: 25th August,2008.
DATE OF PRONOUNCEMENT
OF ORDER : 25th September,2008.
ORAL ORDER :
1. Heard the learned Counsel for the Applicant
and the learned Counsel for the respondent - NCB.
2. The applicant is seeking bail in NDPS
Special Case No.6 of 2008 of NCB pending before
the Special Judge for NDPS cases, Thane. The said
case is under Section 29 r/w. 9A and 25A of the
Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act,
..(2)..
1985.
3. The prosecution case briefly stated is that
specific information was received that one
Shahnawaz Khan with the help of two persons
including the applicant are manufacturing
pseudo-ephedrine which is a controlled substance
at Siddiqui Farm House in Thane. When the
officers reached the said place, they found the
present applicant along with others present there
and 290
controlled
kgs.
order dated 29.3.2008. Hence, this application.
4. Two grounds were raised by the learned
Counsel for the applicant. The first ground is
that at the time of filing of charge-sheet the
..(3)..
C.A. report was not filed. Thus an incomplete
charge-sheet was filed. At the time of filing of
charge-sheet as the C.A. report was not filed,
there was no material before the learned Judge to
come to the conclusion that the substance seized
was pseudo-ephedrine and hence the Court could not
have taken cognizance of the said case.
5. In order to appreciate the above
contention, it would be necessary to give a few
dates.
19.12.2007.
The charge-sheet came to be filed on
arrested on
13.2.2008. As the offence is made punishable
under Section 25A admittedly the charge-sheet
would have to be filed within 60 days i.e.
approximately on 19.2.2008. Though, the
charge-sheet was filed on 13.2.2008 at the time of
filing charge-sheet, no C.A. report was filed and
the C.A. report dated 28.3.2008 was produced
before the Court on 29.3.2008. The bail
application preferred by the applicant came to be
rejected on 29.3.2008.
6. It is contended by the learned Counsel for
the applicant that since the offences registered
..(4)..
against the applicant are punishable with a term
which may extend to 10 years. The case of the
applicant would fall within the ambit of section
167(2)(a)(ii) of the Code and the accused cannot
be detained in custody beyond the period of 60
days from the date of first remand of the
applicant i.e. 19.12.2007 if the charge-sheet is
not filed within the said period. It is contended
that the prosecution ought to have filed the
charge-sheet as contemplated under Section 173(2)
and (5)
However,
of the Code within a period of 60
in the instant case, though
days.
the
charge-sheet is filed by the prosecution on
13.2.2008 i.e. within 60 days from the date of
first remand of the applicant, the same being
incomplete as it was not accompanied with the
documents contemplated under sub-section (5) of
section 173 of the Code, cannot be treated as a
charge-sheet/report, which would empower the Court
to take cognizance of the offences and hence
applicant is entitled to be released on bail in
view of provisions of section 167(2) of the Code.
7. Thus, it was submitted that when the
charge-sheet was filed as the C.A. report was not
..(5)..
filed, it amounted to filing of an incomplete
charge-sheet which cannot be said to be a
charge-sheet within the meaning of Section 173(5)
of Cr.P.C. and as the charge-sheet, as
contemplated under Section 173 of Cr.P.C. was not
filed within the stipulated period of 60 days a
right accrued to the accused to seek release on
bail. In support of this contention, reliance was
placed on a decision of a Single Judge of this
High Court in the case of Sunil Vasantrao
Phulbande
reported
and another v. State
in 2005 Drugs Cases (Narcotics) 32.
learned Counsel for the applicant pointed out that
the said case was also under the NDPS Act. In the
said case also within the stipulated time complete
charge-sheet was not filed. In the said case,
C.A. report was filed beyond the stipulated
period of 90 days and prior to that only
incomplete charge-sheet with all other papers
except C.A. report was filed. In the said case,
the accused came to be released on bail on the
ground that the C.A. report was not filed within
the stipulated time.
8. The learned Counsel for the applicant
..(6)..
submitted that in a case under the NDPS Act report
of the C.A. is the foundation on the basis of
which the Court can proceed to take cognizance of
the offence. It was contended that the Chemical
Analyser's report is the basis to decide whether
the substance seized during the raid falls under
Section 9A or not, which would determine whether
the provisions of NDPS Act are attracted or not.
release on bail under Section 167(2) of Cr.P.C..
9. Reliance is also placed on a decision of
another Single Judge of this Court in the case of
Sharadchandra Vinayak Dongre and others v. State
of Maharashtra reported in 1991 Mh.L.J.656.
the incomplete charge-sheet cannot be treated as a
police report within the meaning of Sub-Section
(2) of Section 173 of Cr.P.C. and there is no
question of Magistrate taking cognizance of the
offence within meaning of Section 190(1)(b) of
Cr.P.C. on the basis of the incomplete
charge-sheet. The said case was under the Bombay
Prohibition Act. In this case, admittedly, the
stated
charge-sheet was incomplete as it was specifically
therein that the investigation is not yet
completed. Consequently, it was held that
incomplete charge-sheet cannot be treated as
police-report. However, such is not the case in
the present case, hence, this decision cannot
apply in the present case.
10. Thereafter, reliance was placed on an
unreported decision of a Single Judge of this
Court Panaji Bench dated 18.7.1998 in the case of
Joaquim M. Correia v. State of Goa passed in
Criminal Misc.Application No.88 of 1998. The said
case was under the NDPS Act involving charas. In
the said case, the entire charge-sheet having been
..(8)..
filed in time, the said decision would not be
applicable to the facts of the present case.
11. Reliance was also placed on a decision of a
Single Judge of this Court dated 22nd December,
2006 in the case of Ms.Malin Lundberg Isabelle v.
the Special Judge on 10th May, 2006.
2006. The Court held that as the charge-sheet was
not filed within time the applicant was entitled
to be released on bail. However, as no such
situation has arisen in the present matter, this
decision too would not be applicable to the facts
of the present case.
..(9)..
12. On the backdrop of above facts and
decisions, the question which arises for my
consideration in the present case is whether mere
filing of charge-sheet within the prescribed time,
unaccompanied by material papers as contemplated
under Section 173(5) of the Code renders it
incomplete and such filing of charge-sheet amounts
to failure to file the same, which in turn confers
on the accused right to be released on bail under
be
section 167(2) of the Code, as the Court would not
competent to take cognizance of the offence on
the basis of such incomplete charge-sheet/report.
13. On perusal of all the decisions, it is seen
that in the said cases there is no reference to
test of the contraband at the spot by field test
kit. In the present case, the complaint as well
as panchnama specifically mention about field
testing kit being taken to the spot and the
samples of the seized material being tested at the
spot using field testing kit and the test
answering positive for pseudo-ephedrine. In Sunil
Phulbande's case (supra) which is a case similar
to the present case, there is no reference at all
..(10)..
to any test kit report.
14. Useful reference may be made to the
decision of the Supreme Court in the case of
Jagdish Budhroji Purohit vs. State of Maharashtra
reported in AIR 1998 SUPREME COURT 3328.
"Moreover, in this case the prosecution had
led evidence on P.W.1 Vijay Kumar Shahasane
and P.W.3 Sidram Dhange, members of the
raiding party, to prove that the powder
which was found from the factory was
Methaqualone and that the tablets which
were found from the factory were
methaqualone tablets. Both of them have
stated that they have received sufficient
training and thus have sufficient knowledge
about narcotic substance and the methods of
testing them. They had carried with them a
kit for the purpose of testing when they
had raided the factory. On analysis by
them the powder was found to be
..(11)..
methaqualone and tablets were found
containing methaqualone. Therefore, even
if Exhibits 61 to 67 are ignored there is
sufficient evidence on record to show that
methaqualone powder and tablets were found
from the appellant's factory. Thus the
appellant's conviction under Section 22 of
the N.D.P.S. Act is quite proper. Both
the witnesses have further stated that on
analysis the green substance which was
found
Therefore,
from one of the cabins was
conviction of the
hashish.
appellant
under Section 20(b)(ii) of the N.D.P.S.
Act is also quite proper."
15. From the above decision, it is seen that
even if there is any lacuna in the C.A. report
the report of the field testing kit conducted by
the officers can be relied upon to convict the
accused. If the report of the field testing kit
can be relied upon to convict the accused then in
the present case where similar test was conducted
it cannot be said that an incomplete charge-sheet
was filed on 13.2.2008. The charge-sheet
forwarded to the Court on that day contained
..(12)..
material which was sufficient for the Court to
take cognizance of the offence. The material
before the Court was sufficient for the Court to
proceed further and to take cognizance as the
material on record on that day clearly showed that
290 kgs. of pseudo-ephedrene came to be seized
and the involvement of applicant and other accused
was also seen from the material in the
charge-sheet filed on 13.2.2008.
16.
Court
In the case of Sunil Phulbande (supra) this
observed that
The charge-sheet / report as
contemplated under Section 173(5) of the Code,
forwarded to the Magistrate should be such that on
the basis of which Magistrate should be able to
proceed further and take cognizance.
It was
further observed that in a given case, certain
documents even though they may not accompany the
charge-sheet may not change the nature of the
charge-sheet/report contemplated under Section
173(2) and (5) of the Code particularly when the
material is sufficient for the Court to take
cognizance of the offence as per the provisions of
the Code. In the present case, on 13.2.2008 there
was sufficient material before the Court to take
..(13)..
cognizance. Moreover, the C.A. report which was
produced on 29.3.2008 was not such as to change
the nature of the charge-sheet in this case.
17. In the present case the material at the
time of filing of the charge-sheet on 13.2.2008
clearly showed that 290 kgs. of pseudo-ephedrine
was found and the applicant was very much present
in the farm house where the pseudo-ephedrine was
found. Thus, at the time of filing charge-sheet
the
accused was made aware of the exact nature of
the offence alleged against him, so also the Court
was aware of the exact nature of the offence
alleged against the accused. Thus, there is no
question of causing any prejudice to the accused.
In the present case, the applicant has not
contended that he has been prejudiced in any
manner as the C.A. report was not filed along
with the charge-sheet. No such pleading infact
has been taken by the applicant. As observed
earlier, there was sufficient material before the
Court and also made known to the accused regarding
the prosecution case against the accused.
18. Useful reference may be made to the
..(14)..
decision of the Supreme Court in the case of
Dinesh Dalmia Vs. CBI reported in (2008) 1
Supreme Court Cases (Cri) 36.
36 In the said case
also an incomplete charge-sheet came to be filed.
In the said case, it was observed that :
"It is true that ordinarily all documents
accompany the charge-sheet. But, in this
case, some documents could not be filed
which were not in the possession of CBI.
arrested on 12.2.2006. The appellant does
not contend that he has been prejudiced by
not filing of such documents with the
charge-sheet. No such plea in fact had
been taken. Even if all the documents had
not been filed, by reason thereof
submission of charge-sheet itself does not
become vitiated in law."
19. Indisputably, the power of the
Investigating Officer to make a prayer for making
further investigation in terms of Sub-Section (8)
..(15)..
of Section 173 is not taken away only because a
charge-sheet under Sub-Section (2) thereof has
been filed. A further investigation is
permissible even if order of cognizance of offence
has been taken by the Magistrate. In the case of
Dinesh Dalmia (supra), it has been further
observed that :
"We may notice that a Constitution Bench of
this Court in K.Veeraswami v. Union of
:
India stated the law in the following terms
(SCC p.716, para 76)
"76..... As observed by this Court in
Satya Narain Musadi v. State of Bihar that
the statutory requirement of the report
under Section 173(2) would be complied with
if the various details prescribed therein
are included in the report. This report is
an intimation to the Magistrate that upon
investigation into a cognizable offence the
investigating officer has been able to
procure sufficient evidence for the court
to inquire into the offence and the
necessary information is being sent to the
..(16)..
court. In fact, the report under Section
173(2) purports to be an opinion of the
investigating officer that as far as he is
concerned he has been able to procure
sufficient material for the trial of the
accused by the court. The report is
complete if it is accompanied with all the
documents and statements of witnesses as
required by Section 175(5). Nothing more
need be stated in the report of the
investigating
necessary that
officer.
the case by adducing acceptable evidence."
20. The charge-sheet is an intimation to the
Magistrate that upon investigation into a
cognizable case the investigating officer has been
able to procure sufficient evidence for the Court
to enquire into the offence and the necessary
information is being sent to the Court. A
charge-sheet is a final report within the meaning
..(17)..
of sub-section (2) of Section 173 of the Code. It
is filed so as to enable the Court concerned to
apply its mind as to whether cognizance of the
offence thereupon should be taken or not. The
report is ordinarily filed in the form prescribed
therefor. One of the requirement for submission
of a police report is whether any offence appears
to have been committed and, if so, by whom. In
this case from the material available before the
Court on 13.02.2008, it was clear that an offence
had been
committed under Section 25 of the
Act and the applicant was involved in the offence.
Investigating Officer to produce the same with the
permission of the Court." It was further observed
that "the word 'shall' used in sub-section (5)
cannot be interpreted as mandatory, but as
..(18)..
directory. Normally, the documents gathered
during the investigation upon which the
prosecution wants to rely are required to be
forwarded to the Magistrate, but if there is some
omission, it would not mean that the remaining
documents cannot be produced subsequently.
Further, the scheme of sub-section (8) of Section
173 also makes it absolutely clear that even after
the charge-sheet is submitted, further
investigation, if called for, is not precluded.
iginvestigation of an offence cannot be
considered to be inconclusive merely for
the reason that the investigating officer,
when he submitted his report in terms of
sub-sec. (2) of S.173 to the Magistrate,
still awaited the reports of the experts or
by some chance, either inadvertently or by
design, he failed to append to the police
report such documents or the statements
under S.161 of the Code, although these
were available with him when he submitted
the police report to the Magistrate.
Therefore, when a charge-sheet is submitted
without the reports of experts well within
..(20)..
the period of 60 days from the date of
arrest, the accused is not entitled to be
released on bail under Section 167(2).
. It was further observed that :
... Since a report to qualify itself to be
a 'police report' is required to contain
only such facts as are mentioned in
sub-section (2) of S.173, so if once it is
found
those
that the police report contained all
facts, then so far as the
investigation is concerned the same has to
be considered to have been completed. It
is not incumbent on the investigating
officer to reduce in writing the statements
of the witnesses; he may merely include
their names in the list of witnesses in
support of the prosecution case when
submitting the charge-sheet. Surely, if
the charge-sheet thus submitted would be
complete as enabling the Magistrate to take
cognizance of the offence, there is no
rational basis for holding that similar
charge-sheet would not be a police report
..(21)..
of the requisite kind if the statements of
the witnesses although had been recorded
under S.161 (3), but either by design or by
inadvertence are not appended with the
report and that the investigation of the
case for that reason alone would be
considered to be incomplete thus entitling
the accused to claim release on bail in
view of the proviso to sub-sec. (2) of
Section 167 of the Code if his detention
had
exceeded
investigation
sixty days.
the report of the expert, so far as his job
of collecting of the evidence is concerned,
that is over the moment he despatches the
material for the opinion of the expert and
incidentally cites him as a witness if he
..(22)..
relies on his testimony."
23. From the decisions referred to above,
including that of the Supreme Court, it is clear
that it is open to the investigating agency to
file further documents even after the charge-sheet
has been filed. In the present case, as stated
earlier, samples in question were tested on the
spot and on testing the report showed that the
material was pseudo-ephedrine which is a
controlled
filed on
substance. When the charge-sheet
13.2.2008, it contained all necessary
was
material as contemplated under Section 173(5) of
Cr.P.C. and the prosecution is not precluded from
filing any additional material like the C.A.
report at a later stage. Filing of C.A. report
has not changed the nature of the offence or the
charge-sheet. Thus, there was sufficient material
to connect the accused with the offence and there
was sufficient material before the Court on
13.2.2008 to take cognizance of the offence. In
the present case even though the report of the
C.A. was not filed, it cannot be said that an
incomplete charge-sheet has been filed and hence
the learned Magistrate could not have taken
..(23)..
cognizance. Looking to all these facts, I am of
the opinion that the applicant is not entitled to
bail under the provisions of Section 167(2) of
Cr.P.C.
24. The second ground canvassed before me is
that there is an amendment to the NDPS Act
including Section 37. In cases of offences under
section 19 or 24 or 27a and offences involving
commercial quantity an accused would not be
released
that there
on
ig bail unless the Court
are reasonable grounds for
is satisfied
believing
that the accused is not guilty of such offence.
The present applicant is facing prosecution for
charges under Sections 25A and 29 read with 9A of
the N.D.P.S. Act and hence obviously his case
would not be covered under Section 37 of the NDPS
Act. Moreover, as far as Section 9A which deals
with controlled substance is concerned, there is
no categorisation of small quantity or commercial
quantity. Therefore, it was contended by the
learned Counsel for the applicant, and in my view
rightly so, that the concept of commercial
quantity is applicable only to narcotic drugs and
psychotropic substances and not to controlled
..(24)..
substances.
25. section 9a of the ndps act deals with the
power to control and regulate controlled
substance. "Controlled substance" means any
substance which the Central Government may, having
regard to the available information as to its
possible use in the production or manufacture of
narcotic drugs or psychotropic substances or to
the provisions of any international Convention, by
notification
be a
controlled
in the official Gazette, declare
substance. The Ministry
to
of
Finance Department of Revenue vide its
notification dated 28th December, 1999 has
declared pseudo-ephedrine a controlled substance
under the Act. The Central Government being of
the opinion that having regard to the use of the
controlled substances in the production or
manufacture of any narcotic drug or psychotropic
substance, it is necessary or expedient so to do
in the public interest, in exercise of powers
conferred by Section 9A of the Act has made the
Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances
(Regulation of Controlled Substance) Order, 1993,
which has come into force w.e.f. 15th April,
..(25)..
1993.
26. A controlled substance is not necessarily
used only to make narcotic drugs or psychotropic
substance, but, it is a versatile substance which
can be used in manufacturing of various things
including innocuous medicines by the
pharmaceutical industry. As far as controlled
substances are concerned, there is no provision
for minimum term of imprisonment unlike sections
19, 24 and 27A of the N.D.P.S.Act.
27. In the decision of this Court in the case
of Shreeniwas Bansidhar Somani vs. The
Intelligence Officer NCB and another dated 14th
February, 2002 in Criminal Application No.181 of
2002, 1250 kgs. of Acetic Anhydride came to be
seized which is a controlled substance. Acetic
Anhydride is used to manufacture brown-sugar i.e.
heroin. In the said case, this Court held that
Acetic Anhydride being a controlled substance,
rigors of section 37 of ndps act would not be
attracted and bail came to be granted to the
accused in the said case. It is pointed out that
the quantity of the controlled substance in the
..(26)..
present case is lesser than the quantity in the
case of Shreeniwas Bansidhar (supra) and hence the
applicant is entitled to be released on bail.
28. There is extensive amendment introduced in
N.D.P.S. Act. The offence falling under section
9A r/w. section 25A is punishable with
imprisonment which may extend to 10 years and also
fine which also may extend to Rs.1 lakh. There
was an embargo on the powers of the Court in
granting
37(1)(b) of
bail under the old provisions of section
the Act. From section 37(1)(b) the
term "imprisonment of 5 years or more" has been
deleted and substituted by "for offence under
section 19 or section 24 or section 27A and also
for offences involving commercial quantity", the
case of the applicant is no more covered by
section 37(1)(b) of the Act. The concept of
commercial quantity does not apply to controlled
substance in view of the provisions relating to
commercial quantity specially section 2(viia) and
section 2(viid) of the Act and the notification
issued by the Government specifying the small
quantities and commercial quantities also shows
that this concept is peculiar to Narcotic Drugs
..(27)..
and Psychotropic Substances.
29. In view of the above legal position and the
decision in the case of Shreeniwas Bansidhar
Somani (supra),
(supra) I am inclined to grant bail to the
applicant.
30. The applicant - Rafael Palafox Garcia to be
released on bail in the sum of Rs.1,00,000/-
Before being released on bail the
be
applicant shall inform the NCB office the address
at which he will reside during the period that he
is on bail. Any change in the address shall also
be communicated to the NCB within two days. The
applicant shall report to the NCB office once in a
week, till conclusion of the trial.
31. Criminal Application is disposed of
accordingly.
(SMT.V.K.TAHILRAMANI,J.)