Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 39, Rule 7(a)
  • Rule 7(a) of Order 39
  • Order 18, Rule 18,
  • Order 26, Rule 9,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 39, Rule 7(a)
  • Rule 7(a) of Order 39
  • Order 18, Rule 18,
  • Order 26, Rule 9,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner owns the building known as “Fair Field Annexe” located at Veer Savarkar Marg, Mahim, Bombay. The respondent is the tenant of flat No. 3 on the second floor of this building. The petitioner initiated proceedings (R.A.E & R. Suit No. 1504/5511 of 1982) against the respondent seeking possession due to default in rent payment. Concurrently, the respondent filed R.A.N No. 437.SR of 1982 for fixation of standard rent. Both proceedings are being heard together by the Small Causes Court.

The respondent sought permission via Notice No. 2031 of 1995 to inspect two flats (No. 6 on the second floor and No. 7 on the third floor) which are not part of the suit. The respondent argued that inspection of these flats was necessary to determine the standard rent of the suit flat No. 3, as the landlord occupied one of these flats and paid rent of Rs. 1,000 per month. The respondent claimed the flats were similar in area and location to the suit flat, justifying inspection to establish this fact.

The petitioner opposed the inspection, contending the Court lacked jurisdiction to grant inspection of flats not subject to the suit, and offered to provide sanctioned building plans instead. Despite opposition, the Small Causes Court granted the inspection order on June 16, 1995, with directions to avoid inconvenience to the occupants of the inspected flats.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Small Causes Court was correct in granting inspection of premises not subject-matter of the suit and in possession of third parties.
  2. Whether the Court had jurisdiction under Order 39, Rule 7(a) of the Code of Civil Procedure to order such inspection.
  3. Whether prior notice to occupants of the flats was necessary before granting the inspection order.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The inspection order is without jurisdiction as Order 39, Rule 7(a) primarily relates to preservation of property and does not authorize inspection of premises not subject to the suit.
  • The Court cannot direct inspection of premises in possession of third parties and unrelated to the suit.
  • Prior notice should have been issued to occupants of flats No. 6 and 7 before passing the inspection order.
  • The petitioner expressed willingness to provide sanctioned building plans as an alternative to inspection.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Inspection of flats No. 6 and 7 is necessary to determine the standard rent of the suit flat No. 3.
  • The landlord's occupation and rent payment of Rs. 1,000 for one of these flats supports the claim that the suit flat's standard rent should be the same.
  • Inspection is needed to establish similarity in area and location between the flats.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sankar Lal Daga v. Phulchand Agarwalla, ILR (1960) 1 Calcutta 529 Inspection of flats not subject-matter of the suit is permissible if necessary for justice. Supported the Court's view that inspection of adjacent flats not subject to the suit was valid for determination of controversy.
Narasimha v. Sengodi, AIR 1955 Mysore 79 Requirement of prior notice before inspection of property belonging to third parties. Court acknowledged the principle but held any grievance must be raised by occupants, not landlord; prior notice was not mandatory here given precautions taken.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the scope of Order 39, Rule 7(a) of the Code of Civil Procedure and found it not limited strictly to the subject-matter of the suit but extends to any property about which questions may arise in the suit. The Court referenced Order 18, Rule 18 and Order 26, Rule 9, which empower inspection and local investigation in suits to elucidate matters in dispute.

The Court rejected the petitioner's contention that inspection could not be ordered for flats not subject to the suit, emphasizing the necessity of such inspection for just determination of the controversy. The Court relied on the precedent of Sankar Lal Daga v. Phulchand Agarwalla to affirm this principle.

Regarding the need for prior notice to occupants of the flats, the Court acknowledged the principle from Narasimha v. Sengodi but held that any grievance should be raised by the occupants themselves. Since the trial Court had taken precautions to minimize inconvenience, the Court found no reason to require prior notice to occupants before ordering inspection.

Consequently, the Court found no error or jurisdictional infirmity in the impugned order and dismissed the revision petition with costs.

Holding and Implications

The Court DISMISSED the revision petition challenging the inspection order.

The direct effect is that the Small Causes Court's order permitting inspection of flats not subject to the suit stands affirmed. The Court clarified that under the Code of Civil Procedure, inspection of properties not directly involved in the suit may be ordered if necessary for resolving the dispute. No new precedent was set beyond affirming existing provisions and case law. The inspection was directed to be conducted on October 20, 1995, as per the trial Court's order.

    Madhukar R. Javle v. Baskar Ramnath Shibad .

    By this petition under Art. 227, the petitioner seeks to challenge an order passed by the Small Causes Court, Bombay, granting respondent's notice for inspection of the flats situated on the second and third floor of the suit building, which are not subject-matter of the suit. Apparently, the Small Causes Court has taken recourse to provisions of O. 39, R. 7(a) of the C.P.C The short question is whether the lower Court was right in granting inspection of premises, which are not the subject-matter of the suit and are in possession of third parties.

    2. Before I deal with the rival contentions, I would like to state briefly the facts leading to this petition, which are few and almost undisputed. The petitioner is the owner of the building known as “Fair Field Annexe” situated at Veer Savarkar Marg, Mahim, Bombay. The respondent is the tenant of flat No. 3 on the second floor of the said building. The petitioner has filed R.A.E & R. Suit No. 1504/5511 of 1982 against the respondent for possession on the ground of default in payment of rent. The respondent has filed R.A.N No. 437.SR of 1982 for fixation of standard rent. Both these proceedings are being heard together by the order of the Chief Judge of the Small Cause Court.

    3. The respondent has taken out Notice No. 2031 of 1995 for allowing the respondent and his architect and authorised agent to enter upon and take inspection of two flats, namely flat No. 6 on the second floor and flat No. 7 on third floor, which are admittedly not the subject-matter of the proceedings before the Small Cause Court. According to the respondent, such inspection is necessary for the purpose of determining the controversy between the parties about the standard rent of the suit flat No. 3, which is the subject-matter of the suit. It is the case of the respondent that the landlord himself was in occupation in respect of one of these two flats and he was paying rent of Rs. 1,000/- per month. It is said that the area of the said flats is equal to the suit flat and, therefore, the standard rent of the suit flat should be the same i.e Rs. 1,000/- per month. The respondent says that in order to establish that the area and location of these flats are identical, an inspection is necessary.

    4. The petitioner has opposed the application vehemently on the ground that such inspection is totally uncalled for. It is contended that the Court has no jurisdiction to grant such inspection, since, admittedly, the two flats in question are not the subject-matter of the suit. The petitioner has also shown his willingness to supply copies of the sanctioned plans of the building. The petitioner, therefore, contended that the order of inspection should not be passed.

    5. By an order dated June 16, 1995, the Small Cause Court has made the notice taken out by the respondent absolute. It is necessary to reproduce the operative part of the order of the Small Cause Court, because the Small Cause Court has issued some additional directions in order to ensure that the occupants of the said two flats should not be inconvenienced in any manner. The order reads:—

    “The plaintiff is directed to give inspection of the flats situated on the second floor and third floor of the suit property as prayed, on 19th May, 1995 between 10.00 a.m and 1.00 p.m

    Parties are directed to give inspection in notice in advance to both the tenants before inspecting and measuring the premises.

    Defendant is also directed to supply copy of this Judgment and Order to the said two tenants for completing smooth inspection, measurement of the said two flats well in advance.

    Parties are directed to take the precaution that they will complete the inspection of the said two flats within about three hours by avoiding any unwarranted inconvenience to the occupants thereof.”

    6. Mr. Jahagirdar, learned counsel for the petitioner, strenuously contended that the impugned order is without jurisdiction. Mr. Jahagirdar says that Rule 7(a) of Order 39 basically relates to preservation of the property and the type of the order, which is passed by the Small Cause Court, is not within the scope of Rule 7(a). Mr. Jahagirdar says that it is not open for the Court to direct inspection of the premises, which is not the subject-matter of the suit. Mr. Jahagirdar also says that in any event it was obligatory on the part of the trial Court to issue prior notices to the occupants of the flat Nos. 6 and 7 before passing any such order.

    7. At the outset, it must be mentioned that Rule 7(a) is not restricted to the subject-matter of the suit. The rule clearly empowers the Court to make an order for inspection of any property, which is the subject-matter of the suit or to which any question may arise therein. At this stage, a reference may also be made to Order 18, Rule 18, which provides that the Court may at any stage of a suit inspect any property or thing concerning which any question may arise. Similarly, under Order 26, Rule 9, in any suit in which the Court deems a local investigation to be requisite or proper for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute, the Court may issue a commission to such person as he thinks fit directing him to make such an investigation and to report thereon to the Court. In view of the aforesaid provisions, it is not possible to accept the contention of Mr. Jahagirdar that in exercise of the powers granted to the Court under the Code, the Court is precluded from directing inspection of some other property adjacent to the suit property should such inspection be necessary in the interest of justice. In my opinion, the scope of Rule 7(a) is wide enough to confer power on the Court to order inspection even in respect of properties, which are not the subject-matter of the suit; provided such inspection is necessary for determination of the controversy before the Court. At this stage, I may mention that in somewhat similar situation, Guha, J. of Calcutta High Court has granted inspection of the flats, which were not the subject-matter of the suit. (Sankar Lal Daga v. Phulchand Agarwalla, ILR (1960) 1 Calcutta 529). In that case, on an application made by the tenant to the Rent Controller for fixation of fair rent the landlord applied for a direction on the Inspector to take measurement of an adjacent similar tenancy in the same premises. Access to the premises was, however, refused by the tenant. The question arose whether the Rent Controller could enforce an order for inspection of the adjoining tenancy. The question was answered in the affirmative by the learned Judge. Thus I do not find any error or infirmity in the impugned order. The order is passed within the four corners of the provisions of Order 39, Rule 7(a) and no exception can be taken of such order, which is an interlocutory order.

    8. Mr. Jahagirdar next contended that the Small Cause Court ought to have issued notices to the occupants of the said flat Nos. 6 and 7 before issuing the order of inspection. Mr. Jahagirdar urged that the Commission cannot be directed to enter upon property of stranger and inspect property, which is not subject-matter of the suit without prior notice to such party. Mr. Jahagirdar placed reliance upon a decision of the Mysore High Court in Narasimha v. Sengodi, AIR 1955 Mysore 79. There cannot be any quarrel with the proposition laid down by the Mysore High Court. But, in my opinion, the grievance, if any, has to be made by the occupants of the flats and not by the present landlord. In any case, the trial Court has taken necessary precaution in order to see that the work of inspection is finished within the minimum period and no incovenience is caused to the occupants of the flats. Therefore, I do not see any reason to issue any prior notices to the said accupants. Revision Application, therefore, fails and the same is dismissed with costs.

    9. It has been brought to my notice that the date fixed by the trial Court for inspection is already expired and, therefore, a fresh date is required to be fixed. It is, therefore, directed that the inspection will be taken in terms of the order of the trial Court on October 20, 1995.

    Certified copy expedited.

    Revision dismissed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Madhukar R. Javle v. Baskar Ramnath Shibad .
    (Sep 19, 1995)