Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged an arbitral award dated 16th May, 2009, received on 1st June, 2009, by filing an application under section 33 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, on 19th June, 2009. The application sought correction, interpretation, or reconsideration of the award on various grounds including limitation and merits. The respondent was served but did not appear before the Tribunal. By order dated 1st July, 2009, the Arbitrator rejected the application, holding that no errors or grounds under section 33 were made out and that the application amounted to a review, which was impermissible. Subsequently, the petitioner filed a petition under section 34 of the Act on 7th October, 2009, seeking to set aside the arbitral award.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an application under section 33 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, which is rejected without any correction, interpretation, or additional award, restarts the limitation period for filing an application under section 34.
  2. Whether the petition filed under section 34 of the Act on 7th October, 2009, is barred by limitation considering the dates of the award, the section 33 application, and its disposal.
  3. The scope and interpretation of sections 33 and 34(3) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, concerning correction, interpretation, additional awards, and limitation periods.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent relied on the decision in State Of Arunachal Pradesh v. Damani Construction Co., (2007) 10 SCC 742, asserting that the Arbitrator has no power to review the merits of the award under section 33.
  • The respondent contended that an application seeking substantive review or clarification beyond the scope of section 33 is misconceived.
  • They argued that the Arbitrator's rejection of the section 33 application does not create a fresh cause of action to file an application under section 34(3) resetting the limitation period.

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that various reasons justified delay in filing the section 34 petition after the rejection of the section 33 application.
  • The petitioner implied that the limitation period should restart from the date of disposal of the section 33 application.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State Of Arunachal Pradesh v. Damani Construction Co., (2007) 10 SCC 742 Arbitrator's lack of power to review merits under section 33; misconceived nature of substantive review applications under section 33. The court relied on this precedent to hold that rejection of section 33 application without correction or modification does not restart limitation under section 34(3).
Ashwin Neema v. Mangalam Clothes (Pvt.) Ltd., 2009(4) Mh.L.J 991 Strict construction of section 34(3) limitation period; section 14 of Limitation Act applies; section 5 of Limitation Act does not apply except for last 30 days. The court cited this to emphasize the absolute and unextendable nature of the limitation period under section 34(3).
State Of Goa v. Western Builders, (2006) 6 SCC 239 Application of section 14 of Limitation Act (exclusion of time) to arbitration proceedings. Referenced to support the applicability of section 14 of the Limitation Act in arbitration proceedings.
Consolidated Engineering Enterprises v. Principal Secretary, Irrigation Department, (2008) 7 SCC 169 Application of section 14 of Limitation Act to arbitration proceedings. Used to reinforce the principle regarding exclusion of time under section 14.
Shakti Tubes Limited v. State of Bihar, (2009) 1 SCC 786 Application of section 14 of Limitation Act to proceedings under section 34 of Arbitration Act. Supported the view that facts and circumstances must be considered for exclusion of time; not automatic.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the scheme of sections 33 and 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Section 33 allows parties to request correction, interpretation, or additional awards within 30 days from receipt of the arbitral award. The Arbitrator must dispose of such requests within specified timeframes, and any correction or modification forms part of a new or modified arbitral award. Section 34(3) prescribes a strict three-month limitation period for filing an application to set aside an award, counted from the receipt of the original award or, if a section 33 request was made, from the date that request was disposed of by the Arbitrator.

The court clarified that if the Arbitrator rejects the section 33 application without any correction, interpretation, or additional award, the original award retains its originality for limitation purposes. Hence, the limitation period under section 34(3) does not restart from the date of rejection of the section 33 application. The limitation period runs from the date of receipt of the original award.

Applying these principles to the facts, the award was dated 16th May, 2009 (received 1st June, 2009), section 33 application was filed on 19th June, 2009 and rejected on 1st July, 2009. The section 34 petition was filed on 7th October, 2009, which was beyond the three-month limitation period plus the thirty-day grace period under section 34(3). The court also noted that the petitioner’s reasons for delay were insufficient to condone the delay, as section 5 of the Limitation Act does not apply except for the last thirty days, and section 14 applies only under specific circumstances.

Therefore, the petition was barred by limitation and liable to be dismissed without examining the merits.

Holding and Implications

The court held that the petition under section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, was dismissed on the ground of limitation. The rejection of the section 33 application without any correction, interpretation, or additional award does not restart the limitation period for filing a section 34 application.

The direct consequence of this decision is that parties must file applications under section 34 strictly within three months from the receipt of the original arbitral award unless a corrected or modified award is issued under section 33. No new precedent was set beyond the strict interpretation of the limitation provisions under the Arbitration Act and the Limitation Act.

    Amit Suryakant Lunavat v. Kotak Securities, Mumbai .

    1. Heard finally, by consent.

    2. The petitioner has moved this Petition under section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, (for short, the Act) thereby challenge is made to the award dated 16th May, 2009 which according to the petitioner received on 1st June, 2009. Admittedly, the petitioner has moved an Application under section 33 of the Act, on 1.9th June, 2009, and various grounds were raised referring to limitation and the merit also and prayed to reconsider all the points. The respondent though served, not appeared before the Tribunal.

    3. By order dated 1st July, 2009, the Arbitrator, observed that; there are no typographical or clerical errors or errors of similar nature in the award; the application, as filed, does not come within any of the criteria falling under section 33; it amounts to review of the award; rejected the application on all grounds.

    4. The petitioner moved/lodged this petition under section 34 of the Act, on 7-10-2009.

    5. The relevant section 33 is reproduced as under:

    “33. Correction and interpretation of award; additional award. — (1) Within thirty days from the receipt of the arbitral award, unless another period of time has been agreed upon by the parties—

    a) a party, with notice to the other party, may request the arbitral tribunal to correct any computation errors, any clerical or typographical errors or any other errors of a similar nature occurring in the award;

    b) if so agreed by the parties, a party, with notice to the other party, may request the arbitral tribunal to give an interpretation of a specific point or part of the award.

    (2) If the arbitral tribunal considers the request made under subsection (1) to be justified, it shall make the correction or give the interpretation within thirty days from the receipt of the request and the interpretation shall form part of the arbitral award.

    (3) The arbitral tribunal may correct any error of the type referred to in clause (a) of sub-section (1), on its own initiative, within thirty days from the date of the arbitral award.

    (4) Unless otherwise agreed by the parties, a party with notice to the other party, may request, within thirty days from the receipt of the arbitral award, the arbitral tribunal to make an additional arbitral award as to claims presented in the arbitral proceedings but omitted from the arbitral award.

    (5) If the arbitral tribunal considers the request made under subsection (4) to be justified, it shall make the additional arbitral award within sixty days from the receipt of such request.

    (6) The arbitral tribunal may extend, if necessary, the period of time within which it shall make a correction, give an interpretation or make an additional arbitral award under sub-section (2) or sub-section (5).

    (7) section 31 shall apply to a correction or interpretation of the arbitral award or to an additional arbitral award made under this section.”

    6. Section 34 sub-clause (3) is also reproduced as under:

    “(1)….

    (3) An application for setting aside may not be made after three months have elapsed from the date on which the party making that application had received the arbitral award or, if a request had been made under section 33, from the date on which that request had been disposed of by the arbitral tribunal:

    Provided that if the Court is satisfied that the applicant was prevented by sufficient cause from making the application within the said period of three months it may entertain the application within a further period of thirty days, but not thereafter.

    (4)…..”

    7. As per the scheme of the Act and these two sections, it is permissible for the parties to apply for correction and/or interpretation and/or for addition in the award within 30 days from the receipt of the award. The petitioner did apply accordingly. As per clause (a) of section 33(1) of the Act with notice to the other party, a party can request the arbitral tribunal to correct any computation errors or any clerical or any typographical errors or any other errors of a similar nature. So far as clause 33(1)(b) is concerned, the agreement/consent of the other party is necessary. The consent can be obtained and/or Arbitrator can take note of the same on given facts and circumstances of the case, after notice to the other side, which is a must, even for the interpretation of a specific point or part of the award.

    8. The Tribunal after hearing both the parties or even otherwise, if there is any correction or any interpretation in the award, it should be made within 30 days from the receipt of the request. It shall form part of the Arbitral award. Therefore, it is mandatory for the parties to apply within 30 days, as well as, for the arbitrator to pass order within 30 days from the receipt of such request.

    9. As per section 33(4) of the Act, unless otherwise agreed by the parties and subject to notice to other party, a party may request within 30 days from the date of receipt of the Arbitral award, the Arbitral Tribunal to make an additional arbitral award, in a case where the Arbitrator, for whatever may be the reason, omitted to decide some portion or part of the claim so made by the parties. Therefore, the consent of the parties here again necessary for such additional arbitral award of the omitted claims only and not otherwise. One party cannot apply for additional award firstly, without due notice and secondly, without consent to reconsider and/or to consider the omitted claims, if any. The Tribunal, within 60 days from the receipt of the request may consider and pass the additional award.

    10. As per section 33(6) of the Act the Tribunal may extend, if necessary, the period of correction or give an interpretation or make any additional award under sub-section (2) or sub-section (5) of section 33 of the Act.

    11. Section 33(7) refers to section 31 of the Act, insofar as the correction or interpretation of the arbitral award and/or additional award made in this section. Section 33 contemplates and form arbitral award. It also means that if there is a correction or interpretation and/or additional award, the Arbitrator will modify and/or pass award, considering the forms and contents as provided under section 31 of the Act. Therefore, whenever there is a correction, modification or any addition of any claim or additional award, it means there will be a new and/or corrected arbitral award and the original award after such correction, clarification and/or additional award, looses its originality for the purpose of limitation as contemplated under section 34(3) of the Act.

    12. As quoted above, section 34(3) provides that an application for setting aside should be made within 3 months from the date on which the party making that application had received the award or if a request had been made under section 33, from the date on which that request had been disposed of by the arbitral tribunal. In my view, considering the scheme of sections 33 and 33(4), it is clear that merely because the application under section 33 is filed within 30 days from the receipt of the award, and the order of the same received within 30 days or 60 days, as referred above, there is no question of starting new limitation period from the date of disposing of the arbitration application under section 33 of the Act, in a case, where the Arbitrator rejects the application without making any modification/correction and/or addition in arbitral award.

    13. There is no justification, as contended, to accept the submission in view of the mandate of section 34 and considering the scheme and purpose of the Arbitration Act that because the application under section 33 of the Act was filed and it was rejected subsequently, therefore, the limitation period commenced afresh from the date of such decision of the award. In my view, it is contemplated only on a situation where the Arbitrator corrects or interprets and/or add or decide to add any additional claims and modified the award as only in such cases the original award looses its originality and therefore an application for setting aside the award needs to be filed within three months from the date of receipt of such corrected or modified award. Therefore, the party who received the award after deciding the application under section 34(3) of the Act, may get the benefit of fresh commencement of limitation from the receipt of the modified and/or corrected award and not otherwise.

    14. In the present case, even otherwise, the award is dated 16th May, 2009, received on 1st June, 2009, the Application under section 33 was filed on 19th June, 2009 which was decided on 1st July, 2009 though received on 9th July, 2009, the present Petition under section 34 was filed on 7th October, 2009. Therefore, in any way, it is beyond limitation of three months, as well as, 30 days thereafter, as contemplated under section 34(3) of the Act.

    15. The learned counsel appearing for the respondent has strongly relied on State Of Arunachal Pradesh v. Damani Construction Co.., (2007) 10 SCC 742, and thereby contended that as the Arbitrator has no power to review, on merits and an application seeking clarification and substantive review of the award no way falls within the ambit of section 33 of the Act. The Apex Court while interpreting the provisions of section 33, as well as section 34(3) observed that such application was totally misconceived and the Arbitrator's decision did not give any fresh cause of action so as to file application under section 34(3) of the Act taking it as a supporting point of limitation from the date of reply/order given by the Arbitrator.

    16. 1 have already observed in Arbitration Petition No. 207 of 2009, Shri. Ashwin Neema v. Mangalam Clothes (Pvt.) Ltd. by order dated 17th April, 2009 [2009(4) Mh.L.J 991] referring to section 34(3) of the Act as under:

    “3. The Apex Court has declared that the provisions in section 34(3) has to be construed strictly. The time limit so prescribed is absolute and unextendable. State Of Goa v. Western Builders, (2006) 6 SCC 239. section 14 of the limitation act provides exclusion of period. (Consolidated Engineering Enterprises v. Principal Secretary, Irrigation Department, (2008) 7 SCC 169. In the case of Shakti Tubes Limited v. State of Bihar, (2009) 1 SCC 786, it is held that the provisions of section 14 of the Limitation Act is applicable to the proceedings under section 34 of the Act. The fact and circumstances has to be seen. It does not apply automatically.”

    17. In view of above, it is further clear that except the case of exclusion as contemplated under section 14 of the Limitation Act, the Court has no power to entertain and/or consider and/or condone the delay as contemplated under section 5 of the Limitation Act while deciding such application under section 34(3) of the Act except last thirty days. Therefore, the submission of the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner that there were various reasons for the petitioner not to initiate proceedings within limitation after receipt of rejection of his application under section 33 of the Act on 1st July, 2009, just cannot be considered as present petition was filed on 7th October, 2009.

    18. Therefore, without observing anything on the merits of the matter, in view of above clear provisions of law, as well as, undisputed position of facts in my view, the present Petition under section 34 of the Arbitration Act is liable to be dismissed on the ground of limitation itself.

    19. The Petition is accordingly dismissed with no order as to costs.

    Petition dismissed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Amit Suryakant Lunavat v. Kotak Securities, Mumbai .
    (Sep 27, 2010)