Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • ORDER 26 RULE 9 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure.16.
  • Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • section 83 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
  • SECTION 83 EVIDENCE ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • ORDER 26 RULE 9 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure.16.
  • Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • section 83 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
  • SECTION 83 EVIDENCE ACT
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal was filed under section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure challenging the judgment and decree dated 18-7-1989 of the Additional District Judge in Regular Civil Appeal No. 92 of 1985. That judgment had dismissed the appeal and confirmed the judgment and decree dated 18-12-1984 of the Joint Civil Judge in Regular Civil Suit No. 31 of 1981, declaring the plaintiffs to be owners of a specific suit site described by certain letters (A-3, A-4, A-12, A-2 and A-3) in the plaint map (Ex. 32), directing defendants to deliver vacant possession after removing construction and permitting plaintiffs to remove construction at defendants' cost if they failed to do so.

The plaintiffs' suit sought declaration of title and injunction, alleging succession to the suit site from their deceased father Tulshiram and describing dimensions and mapped boundaries (letters A-3, A-4, A-10, A-1, A-2, A-3). Plaintiffs alleged that the defendant encroached upon their open land shown on the plaint map and began construction and removed portions of plaintiffs' wall, and that the defendant failed to vacate on demand.

The defendant contested the suit, asserting title by purchase (a sale dated 23-3-1945) to a constructed property, denying that the plaintiff ever possessed the disputed portion, describing the disputed area as previously occupied by the defendant's tin shed and kitchen, and denying any encroachment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the map (Ex. 32) appended to the plaint and forming part of the decree is admissible in evidence and can be presumed accurate under section 83 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, or whether such a map made for the purpose of the suit must be proved to be accurate before it can support a decree.
  2. Whether, in a boundary/encroachment dispute of this nature, the courts below should have ordered a local investigation (appointment of a Commissioner/Surveyor) under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure to ascertain actual measurements and boundary demarcation before granting relief.
  3. Whether the decree passed by the courts below, which relied on the plaint map without evidence of its accuracy or the person who prepared it, can be sustained in law.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Mr. Chandurkar)

  • The plaintiffs had no document of title to the property; the courts below erred in discarding oral evidence and yet assuming plaintiffs' title without basis.
  • The learned Additional District Judge excluded oral evidence and relied on assumptions; this non-application of mind vitiates the judgment.
  • The map (Ex. 32) annexed to the plaint and forming the basis of the decree is not admissible under section 83 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, because it was prepared for the purpose of the suit and was not proved to be accurate.
  • No Commissioner or expert was appointed for local investigation as contemplated by Order 26, Rule 9 CPC; in the absence of an accurate, proved map, the judgment and decree rest on presumptions and assumptions and should be set aside.

Plaintiffs' Arguments (Mr. Paliwal)

  • The defendant purchased the property from a co-sharer by sale-deed dated 27-3-1945 (Ex. 47) which describes the boundaries.
  • The map (Ex. 32) appended to the plaint was prepared on the basis of dimensions and measurements mentioned in the sale-deed, and therefore the appeal does not raise a substantial question of law and should be dismissed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Krishnarao v. Mahadeorao, 1953 N.L.J. Note 230 at page 72 Interpreting Order 26, Rule 9 CPC: the Court has discretion to order local investigation; in boundary/identity disputes a Commissioner should be appointed; oral evidence alone is insufficient to determine encroachment; field measurement by expert is desirable. The Court relied on this decision to support the proposition that a Commissioner/Surveyor ought to have been appointed for local investigation and measurement in the present boundary/encroachment dispute, and that refusal to appoint a Commissioner may amount to a refusal in the exercise of jurisdiction.
Po Gyi v. Maung Paw, 12 I.C. 347 Illustrative authority cited in Krishnarao emphasising when local investigation is appropriate (boundary/identity disputes). Referenced in the Krishnarao discussion as an example of where local investigation is appropriate; supports the Court's view that local investigation is necessary in boundary disputes.
Ram Kishore Sen v. Union of India, AIR 1966 SC 644 Interpreting section 83 Evidence Act: maps/plans made by government authorities may be presumed accurate; maps or plans made for the purpose of a cause must be proved to be accurate and are not entitled to presumptions of accuracy. The Court cited this Supreme Court decision to reinforce that Ex. 32, being a map made for the suit, does not attract a presumption of accuracy and that its accuracy was not established; thus the map cannot be accepted as reliable evidence without proof.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by identifying the central legal question: whether map Ex. 32, which formed part of the decree, is admissible and whether the decree founded on it is sustainable in law, particularly in view of section 83 of the Evidence Act and Order 26, Rule 9 CPC.

The Court reproduced section 83 of the Evidence Act and emphasized its two parts: (1) maps/plans purportedly made by Central or State Government authorities are presumed to be accurately made; and (2) maps/plans made for the purpose of any cause (i.e., prepared at the instance of parties for litigation) must be proved to be accurate. The Court construed the provision to mean that no presumption of accuracy applies to maps prepared for a suit and that the onus of proving accuracy lies on the party producing such a map. The Court noted that such maps are post litem motes and may lack trustworthiness because of the tendency to colour or exaggerate in favour of the party producing them; hence the maker should be sworn and the map proved.

The Court explained that, where disputes about encroachment or site dimensions exist, an agreed map is essential; if parties cannot agree, the Court should appoint a Commissioner under Order 26, Rule 9 CPC to make a local investigation, take measurements and report. Without an accurate, duly proved map (preferably a joint measurement map signed and attached to the decree), a decree based on an unproved map is "probably meaningless" and execution could restart the litigation.

The Court referred to Krishnarao (and the Po Gyi example) to show that refusal to appoint a Commissioner when local investigation is necessary may amount to a refusal in the exercise of jurisdiction, and that field measurement by an expert is desirable since oral evidence alone cannot conclusively prove encroachment or precise measurements.

Applying these principles to the present case, the Court observed that neither a City Surveyor nor any expert had been appointed for local investigation under Order 26, Rule 9 CPC. Although the sale-deed (Ex. 47) contained dimensions, there was no evidence of the person who prepared the plaint map (Ex. 32). In the absence of proof of the map's accuracy or of the maker's evidence, the Court found it impossible to accept Ex. 32 as an accurate basis for granting relief. The Court concluded that the judgments and decree of the lower courts resulted in a miscarriage of justice for this reason.

Consequently, the Court directed that the suit be remanded to the trial Court with specific directions: the trial Court must appoint a Commissioner or Surveyor from the office of the City Surveyor, Buldana, to conduct a local investigation under Order 26, Rule 9 CPC; the Surveyor must take joint measurements after considering title deeds, demarcate boundaries, note precise measurements and any encroachment in the joint measurement map, and submit the map and report to the trial Court.

Administrative directions and timelines were also imposed: the plaintiff must submit an application to the trial Court within two weeks for appointment of the City Surveyor; if the plaintiff fails to do so, the suit shall stand dismissed; the trial Court should decide the matter expeditiously and preferably within six months from receipt of the record; parties are directed to be present before the trial Court on 11-7-2005; record and proceedings are to be sent immediately to the trial Court.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Appeal allowed; the judgments and decrees passed by the Courts below are set aside and the suit is remanded to the trial Court for fresh decision in accordance with law.

Direct consequences and directions given by the Court (as stated in the opinion):

  • The trial Court is directed to appoint a Commissioner or Surveyor from the office of the City Surveyor, Buldana, to conduct a local investigation under Order 26, Rule 9 CPC.
  • The appointed Surveyor shall take measurements of the property after considering the parties' title-deeds, demarcate boundaries in a joint measurement map, note precise area under encroachment (if any), and submit the map and report to the trial Court.
  • The plaintiff must submit an application for appointment of the City Surveyor within two weeks from the date of the opinion; failure to do so will result in dismissal of the suit.
  • The trial Court shall adjudicate the matter expeditiously and preferably within six months from receipt of record and proceedings.
  • Parties are directed to appear before the trial Court on 11-7-2005; records to be sent immediately to the trial Court.

Broader legal implications as articulated in the opinion:

  • Maps or plans prepared for the purpose of litigation are not entitled to a presumption of accuracy under section 83 Evidence Act and must be proved to be accurate by the party who produces them (preferably by the maker of the map).
  • In boundary and encroachment disputes, oral evidence alone is insufficient to resolve precise measurements; local investigation by a competent surveyor or Commissioner under Order 26, Rule 9 CPC is often necessary for a just decision.
  • A decree founded on an unproved map prepared for the suit, absent local investigation or proof of accuracy, cannot be sustained and may lead to a remand for fresh determination based on accurate, jointly prepared or officially surveyed maps.

Appeal allowed.

    Kashinath v. Purushottam Tulshiram Tekade

    Invoking the jurisdiction of this Court under section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, this appeal has been filed challenging the judgment and decree dated 18-7-1989 passed by the learned Additional District Judge in Regular Civil Appeal No. 92 of 1985, whereby the appeal came to be dismissed and the judgment and decree dated 18-12-1984 passed by the learned Joint Civil Judge, Jr. Dn., in Regular Civil Suit No. 31 of 1981 has been confirmed and it was declared that the plaintiffs are the owners of the suit site which is described by letters A-3, A-4, A-12, A-2 and A-3 in the suit map Ex. 32. The defendants were also directed to deliver the vacant possession of the suit site described by letters A-3, A-4, A-12, A-2 and A-3 in the suit map Ex. 32 after removing the construction from it with further direction that if the defendant fails to remove his construction over the above described suit site, the plaintiffs would be entitled to get it removed at their own costs.

    2. Brief facts are required to be stated as under:

    3. The plaintiffs filed a suit for declaration that the suit site is owned by them and the defendants be restrained from interfering with their possession over the suit site. The plaintiffs contended that the father of plaintiff No. 1 left behind him the suit site of his ownership and possession and its size is 12 feet east west and southern side is of 12 feet of measurement. Similarly the north south eastern side is 26 feet and north south western side is 26 feet. The house and open land of the defendant is towards the eastern side of the house of the plaintiff. The plaintiffs No. 1 and 3 are the sons, the plaintiff No. 4 is the daughter and plaintiff No. 2 is the widow of deceased Tulshiram and the plaintiffs No. 1 to 4 are the owners of the abovesaid site as the heirs of Tulshiram. The walls of this house and open plot described in the suit map are there since beginning. The open land described by letters A-3, A-4, A-10, A-1, A-2, A-3 is the subject-matter of this suit. The other walls and house and the open land in front of the house of plaintiff are described in the suit map and the defendant without any right or interest encroached upon the open land of the plaintiffs shown by letters A-3, A-4, A-10 and A-2 in the map and started construction of wall on the land shown by letters A-3, A-4 and A-18. The defendant also removed 3 or 4 lays of bricks from the plaintiffs' wall described by letters A-1, A-2, A-10, A-12 in the map. The defendant was called upon to vacate the portion of the plot on which encroachment is made, but in vain. Therefore, the plaintiffs were constrained to file suit against the defendant.

    4. The defendant contested the suit and contended that his father had purchased the suit site on 23-3-1945 in a constructed position and since then this land is as it is and none of its portion was open land. The defendant also contended that the portion described by letters A-3, A-4, A-12 and A-3 as mentioned in the plaint map was never an open land nor in possession of the plaintiffs. This portion was the place of tin shed of the defendant from which the tin shed is removed for new pucca construction. The defendant contended that the wall described by letters A-3 and A-2 in the plaint map is the joint wall of the plaintiffs and defendant. The ownership of the plaintiffs on the entire portion of the suit map is not admitted by the defendant. The portion shown by letters A-13, A-14, A-15, A-10 in the plaint map was never an open land. There was a tin shed of the defendant over the portion by letters A-13, A-14, A-18 which is to the north to the portion and A-13 and A-14. The portion in the plaint shown as A-3, A-2, A-1 and A-10 was the kitchen in the tin shed of the defendant and that he did not make any encroachment and the suit is totally misconceived and liable to be dismissed.

    5. Mr. Chandurkar, learned counsel, for the appellant contended that admittedly the plaintiffs did not have any document of title to the property and the learned Additional District Judge having discarded the oral evidence adduced, there was no evidence on the basis of which the plaintiffs could be granted a decree in respect of the property. He contended that the learned Additional District Judge took it for granted without any basis or evidence that the plaintiffs had title to the property for which assumption there is no basis whatsoever and in that view of the matter the plaintiffs should not have been granted decree by the courts below. He submitted that the learned Additional District Judge having observed that it was not necessary to go into the oral evidence of the parties and inasmuch as the oral evidence according to him would not out-weigh the sale-deed and further that the admissions given in evidence were all weak admissions and admissions must go the whole hog unlike the present case which was brought to his notice to which discussion need not be made, clearly demonstrates the total, non-application of mind on the part of the learned Additional District Judge to the controversy and that the basic question whether the property in suit as described by letters A-3, A-4, A-10 and A-2 in the plaintiffs' map could be said to have belonged to the plaintiffs, had to be decided on the basis of the evidence, oral and documentary, and inasmuch as the oral evidence as recorded has wholly been excluded by the learned Additional District Judge, that has created a patent error on the approach to the case in question which has the effect of vitiating the judgment as recorded by the learned Additional District Judge.

    6. Mr. Chandurkar, learned counsel, further contended that the decree has been drawn on the basis of the map (Ex. 32) annexed with the plaint and the said map is not admissible in evidence in view of section 83 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. He contended that the substantial question of law that arises in this appeal is, whether on the strength of unproved map, the decree passed by the courts below is sustainable in law. He further contended that no Commissioner was appointed for the purpose of local investigation as is required under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure and in absence of accurate map, the judgment and decree passed by the courts below is purely on the basis of presumptions and assumptions and therefore liable to be set aside.

    7. Mr. Paliwal, learned counsel, for the plaintiffs contended that the defendant had purchased the property from the co-sharer of plaintiffs by sale-deed dated 27-3-1945 (Ex. 47) and the boundaries have been described in the sale-deed. The map (Ex. 32) appended to the plaint which formed part of the decree has been prepared on the basis of the dimensions and measurements mentioned in the sale-deed and, therefore, it would clearly reveal that no substantial question of law is involved in this appeal and the same is liable to be dismissed.

    8. This Court has given thoughtful consideration to the contentions canvassed by the learned counsel for the parties. It would clearly reveal that the question of law that has been involved in this appeal is, whether the map Ex. 32 which formed part of the decree is admissible in evidence in view of section 83 of the Evidence Act and whether the decree passed by the courts below on the basis of the said map can be sustained in law.

    9. In this context, it is necessary to reproduce section 83 of the Evidence Act which contemplates that the Court shall presume that the maps or plans purporting to be made by the authority of the Central Government or any State Government were so made and are accurate; but maps or plans made for the purpose of any cause must be proved to be accurate.

    (emphasis supplied).

    10. The analysis of the aforesaid section would show that the words employed, “but maps or plans made for the purpose of any cause must be proved to be accurate” would clearly “indicate that the maps or plans made for the purpose of any cause must be proved to be accurate and no presumption of law can be drawn that those maps or plans are accurate which are prepared at the instance of the parties for the purpose of the cause.” The onus of proving that such a map is accurate lies on the party who produced it. The maps must be proved by the person who has prepared them. They are post litem motesa and lack necessary trustworthiness. Where the maps are made for the purpose of a suit there is, even apart from fraud which may exist, a tendency to colour, exaggerate and favour which can only be counteracted by swearing the maker to the truth of his plan. Hence, there is no presumption of accuracy in respect of the map or plan which is made for a particular cause and it goes without saying that a map prepared for the purpose of a particular suit must, therefore, be duly proved and it is not admissible in evidence in absence of proof of its accuracy. In any case, in which there is a dispute about an encroachment or dimension of a site, the first essential is to get an agreed map and if the parties cannot agree on one, a Commissioner must be appointed to prepare the same and/or subsequent reference in the pleadings or judgment to place the mark on a map should be referred to this map which must be attached to the decree and signed by the Judge. In the absence of such a map, the decree is probably meaningless and execution means virtually starting the case all over again. The map should be drawn with the North at the top and letters marking points should not be put in side ways or upside down.

    11. I may usefully refer the decision of this Court in the case of Krishnarao v. Mahadeorao, 1953 N.L.J Note 230 at page 72 wherein it has been observed as under:

    “3. The trial Court rejected the application stating that the question of encroachment by the defendant on a particular date is to be proved by positive evidence by the plaintiff and, therefore, it did not think it desirable to appoint a Commissioner. It is against this order that the plaintiff has come up in revision.

    4. Order 26, Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Code is as follows:

    “In any suit in which the Court deems a local investigation to be requisite or proper for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute, or of ascertaining the market value of any property, or the amount of any mesne profits or damages or annual net profits, the Court may issue a commission to such person as it thinks fit directing him to make such investigation and to report thereon to the Court.”

    5. Under the above rule, the Court has a discretion to order local investigation or not. The object of local investigation is not so much to collect evidence which can be taken in Court but to obtain evidence which from its peculiar nature can only be had on the spot. Cases of boundary disputes and disputes about the identity of lands are instances when a Court should order a local investigation under this rule. Po Gyi v. Maung Paw, 12 I.C 347.”

    6. In order to determine whether there has been an encroachment. It is always desirable to get the fields measured by an expert and find out the exact area encroached upon. Oral evidence cannot conclusively prove such an issue. The order of the lower Court refusing to appoint a Commissioner amount to a refusal in exercise jurisdiction. It is set aside. The plaintiff's application under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Code for appointment of Commissioner is allowed.”

    12. I am in respectful agreement with the view taken by this Court in the aforementioned case. It is clear that under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the Court has the discretion to order local investigation or not. The object of the local investigation is not so much to collect evidence which can be taken in Court but to obtain evidence which from its peculiar nature can only be had on the spot. The cases of boundary dispute and disputes about the identity of lands are instances, when a Court should order a local investigation under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure. In order to determine whether there has been an encroachment, it is always desirable to get the fields measured by an expert and find out the area encroached upon. Oral evidence cannot conclusively prove such an issue.

    13. Reference may also be had to the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Ram Kishore Sen v. Union of India, AIR 1966 SC 644 wherein if has been held in para 12 as under:

    “It is true that section 83 of the Evidence Act provides that the Court shall presume that the maps or plans purporting to be made by the authority of the Central Government or any State Government were so made and are accurate, but the maps or plans made for the purpose of any cause must be proved to be accurate. The presumption of accuracy can thus be drawn only in favour of the maps which satisfy the requirements prescribed by the first part of section 83. Exh. A-1 obviously does not fall under the category of the said map and so there can be no question of drawing any presumption in favour of the accuracy of the said map. In fact, we have already indicated, the learned Judge has given very good reasons for showing that the map does not appear to be accurate. Therefore, even if the map is held to be relevant its accuracy is not at all established; that is the conclusion of the learned Judge and Mr. Mukherjee has given us no satisfactory reasons for differing from the said conclusion.”

    14. In view of the aforesaid legal position, it appears to be absolutely necessary that the City Surveyor ought to have been appointed when the question arises as to whether any encroachment has been made or not. The appointment of City Surveyor or Cadastral Surveyor for taking joint measurement of the property owned by the plaintiff and defendant for the purpose of local investigation under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure not only become relevant but appears to be absolutely essential for the just decision of the case.

    15. In the present case neither the City Surveyor nor any expert has been appointed for the purpose of local investigation under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure and though the dimension of the property has been mentioned in the sale-deed (Ex. 47), in absence of any evidence of the person who prepared the map it is not possible to accept that the map which formed part of the decree is an accurate map and can be made basis for granting relief to the plaintiff. In fact, the impugned judgments and decree passed by the Courts below have resulted into miscarriage of justice and in such circumstances there is no alternative except to remand this suit to the trial Court with directions to appoint the Commissioner/Surveyor from the office of City Surveyor, Buldana for the purpose of local investigation under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

    16. The suit is accordingly remanded to the trial Court and the trial Court is directed to appoint the Commissioner or a Surveyor from the office of City Surveyor, Buldana for the purpose of local investigation under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The plaintiff is directed to submit his application before the trial Court within two weeks from today for appointment of City Surveyor who shall conduct local investigation in accordance with the provisions of Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure and take the measurements of the property owned by the parties after taking into consideration the title-deeds of the parties and shall also demarcate the boundaries of the property by noting down the actual measurements in the joint measurement map itself by showing the precise and concise area under encroachment, if any, and then shall submit the map and report to the trial Court. In such circumstances, the appeal is allowed. The judgments and decrees passed by the Courts below are set aside and the suit is remanded to the trial Court for fresh decision in accordance with law and in the light of the observations made above. The trial Court shall decide the matter expeditiously and preferably within six months from the receipt of record and proceedings of this case. The record and proceedings be sent immediately to the trial Court. Parties are directed to remain present before the trial Court on 11-7-2005. If the plaintiff does not submit his application for appointment of the Commissioner or Surveyor within two weeks, as stated above, the suit shall stand dismissed.

    Appeal allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kashinath v. Purushottam Tulshiram Tekade
    (Jun 16, 2005)