Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Maharashtra Recognition of Trade Unions and Prevention of Unfair Labour Practices Act, hereinafter referred
  • Ss. 3(1)(a) and 3(1)(b) read with S. 5(2) of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948, hereinafter referred to as the Act,
  • MINIMUM WAGES ACT
  • Section 4(1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Maharashtra Recognition of Trade Unions and Prevention of Unfair Labour Practices Act, hereinafter referred
  • Ss. 3(1)(a) and 3(1)(b) read with S. 5(2) of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948, hereinafter referred to as the Act,
  • MINIMUM WAGES ACT
  • Section 4(1)
Smart Summary

Comprehensive Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Article 226 challenges an order of the Industrial Court, Mumbai, in Complaint (ULP) No. 133 of 1995 under the Maharashtra Recognition of Trade Unions and Prevention of Unfair Labour Practices Act (the MRTU Act). The petitioner is Harilal Jechand Doshi, operating the Ghatkopar Hindu Sabha Hospital (a charitable hospital). Respondent 1 is a trade union which filed the complaint on behalf of an employee, Smt. Indira Vyas.

The employee worked as a part-time clerk from 1979, receiving total wages of Rs. 892.60 (basic Rs. 412 + dearness allowance Rs. 480.60). On 8 November 1991 she became a full-time permanent clerk and was paid total wages of Rs. 1,154 (basic Rs. 227 + DA Rs. 927), and from 1 January 1992 total salary of Rs. 1,227 (basic Rs. 300 + DA Rs. 927).

On 14 March 1988 the State Government issued a notification under Sections 3(1)(a), 3(1)(b) read with Section 5(2) of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948 prescribing minimum monthly basic pay of Rs. 818 and special allowance of Rs. 336 for clerks employed in hospitals.

The union filed Complaint No. 133 of 1995 on 4 January 1995 alleging that by not paying the basic rate of wages as per that notification the hospital committed an unfair labour practice and sought refixation of the basic rate. By the impugned order dated 29 January 1999 the Industrial Court held that the petitioner committed an unfair labour practice under item (9) of Schedule IV of the MRTU Act and directed payment of Rs. 818 as basic and DA of Rs. 927 per month with annual increments from 8 November 1991 onwards except for the period 8 November 1992 to 4 January 1995. The petitioner challenged the legality and correctness of that order in this petition.

Note: The opinion refers to the impugned order as dated "29 January 1999" in several places and also, once, as "29 January 1989" (see para 20). The summary above follows the dates as they appear in the provided opinion without attempting to reconcile the inconsistency.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, when an employer has paid an employee a total sum that is not less than the minimum rate of wages fixed under the Minimum Wages Act (composed of component parts such as basic wage and dearness allowance), the employer nonetheless contravenes the Act by paying a component (the basic wage) at a rate lower than that separately prescribed by the notification.
  2. Specifically, whether the concerned employee was entitled to recover the difference between the basic wage actually paid (Rs. 300 per month) and the basic wage prescribed by the notification (Rs. 818 per month), notwithstanding that the total monthly payment exceeded the minimum wage prescribed by the notification.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (Sri Bukhari)

  • The statutory scheme of the Minimum Wages Act is to secure a minimum total wage for each employee; compliance requires payment of the minimum total, not separate adherence to each component's notified rate.
  • Since the employee was paid a total amount greater than the notified minimum total wage, there was no breach of the employer's duty under Section 12(1) of the Act.
  • Relied on authority (including Airfreight Ltd. v. State of Karnataka and other cases) establishing that where the employer pays a total sum higher than the minimum rates (including cost of living allowances), the employer need not separately pay the variable dearness allowance or other components at the notified rates.

Respondent's Arguments (Sri Ganguli)

  • The notification separately prescribed a basic rate of wages and, because the notification has not been challenged, the employer is obliged to pay that basic rate as notified by the State Government.
  • Consequently, failure to pay the basic rate of Rs. 818 per month constituted a breach despite total payments made.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Airfreight Ltd. v. State of Karnataka [1999 (4) L.L.N. 1] Held that the Act and its scheme do not require the minimum wage rates to be split into separate independent components for each necessity; where an employer pays a total sum higher than the minimum rates (including V.D.A.), the employer is not required to pay the V.D.A. separately as an independent component. The court relied on this authority to support its interpretation that components (basic wage and dearness allowance) need not each match the notified figure so long as the total wage paid is not less than the minimum rate fixed under Section 4(1).
Chairman of Madras Port Trust v. Claims Authority [AIR 1957 Mad 69] Establishes that the object of the Minimum Wages Act is to provide a minimum wage for each employee; the contractual wage-structure remains unaffected so long as the minimum is paid; if contractual rates exceed statutory minimums the statutory obligation does not come into play; employer not guilty if a particular component is lower but total exceeds minimum. The court used this precedent to reinforce the view that the Act guarantees a minimum total and does not invalidate contractual allocation of wage components where the total exceeds the statutory minimum.
Union of India v. Rathi [A.I.R. 1963 Bom. 54] Recalls that the object of the Act is to provide minimum wages according to nature and duration of work and directs attention to determining the total liability imposed on the employer. The court cited this case to emphasize that the relevant inquiry is the total statutory liability of the employer, supporting the conclusion that total wages paid are determinative.
Municipal Borough v. Gundawan [A.I.R. 1965 Mys. 317] Holds that the Act guarantees a minimum rate of wages and if wages paid by the employer exceed what the employee would get based on the minimum wages, no relief can be given under the Act. The court relied on this authority to support the conclusion that no relief under the Minimum Wages Act is available where the total wages paid exceed the statutory minimum.
Imperial Tobacco Company v. State [A.I.R. 1970 Pat. 193] After considering the Madras decision, the court held that if wages paid by the employer exceed the minimum wages,then no relief can be given under the Act even where the Act provides separate regulations (e.g., overtime pay rules). The court cited this case to demonstrate consistent judicial treatment that total payment in excess of minimum rates precludes relief under the Act for alleged shortfall in individual components.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a structured manner:

  1. Fact analysis: The Industrial Court had found that the employee's component basic wage was less than Rs. 818 as per the notification, but it was common ground that the total monthly payments (basic + dearness allowance) made by the employer never fell below the total minimum wages prescribed by the 14 March 1988 notification.
  2. Statutory framework: The court examined the relevant provisions of the Minimum Wages Act — the definition of "wages" (Section 2(h)), the duty of the appropriate Government to fix minimum wages (Section 3(1)), and the form that a minimum rate of wages may take (Section 4(1)), which contemplates that minimum rate may consist of a basic rate and a special allowance or an all-inclusive rate.
  3. Legal question isolate: The primary legal question identified in the petition was whether the employee was entitled to recover the shortfall between the basic wage actually paid (Rs. 300) and the basic wage notified (Rs. 818), notwithstanding that the aggregate wage paid was above the minimum total.
  4. Precedential support: The court reviewed authorities (including Airfreight Ltd. v. State of Karnataka, Chairman of Madras Port Trust v. Claims Authority, Union of India v. Rathi, Municipal Borough v. Gundawan, and Imperial Tobacco Company v. State) that emphasize that the object of the Act is to guarantee a minimum rate of wages for employees and that where the total of payments made by an employer exceeds the minimum fixed rate, relief is not available under the Act merely because a particular component is lower than the notified figure.
  5. Interpretation of Section 4(1): The court held that Section 4(1) provides for a minimum rate which may consist of component parts but does not postulate separate minima for those components; each component does not itself constitute the minimum rate within the meaning of Section 4(1). Consequently, if an employer has paid the total wages more than the minimum rate within the meaning of Section 4(1), there is no contravention of the Act.
  6. Application to facts: Applying that interpretation to the present facts — where the employee was paid both components and the aggregate amount exceeded the minimum prescribed under the notification — the court concluded that the employer had not contravened the Minimum Wages Act.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The petition succeeds and, accordingly, the court QUASHED AND SET ASIDE the impugned order of the Industrial Court in Complaint (ULP) No. 133 of 1995. The opinion states: "The impugned order, dated 29 January 1989, passed by the Industrial Court, Mumbai, in Complaint (ULP) No. 133 of 1995 is quashed and set aside. No order as to costs."

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The Industrial Court's direction that the employer pay the basic wage at Rs. 818 (with specified DA and increments from specified dates) is annulled; the petitioner (the hospital) prevails in this petition.
  • No order as to costs was made by the court.

Broader implications:

The opinion primarily addresses the interpretation and application of the Minimum Wages Act to the facts before the court. The court applied existing authorities to conclude that where total payments by an employer meet or exceed the minimum rate prescribed under Section 4(1), a shortfall in an individual component (such as basic wages) does not by itself constitute a contravention of the Act. The opinion does not state that it is establishing a new precedent beyond applying and following the cited authorities.

Parties to act on an ordinary copy duly authenticated by the associate of this Court.

    Harilal Jechand Doshi Ghatkopar Hindu Sabha Hospital v. Maharashtra General Kamgar Union And Another

    1. This petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India challenges the order, dated 29 January 1999, made by the Industrial Court, Mumbai, in Complaint (ULP) No. 133 of 1995, a proceeding under the provisions of the Maharashtra Recognition of Trade Unions and Prevention of Unfair Labour Practices Act, hereinafter referred to as the MRTU Act.

    2. The petitioner Harilal Jechand Doshi, Ghatkopar Hindu Sabha Hospital, is a charitable hospital. Respondent 1 is a trade union, who had filed the above complaint before the Industrial Court, Mumbai, on behalf of a member-employee Smt. Indira Vyas. The concemea employee was working with the petitioner as part-time clerk since 1979 and drawing a sum of Rs. 892.60 as wages comprising of Rs. 412 as basic and Rs. 480.60 as dearness allowance. On 8 November 1991, the concerned employee was appointed as a full-time permanent clerk. She was paid total wages amounting to Rs. 1,154 comprising of Rs. 227 as basic and Rs. 927 as dearness allowance. From 1 January 1992, the concerned employee is drawing a total salary of Rs. 1,227, comprising of Rs. 300 as basic wages and Rs. 927 as dearness allowance.

    3. On 14 March 1988 the State Government issued a notification, being Notification No. MWA 5287/6730.LAB/7 under Ss. 3(1)(a) and 3(1)(b) read with S. 5(2) of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948, hereinafter referred to as the Act, prescribing the minimum monthly basic pay of Rs. 818 and special allowance of Rs. 336 for the clerks employed in hospitals.

    4. On 4 January 1995, the union filed Complaint No. 133 of 1995 before the Industrial Court under items (5) and (9) of Sch. IV of the MRTU & PULP Act. It is urged by the union that by not paying the basic rate of wages as per the notification issued under the Act, the petitioner hospital, has indulged in unfair labour practice and, therefore, a prayer is made for refixation of the basic rate of wages of the concerned employee. By the impugned order, dated 29 January 1999, the Industrial Court declared that the petitioner has committed an unfair labour practice under item (9) of Sch. IV of the MRTU Act and directed the petitioner to pay to the concerned employee at Rs. 818 and dearness allowance of Rs. 927 per month along with annual increments applicable to the basic rate of wages of Rs. 818 per month from 8 November 1991 onwards excepting for the period from 8 November 1992 to 4 January 1995. The legality and correctness of this order is challenged in the present petition.

    5. A reading of the order of the Industrial Court shows that the Industrial Court noted that the total wages paid to the employee were more than the minimum wages prescribed under the relevant notification issued under S. 5 of the Act. However, what has been held by the Industrial Court is that the employee was not paid the basic wage of Rs. 818 per month as per the notification and this amounts to violation of a mandatory provision of the Act. In that view of the matter, the Industrial Court directed the employer to pay basic wage at the rate of Rs. 818 per month.

    6. The main argument of Sri Bukhari, learned counsel for the petitioner, is that the wages paid to the employee were more than the total minimum wages prescribed under the notification. Sn Bukhari urged that what the employee is entitled to get is the wages, the totality thereof, at a rate not less than the minimum rate prescribed and, therefore, if the employee is paid more than the minimum wages, it cannot be said that there was breach of the employer's duty, as defined by S. 12(1) of the Act.

    7. In reply, Sri Ganguli, learned counsel for the respondent, contended that the payment of basic rate of wages was separately prescribed under the notification and since that notification has not been challenged by the petitioner-employer, the employer is bound to pay the basic rate of wages as notified by the State Government.

    8. The employee concerned was during the relevant period paid wages made up of two component parts, namely, basic wage and dearness allowance, i.e, special allowance It is a common ground that the total of the two payments actually made to the employee each month during the relevant period calculated on the basis of the contractual rates, never fell below the total of the minimum wages calculated on the basis of the minimum wages prescribed by the notification, dated 14 March 1988. It is also a common ground that what was paid as basic wage by the employer was Rs. 300 per month, whereas the notification provided for the basic wage of Rs: 818 a month. Whether, in the circumstances of the case, the employee was also entitled to the difference between Rs. 300 and Rs. 818 is the question, which is required to be decided in this petition.

    9. In order to appreciate the rival contentions, it is necessary to look into the relevant provisions of the Act. Section 2(h) of the Act defines “wages” as follows:

    “Wages” means all remunerations, capable of being expressed in terms of money, which would, if the terms of the contract of employment express or implied were fulfilled, be payable to a person employed in respect of his employment or of work done in such employment and mcludes house rent allowance but does not include —

    (i) the value of:

    (a) any house-accommodation, supply of light, water, medical attendance, or

    (b) any other amenity or any service excluded by general or special order of the appropriate Government.

    (ii) any contribution paid by the employer to any pension fund or provident fund or under any scheme of social insurance;

    (iii) any travelling allowances or the value of any travelling concession,

    (iv) any sum paid to the person employed to defray special expenses entailed on him by the nature of his employment; or

    (v) any gratuity payable on discharge.”

    10. Section 3(1) of the Act directs the appropnate Government to fix the minimum rates of wages. Section 3(1) reads thus:

    “Section 3(1). The appropnate Government shall, in the manner hereinafter provided —

    (a) fix the minimum rates of wagespayable to employees employed in an employment specified in Part I or Part II of the schedule and in an employment added to either part by notification under S. 27

    Provided that the State Government may, instead of fixing minimum rates of wages under this clause for the whole State, fix such rates for a part of the State or for any specified class or classes of such employments in the whole of the State or any part thereof; and in the case of an employment under any local authority; the State Government may fix such rates for any specified local authority, or class of local authonty;

    (b) review at such intervals as it may think fit, such intervals not exceeding five years, the minimum rates of wages so fixed and revise the minimum rates, if necessary:

    Provided that, where for any reason the appropriate Government has not reviewed the minimum rates of wages fixed by it in respect of any scheduled employment within any interval or five years, nothing contained in this clause shall be deemed to prevent it from reviewing the minimum rates after the expiry of the said period of five years and revising them, if necessary, and until they are so revised the minimum rates in force immediately before the expiry of the said period of five years shall continue in force.

    (1A) ***”

    11. Section 4 of the Act prescribes the minimum rate of wages and reads as follows:

    “4. Minimum rate of wages. — (1) Any minimum rate of wages fixed or revised by the appropriate Government in respect of scheduled employments under S. 3 may consist of:

    (i) a basic rate of wages and a special allowance at a rate to be adjusted to such intervals and in such manner as the appropriate Govemment may direct, to accord as nearly as practicable with the variation in the cost of living index number applicable to such worker (hereinafter referred to as the cost of living allowance); or

    (ii) a basic rate of wages with or without the cost of living allowance and the cash value of the concession in respect of supplies of essential commodities at concession rates, where so authorised; or

    (iii) an all inclusive rate allowing for the basic rate, the cost of living allowance and the cash value of the concessions, if any.

    (2) The cost of living allowance and the cash value of the concessions in respect of supplies of essential commodities at concession rates shall be computed by the competent authority at such intervals and in accordance with such direction as may be specified or given by the appropriate Government.”

    12. The duty cast upon by S. 3(1) in fixing the wages has to be discharged by publication of a notification as provided under S. 5(2) of the Act. When such a notification is published, the duty is then cast upon the employer by S. 12(1) of the Act to pay to the employer the wages not less than what has been notified by the Government as the minimum payable.

    13. Sri Bukhari's argument is that the scheme of the Act is to provide a minimum wage for each employee and so long as that minimum wage is paid, there is compliance with the provisions of the Act. It is not the requirement of the statute that each component part of the minimum wages, such as the basic wage and the deamess allowance/special allowance should be paid at the rate prescribed under the notification.

    14. Sri Bukhari brought to my notice a recent judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Airfreight, Ltd. v. State of Karnataka [1999 (4) L.L.N 1]. In that case, the appellant-company was paying more than the minimum wages including deamess allowance. The question before the Court was whether the workers were entitled to variable deamess allowance (V.D.A) under a notification issued by the State Government under the Minimum Wages Act. The Apex Court held that neither the scheme nor any provision of the Act provides that the rates of minimum wages are to be split up on the basis of the cost of each necessity taken into consideration for fixing the same. Hence, in the cases where an employer is paying a total sum which is higher than the minimum rates of wages fixed under the Act, including the costs of living index (V.D.A), he is not required to pay V.D.A separately. Where minimum wage is linked with the cost of living index, the amount paid on the basis of deamess allowance is not to be taken as an independent component of the minimum wages but as part and parcel of the process of computing the rates of minimum wages which is to be detennined after taking into consideration the cost of various necessities.

    15. Sri Bukhari also drew my attention to the case of Chairman of Madras Port Trust v. Claims Authority [AIR 1957 Mad 69], wherein it was held by the Madras High Court that what the employee is entitled to is the wages and the scheme of the Minimum Wages Act is to provide for a minimum wage for each employee. It further also lays down that the Act provides for a payment of a minimum So long as that minimum is paid the contractual wage-structure is left unaffected and the component parts of wages could still be regulated by contract between the employer and employee and that definition of wages postulates a contractual basis, express or implied If the contract rate of wages is higher, the statutory right and obligation do not come into play. It was also held that if the wages paid to the concerned workmen under various heads of monthly wages, dearness allowance, house rent allowance, etc., exceeded the minimum rate of wages fixed under the Act the employer could not be held guilty of contravening the nofication, though a particular component of the wage-structure, viz., dearness allowance, was at a rate lower than the one fixed under that Act.

    16. Sri Bukhari also drew my attention to the decision of this Court in the case of Union of India v. Rathi [A.I.R 1963 Bom. 54], in which it was laid down that the object of the said Act being to provide minimum wages to the employees according to the nature and the duration of the work done by the employees, one has to find out what is the total liability imposed on the employer.

    17. The next case relied upon by Sri Bukhari is of Municipal Borough v. Gundawan [A.I.R 1965 Mys. 317], wherein learned Single Judge was pleased to hold that from the scheme of the Act it is clear that its object was to guarantee to those who are working in scheduled employment, a minimum rate of wages, and if the wages paid by the employer are more than what the employees would have got on the basis of the minimum wages, then no relief can be given under the Act.

    18. The last case relied upon by Sri Bukhari is of the Patna High Court in Imperial Tobacco Company v. State [A.I.R 1970 Pat. 193]. In that case, the Division Bench, after considering the decision of the Madras High Court held that if the wages paid by the employer are more than what the employees would have got on the basis of the minimum wages, then no relief can be given under the Act in spite of the Act providing for the regulation of the hours of work, or rule 25 by prescribing wages for the overtime work at double the ordinary rate of wages.

    19. It is thus clearly seen that S. 4(1) of the Act provides for the minimum rate which could consist of component parts. Section 4(1) does not postulate different minimum for the several components; nor can each such minimum constitute the minimum rate of wages within the meaning of S. 4(1). If the employer has paid the total wages more than the minimum rate of wages within the meaning of S. 4(1), there cannot be any contravention of the provisions of the Act. In the instant case, the minimum wages composes of two component parts, namely, basic wage and dearness allowance. It is not disputed that the employee in the present case has been paid the wages under both the component parts and the total amount paid to the employee is higher than the minimum wages prescribed under the notification. Under the circumstances, it cannot be said that the employer has contravened the provisions of the Minimum Wages Act.

    20. In the result, the petition succeeds. The impugned order, dated 29 January 1989, passed by the Industrial Court, Mumbai, in Complaint (ULP) No. 133 of 1995 is quashed and set aside. No order as to costs.

    21. Parties to act on an ordinary copy duly authenticated by the associate of this Court.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Harilal Jechand Dosh... v. Maharashtra General ...
    (Aug 12, 1999)