have been framed but recording of evidence has not commenced. The petitioner has not even filed an affidavit in lieu of examination in chief of himself or any of his witnesses.

    10. The question required to be considered is: Whether the trial commences on framing of the issues or whether it commences when an affidavit of any witness in lieu of examination in chief is filed after framing of the issues?

    11. Relying upon a decision of the Supreme Court in Vidyabai v. Padmalatha, 2009 (4) Mh.L.J (SC) 30 : (2009) 2 SCC 409 : AIR 2009 SC 1433, counsel for the respondents submitted that the trial commences on issues being framed. He invited my attention to paragraph 8 of the said decision which reads thus:

    “The question, therefore, which arises for consideration is as to whether the trial had commenced or not. In our opinion, it did. The date on which the issues are framed is the date of first hearing. Provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure envisage taking of various steps at different stages of the proceeding. Filing of an affidavit in lieu of examination in chief of the witness, in our opinion, would amount to commencement of proceeding.”

    Placing strong reliance on the sentence “the date on which the issues are framed is the date of first hearing”, counsel submitted that the moment the issues are framed the trial commences. In my view, this is misreading of the judgment. It is a settled principle of law that judgments of Courts are not to be read as a statute. A sentence in the judgment cannot be read in isolation. It must be read in the context in which it appears and cannot be read as a provision of a statute. The expression “the date of first hearing” appearing in second sentence of the above quoted paragraph is to be read in the context of subsequent sentence which reads:

    “Filing of an affidavit in lieu of examination in chief of the witness, in our opinion, would amount to commencement of proceeding”. The Supreme Court has only said: “framing of issues is the first date of hearing” but that does not mean that on framing of issues the trial has commenced. Even after issues are framed, suits often are adjourned several times because of applications for adjournment made by either of the parties. Some times the matter is not even called out because the Court remains busy in dealing with older matters which are on board. Though the framing of issues is the first date of hearing, the actual hearing commences only when a party files an affidavit of himself or his first witness in lieu of examination in chief. That is the commencement of the trial.

    12. For these reasons, there is no merit in the contention of the respondents that the application for amendment was barred by proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code.

    13. The writ petition is accordingly allowed and Rule is made absolute. The petitioner shall carry out the amendment within 4 weeks of the writ being received by the trial Court.

    Petition allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ajit Narsinha Talekar v. Nirmala Wamanrao Kekade And Others
    (Jul 15, 2010)