AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2009 BHC 10170
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2009 BHC 10170
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Bilal Nazki, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This judgment consolidates two writ petitions raising identical issues concerning alleged abuse of powers by Executive Magistrates under Chapter VIII of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC). The Court treats these matters as sample cases illustrating systemic misuse of Chapter VIII powers exercised by Assistant Commissioners of Police acting as Executive Magistrates in the State of Andhra Pradesh (noting practical access issues for persons from remote villages).

The Court took the facts of Criminal Writ Petition No. 2682 of 2008 for decision. In that matter the petitioners received a notice on 24 March 2008 under section 111 CrPC. The petitioners stated they were law‑abiding and had prior proceedings: in Sessions Case No. 58 of 1996 one petitioner was acquitted and another discharged, and in C.R. No. 8 of 2008 petitioner No.1 had anticipatory bail.

The Executive Magistrate issued the section 111 notice on 24 March 2008 fixing hearing for 6 April 2008, but, according to the petitioners, passed orders the same day under section 116(3) CrPC directing the petitioners to furnish an interim bond for good behaviour on specified conditions without hearing them. The conditions included two sureties: one with a solvency certificate from the area of residence and one "chairman" not involved in the dispute. The petitioners say they could not arrange the sureties, and petitioner No.1 was arrested and sent to jail the same day. Petitioner No.1 filed a revision in the Court of Sessions Judge, which was partly allowed.

Earlier in separate proceedings the petitioners had challenged Chapter VIII action by way of a writ petition which was disposed of on 20 October 2008 upon a statement by respondents that the Chapter proceedings had been dropped.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an Executive Magistrate acting under section 111 CrPC may, without conducting any inquiry, require an interim bond for good behaviour and direct arrest and detention for failure to furnish such bond on the same day the notice is issued.
  2. Whether the interim exercise of Chapter VIII powers (including orders under section 116(3) CrPC) is lawful without making any inquiry into the truth of the information as required by the statutory scheme and established precedent.
  3. What procedural safeguards or administrative measures should be directed to prevent abuse or misconstruction of Chapter VIII powers by Executive Magistrates (particularly police officers acting as Executive Magistrates)?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' contentions

  • The petitioners received a section 111 CrPC notice dated 24 March 2008 fixed for hearing on 6 April 2008, but the Executive Magistrate passed orders the same day under section 116(3) CrPC directing them to furnish interim bonds without any opportunity to be heard.
  • Two sureties were ordered: (1) a surety with a solvency certificate from the area of residence; and (2) a "chairman" who was not involved in the dispute but from the same area. The petitioners contended obtaining such sureties, particularly from the specified chairman, was impossible because of an existing dispute.
  • Because they could not furnish the sureties, petitioner No.1 was arrested and remanded to custody on 24 March 2008. The petitioners asserted that no show‑cause opportunity was given and the arrest and detention were therefore unlawful.
  • The petitioners sought compensation of Rs. 10,000 per day for illegal custody (noting petitioner No.1 remained in custody for four days).

Respondent/Executive Magistrate

  • The Executive Magistrate filed an additional affidavit tendering an apology to the Court, sought condonation for the error, and stated that he had not exercised the power with malice.
  • The record also reflects that the learned Public Prosecutor was heard and that the Executive Magistrate personally attended Court for hearing.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Madhu Limaye v. Sub Divisional Magistrate, Monghyr; (1970) 3 SCC 746 : AIR 1971 SC 2486 Laid down parameters of section 117 CrPC: an immediate inquiry into the truth of the information is contemplated before an interim bond is ordered; some inquiry is required before ordering an interim bond that could lead to custody. The Court reproduced paragraph 43 of this Constitutional Bench decision and relied on it to hold that the Executive Magistrate must conduct some inquiry into the truth of information before ordering an interim bond and detaining a person; the impugned orders failed this requirement.
Empress v. Babua, (1883) ILR 6 All 132 Authority noted (via Straight J.) that an order under section 112 (historical reference) is based on hearsay but section 117 inquiry is to ascertain truth — distinguishing mere hearsay from an inquiry into truth. Cited within the Madhu Limaye passage reproduced by the Court to support the proposition that an inquiry (not mere adjournment on hearsay) is required before ordering bonds or custody.
Nafar Chandra Pal v. Emperor, 28 Cal. WN 23 : AIR 1924 Cal 114 Illustrates that a petition and a report alone may be insufficient material to justify interim measures; factual material must be definite. Used in the Madhu Limaye reasoning (quoted by this Court) to show that inadequate material does not justify ordering interim bonds or detention without inquiry; the Court applied this principle to find the Executive Magistrate's action deficient.
A.D. Dunne v. Hem Chunder, (1869) 12 Suth WR Cr 60 (FB) Older authority stressing safeguards around orders that may affect personal liberty; the commentary of Sir Barnes Peacock was held applicable to current law to require inquiry before jeopardy of detention. Relied on (through Madhu Limaye) to reinforce that detaining a person without inquiry into truth runs counter to guarantees of liberty; supported the Court's finding that the impugned interim orders were unlawful.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by identifying a broader pattern of complaints that Executive Magistrates (frequently Assistant Commissioners of Police acting as Executive Magistrates) in urban areas were abusing Chapter VIII CrPC powers. The Court observed an institutional problem: police officers are routinely invested with magisterial powers without necessarily being trained as magistrates, and this creates a conflict of interest and potential for misuse.

Focusing on the facts of Criminal Writ Petition No. 2682 of 2008, the Court noted that the Executive Magistrate issued a section 111 CrPC notice on 24 March 2008 (fixing hearing for 6 April 2008) but on the same date purportedly passed orders under section 116(3) CrPC requiring interim bonds and specifying onerous surety conditions. The order demanded two sureties: one with a solvency certificate from the petitioners' area of residence and one being a "chairman" not involved in the dispute — an imposition the petitioners said was impossible to meet.

The Court analyzed the statutory scheme of Chapter VIII (referencing sections 107–111, 116, 117 and section 17 as raised in the opinion) and explained the proper sequence:

  • When a Magistrate acting under sections 107–110 considers it necessary to require a person to show cause, he must make a written order under section 111.
  • Section 111 empowers the Magistrate to require a person to show cause and, if necessary, to start an inquiry.
  • An inquiry must be conducted in terms of section 116, and only upon inquiry, if the Magistrate concludes that a bond is necessary and the person refuses, may the person be sent to custody pending completion of inquiry and final order (with reference to section 17 and its provisos).
  • The Court emphasized that no person against whom proceedings are not being taken under sections 108–110 shall be directed to execute a bond for maintaining good behaviour (citing the proviso), and that the conditions of any bond must not be more onerous than those specified in the section 111 order.

The Court relied heavily on Madhu Limaye (and the authorities cited within it) to stress that an interim bond or custody cannot be ordered without some inquiry to ascertain the truth of the information — the liberty interest requires a strict construction of magisterial powers. The Madhu Limaye passage expressly condemns routine adjournment followed by demand for an interim bond leading to custody without inquiry; the Court applied that principle and found the Executive Magistrate's actions unlawful at every stage.

The Sessions Judge had earlier "more or less" upheld the impugned orders save for striking down the chairman‑surety condition; this Court disagreed with the legality of the custody and found the petitioners had been held in illegal custody. However, because the Executive Magistrate filed an affidavit apologizing and stating lack of malice, and after hearing the Public Prosecutor and the Magistrate personally, the Court gave the Magistrate the benefit of doubt on the ground of possible ignorance and lack of training.

Rather than imposing a punitive monetary award in this instance, the Court issued administrative and procedural directions intended to prevent recurrence: mandatory training/crash courses for Executive Magistrates; involvement of Sessions Judges in training; procedural safeguards ensuring sufficient time to furnish bonds; prohibition on seeking interim bonds at inquiry stage unless satisfied as to truth of information; mandatory transmission of orders sending persons to jail to the Principal Sessions Judge and the Magistrate's departmental superior; and enabling the Principal Sessions Judge to intervene by revision under section 397 CrPC where appropriate.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Both writ petitions are disposed of. The Court held that the Executive Magistrate's orders (ordering interim bonds and directing custody on the same day as the section 111 notice, without inquiry or opportunity to be heard) violated the statutory scheme and established judicial principles requiring inquiry before ordering interim bonds or custody. The petitioners were found to have been kept in illegal custody.

Direct consequences and directions issued by the Court:

  • The Court directed the State Government to immediately train all Executive Magistrates on the correct application of Chapter VIII CrPC provisions, preferably by a crash course at the State police academy with Sessions Judges invited to teach.
  • When a Magistrate passes an interim or final order requiring a person to give a bond, the person must be given sufficient time to furnish the bond and surety.
  • At the inquiry stage, a Magistrate shall not ask for an interim bond pending inquiry unless he is satisfied about the truth of the information sufficient to make out a case for seeking a bond.
  • Whenever an Executive Magistrate directs custody under subsection (3) of section 116 (Chapter VIII), a copy of that order shall be sent immediately to the learned Principal Sessions Judge; upon receipt the Principal Sessions Judge may examine the order and intervene by revision under section 397 CrPC if warranted.
  • A copy of any such custodial order shall also be sent to the immediate superior of the Executive Magistrate in his department.

The Court also recorded that the Executive Magistrate tendered an apology and sought condonation; consequently the Court gave the Magistrate the benefit of doubt on grounds of possible ignorance and lack of training rather than concluding malice or imposing additional punishment in the present matter.

The opinion does not state that any new binding legal precedent was created by this judgment; rather it applied existing precedents (notably Madhu Limaye) and issued administrative and procedural directions to prevent abuse of Chapter VIII powers.

Order accordingly.
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Pravin Vijaykumar Taware And Others v. Special Executive Magistrate, Baramati And Another

    Bilal Nazki, J.:— Number of cases are coming before this Court complaining of an abuse of powers by the Executive Magistrate under Chapter VIII of the Criminal Procedure Code. These cases come from the cities or bigger towns. This Court has not seen a case coming from a remote village. Obviously, the people living in such areas do not find it possible to reach the High Court. Therefore, this Court presumes that these powers may be abused with impunity as the persons suffering under these areas may not be able to reach the High Court. The power of the Executive Magistrate are exercised in the State of Andhra Pradesh by the Assistant Commissioner of Police In-Charge of the area. There is always a clash of interest between a Police Officer In-Charge of an area and the Magistrate exercising the magisterial power within the same area. We had earlier also expressed a desire that the Government should consider delegating these powers either to Judicial Magistrates or at least to officials of the Revenue Department. The provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code are being misused and abused sometimes purposely, but more often without note because of ignorance of law. We are taking this case as one of the sample cases for the purpose of demonstrating as to how the provisions of law are being abused.

    2. Since the issues involved in both the above writ petitions are same, both the writ petitions are being decided by this common judgment. For the purpose of deciding the issue, the facts in Criminal Writ Petition No. 2682 of 2008 are taken note of.

    3. The petitioners received a notice 24th March, 2008. The petitioners submit that they are law abiding citizens and have never been involved in commission of any offence. According to them, two false complaints were registered against the petitioners. In Sessions Case No. 58 of 1996, one of petitioner was acquitted and another was discharged. In another case being C.R No. 8 of 2008 the petitioner No. 1 had been admitted to bail in anticipation of his arrest. The respondent issued a notice under section 111 of the Criminal Procedure Code on 24th March, 2008 and the proceedings were fixed for hearing 6th April, 2008. But the respondent passed orders on the same day i.e 24th March, 2006 purportedly under section 116(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure without giving any opportunity of being heard, directing the petitioners to execute an interim bond for good behaviour on conditions. The petitioners contend that it was not possible for the petitioners to arrange for surety and the surety which the respondents had sought and, therefore, the petitioner No. 1 was arrested and sent to jail on the same day. The petitioner No. 1 filed a revision in the Court of Sessions Judge. The learned Sessions Judge allowed the revision partly.

    4. Earlier also the proceedings were initiated against the petitioners which they had challenged by filing a Writ Petition and the writ petition was disposed of as a statement was made by the respondents that the Chapter proceedings against the petitioners were dropped. This order had been passed on 20th October, 2008.

    5. Before going to the counter affidavit, it will be necessary to have a look on the orders passed by the Executive Magistrate on 24th March, 2008. He passed an order under section 111 of the Criminal Procedure Code, referred to two cases and then said, “I have confirmed that there will not be any improvement in the behaviour of the respondents (petitioners herein) in future”. Then says, “Therefore, it is proper to proceed against you as per section 110(e)(g) of Criminal Procedure Code, hence why not be taken one surety with solvency certificate of Rs. 1,00,000/- for 1 year for good behaviour from you and another chairman who is not involved in the dispute, as such two sureties from the area where the respondents are residing? Its reasons be given orally or in writing. You have been given the date 6-4-2008 for the work.” In fact this was not a show cause notice but was an order to furnish two sureties from the area where the petitioners were residing. It was also stated that one surety must be given by the Chairman. We do not know how can the respondents ask a surety of a particular person and if the particular person was not ready to give surety that would eventually mean that the man would have to go to Jail. This order was passed on 24th March, 2008, per se fixed on 6th April, 2008. But the petitioners were brought perhaps after arresting them before the Magistrate on the same day and on the same day he passed another order under section 116(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure in which he brazenly stated that for the interim period till the inquiry is completed the respondents (Petitioners in this writ petition) should give surety on following terms:

    (1) One surety with Solvency Certificate in the area where the respondents are residing.

    (2) One surety chairman who is not involved in the dispute in the area where the respondents are residing.

    Then on same day he puts a question as to whether the Petitioners wanted to say anything about interim bond. Records answer as “No” and then passed an order, which reads thus:

    “Respondent :Pravin Vijaykumar Taware, R/o Sanghvi, Tal. Baramati, Dist. Pune, this respondent was produced before me as per section 110(e)(g) of Cri. Pro. Code and the enquiry of the respondent is adjourned upto date 7-4-2008, which is necessary.

    Therefore, take the custody of the respondent and produce before me on the above day in the Court of Special Executive Magistrate, Pune Rural Chavan Nagar, Pune-8, on 7-4-2008 in the morning 11.00 hours, as such informing you.

    Issued on 24-3-2008 with my signature and seal of the Court. The Respondent was arrested on 24-3-2008.”

    And sends the petitioner to jail.

    6. At no point of time the petitioners were given a chance to show cause against the furnishing of bond and at no point of time they were also given a chance to arrange for the bond and the conditions imposed were such that it was impossible to get a bond from the Chairman with whom according to the petitioners, the petitioners had a dispute. This is absolutely defensible. The scheme of Chapter VIII of the Criminal Procedure Code is that when a Magistrate acting under sections 107, 108, 109 or 110 of the Criminal Procedure Code deems it necessary to require any person to show cause under such sections, he shall make an order in writing. Therefore, when the Magistrate takes action under section 111 of the Criminal Procedure Code, he has no power to arrest and detain a person. His power is to require to show cause and if necessary start an inquiry. Inquiry has to be done in terms of section 116 of the Criminal Procedure Code and if at that stage the Magistrate is of the view that during the inquiry a person should be asked to give a bond and he refuses to give a bond then the person may be sent to custody till the inquiry is complete and final order can be passed under section 17 of the Criminal Procedure Code. Now this section also has proviso. One of the proviso is, “No person against whom proceedings are not being taken under section 108, section 109, or section 110 shall be directed to execute a bond for maintaining good behaviour”. Then the second proviso is that, “the conditions of such bond, whether as to the amount thereof or as to the provision of sureties or the number thereof or the pecuniary extent of their liability, shall not be more onerous than those specified in the order under section 111”.

    7. Even directing a person to give bond and on failure send him to jail cannot be done even at the interim stage unless some sort of inquiry is conducted with regard to truth of the information. This question came before the Supreme Court as early as in the year 1971 in the case of Madhu Limaye v. Sub Divisional Magistrate, Monghyr, reported in (1970) 3 SCC 746 : AIR 1971 SC 2486, and the Constitutional Bench laid down the parameters of section 117 of the Criminal Procedure Code. Paragraph 43 of the judgment is reproduced here below:

    “43. In our opinion, the words of the section are quite clear. As said by Straight J. in Empress v. Babua, (1883) ILR 6 All 132, the order under section 112 is on hearsay but the inquiry under section 117 is to ascertain the truth of the necessary information. Sub-section (1) contemplates an immediate inquiry into the truth of the information. It is pending the completion of the inquiry that an interim bond can be asked for if immediate measures are necessary, and in default it is necessary to put the person in custody. Therefore, as the liberty of a person is involved, and that person is being proceeded against on information and suspicion, it is necessary to put a strict construction upon the powers of Magistrate. The facts must be of definite character. In Nafar Chandra Pal v. Emperor, 28 Cal. WN 23 : (AIR 1924 Cal 114) there was only a petition and a report and these were not found sufficient material. In some of the cases before us no effort was made by the Magistrate to inquire into the truth of the allegation. The Magistrate adjourned the case from day to day and yet asked for an interim bond. This makes the proceedings entirely one sided. It cannot be described as an inquiry within an inquiry as has been said in some cases. Some inquiry has to be made before the bond can be ordered. We, therefore, approve of those cases in which it has been laid down that some inquiry should be made before action is taken to ask for interim bond on placing the person in custody in default. In an old case reported in A.D Dunne v. Hem Chunder, (1869) 12 Suth WR Cr 60 (FB), a Full Bench of the Calcutta High Court went into the matter. The case arose before the present Code of Criminal Procedure and, therefore, there was no provision for an interim bond but what Sir Barns Peacock, C.J said applies to the changed law also not only with regard to the ultimate order but also to the interim order for a bond. The section even as it is drafted today is hedged in with proper safeguards and it would be moving too far away from the guarantee of freedom, if the view were allowed to prevail that without any inquiry into the truth of the information sufficient to make out a prima facie case a person is to be put in jeopardy of detention. A definite finding is required that immediate steps are necessary. The order must be one which can be made into a final order unless something to the contrary is established. Therefore, it is not open to a Magistrate to adjourn the case and in the interval to send a person to jail if he fails to furnish a bond. If this were the law a bond could always be insisted upon before even the inquiry began and that is neither the sense of the law nor the wording or arrangement of the sections already noticed.”

    8. Therefore, at every stage the law has been violated. Surprisingly, the order challenged before the Sessions Judge was more or less upheld and the learned Sessions Judge noted that the impugned orders were not illegal or without jurisdiction. Only the condition of furnishing surety of the Chairman was set aside. The petitioners remained in illegal custody and we have no doubt about that. The petitioner seeks compensation of Rs. 10,000/- per day. He remained in custody for 4 days. Earlier also we have imposed costs. But in this case an additional affidavit was filed by the Executive Magistrate tendering an apology to the Court. He sought condonation of the error committed by him and stated on affidavit that he had not exercised the power with any malice.

    9. After hearing the learned Public Prosecutor and also the Executive Magistrate, who was also present in the Court, we give benefit of doubt to the Magistrate on the ground that perhaps these Magistrates are not aware of the law. They are not trained to act as Magistrate. We understand they have not undergone any training before they were given the powers of a Magistrate. When a person is appointed or posted as an Assistant Commissioner of Police, he is almost mechanically appointed as an Executive Magistrate and is given authority to execute powers under Chapter VIII of the Criminal Procedure Code. Since the Government is not interested in taking away these powers from the Police Officers and handover the powers to judiciary or to revenue officials, we are inclined to give the following directions:

    (1) That the State Government shall immediately take steps to train its all Executive Magistrates so that they understand as to how the provisions of Chapter VIII of the Criminal Procedure Code have to be applied.

    (2) We understand that there is a police academy in the State. All the Executive Magistrate should undergo a crash course. Preferably the Sessions Judges should be invited to teach these Magistrate about the nuances of law, so that the powers are not abused or misused by the Executive Magistrate.

    (3) Whenever, an order is passed by a Magistrate at interim stage or at final stage requiring a person to give a bond, he shall be given sufficient time to furnish the bond and the surety.

    (4) At the stage of inquiry, the Magistrate shall not ask for an interim bond pending inquiry unless the Magistrate has satisfied himself about the truth of the information sufficient to make out a case for seeking a bond.

    (5) Whenever, an Executive Magistrate passes an order under subsection (3) of section 116 of Chapter VIII of the Criminal Procedure Code directing a person to be sent to jail, a copy of the order shall be sent to the learned Principal Sessions Judge immediately.

    (6) On receiving copy of the order, the learned Principal Sessions Judge shall go through the order and if he finds a case of revision, he may intervene under section 397 of the Criminal Procedure Code.

    (7) A copy of the order directing a person to be sent to jail under Chapter VIII of the Criminal Procedure Code shall also be sent to the immediate superior of the Magistrate in his Department.

    With the above observations and the guidelines, both the writ petitions are disposed of.

    10. Copy of this order shall be sent to all the Principal Sessions Judges in the State of Maharashtra as also to the Principal Secretaries of the State, Law and Judiciary and Home Department.

    Order accordingly.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pravin Vijaykumar Taware And Others v. Special Executive Magistrate, Baramati And Another
    (Jun 18, 2009)