Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Bombay Rent Act,
  • clauses (b) and (c). Rule
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Bombay Rent Act,
  • clauses (b) and (c). Rule
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a 71-year-old widow, filed Suit No. 912 of 1978 seeking possession of certain premises following the termination of tenancy on 31/07/1978. The suit was initially decreed in favor of the petitioner by the trial court on 27/04/1987. However, this decree was reversed by the District Court of Kolhapur in Regular Civil Appeal No. 172 of 1987, which dismissed the petitioner’s suit. The petitioner sought to occupy the ground floor premises to start a business, asserting a bona fide and reasonable need, which was contested by the tenant.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner’s bona fide and reasonable requirement of the premises justifies granting possession despite the tenant’s long occupation.
  2. Whether the tenant’s claimed hardship can override the landlord’s right to possession based on bona fide need.
  3. The determination of the correct standard rent payable for the premises.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner, as a widow aged 71, has a genuine and reasonable need to occupy the premises to start a business with family support.
  • The bona fide nature of her requirement is supported by ample material and should not be denied.
  • The tenant’s hardship claim is unfounded as the landlord is best placed to assess her own needs.
  • The petitioner’s need to occupy the ground floor premises in the city is reasonable and justifies eviction.

Respondent Tenant’s Arguments

  • The tenant claimed that eviction would cause greater hardship, particularly due to the disruption of his liquor business.
  • The tenant offered to provide alternate accommodation at his cost, suggesting accommodation of the landlord’s needs without eviction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Motor Motor Cycle House and Metro Cottage Industries, Pune and Anr. Vs. Kamlabai Dattatraya Kale & Ors., 2005 (3) Mh.L.J. 1109 Landlord’s bona fide and reasonable requirement of premises justifies eviction; hardship generally tilts in favor of landlord once bona fide need is proved. The court relied on this precedent to affirm that the landlord’s genuine need outweighs tenant’s hardship claims and supports eviction.
Narayan Rajaram Alchetty Vs. Balamma Baburao Shrirekam & Anr, 2005 Bom R.C. 426 Supports the principle of bona fide need of landlord for possession of premises. The court cited this case to reinforce the landlord’s right to possession based on bona fide and reasonable requirement.
Julieta Antonieta Tarcato Vs. Suleiman Ismail, 2008 (1) S.C.C. 173 Recognizes the landlord’s right to exclusive possession when bona fide and reasonable need is established. The court quoted this apex court observation to emphasize that it is unfair to compel a landlord to share accommodation when bona fide need is proved.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the bona fide and reasonable nature of the petitioner’s requirement to occupy the ground floor premises to start a business at her advanced age, supported by family assistance. It found the lower appellate court erred in dismissing the petitioner’s claim, as the petitioner had sufficiently demonstrated genuine need. The tenant’s assertion of hardship was deemed insufficient to override the landlord’s right, especially since the tenant’s business relocation was not a legally compelling hardship. The court emphasized that the landlord is the best judge of her requirements and that the tenant cannot dictate adjustments to the landlord’s needs. Citing relevant precedents, the court held that the landlord’s bona fide need for possession outweighs the tenant’s long occupation and goodwill. Regarding rent, the court found no perversity in accepting the agreed rent of Rs. 100/- per month as the standard rent, rejecting the appellate court’s fixation of Rs. 55/- as incorrect since the tenant had not filed a separate prayer under the Bombay Rent Act.

Holding and Implications

The court quashed and set aside the impugned appellate order dated 31/08/1991 and maintained the trial court’s decree dated 27/04/1987 granting possession to the petitioner. The petitioner’s bona fide and reasonable requirement was accepted as sufficient ground for eviction of the tenant. The agreed rent of Rs. 100/- per month was upheld as the standard rent. The judgment was stayed for two months on condition that no third-party rights or interests be created during the stay period.

The decision directly restores possession rights to the petitioner and corrects the appellate court’s errors, but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond the application of established principles regarding bona fide need and standard rent determination.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Mrs.Sharadabai Anandrao Durgule v. Smt.Bhyanabaibahinabai

    the tenancy accordingly on 31/07/1978. The Petitioner ( 3 ) filed Suit No.912 of 1978 for possession of the suit premises. The suit was resisted. The suit was decreed by an order dated 27/04/1987, on all counts.

    However, the District Court of Kolhapur in Regular Civil Appeal No. 172 of 1987 allowed the appeal and reverse the said decree of possession and dismissed the Petitioner's suit.

    3. The Petitioner who is aged 71 years widow have two grandsons and one grand-daughter from elder son, Shri Subhash Therefore, and his son Abhijit is a Auto Bike requirement for her own business alongwith Mechanic.

    other members of the families including two sons and two grand-sons just cannot be overlooked. The requirement to accommodate such members just cannot be overlooked. The grand mother at this age with financial and physical help of family wants to start some business, I see there is no reason to not consider her case, specially when the property at ground floor is situated in the midst of the city.

    The desire of starting business cannot be said to be dishonest or insincere. There is ample material to support her bonafide, reasonable and genuine need of the premises. The Appellate Court below erred in law to deny the rights to occupy premises for her bonafide ( 4 ) and reasonable need, when she has proved that the need is both genuine and reasonable. In the present facts and circumstances of the case, I am also convinced that the same is proved and the decree of eviction must follow on this ground of bonafide need.

    4. It is difficult to accept the case of Respondent tenant that he would suffer greater hardship. The landlady/landlord is the best judge of his/her requirement. The tenant cannot dictate that how they should to show adjust their need. There is nothing on record that the landlady's need is dishonest. The bonafide and reasonable requirement as stated and proved in the present case itself, in my view is sufficient to grant the decree on that ground. (Motor Motor Cycle House and Metro Cottage Industries, Pune and Anr. Vs. Kamlabai Dattatraya Kale & Ors., 2005 (3), Mh.L.J. 1109) 1109 and Narayan Rajaram Alchetty Vs. Balamma Baburao Shrirekam & Anr. 2005 Bom R.C. 426.

    5. The tenants long occupation and acquisition of the goodwill in the said premises should not prevail over the rights of landlord to occupy his or her premises.

    In the present case as noted, the Petitioner is staying in the said building and required the premises ( 5 ) of the ground floor in the same building just cannot be overlooked. The submission that she can start her business at any other place and the tenant is ready to provide the suitable accommodation at his costs to the landlord, is in no way can be the ground to hold that the hardship would cause to the tenant, as his liquor business would be required to be shifted from the said premises. As noted in Motor Cycle House and Metro Cottage Industries, Pune (Supra) that once the landlord has placed on the record the material evidence to support his bonafide and reasonable and as it is proved, the question of hardship normally need tilts in favour of the landlord. In the present case, it is in favour of the landlord. In view of the above facts and circumstances, the reasoning given by the lower Appellate Court on this ground, is also, therefore, incorrect.

    6. Therefore, I am of the view that the Plaintiff landlady has proved the reasonable and bonafide requirement of the premises and she would suffer greater hardship if the decree for the possession is not passed and therefore, Plaintiff-Petitioner entitled for the possession of the suit premises as prayed and as granted by the Trial Court by order ( 6 ) dates 27/04/1987. The Apex Court in Julieta Antonieta Tarcato Vs. Suleiman Ismail, 2008 (1) S.C.C. 173, has observed another facet of bonafide need as under:-

    . The appellant being the owner of the suit premises, her need being bona fide and reasonable, it would be unfair to compel her to share the accommodation in another premises with its co-owner."

    given With regard to the standard rent, the by the Trial Court as held that the agreed rent reasoning of Rs.100/- is the standard rent of the suit premises is correct. The Appellate Court held that the Respondent-Defendant was paying the rent and as given as per oral evidence of Defendant No.1 as per Rs.100/-

    last 30 years and never disputed this and I see there is no reason to disturb the agreed rent of Rs.100/-

    per month as a standard rent as ordered by the Trial Court. There is no perversity to hold agreed rent as a standard rent, specially in the present facts and circumstances of the case. Admittedly, the tenant did not file the separate prayer for fixing standard rent as per the provisions of the Bombay Rent Act, the reasoning given, therefore, by the Appellate Court ( 7 ) fixing the standard rent at Rs.55/- p.m. as it was fixed in the year 1970, is incorrect.

    8. Therefore, taking all this into account, the impugned order dated 31/08/1991 passed by the 5th Additional District Judge, Kolhapur is quashed and set aside and the impugned order and Judgment dated 27/04/1987 passed by the 2nd Jt. Civil Judge, Junior Division, Kolhapur is maintained.

    prayer In the result, the Petition is allowed in terms of clauses (b) and (c). Rule made absolute. No order as to costs.

    10. The learned counsel appearing for Respondent Nos.

    1 and 2, seeks stay of this Judgment. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, the effect and operation of this Judgment is stayed for two months on the condition that there shall not be any third party right and interest of whatsoever nature be created by the Respondents and parties in possession.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mrs.Sharadabai Anandrao Durgule v. Smt.Bhyanabaibahinabai
    (Dec 3, 2008)