AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966,
  • provisions of section 127 of the MRTP Act.5.
  • provisions of section 38 of the MRTP Act
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966,
  • provisions of section 127 of the MRTP Act.5.
  • provisions of section 38 of the MRTP Act
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are the owners of land comprising field survey Nos. 90/1, 90/2 and 90/3, Mouza Sindi, Tahsil and District Wardha. Under a 1976 development plan (referred to also as the 1978 development plan in the judgment), plot No. 90/1 was reserved for open space and plot No. 90/2 for a high school and playground. The petitioners relied upon section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning (MRTP) Act, 1966: they served a notice on the Planning Authority on 26-7-1988 claiming that the reservation should lapse because the land was not acquired within the statutory period and acquisition proceedings had not been commenced. The Municipal Council passed a resolution dated 29-4-1995 expressing its inability to acquire the land and to pay compensation and purporting to release the reservation, but allegedly did not act in accordance with that resolution. The petitioners filed Writ Petition No. 3763/1998; this Court on 21-9-1999 held that the regional reservation under the 1978 development plan had lapsed, but declined other relief. Subsequently, a revised draft development plan was published by the Municipal Council on 13-11-1997; the petitioners submitted objections (20-11-1999) and a final development plan was published on 9-1-2004, in which the petitioners' land was again shown as reserved. The petitioners challenged the re-imposition of reservation in the present petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a Planning Authority, by exercising its power to revise the development plan under section 38 of the MRTP Act, can re-impose a reservation that has already lapsed under the contingencies and consequences prescribed by section 127 of the MRTP Act (i.e., whether the rights accrued to the landowner under section 127 can be taken away by a subsequent exercise under section 38).
  2. Whether the petition should be dismissed on the ground of delay and laches because the draft revised development plan was published on 13-11-1997 and the petition was filed in 2004.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as advanced by Shri Manohar)

  • The petitioners owned plots 90/1, 90/2 and 90/3; these were reserved under the earlier development plan.
  • Under section 127 MRTP Act, because acquisition was not initiated within ten years, the reservation lapsed; petitioners served notice on 26-7-1988 and the Planning Authority by resolution dated 29-4-1995 expressed inability to acquire and released the land.
  • This Court in Writ Petition No. 3763/1998 (judgment dated 21-9-1999) declared the reservation to have lapsed; that finding gave the petitioners the right to develop the land as permissible for adjacent land under the plan.
  • The revised final development plan (published 9-1-2004) again reserved their land for garden/playground, but once reservation has lapsed under section 127 the Planning Authority cannot resurrect it by exercising powers under section 38.
  • Reliance was placed on a Division Bench judgment of this Court in Shri Baburao Dhondiba Salokhe v. Kolhapur Municipal Corporation (2003) and the law therein construing the effect of section 38 vis-à-vis section 127.

Respondent No. 2's Arguments (as advanced by Shri Sambre)

  • Because the draft revised development plan showing reservation was published on 13-11-1997, the petitioners should have challenged that reservation within a reasonable time; filing in 2004 amounts to delay and laches, warranting dismissal.
  • Section 38 of the MRTP Act authorizes the Planning Authority to revise the development plan once in twenty years; the re-imposition of reservation under that provision is consistent with the statutory scheme and therefore sustainable.

Respondent No. 1's Position

  • The Assistant Government Pleader for respondent No. 1 adopted the line of argument advanced by respondent No. 2 (i.e., reliance on section 38 and the delay/laches contention).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Writ Petition No. 3763/1998 (this Court), judgment dated 21-9-1999 Determination that the regional reservation on the petitioners' land (from the 1978 development plan) had lapsed under the contingencies of section 127 MRTP Act. The Court treated that earlier final finding as establishing that reservation had lapsed and therefore the consequences prescribed by section 127 must follow. This prior judgment formed the factual and legal starting-point for the present decision.
Shri Baburao Dhondiba Salokhe v. Kolhapur Municipal Corporation, Kolhapur, 2003 (3) Mh. L.J 820 : 2003 (3) All MR 433 (Division Bench) Interprets the MRTP Act (in light of Apex Court authority) to hold that the power of revision under section 38 cannot be read so as to take away substantive rights accrued to an owner under section 127; a revised draft or final plan does not automatically revive a reservation that has lapsed. The Court relied on and followed this Division Bench ruling to conclude that once reservation has lapsed under section 127, the Planning Authority cannot revive that reservation under the exercise of powers in section 38.
Bhavnagar University v. Palitana Sugar Mills (P) Ltd., (2003) 2 SCC 111 (Apex Court) Legal principles concerning the interplay between statutory obligations to revise plans and the rights accrued to owners; used as authority for the proposition that revision powers do not oust substantive rights conferred by other statutory provisions. This Supreme Court authority was taken into account (and applied in the Division Bench ruling cited above) to support the proposition that section 38 cannot be read to take away rights accrued under section 127; the present Court relied upon that line of reasoning in reaching its conclusion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began from the incontrovertible factual and legal premise that this Court, in Writ Petition No. 3763/1998 (judgment dated 21-9-1999), had held that the regional reservation applicable to the petitioners' land under the 1978 development plan had lapsed. Under section 127 of the MRTP Act, such lapsing carries the consequence that the land is "deemed to be released" from the reservation and becomes available to the owner for development as permissible for adjacent land under the relevant plan.

The specific legal question framed was whether the Planning Authority, by invoking its power to revise the development plan under section 38 (which permits revision of the plan), could effectively negate the substantial right that had accrued to the owners on account of the operation of section 127 and thereby re-impose the same reservation. The Court observed that a similar issue was considered by the Division Bench in Shri Baburao Dhondiba Salokhe, which in turn relied upon the Supreme Court's observations in Bhavnagar University v. Palitana Sugar Mills (P) Ltd. The combined legal position distilled from those authorities is that the statutory power to revise a plan (section 38) does not, and cannot, be read so as to deprive a landowner of the substantive right conferred by section 127 when a reservation has lapsed in the manner provided by that section.

Applying that principle to the facts, the Court noted that although a revised draft development plan was published on 13-11-1997 and a final development plan on 9-1-2004 again showing the petitioners' plots as reserved, those acts could not "revive" a reservation that had already lapsed. The Court therefore concluded that the action of the Planning Authority in subjecting the petitioners' land once again to the same reservation was legally unsustainable.

On the procedural contention of delay and laches, the Court rejected the respondent's submission. It observed that the final development plan came into force in 2004 and the petition was filed in 2004; on that basis the Court did not accept that the petition was barred by delay or laches.

Finally, having held the re-imposition of reservation to be contrary to law, the Court declared the reservation in the final development plan (published on 9-1-2004) to be illegal and directed that the petitioners may make an application for permission to develop the land; the Planning Authority was directed to decide such application on merits within three months of receipt.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

THE COURT DECLARED THE RESERVATION IN THE FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN (PUBLISHED 9-1-2004) TO BE ILLEGAL AND UNSUSTAINABLE IN LAW, AND HELD THAT PLOTS NO. 90/1 AND 90/2 ARE RELEASED FROM RESERVATION.

Immediate implications and orders:

  • The petitioners' land (plots 90/1 and 90/2) is declared released from reservation shown in the final development plan published on 9-1-2004.
  • The petitioners are entitled to make appropriate applications to the Planning Authority for permission to develop the land in question.
  • The respondent No. 2 (Planning Authority) is directed to decide any such application on its own merits according to law as early as possible and in any case within three months from the date of receipt of the application.
  • The rule is made absolute in the terms stated; the Court ordered no costs.

Broader legal implication (as applied by the Court):

The decision reiterates and applies the principle that the statutory power to revise a development plan under section 38 of the MRTP Act cannot be read so as to deprive or annul substantive rights which have already accrued to an owner under section 127 where a reservation has lawfully lapsed. The opinion does not state that it is laying down a novel precedent beyond applying the legal position already recognized in earlier decisions referenced in the judgment.

Order accordingly. Rule made absolute. No order as to costs.

    Kishor Gopalrao Bapat And Others v. State Of Maharashtra And Another

    D.D Sinha, J.:— Rule returnable forthwith. Heard Shri Manohar, learned Counsel for the petitioners, Shri Patel, learned Assistant Government Pleader for the respondent No. 1, and Shri Sambre, learned Counsel for the respondent No. 2.

    2. Shri Manohar, learned Counsel for the petitioners, states that petitioners are owners of land bearing field survey Nos. 90/1, 90/2 and 90/3 situated at Mouza Sindi, Tahsil and District Wardha. In the year 1976 the above-referred land was reserved under development plan of the city for open space (plot No. 90/1) and for High School and playground (plot No. 90/2). It is contended that in view of section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966, since land was not acquired within ten years from the date on which final regional plan or final development plan came into force and proceedings for the acquisition of above-referred land under the MRTP Act or under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 were not commenced within such period, the petitioners served notice dated 26-7-1988 on the Planning Authority, i.e Municipal Council, Wardha. It is contended that in view of provisions of section 127 of the mrtp act, after service of the above-referred notice on the Planning Authority, if within six months from the date of service of such notice, the land is not acquired or no steps are taken for its acquisition, reservation, allotment or designation shall be deemed to have lapsed and thereupon the land shall be deemed to be released from such reservation, allotment or designation and shall become available to the owner for the purpose of development as otherwise permissible in the case of adjacent land under the relevant plan. It is submitted that the Planning Authority vide Resolution dated 29-4-1995 expressed its inability to acquire the above referred land of the petitioners and to pay compensation to them and, therefore, released the above-referred land of the petitioners from the relevant reservation. However, in spite of that, the Planning Authority failed to act as per its Resolution dated 29-4-1995 and, therefore, petitioners were constrained to file Writ Petition No. 3763/1998 before this Court seeking declaration that the reservation on the land of the petitioners has lapsed as per provisions of section 127 of the mrtp act.

    3. Learned Counsel, Shri Manohar submits that this Court vide judgment dated 21-9-1999 passed in Writ Petition No. 3763/1998 held and declared that regional reservation on the petitioners' land which applied on account of the 1978 development plan has lapsed, but declined to grant any other relief to the petitioners in view of subsequent developments. It is contended that in view of the above-referred judgment of this Court, the land of the petitioners after lapsing of reservation was deemed to be released from such reservation and was available to the petitioners for the purpose of development as otherwise permissible in the case of adjacent land under the relevant plan. However, the respondent Municipal Council published revised draft development plan on 13-11-1997. The petitioners submitted their objections before the Planning Authority on 20-11-1999 and final development plan was published on 9-1-2004.

    4. It is submitted by learned Counsel Shri Manohar that in the revised final development plan, the land of the petitioners, i.e plot No. 90/1 is shown to be again reserved for garden (reservation No. 25) and plot No. 90/2 was again reserved for playground (reservation No. 28). It is contended that once reservation is lapsed in view of section 127 of the mrtp act, right of the ownership for development of the said land cannot be again subjected to reservation via section 38 of the mrtp act. It is submitted Chat controversy in this regard is concluded by the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in the case of Shri Baburao Dhondiba Salokhe v. Kolhapur Municipal Corporation, Kolhapur, 2003 (3) Mh. L.J 820 : 2003 (3) All MR 433. It is contended that as per law laid down by this Court in the above-referred judgment, the Planning Authority is not legally competent to reserve the land, which is released from the reservation due to lapsing of reservation in view of provisions of section 127 of the mrtp act and, therefore, in the instant case, the action of the Municipal Council in again reserving land of the petitioner for garden and playground respectively is not sustainable in law and petitioners may be permitted to develop the land as per provisions of section 127 of the mrtp act.

    5. Shri Sambre, learned Counsel for the respondent No. 2, states that the draft development plan was published on 13-11-1997 wherein land of the petitioners was shown to be reserved for garden and playground and, therefore, if petitioners wanted to challenge the said reservation, then petitioners ought to have approached this Court within a reasonable time. However, petitioners have filed the present petition in the year 2004 and, therefore, petition suffers from laches and delay and needs to be dismissed on that count alone.

    6. It is further contended by learned Counsel Shri Sambre that as per section 38 of the MRTP Act, power is vested with the Planning Authority to revise the development plan once in twenty years from the date on which development plan has come into operation and, therefore, action of the respondent Planning Authority is consistent with the provisions of section 38 of the MRTP Act and reservation applied to the land of the petitioners is, therefore, sustainable in law.

    7. Shri Patel, learned Assistant Government Pleader for the respondent No. 1, more or less has adopted the line of argument advanced by Shri Sambre, learned Counsel for the respondent No. 2.

    8. We have given our anxious thought to the various contentions canvassed by the learned respective Counsel for the parties and also perused relevant provisions of the MRTP Act as well as judgment of this Court relied on by the learned Counsel for the petitioners. In the instant case, it is not in dispute that this Court vide judgment dated 21-9-1999 passed in Writ Petition No. 3763/1998 has finally held thus:

    “In these circumstances, we hold and declare that the regional reservation on the petitioners' land which applied on account of the 1978 Development Plan has lapsed, but we decline to grant any other relief to the petitioners in view of the subsequent developments. Rule accordingly partly made absolute. No order as to costs.”

    9. In view of the above-referred finding recorded by this Court in the aforesaid writ petition, it is evident that reservation on the land of the petitioners, i.e plot No. 90/1 for the open space and plot No. 90/2 for High School and playground in the 1978 development plan was declared to have been lapsed and, therefore, necessary consequences stipulated in section 127 of the mrtp act must necessarily follow. Under the scheme of section 127 of the mrtp act, if reservation is lapsed in view of contingencies mentioned therein, then necessary consequence is that land under reservation shall be deemed to be released from such reservation and land shall become available to the owner of the land for the purpose of development as otherwise permissible in the case of adjacent land under the relevant plan.

    10. In the instant case, the respondent No. 2 Planning Authority published revised draft development plan of the city on 13-11-1997 wherein land of the petitioner, which is released from reservation under section 127 of the MRTP was again shown to be reserved for garden and playground, i.e garden (plot No. 90/1) and playground (Plot No. 90/2). The petitioners had submitted objections to the revised draft development plan. However, the final development plan was published on 9-1-2004 keeping the reservation intact as mentioned in the draft development plan so far as plots of the petitioners are concerned.

    11. The question, which falls for our consideration in the present petition is whether the Planning Authority exercising power under section 38 of the MRTP Act, which deals with revision of development plan, can take away the rights accrued to the owner of the land on account of lapsing of reservation in view of contingencies mentioned in section 127 of the mrtp act. Similar factual and legal situation arose in the case of Shri Baburao Dhondiba Solakhe (cited supra) and this Court after taking into consideration the law laid down by the Apex Court in Bhavnagar University v. Palitana Sugar Mills (P) Ltd., (2003) 2 SCC 111, in paragraph (17) observed thus:

    “The legal position as regards MRTP Act on the basis of aforesaid observations made by the Apex Court in Bhavnagar University emerges that by imposition of a statutory obligation under section 38 on the part of the State or the appropriate authority to revise the development plan the rights of the owners accrued in terms of section 127 are not taken away. section 38 of mrtp act, in our opinion, does not and cannot be read to mean that substantial right conferred upon the owner of the land or the person interested under section 127 is taken away. In other words, section 38 does not envisage that despite the fact that in terms of section 127, the reservation lapsed, only because of a draft revised development plan or final revised development plan is made would not automatically result in revival of reservation that had lapsed. If the reservation of the petitioner's land for the purposes of garden had lapsed and as we found in fact has lapsed on 28-2-1992, because of draft revised plan made in the year 1992 and thereafter final revised development plan sanctioned in the year 1999 would not revive the lapsed reservation.”

    12. The above-referred observations of this Court make it evident that once reservation is lapsed in view of contingencies mentioned in section 127 of the mrtp act, the necessary consequence under the scheme of section 127 of the mrtp act must follow. The land which is released from the reservation becomes available to the owner for the purpose of development as otherwise permissible in the case of adjacent land under the relevant plan. This right which is conferred or accrued to the owner of the land due to lapsing of reservation cannot be taken away by the Planning Authority by exercising power under section 38 of the mrtp act.

    13. We do not agree with the contention of the learned Counsel for the respondent No. 2 that petition suffers from delay and laches particularly when final development plan came into force in the year 2004 and petition is also filed in the year 2004 and, therefore, same is rejected.

    14. In view of the above-referred settled legal position, the land of the petitioners cannot be again subjected to same reservation, which was made earlier in 1978 development plan and, therefore, we have no hesitation to hold that the act of the Planning Authority subjecting the land of the petitioners once again to reservation is unsustainable in law and, therefore, we declare the said reservation as illegal and unsustainable in law and land of the petitioners, i.e plot No. 90/1 and 90/2 is declared to be released from reservation made in the final development plan, which was published on 9-1-2004. The petitioners are entitled to make appropriate application for permission to develop the land in question to the Planning Authority. If such application is made by the petitioners, respondent No. 2 Planning Authority is directed to decide the same on its own merits according to law as early as possible and in any case not beyond the period of three months from the date of receipt of such application.

    15. The rule is made absolute in the above terms. No order as to costs.

    Order accordingly.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kishor Gopalrao Bapat And Others v. State Of Maharashtra And Another
    (Jun 20, 2005)