Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1980 (hereinafter referred
  • Section 152 read with Section 151 and Section 153 of the said Code.
  • Section 151 and Section 153 of the said Code.
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1980 (hereinafter referred
  • Section 152 read with Section 151 and Section 153 of the said Code.
  • Section 151 and Section 153 of the said Code.
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition was filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenging the judgment and order dated 4 July 1984 of the 3rd Joint Civil Judge, Junior Division, Pune, rejecting an application (Exh. 1) in C-Application No. 60 of 1984.

The petitioners are the legal representatives of the original plaintiff in Regular Civil Suit No. 1389 of 1978 (Civil Judge, Senior Division, Pune) against the respondents. The suit had initially resulted in an ex parte decree on 29 July 1980. That decree was set aside on remand in Writ Petition No. 3293 of 1981. After remand, a decree for possession was passed in favour of the original plaintiff on 5 July 1984, which the opinion records as having attained finality.

On 23 March 1984 the petitioners applied to the trial court pointing out that the suit property had been incorrectly described in the plaint as Survey No. 66/5A instead of Survey No. 66A/5 and sought correction. The trial court rejected that application on the ground that the plaint itself mentioned the survey number as 66/5A. On 9 April 1984 the petitioners filed an application invoking Section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) to correct a typographical mistake in the plaint and in the judgment and decree. The application alleged that the correct survey number (66A/5) was indicated in other parts of the record and that the defendants were aware of the correct number.

Initially, original defendant No. 1 was made a party to the section 152 application; other defendants were later added and served. Only original defendant No. 1 (respondent No. 1) filed a reply. The trial court rejected the application, holding the error was not clerical or arithmetical and that the original plaintiff could and should have corrected it earlier.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a mistake in the plaint describing the survey number of the suit property (recorded as Survey No. 66/5A instead of 66A/5) is a clerical or typographical error that can be corrected after a decree has been passed.
  2. Whether Section 152 CPC (power to amend judgments, decrees or orders for clerical or arithmetical mistakes) may be invoked to correct an error in the plaint, and if not, whether the Court may nevertheless correct such an error by exercising powers under Section 151 and/or Section 153 CPC.
  3. Whether refusal by the trial Court to allow correction, on the ground that the plaintiff should have corrected the plaint earlier, was correct in the circumstances of the case.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' (Appellants') Arguments

  • The correct survey number (Survey No. 66A/5) was stated in the deposition of the original plaintiff and shown on the map annexed to the plaint.
  • The incorrect survey number in the plaint was due to a typographical error and should be corrected even after the decree was passed.
  • The defendants were aware of the correct survey number throughout the proceedings.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Accidental errors or mistakes can be corrected only if they are in the judgment or decree; a mistake that has crept into the plaint cannot be corrected after a decree has become final.
  • The judgment must conform to the description of the property in the plaint, and the decree must conform to the operative part of the judgment; thus, if the plaint is not corrected, the judgment and decree cannot be amended to alter the plaint's description.
  • The original plaintiff had multiple opportunities (including appeal and writ proceedings) to correct the plaint but failed to do so, and therefore no interference under Article 227 was warranted.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by identifying the statutory provisions relevant to the dispute, reproducing the text of:

Section 151 CPC — "Nothing in this Code shall be deemed to limit or otherwise affect the inherent power of the Court to make such orders as may be necessary for the ends of justice, or to prevent abuse of the process of the Court."
Section 152 CPC — "Clerical or arithmetical mistakes in judgments, decrees or orders or errors arising therein from any accidental slip or omission may at any time be corrected by the Court either of its own motion or on the application of any of the parties."
Section 153 CPC — "The Court may at any time and on such terms as to costs or otherwise as it may think fit, amend any defect or error in any proceeding in a suit; and all necessary amendments shall be made for the purpose of determining the real question or issue raised by or depending on such proceeding."

The court then examined the record and identified multiple places where the correct survey number (Survey No. 66A/5) was recorded:

  • The map annexed to the plaint (and to the decree).
  • Paragraph 1 of the judgment dated 29 July 1980 (original judgment) which referred specifically to Survey No. 66A/5 and the plaintiff's claim to 19 gunthas out of that survey number.
  • The affidavit dated 22 December 1983 by the power of attorney holder of the deceased plaintiff's legal representatives.
  • The deposition of the power of attorney holder, Shankar Narhari Kavade.
  • Application Exh. 37 dated 25 October 1982 stating the claim to possession of 19 gunthas out of Survey No. 66A/5.
  • The judgment and order dated 30 June 1986 in Misc. Application No. 3 of 1984 (mesne profit application) referring to the subject-matter as Survey No. 66A/5.

The court also noted that several pleadings of the defendants (e.g., written statements Exh. 131 and Exh. 145, an application for amendment Exh. 62 and its reply Exh. 88) indicated that the defendants understood the suit to concern Survey No. 66A/5. On this factual matrix the court concluded that the reference in the plaint to "Survey No. 66/5A" was an accidental or typographical mistake.

The court addressed the technical objection that Section 152 CPC cannot be used to amend the plaint itself. While acknowledging that Section 152 is limited to correction of judgments, decrees or orders, the court held that broader correctional powers exist under Section 151 (inherent powers) and Section 153 (power to amend proceedings) of the CPC. The court reasoned that these provisions permit the court to correct accidental slips that are necessary to effectuate the ends of justice.

Applying those provisions to the present record, the court found it was "eminently a case" for correction: both parties had treated the suit as relating to Survey No. 66A/5; the incorrect notation in the plaint was obviously a typographical error; and correction was necessary to give effect to the true intentions of the parties and the meaning of the decree for possession.

The court therefore concluded that the trial judge erred in refusing correction on the ground that the mistake was not clerical or that the plaintiff should have corrected it earlier. The court held that the trial judge should have exercised power under Section 152 read with Sections 151 and 153 (i.e., using the combined corrective/amendment and inherent powers) to permit the correction.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core ruling): The petition is allowed — the impugned order is quashed and set aside; the application C-Application No. 60 of 1984 is allowed.

Specific directions given by the Court (as recorded in the order):

  • Rule is made absolute.
  • The application made by the petitioners (C-Application No. 60 of 1984) is allowed; necessary amendment to be carried out within two weeks from the date on which the order is received by the trial Court.
  • The petitioners are directed to pay costs of Rs. 2,500/- to the respondents.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The plaint and related judgment/decree are to be corrected to reflect Survey No. 66A/5, and costs of Rs. 2,500 are payable by the petitioners to the respondents.
  • Procedural implication drawn by the court: Where a mistake in the plaint is an obvious accidental or typographical error and the parties and record show the true description, a court may correct that error by invoking the combined operation of Section 152 read with Section 151 and Section 153 CPC so as to give effect to the intentions of the parties and the decree. (This statement of principle is articulated in the opinion as the basis for allowing the correction in this case.)

Disposition: Application allowed.

    Narhari Balku Kavade (Deceased By Lrs.) And Others v. Hanmanta Timma Pujari (Deceased By Lrs.) And Others

    1. By this petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, the petitioners have challenged the judgment and order dated 4th July 1984 passed by the learned 3rd Joint Civil Judge, Junior Division, Pune, below application Exh. 1 in C-Application No. 60 of 1984.

    2. The petitioners are the legal representatives of the original plaintiff in Regular Civil Suit No. 1389 of 1978 filed in the Court of the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Pune, against the respondents. The said suit initially came to be decreed ex parte on 29th July, 1980. Thereafter, in Writ Petition No. 3293 of 1981 an order of remand was passed by setting aside the decree passed on 29th July, 1980. After the remand, a decree for possession was passed in favour of the original plaintiff on 5th July, 1984 which has admittedly attained finality. On 23rd March, 1984, the petitioners made an application before the trial Court pointing out that in the judgment, suit property has been wrongly described as Survey No. 66/5A instead of Survey No. 66-A/5 and prayed for effecting necessary corrections. The said application was rejected by the trial Court on the ground that in the plaint, the survey number was mentioned as Survey No. 66/5A. On 9th April, 1984, an application was made by the petitioners by invoking Section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1980 (hereinafter referred to as “the said Code”), praying for correcting a typing mistake in the plaint as well as in the Judgment and Decree passed in the said suit. The case of the petitioner in the said application was that the suit property is Survey No. 66A/5 of village Dobadwadi, Ghorpadi Village, Pune and by mistake in the first paragraph of the plaint and in the schedule to the plaint survey number of the property was typed as 66/5A instead of 66A/5. A contention was raised in the said application that correct survey number was mentioned in the deposition of the original plaintiff and also at various other places and the defendants in the suit were fully aware about the correct survey number which was the subject-matter of the suit.

    3. Initially the original defendant No. 1 was made a party to the application under section 152 of the said code and later on other defendants were added as parties and were served with the notice of the application. However, reply was filed only by original defendant No. 1 i.e respondent No. 1 herein. It was contended that the mistake in the plaint cannot be allowed to be rectified as the said mistake was not corrected when the proceedings were filed earlier in the District Court and in this Court.

    4. While rejecting the application by passing the Impugned order, the learned trial Judge came to the conclusion that it was not a clerical or arithmetical mistake and as such the original plaintiff could have taken notice of the said mistake earlier and could have corrected it. The learned Judge further held that the original plaintiff failed to do so as he was not knowing the correct number of the said property. The learned trial Judge, therefore, came to the conclusion that it cannot be said that the mistake was clerical or arithmetical mistake or accidental slip or omission.

    5. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners contended that the correct survey number of the said property was mentioned in the deposition of the original plaintiff and on the map annexed to the plaint. He further submitted that the original defendants were all along aware about the correct survey number of the property in respect of which the suit was filed. He submitted that incorrect survey number was mentioned in the plaint only due to typographical error and the said error can be corrected even after decree was passed.

    6. The learned counsel appearing for some of the respondents contended that the accidental errors or mistake can be corrected only if the said mistakes or errors were in the judgment or decree of the Court and the mistake which has crept in the plaint itself cannot be corrected after the decree is passed in the suit and the decree has attained finality. He submitted that the judgment has to be in conformity with the description of the property in the plaint and the decree has to be in conformity with the operative part of the judgment. He therefore submitted that as the description of the property in the plaint cannot be corrected, there is no question of correcting the description of the suit property in the judgment and decree. He submitted that after the decree was passed in the suit for the first time on 29th July, 1980, there was an appeal preferred in the District Court challenging the said decree. The said appeal however came to be dismissed. He submitted that against the judgment in the appeal, a Writ Petition was filed in this Court in the year 1981 in which the order of remand was passed. He submitted that at no stage of all these proceedings, the original plaintiff made any efforts to get the description of the suit property in the plaint corrected though several opportunities were available. The learned counsel therefore submitted that no interference was called for in this petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

    7. Before adverting to the submissions made by the learned counsel appearing for the parties, it is necessary to refer to the relevant provisions. section 151 of the code reads thus:

    151. Saving of inherent powers of Court.— Nothing in this Code shall be deemed to limit or otherwise affect the inherent power of the Court to make such orders as may be necessary for the ends of justice, or to prevent abuse of the process of the Court.

    section 152 of the said code reads thus:

    152. Amendment of judgments, decrees or orders — Clerical or arithmetical mistakes in judgments, decrees or orders or errors arising therein from any accidental slip or omission may at any time be corrected by the Court either of its own motion or on the application of any of the parties.

    Section 152 gives power to the Civil Court to correct accidental errors and omissions in the judgment, order or decree of the Court.

    section 153 of the code reads thus:

    153. General power to amend.— The Court may at any time and on such terms as to costs or otherwise as it may think fit, amend any defect or error in any proceeding in a suit; and all necessary amendments shaft be made for the purpose of determining the real question or issue raised by or depending on such proceeding.

    Insofar as section 153 of the code is concerned, it is a general power vesting in the Civil Court to allow amendments to the proceedings of a suit at any stage. The said power includes power to allow amendment of pleadings.

    8. In para 1 of the plaint, the survey number of the suit property is mentioned as 66/5A. The same survey number appears in the schedule of the property in the plaint. The original record of the suit is available. A perusal of the original records shows that the correct survey number of the said property i.e Survey No. 66A/5 appears at several places as under:

    (i) In the map annexed to the plaint, which is also annexed to the decree passed in the suit.

    (ii) In paragraph 1 of the judgment dated 29th July, 1980 which was originally passed in the suit, there is a specific reference to survey No. 66A/5 and it is stated that by filing a suit the original plaintiff has sought vacant possession of 19 gunthas out of the said survey number.

    (iii) The affidavit dated 22nd December, 1983 of the power of attorney holder of the legal representatives of the deceased plaintiff.

    (iv) The deposition of Shankar Narhari Kavade, power of attorney holder of the legal representative of the original plaintiff.

    (v) The Application as Exh. 37 dated 25th October, 1982. In the said application it is specifically stated that the original plaintiff was seeking possession of an area of 19 gunthas out of survey No. 66A/5.

    (vi) The judgment and order dated 30th June, 1986 in Misc. Application No. 3 of 1984. The said Misc. Application was filed for determination of mesne profit as per the decree passed in the said suit. It is specifically stated in para 1 of the judgment that the subject matter of the suit was land bearing survey No. 66A/5.

    9. It is pertinent to note that even the defendants in the suit were all along aware that the suit was filed in respect of the land bearing Survey No. 66A/5. In the written statement at Exh. 131 filed by some of the defendants, a specific contention is raised stating therein that the said defendants were in possession of huts which were given house numbers and the said house numbers have nothing to do with the land bearing Survey No. 66A/5. Similar contention is found in written statement at Exh. 145. It is pertinent to note that an application was made at Exh. 62 by the original defendants for amendment of written statement. In the said application, there is a clear indication that even the defendants were aware that it was the specific case of the original plaintiff that the defendants had construed house by encroaching upon survey No. 66A/5. A reference to the said survey number is found at two places in the said application for amendment and a specific contention is raised that the huts constructed by the defendants having nothing to do with survey No. 66A/5 of the original plaintiff. The defendants filed reply at Exhibit 88 to the application for amendment filed by the original plaintiff. A perusal of the said reply shows that the defendants were aware that the original plaintiff was claiming possession of part of survey No. 66A/5.

    10. It is very clear from the record of the suit that the original plaintiff all along claimed to be the owner of survey No. 66A/5 and claimed possession of part of the said survey number. Even in the deposition of the constituted attorney of the legal representatives of the original plaintiff the said survey number is mentioned. Even from the pleadings of the defendants which are on record of the suit, it is very clear that the defendants were also aware that the original plaintiff was claiming possession of survey No. 66A/5. As stated earlier, even in the map annexed to the plaint which forms part of the decree passed in the suit, survey No. 66A/5 is mentioned. It is therefore very clear that both original plaintiff as well as the defendants were fully aware that the decree for possession was sought in respect of land bearing survey No. 66A/5. It is therefore clear that reference to Survey No. 66/5A in the plaint was obviously due to an accidental or typographical mistake.

    11. The contention of the learned counsel for the defendants is that section 152 of the said code cannot be invoked to amend the plaint. This contention appears to be correct. The power of the Court to make corrections for correcting errors arising due to accidental slip which are necessary for the ends of justice is not confined only to the power exercisable under section 152 of the said code. Extensive powers can be exercised even under Section 151 and Section 153 of the said Code. It is eminently a case in which the accidental slip should be corrected as the correction is necessary for the ends of justice. It would be a blot upon the judicial administration if the Courts were powerless to do justice in a case of this sort where corrections are necessary in order to give effect to the intentions of the parties themselves. The correction is required to be made with a view to give true meaning to the decree for possession.

    12. In the present case even the defendants were aware all along about the correct survey number of the property in respect of which decree was prayed for by the original plaintiff. Even the defendants were aware about the description of the property in respect of which decree was being prayed for and passed. It appears that there is accidental error and/or slip in describing the survey number in the suit. The said error ought to have been permitted to be corrected by the learned trial Judge by exercising powers under Section 152 read with Section 151 and Section 153 of the said Code. Merely because the petitioners have purported to apply only under section 152 of the code, relief cannot be denied to the petitioners. Hence, the impugned order deserves to be quashed and set aside and the application made by the petitioner deserves to be allowed.

    13. Due to accidental error on the part of the petitioners in describing the suit property, the respondents have been dragged to one more litigation. Therefore, this is a fit case where costs should be awarded to the respondents. The costs are quantified at Rs. 2500/-.

    14. Hence, I pass the following order:

    (i) Rule is made absolute.

    (ii) The application made by the petitioner i.e C-Application No. 60 of 1984 is allowed. Necessary amendment be carried out within a period of two weeks from the date on which this order is received by the trial Court.

    (iii) The petitioners are directed to pay costs of Rs. 2500/- to the respondents.

    Application allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Narhari Balku Kavade... v. Hanmanta Timma Pujar...
    (Apr 2, 2004)