Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Regulation 12 of Medical Council of India Regulations the rule
  • passing.11. Rules 56 and 57 of Ordinance 01/2002 (Amended)
  • Rule with the Regulation of Medical Council of India.7.
  • INDIAN MEDICAL COUNCIL ACT 1956
  • Rules 56 and 57 of Ordinance 01 of 2002
  • State Act. Regulation 12
  • Rule 56.2.1(iii)
  • Rule 57(D)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Regulation 12 of Medical Council of India Regulations the rule
  • passing.11. Rules 56 and 57 of Ordinance 01/2002 (Amended)
  • Rule with the Regulation of Medical Council of India.7.
  • INDIAN MEDICAL COUNCIL ACT 1956
  • Rules 56 and 57 of Ordinance 01 of 2002
  • State Act. Regulation 12
  • Rule 56.2.1(iii)
  • Rule 57(D)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — F.I. Rebello, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitions arise from candidates pursuing the M.B.B.S. course in colleges affiliated to the Maharashtra University of Health Sciences (the University). The petitioners had passed earlier professional examinations including Third M.B.B.S. (Part I) and appeared for Third M.B.B.S. (Part II) examinations conducted by the University in December 2005, with results declared on 18-2-2006. Several petitioners were shown as failed in subjects “General Surgery” or “General Medicine”; their mark-sheets (displayed on the University website and provided to students) indicated failure in the practical paper of those subjects.

The legal dispute centers on the method of assessment and standard of passing, in particular the treatment of internal assessment marks under Regulation 12 of the Medical Council of India’s (MCI) "Regulations on Graduate Medical Education, 1997" and the University’s Rules (notably Rules 56 and 57 of Ordinance 01/2002, amended by notifications in 2006). Prior litigation at this High Court (Writ Petition No. 5725 of 2003 and others) resulted in a Division Bench decision on 12-12-2003 (Ms. Sheetal A. Abhyankar). A Kerala High Court Division Bench had earlier taken a different view (K. Fahad Mohamed v. Calicut University, 25-9-2002). The present petitions challenge the amended Rule 57 (as notified 20-2-2006) and seek relief based on the interpretation and primacy of MCI Regulation 12.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Rule 57 of the University's Ordinance (as amended) is consistent with or ultra vires Regulation 12 of the Medical Council of India’s Regulations on Graduate Medical Education, 1997.
  2. Whether internal assessment marks constitute an independent head of passing (requiring 50% thereon) or are to be added to theory and practical marks respectively, with internal assessment having only a 35% eligibility threshold.
  3. Whether the Court should follow the earlier Division Bench decision in Writ Petition No. 5725 of 2003 (Ms. Sheetal A. Abhyankar) or depart from it in light of (a) subsequent amendment of the Rules, (b) a clarification issued by the MCI dated 17-9-2002, and (c) persuasive decisions of courts of co-ordinate jurisdiction (e.g., the Kerala High Court).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Case

  • The petitioners presented the factual position that, on the declared results for the Third M.B.B.S. (Part II), they had failed in the practical paper (General Surgery or General Medicine) as reflected on their mark-sheets.
  • Implicit in the petitions is a challenge to the University’s treatment of internal assessment and/or the calculation that led to their failures.

Medical Council of India (Respondent No. 1) — Submissions

  • The MCI submitted that Regulations framed under section 33 of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 are statutory, binding and mandatory on Universities and medical institutions (relying on apex court authorities mentioned in the affidavit).
  • The MCI framed the "Regulations on Graduate Medical Education, 1997" and the distribution of marks shows internal assessment is separately marked (Theory-20; Practical-20) but, by the MCI’s clarification, internal assessment marks are to be clubbed with practical/clinical performance (and theory internal marks with theory/oral) rather than treated as a separate passing head.
  • The MCI pointed to a clarification dated 17-9-2002 and exhibited the distribution of marks to show how internal assessment is to be allocated and added to theory/practical totals.
  • The MCI contended that internal assessment primarily has a 35% requirement as eligibility for appearing in the final University examination but does not itself form an independent head requiring 50% to pass.

University — Submissions

  • The University relied on Rules 56 and 57 of Ordinance 01/2002 (as originally framed) and on the earlier Division Bench decision of this Court (Ms. Sheetal A. Abhyankar, 12-12-2003) holding those rules not inconsistent with Regulation 12, such that a student must pass in three heads (Theory; Practical/Clinical; Internal Assessment) with 50% in each.
  • The University noted that students sign examination forms acknowledging they have reviewed the syllabus, Ordinance and Rules, and argued petitioners could not challenge longstanding Rules applied previously.
  • The University pointed out that the internal assessment passing requirement had been reduced to 35% by the MCI via notification dated 15-10-2003.
  • After the earlier Division Bench decision, the University amended Rule 57 by notification dated 20-2-2006; the present petitions challenge that amended Rule.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
MCI v. State of Karnataka, (1998) 6 SCC 131 Authority for the proposition that Regulations framed by the Medical Council of India under section 33 are statutory in character and binding. The Court treated MCI regulations as statutory/subordinate legislation with binding force on Universities and relied on that principle in assessing whether University Rules conflicted with Regulation 12.
Dr. Preeti Srivastava v. State of M.P., (1999) 7 SCC 120 Also cited to support the statutory character and binding effect of MCI regulations made under section 33. Used to reinforce the legal status of MCI regulations when determining the validity of University Rules inconsistent with those regulations.
Ms. Sheetal A. Abhyankar v. Maharashtra University of Health Sciences — Writ Petition No. 5725 of 2003 (Division Bench, 12-12-2003) [reported 2004 (2) Mh. L.J 689] Held that Rules 56 and 57 were not inconsistent with Regulation 12 and that a candidate must obtain 50% in each of the three heads (Theory, Practical, Internal Assessment). The Court examined whether to follow that earlier Division Bench decision but found that decision related to the earlier form of the Rules; the present case concerns the amended Rule 57 and additional materials (MCI clarification, Kerala decision) which justified re-examination.
K. Fahad Mohamed v. Calicut University (Kerala High Court, 25-9-2002; W.A. No. 1777 of 2002) Held that internal marks must be added to respective subject (theory/practical) aggregates and that a candidate passes if 50% is obtained in (University theory + orals + internal assessment theory) and 50% in (University practicals + internal assessment practicals/clinicals). The Court considered this decision persuasive: it supported the MCI's clarification and the Court accepted the approach that internal assessment marks are to be added to theory/practical marks rather than forming an independent passing head.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by identifying the nature of the instruments involved: the MCI Regulations are subordinate (statutory) legislation made under a Central Act (Indian Medical Council Act, 1956) and University Rules are subordinate legislation under a State Act. Where inconsistency exists, the Central Act-derived Regulations prevail.

The Court examined Regulation 12 of the MCI Regulations (both the distribution of marks under Regulation 12(4) and provisions on internal assessment under Regulation 12(2)). It noted that Regulation 12(2)(iv) prescribes weightage for internal assessment as 20% of total marks in each subject and Regulation 12(2)(v) requires a student to secure at least 35% of the total marks fixed for internal assessment as eligibility to appear in the final University examination.

The Court emphasized the MCI's clarification (Exhibit R-1/1 dated 17-9-2002) which explained that although internal assessment is separately marked (Theory 20; Practical 20), those internal assessment marks are to be clubbed with the respective performance (theory with theory/oral; practical internal marks with practical/clinical) and do not constitute an independent passing head. The Court held that this interpretation was consistent with the language of Regulation 12(2)(iv) — internal assessment is expressed as a percentage of total marks in each subject — and with the distribution table showing how totals are assembled.

The Court gave persuasive weight to the Kerala High Court decision (K. Fahad Mohamed) which had reached the same conclusion (internal marks to be added to relevant aggregates). The Court also observed that the earlier Division Bench of this Court (Ms. Sheetal A. Abhyankar) had not adverted to the MCI clarification or the Kerala decision and had considered the earlier form of Rules 56 and 57; by contrast, the present case concerned amended Rule 57 notified on 20-2-2006.

The Court applied the principle that when the maker of subordinate legislation (here, the MCI) clarifies the meaning of its own regulation, courts should accept that interpretation unless it is absurd or clearly contrary to the Regulation or the parent Act. Finding no such absurdity or clear contradiction, the Court accepted the MCI’s elucidation that internal assessment marks are to be added to theory and practical marks at the final examination and that internal assessment as a separate head is limited to a 35% eligibility threshold.

The Court concluded that the amended Rule 57 (specifically Rule 57(D) in Notification No. 05/2006 dated 20-2-2006), which treated internal assessment as an independent head of passing requiring 50%, is inconsistent with Regulation 12 and therefore ultra vires. The Court held that the marks obtained in internal assessment (both theory and practical) must be added to the theory + oral and practical/clinical marks respectively, and that candidates must obtain 50% in theory and practical and a 50% aggregate as per the MCI Regulations as clarified.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court declared that Rule 57(D) (as amended by Notification No. 05/2006 dated 20-2-2006) is ultra vires Regulation 12 of the Medical Council of India Regulations and therefore void to the extent it treats Internal Assessment as an independent head of passing requiring 50% marks.

Direct consequences and orders given by the Court:

  • The marks obtained in the Internal Assessment (theory and practical) must be added to the marks obtained in the final University examinations for theory + oral and practical/clinical respectively, in accordance with Regulation 12 and the MCI clarification.
  • Candidates must obtain 50% in theory (including orals) and 50% in practical/clinical in the subject and also a 50% aggregate as per the MCI Regulations as interpreted by the Court.
  • The University is directed to recalculate marks in accordance with this interpretation.
  • The petitions were made absolute in terms of the petitioners' prayer clauses (a), (b), (e) and partly in terms of prayer clause (c) to the extent of Rule 57(D) in Notification No. 05/2006 dated 20-2-2006. The Court concluded with the operative order: "Order accordingly." (i.e., the relief prayed to the extent indicated was allowed).

Implications beyond the parties: The opinion is focused on the direct effect on the University Rules and on recalculation of individual results; the Court based its holding on the primacy of the MCI Regulations and their clarification. The opinion does not purport to set a novel principle beyond affirming that subordinate University rules inconsistent with MCI Regulations are ultra vires and must yield to the latter; the decision's immediate effect is declaratory and remedial for the affected candidates (recalculation consistent with Regulation 12).

Order accordingly.
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Laya Binaykumar Pandey v. Medical Council Of India And Others

    F.I Rebello, J.:— All these petitions are being disposed of by a common order as the issue involved is the same. The petitioners are prosecuting their M.B.B.S Course in colleges affiliated to the Maharashtra University of Health Sciences (hereinafter referred to as University), having been admitted to a medical course. It is the case of the petitioners that they have passed their first and second M.B.B.S examinations. They have also passed third M.B.B.S (Part-I) examination. They appeared for third M.B.B.S (Part II) examinations conducted by the University in December, 2005, the results of which were declared on 18-2-2006. In the result declared, some petitioners were declared to have failed in the subject “General Surgery” and some petitioners in the subject “General Medicine”. The mark-sheets were displayed on the website of the University and the copies of the same were also provided to the students. It is the case of the petitioners that on perusal of the mark sheets, it would reveal that the petitioners had either failed in the practical paper of the subject “General Surgery” and or “General Medicine” and as such had been declared to have failed in the said examination.

    2. The respondent No. 1 Medical Council of India is a statutory body established under the provisions of Indian Medical Council Act, 1956. The act is a central legislation enacted by Parliament. Under section 33 of the Act, the Council is empowered to frame regulations in a manner provided, so as to achieve the object provided under the Act. The regulations framed by the Medical Council of India under section 33 are thus made binding on all the Universities and medical institutions imparting medical training and/or conferring degrees. The institutions which conduct medical courses must do so in confirmity with the regulations framed by the Medical Council of India. No medical institution or University, it is submitted, can ignore the mandatory regulations framed by the above statutory body and/or can frame its Rules which are contrary or inconsistent with the regulations framed by the Medical Council of India. The Medical Council of India under its regulations framed under section 33 has framed regulations, which impel and include the commencement and duration of the course and the method of assessment and standard of passing. In the instant case we are concerned with the regulation prescribed by the Council in relation to the method of assessment and standard of passing. The Medical Council has framed regulations on graduate medical examination in the year 1997, in exercise of the powers conferred under section 33 of the Act. The regulations inter alia provide for the manner in which students are to be tested in the examinations, distribution of the marks in each paper and the minimum marks required for declaring the student as having passed in the subject and course. In terms of the regulations framed, the distribution of marks in the various disciplines is as under:

    “12(4) DISTRIBUTION OF MARKS TO VARIOUS DISCIPLINES:

    (A) First Professional examination: (Pre-clinical Subjects):—

    (a) Anatomy: Theory-Two papers of 50 marks each. (One applied question of 10 marks in each paper) 100 marks Oral (Viva) 20 marks Practical 40 marks Internal Assessment (Theory-20;Practical-20) 40 marks Total 200 marks (b) Physiology including Biophysics Theory-Two papers of 50 marks each (One applied question of 10 marks in each paper) 100 marks Oral (Viva) 20 marks Practical 40 marks Internal Assessment (Theory-20; Practical-20) 40 marks Total 200 marks (c) Biochemistry : Theory-Two papers of 50 marks each (One applied question of 10 marks in each paper) 100 marks Oral (Viva) 20 marks Practical 40 marks Internal Assessment (Theory-20; Practical-20) 40 marks Total 200 marks

    Pass: In each of the subjects, a candidate must obtain 50% in aggregate with a minimum of 50% in Theory including orals and minimum of 50% in Practicals.”

    3. We may also gainfully referred to Regulation 12(2) which reads as under:

    “12(2) INTERNAL ASSESSMENT:

    (i) it shall be based on day to-day assessment (see note), evaluation of student assignment, preparation for seminar, clinical case presentation etc.;

    (ii) regular periodical examinations shall be conducted throughout the course. The question of number of examinations is left to the institution;

    (iii) day to day records should be given importance during internal assessment;

    (iv) weightage for the internal assessment shall be 20% of the total marks in each subject;

    (v) student must secure at least 35% marks of the total marks fixed for internal assessment in a particular subject in order to be eligible to appear in final university examination of that subject.”

    4. It is submitted that on reading of the said regulation, it would be clear that to pass the examination, the candidate must obtain 50% of the aggregate marks in theory + oral + internal assessment of theory and 50% of the aggregate marks in practical + internal assessment/clinical. The regulation also provides for grace marks to be awarded. The 35% requirement enables the student to appear for the University final examination.

    5. The University had earlier framed regulations, we are concerned with Regulations 56.2 and 57, which reads as under:

    “56.2 Heads of passing of various courses in their respective faculties will be as under:—

    56.2.1 Medical

    i. Theory + Oral

    ii. Practical

    iii. Internal Assessment (Theory + Practical)

    57. The standard of passing: A candidate to be eligible to pass the examination must have obtained not less than 50% of marks in each of the heads of the respective subject.”

    6. The University in 2003 followed regulations 56 and 57 in declaring the results of the final examination. Several students aggrieved, filed Petitions before this Court i.e Writ Petition No. 5725 of 2003 and other Writ Petitions. A learned Division Bench of this Court, was pleased to dispose of the Writ Petitions by order dated 12th December, 2003. The learned Division Bench was pleased to observe as under:

    “The requirement of obtaining 50% of the total marks fixed for Internal Assessment is clearly spelt out by Regulation 12. What has been provided by Rule 57 is same. That is to say a candidate must obtain not less than 50% of the total marks prescribed for Theory, Practical and Internal Assessment separately. It only explains what has been ordered by Medical Council of India. Medical Council of India asserts that he must secure 50% of marks. University asserts he must secure so in each of the three heads. This cannot therefore be termed as inconsistent Rule with the Regulation of Medical Council of India.”

    7. After so saying, the learned Bench was pleased to observe that in its opinion, there is no inconsistency nor can it be inferred from Regulation 12, that the Council always desired to club internal assessment in theory and practicals. Regulation 12 clearly provides for different marks for such heads. After so holding the learned Division Bench was pleased to observe that Rules 56 and 57 of Ordinance No. 1 of 2002 as framed by the Health University are not in any manner inconsistent with Regulation 12 as framed by the Council, insofar as they required a student to pass all the three heads with 50% marks i.e (1) theory, (2) practical and (3) internal assessment. In view of that, the Petitions came to be dismissed.

    8. The very issue and regulations of Medical Council of India were also in issue before a learned Division Bench of the Kerala High Court. A learned Bench of the Kerala High Court considered the affidavit filed by one Dr. K.K Arora, Joint Secretary of Medical Council of India and also considered the clarification issued by the Medical Council of India. The learned Division Bench while disposing of the petition was pleased to hold as under:

    “6. In the result, we hold that under the Regulations a candidate shall be declared to have passed if he has got 50% of the aggregate marks in University theory + orals + internal assessment theory and 50% of the aggregate marks in University practicals + internal assessment practicals/clinicals.”

    9. In other words, insofar as the Kerala High Court is concerned the view taken was that internal marks must be added to the respective subjects in theory and practicals and then the aggregate of 50% should be worked out. This judgment was pronounced on 25th September, 2002. It appears that this judgment considering that Medical Council is an All India body and the Act is a Central Act was not brought to the attention of the learned Bench of this Court which decided the earlier batch of petitions. Counsel for the respondent University states that it was brought to the notice, but we find no reference to the judgment, in the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court.

    10. Subsequent to the judgment of this Court, the University has amended Rule 57 of the ordinance as can be seen from Notification dated 20-2-2006 and the Rule 57 of the ordinance now reads as under:

    “‘HEAD OF PASSING’ AND ‘STANDARD OF PASSING’ WILL BE AS UNDER:—

    HEAD OF PASSING STANDARD OF PASSING (A) Theory + Oral 50% marks. (B) Practical/Clinical 50% marks. (C) Internal Assessment (Theory + Practical) 35% marks (for eligibility) (Refer Notification No. 09/2006) (D) Aggregate of all the 50% marks. Above mentioned heads of passing.”

    11. Rules 56 and 57 of Ordinance 01/2002 (Amended) will be suitably amended. All students should be informed accordingly.

    It is this Rule as amended, which is the subject-matter of the present Petitions.”

    12. On behalf of the Medical Council of India, Shri Ashok Kumar Harit, Deputy Secretary, has filed an affidavit. It is set out that regulations were framed by the Medical Council of India under section 33 with the prior approval of the Central Government. All such regulations are statutory in character and are binding and mandatory regulations based on the judgment of the Apex Court in the cases of MCI v. State of Karnataka, (1998) 6 SCC 131 and Dr. Preeti Srivastava v. State of M.P, (1999) 7 SCC 120. The Medical Council in exercise of its powers conferred by section 33 of the Act and after obtaining prior permission of the Government made regulations being “Regulations on Graduate Medical Education, 1997” for the purpose of regulating Medical Education in the country on 4-3-1997 and which have been published in the Official Gazette of India on 17-5-1997. In Para-9 it is then set out that even though internal assessment is separately marked on a 50-50 basis for theory and practical respectively, it is clubbed with the performance in the practical/clinical examination, whereas the viva-voce performance is clubbed with the performance in the Theory examination. It is set out that internal assessment marks are to be clubbed with the practical/clinical performance. They do not form a separate or independent passing head. Reference is then made to Rules of University and it is submitted that the Rules have to be read in such a manner so as to remain in confirmity with the provisions of Regulation 12 of 1997 Regulations of the Council.

    13. Reference is then made to Exhibit R-1/1 dated 17-9-2002, which provides the manner in which the marks are to be distributed. It would be gainful to reproduce the same:

    Distribution of marks for various disciplines have been provided under Sub-Regulations (4) of Regulation 12. For example the marks for Anatomy are as follows:—

    “(A) First Professional examination: (Pre Clinical subjects):—

    (a) Anatomy : Theory - Two papers of 50 marks each (One applied question of 10 marks in each paper) 100 marks Oral (Viva) 20 marks Practical 40 marks Internal Assessment (Theory-20 Practical-20) 40 marks Total 200 marks.”

    14. It may be observed from the above that out of the total 200 marks for the subject of Anatomy, 40 marks i.e 20% of the total marks have been provided for internal assessment (theory - 20 and practical - 20). As regards the candidate obtaining 50% in aggregate with minimum of 50% in theory including orals and minimum of 50% in Theory including orals and minimum of 50% in practical prescribed under “distribution of marks of various disciplines”, it may be pointed out that so far as Anatomy is concerned, a student has to obtain a minimum of 70 marks in theory out of a total of 140 marks (100+20+20=140) and a minimum of 30 marks out of a total of 60 marks in practical (40+20). Further, the student has also to obtain a minimum of 35% of marks in internal assessment prescribed for each subject. For example, in Anatomy, he has to obtain a minimum of 20 marks out of total 40 marks earmarked for internal assessment. Thus there is no contradiction in the percentage of marks prescribed for passing of an examination as per the regulations.”

    15. On behalf of the University Shri Govind Prabhakar Jadhav, Deputy Registrar, has filed an affidavit. It is pointed out that Rules 56 and 57 of Ordinance 01 of 2002 as framed by the University, have been held not to be inconsistent with Regulation 12 as framed by the Medical Council of India. In terms of the judgment, a student has to pass in all the three heads with 50% marks, namely in, 1. Theory, 2. Practical/clinical, and 3. Internal Assessment. Reference is made to the examination form and the specific declaration given by all the students, declaring that the students have gone through the syllabus prescribed, the Ordinance and the Rules. It is submitted that the petitioner is not entitled to challenge the Rules which have been in existence since 2003 and which have been applied for examinations conducted thereafter wherein the petitioner herein had appeared. Insofar as securing 50% in internal assessment, that has been reduced to 35% and the Medical Council has enacted the same by its notification dated 15-10-2003.

    16. Reference is then made to Regulations. It is then set out as under:

    “9. It is submitted that from the Regulations of the Medical Council of India as well as University the following position emerges:

    (i) The student must secure 35%, in the Internal Assessment (Theory + Practical) being the eligibility criteria to appear for the examination, as per the Regulations No. 12(2)(v) of Regulations on Graduate Medical Education, 1997, as amended by notification dated 15-10-2003;

    (ii) The student must pass Theory + Oral with 50% minimum;

    (iii) The student must obtain 50% minimum marks in Practical/Clinical;

    (iv) The student must obtain 50% minimum as aggregate of the above mentioned three heads of passing.”

    17. It is, therefore, set out that internal assessment is a separate head of passing, in which a candidate must have to obtain 50% marks failing which the student would be declared to have failed.

    18. From the above pleadings, the question which really would arise is whether Rule 57 as framed by the University is ultra vires Regulation 12 of the Regulations framed by Medical Council of India.

    19. To answer the issue, we may first consider the contentions advanced on behalf of the University that once the Division Bench of this Court has taken a view in Writ Petition No. 5725 of 2003 and other Petitions decided on 12-12-2003, it is not open to this Court to take a view different from the view taken by the earlier Bench. If the Court is inclined not to accept that view, the proper step would be to refer the matter to a larger Bench. We have no difficulty in accepting that proposition. The question is whether in this case, if we come to the conclusion that the Rules as framed by the University are inconsistent with the Regulations of Medical Council of India, we should refer the matter to a larger Bench.

    20. Firstly, as we may point out that the learned Division Bench was considering the Rules before their amendment. Rules 56 and 57 have been subsequently amended and notified by Notification Nos. 04/2006 and 05/2006 both dated 20-2-2006. From the notification it appears that the amendment has been done to give effect to the judgment of this Court. Whatever be the position, the fact would remain that what is in issue before us are the new Rules as framed by the University and considering the new Rule, whether we should follow the ratio of the judgment delivered in Writ Petition No. 5725 of 2003 in the case of Ms. Sheetal A. Abhyankar v. Maharashtra University of Health Sciences decided on 12th December, 2003 [since reported in 2004 (2) Mh. L.J 689]

    21. The second aspect of the matter is that it appears that the clarification issued by the Medical Council of India on 17-9-2002 was not brought to the attention of the learned Division Bench. Though the learned Bench referred to this affidavit filed on behalf of the Medical Council of India, no reference is made to that clarification. A third aspect of the matter is the view taken by the Kerala High Court a Court of co-ordinate jurisdiction. Though the view is not binding, it had a persuasive value. A view of a Court of co-ordinate jurisdiction considering that the Medical Council of India is constituted under a Central Act and had framed the Regulations under that Act ought to have been considered or distinguished as normally there ought not to be different interpretations of the same provision in different States. Courts of co-ordinate jurisdiction as far as possible, if a view taken by a Court of co-ordinate jurisdiction is a view capable of being taken, should normally adopt the same, unless it found that the view cannot be sustained in view of the language of the enactment. The judgment was not adverted to at all.

    22. We are, therefore, clearly of the view that it is open to us considering Rule 57 as now amended, to consider the true impact of the Rules 56 and 57 as amended and whether they are inconsistent with the Regulations framed by the Medical Council of India under powers conferred on it under section 33 of the Act.

    23. We may now proceed to examine the stand of the Medical Council of India. It may be made clear that the Regulations have been made by the Medical Council, in exercise of the powers delegated to it. In other words, the Regulations are sub-ordinate legislation. Similarly, the University has also made the Rules as a delegate and is also an exercise in sub-ordinate legislation.

    24. The first question that we will have to answer is whether Rules 56 and 57 are inconsistent with Regulation 12 and if inconsistent what is the effect. As explained by the Medical Council, the distribution of marks is under the heads Theory and Practicals. The marks for internal assessment are both for Theory and Practical to the extent of 20%. Insofar as the internal assessment is concerned, the first requirement is that the student must secure at least 35% marks in internal assessment in order to be eligible to appear for the final University examination. In other words it is only when a student secures minimum 35% marks, does the student become eligible to be admitted for the final University examination. The second aspect, according to the Council, is that the marks obtained in the internal assessment are not to be treated under a distinct head or subject. This can be supported by the language of Regulation 12(2)(iv), which states that weightage for the internal assessment shall be 20% of the total marks in each subject. This was not noted by the learned Division Bench whilst deciding the case of Sheetal Abhyankar (Supra). Insofar as the marks obtained for theory in the internal examination, those marks will be added to the marks obtained in theory for the final examination and similarly the marks assigned to practicals of internal assessment, would be added to the marks obtained in practicals at the final examinations. In other words, there is no requirement that the student must secure 50% aggregate in internal assessment as a distinct head. Internal assessment only requires that the student obtain 35% marks in order to enable the student to appear for the examination. Once a student secures 35%, then the marks obtained in internal assessment are to be added to Theory and Practical papers respectively in terms of Regulation 12(4). In our opinion, therefore, a reading of Regulation 12 with the clarification dated 17-9-2002, leaves no manner of doubt that the marks obtained in internal examination will have to be added with the marks obtained at the final examinations for Theory and Practicals respectively and cannot be adjudged under independent head. This view was accepted by the learned Division Bench of the Kerala High Court in the case of K. Fahad Mohamed v. Calicut University decided on 25th September, 2002 in W.A No. 1777 of 2002 (c).

    25. The other aspect is that when a body making the sub-ordinate legislation, clarifies the meaning of the Rule it has made, in the absence of absurdity or that clarification being clearly contrary to the language of the Regulation or the Parent Act, normally the Court should accept the interpretation, as the maker of the Rule would be the best person to know the object behind the Rule and how they understood the Rule when it was framed. In the instant case, from the affidavit filed on behalf of the Medical Council, the Rule as they understood it, has been explained. Under the regulation the marks obtained in the Theory and Practical examination for internal assessment are to be added to the marks of theory and practicals at the final examinations and are not to be counted as a separate head. As a separate head, it is limited to obtaining 35% marks for being eligible to appear for the examinations. We are, therefore, clearly of the view that the explanation given by the Medical Council of India to Regulation 12 should be accepted.

    26. That leave us with the next question, as to whether Rules 56 and 57 are contrary to Regulation 12(4). We are clearly of the opinion that Rule 57 as now amended is clearly ultra vires Regulation 12 of Medical Council of India Regulations the rule being inconsistent with the Regulations. Rule 57 has been made by the delegate under the State Act. Regulation 12 has been enacted by a delegate, under the Central Act after following the due procedure. Considering that the Central Act holds the field, which has conferred power on the Council to make Regulations, any provision of law inconsistent with that, will have to be held to be ultra vires. To that extent Rule 57(D) which seeks to hold that the Internal Assessment is a independent head of passing is clearly violative of Regulation 12 and will have to be declared as null and void. The marks obtained in the Internal Assessment, both Theory and Practical, will have to be added to the Theory + Oral and Practical/Clinical marks in terms of the Medical Council of India Regulations as clarified. The candidate would have to obtain 50% marks in theory and practical, in the subject and also obtain aggregate of 50% marks. Insofar as Rule 56.2.1(iii) is considered that does not deal with the subject, as Rule 56.2, is Heads of Passing. That Rule will have to be read with Rule 57 as it now stands.

    27. Once we hold that Rule 57(D) is ultra vires, the respondent University will have to recalculate the marks based on what we have stated and as how we have understood the Regulation 12 as clarified by Medical Council of India. In the light of that Petitions made absolute in terms of prayer clauses (a), (b), (e) and partly in terms of prayer clause (c) to the extent of Rule 57(D) in terms of Notification No. 05/2006 dated 20-2-2006

    Order accordingly.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Laya Binaykumar Pandey v. Medical Council Of India And Others
    (Jun 23, 2006)