Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

By an agreement dated 22 May 2008, the Petitioner appointed the Respondent as an exclusive agent for designated branding sites within a shopping mall. The Petitioner permitted the Respondent to display advertisements at the mall, in a theatre, and on ticket jackets. Disputes arose regarding whether all contractual facilities were made available by the Petitioner. On 29 August 2008, the Petitioner acknowledged deficiencies and offered to extend the contract duration as compensation, which the Respondent accepted on 2 September 2008, requesting a formal amendment. The contract term was initially from 22 May 2008 to 31 July 2009, later extended formally to include August and September 2009. Correspondence revealed payment delays by the Respondent, with assurances to clear dues. The Petitioner issued a statutory notice under Sections 433 and 434 of the Companies Act, 1956 on 19 December 2008 and terminated the agreement.

The Petition for winding up claims amounts due from July 2008 to July 2009, including service tax, totaling Rs. 25.02 lakhs with interest at 18% per annum. The maintainability of the Petition was challenged by the Respondent, asserting that the claim largely relates to damages requiring adjudication and thus is not a debt due and payable. The Petitioner countered, relying on the contract's liquidated damages clause and the Supreme Court's judgment in Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd., asserting entitlement to the claimed sum unless it is unreasonable or penal in nature.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a petition for winding up can be maintained on a claim primarily for damages for breach of contract, without adjudication.
  2. Whether the contractual clause stipulating payment of a fixed sum as liquidated damages constitutes a debt due and payable, or merely a claim for damages requiring adjudication.
  3. Whether the principles established in Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd. apply to the facts of this case to sustain the Petition.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The contractual clause provides for a non-refundable minimum guaranteed royalty payable by the Respondent, constituting a liquidated damages clause.
  • Reliance on the Supreme Court judgment in Saw Pipes Ltd. to assert entitlement to the sum named in the contract unless shown to be unreasonable or penal.
  • The Respondent's failure to pay the minimum guaranteed royalty results in a debt due and payable with interest at 18% per annum.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The substantial part of the claimed amount is for loss or damages due to alleged breach, which requires evidential proof beyond summary winding up proceedings.
  • No debt can be considered due and payable unless the extent of loss or damages is adjudicated and ascertained by a competent court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd., 2003 5 SCC 705 Clarifies that where a contract unambiguously stipulates liquidated damages, the party in breach must pay unless the sum is unreasonable or penal; also explains the court's role in assessing reasonableness and penalty. The Court acknowledged the principle but distinguished the present case, noting that adjudication is required to crystallize the debt and determine reasonableness or penalty, which cannot be decided in winding up proceedings.
Greenhills Exports (P) Ltd. v. Coffee Board, 2001 106 Company Cases 391 (Karnataka High Court Division Bench) Defines the difference between a "debt" and a claim for "damages," holding that damages require adjudication before becoming a debt due and payable. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that claims for damages cannot sustain a winding up petition until adjudicated, reinforcing that liability crystallizes only upon court decree.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the contractual provisions, particularly Clause 8, which allows termination and claim of the entire royalty/minimum guaranteed amount with interest upon payment default. While the clause appears to provide for liquidated damages, the Court emphasized that a petition for winding up cannot be maintained on a claim that is essentially for damages, which require adjudication to crystallize into a debt. The Court referred to the Greenhills Exports decision, distinguishing between damages and debts, and reiterated that damages become payable only after judicial determination. Although the Petitioner relied on the Saw Pipes judgment to argue entitlement to liquidated damages without proof of loss, the Court noted that in Saw Pipes the claim arose from an arbitral award after adjudication, unlike the present summary winding up context. The Court concluded that the contractual clause, if regarded as liquidated damages, requires adjudication to determine reasonableness and penalty issues and to crystallize the debt. Hence, the winding up petition was not maintainable as the claim had not yet been judicially established as a debt due and payable.

Holding and Implications

The Petition for winding up is dismissed on the ground of non-maintainability.

The dismissal leaves the Petitioner free to pursue other legal remedies in accordance with law. The decision clarifies that claims for damages, even if stipulated as liquidated damages in a contract, require adjudication before becoming debts that can sustain winding up proceedings. No new precedent is created; the ruling underscores the necessity of judicial determination to crystallize a debt due and payable in such contexts.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    E-City Media Private Limited v. Sadhrta Retail Limited

    ORAL ORDER :

    1. By an agreement dated 22nd May, 2008 the Petitioner appointed the Respondent as an exclusive agent for designated branding sites situated within the premises of a shopping mall. Shorn of detail, the Petitioner permitted the Respondent to display advertisements at the mall, in a theatre and upon ticket jackets. During the term of the agreement there were disputes over whether all the facilities under the contract were made available by the Petitioner to the Respondent. On 29th August, 2008 the Petitioner, while recognizing deficiencies, offered to extend the duration of the contract as compensation. The Respondent by its email of 2 September, 2008 agreed to accept the compensation recommended and proceeded to state that a formal amendment to the contract ought to be signed by the parties. The Petitioner by a communication of 26 September, 2008 recorded that a revised duration issued as agreed towards compensation, was being forwarded to the Respondent. The term of the contract between the parties was to commence on 22 May, 2008 and was to conclude on 31st July, 2009. The term was extended by a formal amendment to cover the months of August and September 2009. There was a further exchange of correspondence by which on 26 September, 2008 the Respondent acknowledged that there was a delay on its part in effecting payments. One of the directors of the Respondent also addressed an email of 1 November, 2008 furnishing an assurance that all payments would be cleared. This was followed by a communication dated 6 March, 2009 seeking a meeting to settle the pending issues. The Petitioner issued a statutory notice under Sections 433 and 434 of the Companies Act, 1956 on 19 December, 2008 and proceeded to terminate the agreement.

    2. The claim which forms the basis of the petition for winding up has been particularized in Exhibits H and I to the Petition. The claim is for amounts due and payable between July 2008 until 31 December, 2008 (Exhibit H) and for the period between 1 January, 2009 until 31 July, 2009 (Exhibit I). Service tax dues have been claimed thereon. The total claim is in the amount of Rs. 25.02 lacs on which interest at the rate of 18% has been claimed.

    3. The maintainability of the Petition has been questioned. The Respondent which has filed an affidavit in reply in these proceedings submits that a substantial part of the debt or dues alleged in the Petition is for loss or damages sustained on an alleged breach by the Respondent of the agreement dated 22 May, 2008. It is urged that the determination of loss or damages will require evidential proof which lies beyond the summary nature of proceedings for winding up. It has been urged that no debt can be held to be due and payable unless the extent or loss of damages has been ascertained.

    4. On the other hand, it has been submitted on behalf of the Petitioner that even if the provision of the contract is held to be in the nature of liquidated damages, in view of the judgment of the Supreme Court in Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd. 2003 5 SCC 705, the Petitioner would be entitled to claim the sum named by the parties in the contract unless it is held to be unreasonable or by way of penalty. In the present case it was urged that there is no defence to the effect that the sum named is either unreasonable or by way of penalty. Learned counsel submitted that in terms of the contract the Respondent is liable to pay the minimum guaranteed royalty and the failure of the Respondent to do so would result in a debt due and payable.

    5. Clause (i) of the contract provides that the Respondent was to pay a sum of Rs. 22,92,700/- as and by way of a non-refundable royalty, which is described as a minimum guarantee on a yearly basis. Clause 8 of the contract upon which the maintainability of the Petition would depend provides, insofar as is material, as follows :

    “8. Making payments of the Royalty/MG amounts as provided in Clause No. 1 and Annexure 1 the payment to Fun Multiplex on due dates as per Clause No. 1 and Annexure 1 hereto above and non-termination are the ESSENCE of this Agreement. Further it is specifically agreed that :

    a. Sadhrta Retail Pvt. Ltd. and E City Media cannot terminate this Agreement other than in the event the following occurs:

    A. In case Sadhrta Retail Pvt. Ltd. fails to make payment or if the cheque is dishonoured for any reason whatsoever of the Royalty/MG amount for a period of any one month during the term of this Agreement then E City Media shall be at liberty to terminate this Agreement after giving 7 days notice and dispose of the rights herein granted to Sadhrta Retail Pvt. Ltd in any manner as E City Media may deem fit and proper and in such an event Sadhrta Retail Pvt. Ltd. shall make good the losses and damages which may be suffered by E City Media. On occurrence of such an event, Sadhrta Retail pvt. Ltd. shall be liable to pay to E City Media on demand the entire Royalty/MG amount mentioned in this Agreement with interest at 18% per annum.”

    6. The Petitioner terminated the contract by its communication dated 19 December, 2008 in view of defaults allegedly committed by the Respondent in making payments due under the contract. Clause 8 of the agreement provides that in the event that the Respondent fails to make payment for a period of any one month during the term of the agreement, the Petitioner would be at liberty to terminate the agreement with notice of seven days. In that event, the Respondent is obligated to make good the losses and damages which may be suffered by the Petitioner. On the occurrence of such an event, the Respondent is liable to pay to the Petitioner on demand the entire royalty/minimum guaranteed amount mentioned in the agreement with interest at the rate of 18% per annum. Clause 8 is a provision for liquidated damages arising out a default on the part of the Respondent in paying the royalty and minimum guaranteed amount.

    7. A petition for winding up cannot be maintained upon a claim for damages. Damages become payable only when they are crystallized upon adjudication. Until and unless an adjudication takes place with a resultant decree for damages, there is no debt due and payable. Damages require adjudication. Until then, the liability of a party in alleged breach of a contract does not become crystallized.

    8. This position has been reiterated in a judgment of a Division Bench of the Karnataka High Court in Greenhills Exports (P) Ltd. v. Coffee Board 2 2001 106 Company Cases 391. Mr. Justice R.V Raveendran (as the Learned Judge then was) speaking for the Division Bench formulated the propositions of law which emerge from judgments of the Supreme Court and the High Court. The Court held as follows :

    “(i) A “Debt” is a sum of money which is now payable or will become payable in future by reason of a present obligation. The existing obligation to pay a sum of money is the sine qua non of a debt.

    “Damages” is money claimed by, or ordered to be paid to; a person as compensation for loss or injury. It merely remains a claim till adjudication by a court and becomes a “debt” when a court awards it.

    (ii) In regard to a claim for damages (whether liquidated or unliquidated), there is no “existing obligation” to pay any amount. No pecuniary liability in regard to a claim for damages, arises till a court adjudicates upon the claim for damages and holds that the defendant has committed breach and has incurred a liability to compensate the plaintiff for the loss and then assesses the quantum of such liability. An alleged default or breach gives rise only to a right to sue for damages and not to claim any “debt”. A claim for damages becomes a “debt due”, not when the loss is quantified by the party complaining of breach, but when a competent court holds on enquiry, that the person against whom the claim for damages is made, has committed breach and incurred a pecuniary liability towards the party complaining of breach and assesses the quantum of loss and awards damages. Damages are payable on account of a fiat of the court and not on account of quantification by the person alleging breach.

    (iii) When the contract does not stipulate the quantum of damages, the court will assess and award compensation in accordance with the principles laid down in section 73. Where the contract stipulates the quantum of damages or amounts to be recovered as damages, then the party complaining of breach can recover reasonable compensation, the stipulated amount being merely the outside limit.

    ……

    (v) Even if the loss is ascertainable and the amount claimed as damages has been calculated and ascertained in the manner stipulated in the contract, by the party claiming damages, that will not convert a claim for damages into a claim for an ascertained sum due. Liability to pay damages arises only when a party is found to have committed breach. Ascertainment of the amount awardable as damages is only consequential.”

    9. On behalf of the Petitioner, however, reliance was sought to be placed on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Saw Pipes (supra). The judgment of the Supreme Court in Saw Pipes (supra) holds that where the terms of a contract make an unambiguous stipulation for the payment of liquidated damages in the event of breach, a party guilty of a breach is required to pay compensation named in the contract unless it is held that the estimate of damages is unreasonable or by way of penalty. Paragraph 68 of the judgment which lays down the propositions of law contains the following

    “68. From the aforesaid discussions, it can be held that:

    (1) Terms of the contract are required to be taken into consideration before arriving at the conclusion whether the party claiming damages is entitled to the same.

    (2) If the terms are clear and unambiguous stipulating the liquidated damages in case of the breach of the contract unless it is held that such estimate of damages/compensation is unreasonable or is by way of penalty, party who has committed the breach is required to pay such compensation and that is what is provided in Section 73 of the Contract Act.

    (3) Section 74 is to be read along with Section 73 and, therefore, in every case of breach of contract, the person aggrieved by the breach is not required to prove actual loss or damage suffered by him before he can claim a decree. The court is competent to award reasonable compensation in case of breach even if no actual damage is proved to have been suffered in consequence of the breach of a contract.

    (4) In some contracts, it would be impossible for the court to assess the compensation arising from breach and if the compensation contemplated is not by way of penalty or unreasonable, the Court can award the same if it is genuine pre-estimate by the parties as the measure of reasonable compensation.”

    10. The judgment in Saw Pipes (supra) holds that if parties, observations : when they make a contract, know that a particular loss is likely to result from a breach, it is open to them to agree upon the payment of a named sum as compensation in the event of breach. In such a case it may not be necessary to lead evidence to prove damages unless the Court arrives at the conclusion that no loss is likely to occur by the breach. Where the Court comes to the conclusion that a term contemplating damages is by way of penalty, it would be open to the Court to grant reasonable compensation not exceeding the amount named in the contract on proof of damages. These observations of the Supreme Court will indicate that where a claim arises on account of damages for breach, the claim by its very nature requires adjudication by the Court. In Saw Pipes, as the facts of the case show, the proceedings before the Supreme Court arose upon an arbitral award which was challenged before the High Court under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. There was in that case an adjudication on the question of damages.

    11. If the clause in the present case is regarded as being a clause which stipulates the payment of a named sum by way of liquidated damages a debt will become crystallized only upon an adjudication of damages in a suit. Prior to an adjudication, it still constitutes a claim for damages. The decree of the Court is what transforms the claim into a stated sum due and payable by way of damages. Whether the amount is reasonable or by way of a penalty are evidential matters which cannot be decided in a petition for winding up. For, as the judgment in Saw Pipes holds, even if the sum stipulated by way of liquidated damages is clear, the jurisdiction of the Civil Court extends to determining whether it is unreasonable or by way of penalty. All these issues have to be decided in a suit. Whether or not evidential proof will be required to sustain such a claim is again a matter for the trial Court or, as the case may be, an arbitral forum to decide. The Petition for winding up would manifestly not be maintainable. Until an adjudication results in duly constituted proceedings, it cannot be held that there is a debt due and payable.

    12. For all these reasons, the Company Petition would have to be dismissed on the ground that it is not maintainable, leaving it open to the Petitioner to have recourse to its remedies in accordance with law. The Petition shall accordingly stand dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    E-City Media Private Limited v. Sadhrta Retail Limited
    (Nov 20, 2009)