AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • S. 77A of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960.The
  • S. 77A of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960
  • Ss. 77A(b) and 77A(c) of the Co-operative Societies Act,
  • Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 (the Act).
  • sub-section (2) of S. 73G
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • S. 77A of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960.The
  • S. 77A of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960
  • Ss. 77A(b) and 77A(c) of the Co-operative Societies Act,
  • Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 (the Act).
  • sub-section (2) of S. 73G
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are directors of Balasaheb Desai Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Limited, a co‑operative society registered under the Maharashtra Co‑operative Societies Act, 1960. The Board of Directors comprised 15 members (11 elected members, 2 worker representatives, 1 co‑opted expert director and 1 representative of the District Central Co‑operative Bank). The last election was held in 1984. Under S. 73G(2) of the Act their term was for five years and thus expired in 1989. Elections to a new Board could not be held before or after expiry of that term.

On 15 October 1993 the Director of Sugar (who also functioned as Additional Registrar of Co‑operative Societies) issued a show‑cause notice invoking S. 77A of the Act proposing removal of the existing Board and appointment of an administrator. The Board submitted a written reply on 16 November 1993 explaining the reasons elections could not be held and requesting withdrawal of the proposed action. On 20 November 1993 the Director dismissed the Board and appointed Shri Y. B. Khavale, Joint Director (Sugar) (Administration), as Administrator under powers invoked in the order (the order refers to S. 77A and the court later refers to S. 11A as the power exercised). The petitioners appealed to the Additional Chief Secretary, Government of Maharashtra, who on 7 January 1994 dismissed the appeal, relying inter alia on S. 73G(2B) (as substituted by Maharashtra Act 20 of 1986) and the view that after the aggregate six‑year period the members cease to hold office. The petitioners challenged that appellate order by filing this writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Ss. 77A(b) and 77A(c) of the Maharashtra Co‑operative Societies Act, 1960 applied so as to permit dismissal of the elected Board and appointment of an administrator where elections had not been held after expiry of the term that began in 1984.
  2. Whether, after the 1986 amendment to S. 73G (in particular sub‑secs. (2) and (2B)), the members of a managing committee continue to hold office until the first meeting of the newly elected committee (as held in pre‑1986 authority) or whether they cease to hold office on expiry of the (extended) term in circumstances where elections were not held.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as presented)

  • S. 77A did not apply because clause (b) permits appointment of an administrator only where there is a failure on the part of the committee to elect members or fill vacancies within the term; in the petitioners' submission there was no such failure attributable to them.
  • Because the show‑cause notice and the dismissal order were issued under S. 77A, reliance could not be placed on S. 73G(2) (pre‑amendment wording) to support the order.
  • Reliance was placed on the decision in Ghatageepa Parreppa Mugeri v. M. R. Naik (1983 Mah LJ 984 : AIR 1984 Bom 56) for the proposition that an existing committee is entitled to continue functioning until the new committee takes office (i.e., until the first meeting of the newly elected managing committee).

State / Appellate Authority Position (as recorded)

  • The Additional Chief Secretary dismissed the petitioners' appeal on the ground that S. 73G(2B) (substituted by Maharashtra Act 20 of 1986) provides that where elections are not held before the expiry of the term or extended term, the members cease to hold office and are deemed to have vacated their offices, thereby attracting S. 77A and empowering appointment of an administrator.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ghatageepa Parreppa Mugeri v. M. R. Naik, 1983 Mah LJ 984 : (AIR 1984 Bom 56) Authority for the proposition (under the pre‑1986 version of S. 73G(2)) that members of an elected managing committee continue to function until immediately before the first meeting of the newly elected managing committee (i.e., they do not become functus officio immediately on expiry of the five‑year period). The court distinguished and rejected reliance on this precedent because it was decided under the pre‑1986 statutory regime. After the 1986 amendment (insertion/substitution of S. 73G(2), (2A) and (2B)), the law expressly provides for cessation of office on expiry of the term or extended term where elections were not held; thus the earlier authority no longer applies to the amended statutory framework.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a textual and contextual analysis of Ss. 77A and 73G of the Maharashtra Co‑operative Societies Act as they stood at the relevant time. The analytical steps recorded in the opinion are:

  1. Construction of S. 77A: The court reproduced S. 77A and observed that the Registrar may appoint administrators where any of the conditions in clauses (a)–(f) exist. Clause (b) was examined in detail and read as containing two alternative situations: (i) the term or extended term of the committee or any of its members has expired; or (ii) where, for any other reason, an election is held and there is a failure to elect all or any required members. The court emphasized that these two conditions are alternative and not cumulative, so the expiry of term alone can invoke S. 77A.
  2. Examination of S. 73G and the 1986 amendment: The opinion compared S. 73G(2) as it stood before the 1986 amendment with the substituted provision after Maharashtra Act 20 of 1986. Prior to amendment, S. 73G(2) provided that elected members served five years but "shall continue in office until immediately before the first meeting of the members of the new committee." The 1986 substitution changed this: the five‑year term could be extended by the State Government for reasons recorded in writing for up to one year, but the aggregate could not exceed six years. Crucially, sub‑section (2B) (inserted in 1986) states that where, for any reason, elections were not held before expiry of the term or extended term, the members cease to hold office on the expiry and shall be deemed to have vacated their offices.
  3. Application of the statutory text to the facts: The court applied the amended statutory provisions to the timeline of this case. The election occurred in 1984; the five‑year term expired in 1989. There was no material showing that the State Government extended the term. Even assuming an extension, the aggregate six‑year period would have expired in 1990. On expiry of six years, S. 73G(2B) operates to terminate the office of the committee and its members, making them deemed to have vacated their offices.
  4. Conclusion on S. 77A's applicability and officials' powers: Because the committee had ceased to hold office by operation of S. 73G(2B), S. 77A was attracted and empowered the Registrar (Director of Sugar acting as Additional Registrar) to appoint an administrator. The court concluded that the Director was therefore justified in appointing an administrator (the opinion also refers to exercise of powers under S. 11A in this context), and the appellate authority was justified in confirming that appointment and dismissing the appeal.
  5. Treatment of prior precedent: The court considered the petitioners' reliance on Ghatageppa Parreppa Mugeri and explained that the holding in that case arose under the pre‑1986 statutory provision which permitted continuation until the first meeting of the newly elected committee. That statutory position was altered by the 1986 amendment; therefore the earlier decision was not applicable and reliance on it was "totally misplaced and unjustified."

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition was dismissed. Emphatically, the court held that the order dated 20 November 1993 of the Director of Sugar under S. 77A of the Maharashtra Co‑operative Societies Act, 1960 was in accordance with law, and the appellate authority was justified in dismissing the petitioners' appeal.

DISPOSITION: The petition is dismissed (at the admission stage).

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The dismissal of the Board of Directors and the appointment of the Administrator (Shri Y. B. Khavale) were upheld.
  • The petition was dismissed at the admission stage and the court ordered that there shall be no order as to costs.
  • A certified copy of the order was to be expedited.

Broader legal implication noted by the court: the 1986 amendment to S. 73G (including the insertion of sub‑sec. (2B)) changed the legal position that previously allowed an outgoing committee to continue until the first meeting of the newly elected committee; after the amendment, members will cease to hold office on expiry of the term or extended term where elections have not been held, and S. 77A may be invoked in such circumstances. The court treated prior authority decided under the pre‑1986 wording as distinguishable and no longer controlling in the amended statutory regime.

Final Court Order (as recorded): Petition dismissed. No order as to costs. Certified copy expedited.

    Shamburaj Shivajirao Desai And Others v. Director Of Sugar, Maharashtra State, Pune And Others

    1. petitioners are the directors of Balasaheb Desai Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Limited, a co-operative society registered under the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 (“the Act”). By this writ petition they seek to challenge the legality of the order of the Additional Chief Secretary to the Government of Maharashtra, Co-operation and Textile Department dated 7 January, 1994 dismissing the appeal of the petitioners against the order of the Director of Sugar (Administration) and Additional Registrar of the Co-operative Societies, Maharashtra dated 20 November, 1993 by which in exercise of the powers under Ss. 77A(b) and 77A(c) of the Co-operative Societies Act, the Board of Directors of the society comprising of the petitioners was dismissed and in their place, the Joint Director (Sugar) (Administration) was appointed as the Administrator.

    2. The material facts of the case relevant for the determination of the controversy raised in this writ petition are as follows:

    The Board of Directors of the Society consists of 15 directors of which 11 are elected from amongst the members, 2 are representative of workers, one is coopted as expert director and one is the representative of the District Central Co-operative Bank. The last election of the Board of Directors was held in 1984. The term of the said Board under S. 73G(2) of the Act was for five years. The term of the above Board expired in 1989. For one reason or the other election of the members of the Board could not be held before the expiry of the term in 1989 and till now. On 15 October, 1983 the Director of Sugar, Maharashtra State, who is also the Additional Registrar of Co-operative Societies, issued a notice to the society, its managing director and workers to show cause against proposed removal of the existing Board of Directors and appointment of an administrator in their place. In the above notice it was stated inter alia—

    “Whereas, it has now become clear that the period of the Board of Directors of the Karkhana is ended in the month of June, 1989 and newly elected Board of Directors could not take charge. Therefore, I am satisfied that it has become necessary now to take legal action under the provisions of S. 77A of the Act, AND WHEREAS, before taking action under S. 77A of the Act, concerned persons should be heard and therefore they should be given such opportunity. THEREFORE, show cause as to why though the prescribed period of the Board of Directors of the Karkhana was expired the new Board of Directors could not take charge, therefore, show cause. Why the existing Board of Directors should not be removed and the administrator should not be appointed in its place, before 26th October, 1993 either in person of the representative duly authorised by you to the undersigned. If you fail to show cause as aforesaid within the prescribed time limit or the course shown is not satisfactory, further action as provided in S. 77A of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960.”

    The members of the Board of directors submitted written reply to the show cause on 16 November, 1993. In the said reply, the circumstances due to which election could not be held so long were set out and the Director was requested to drop the proposed action under S. 77A. The Director did not find the cause shown by the petitioners satisfactory and by order dated 20 November, 1993 dismissed the Board of Directors of the Society and appointed Shri Y.B Khavale, Joint Director (Sugar) (Administration) as the administrator to discharge the duties and responsibilities of the Board. The petitioners appealed against the above order to the Additional Chief Secretary of the State Government. The main grievance in the appeal was that the election could not be held due to reasons beyond their control and in such a situation S. 77A was not applicable. The Additional Chief Secretary was not satisfied with the above contention and dismissed the appeal on the ground, inter alia, that under S. 73G(2B) of the Act as substituted by the maharashtra act 20 of 1986, on expiry of an aggregate period of 6 years from the date on which the first meeting was held, the members cease to be members of the committee and as such S. 77A was clearly attracted. Aggrieved by the above order, this writ petition has been filed.

    3. The main submission of the learned counsel for the petitioners Mr. K.K Singvi is that S. 77A has no application to the facts of the present case as under Cl. (b) thereof power to appoint administrator can be exercised only in a case where there is a failure to elect the members or fill-up the vacancies within the term of the committee. In the instant case, according to the counsel, “there is no failure on the part of the petitioners to hold the election” and hence S. 77A has no application. Counsel further submits that the show-cause notice was issued by the Director of Sugar under S. 77A of the Act. Order of dismissal of the Board of Directors and appointment of administrator has also been passed under the said section. In such a case, reliance cannot be placed on S. 73G(2) of the Act in support of the said order. Reliance is placed on a decision of this Court in Ghatageepa Parreppa Mugeri v. M.R Naik, 1983 Mah LJ 984 : (AIR 1984 Bom 56) in support of the contention that the existing committee is entitled to continue to function till a new Board is elected.

    4. I have carefully considered the submissions of the learned counsel. For a proper appreciation of the same, it is necessary to peruse the provisions of Ss. 77A and 73G of the Act. S. 77A, as stood at the material time, so far as it is relevant, reads:

    “77A. Appointment of member of committee, new committee or Administrator, where there is failure to elect member to constitute committee or where committee does not enter upon office— (1) where the Registrar is satisfied that,—

    (a) at the first constitution of the committee of any society there is a failure to elect all or any of the members of the committee;

    (b) the term or extended term as the case may be, of the committee of any society or of any of its members has expired or for any other reason election is held and there is a failure to elect all or any of the members required to fill the vacancies;

    (c) any committee is prevented from entering upon office;

    (d) a new committee has failed to enter upon office on the date on which the term of office of the existing committee expired; or

    (e) a new committee cannot for any reason be constituted before the expiry of the term of office of the existing committee;

    (f) where more than one group of persons in a society is claiming to be elected as the committee members and proceedings in respect thereof have been filed in the Co-operative Court;

    the Registrar may, either suo motu or on the application of any officer of the society, by order appoint—

    (i) any member or members of the society to be the member or members of the committee to fill the vacancies;

    (ii) a committee, consisting of not more than three members of the society, or one or more administrators, who need not be members of the society, to manage the affairs of the society till a new committee enters upon office:

    From the reading of the above section, it is clear that the Registrar on being satisfied about the existence of any of the conditions mentioned in Cls. (a) to (f) of S. 77A may appoint one or more administrators to manage the affairs of the society till a new committee enters upon office. Cl. (b) applies if,

    (i) the term or extended term, as the case may be, of the committee of any society or of any of its members has expired; or

    (ii) for any other person election is held and there is a failure to elect all or any of the members required to fill the vacancies.

    The above two conditions are not cumulative but alternative. Existence of any one of them will call for action under S. 77A. In the case of expiry of the term or extended term of the committee, the power is to appoint a committee of not more than three members of the society or one or more administrators who need not be members of the society to manage the affairs of the society till a new committee enters upon office. It may be pertinent to mention that the words “for extended as the case may be” in Cl. (b) were inserted by Maharashtra Act 20 of 1986. This is relevant because by the very amendment sub-sec. (2) of S. 73G was also substituted. Earlier the sub-section read as follows:

    “(2) When the election of all the members of the committee of any such society is held at the same time, the members elected on the committee at such general election shall hold office for a period of five years from the date on which the first meeting is held and shall continue in office until immediately before the first meeting of the members of the new committee.”

    (Emphasis supplied)

    By the maharashtra act 20 of 1986, the following was substituted in its place:

    “(2) “when the election of all the members of the committee of any such society is held at the same time; the members elected on the committee at such general election shall hold office for a period of five years from the date on which the first meeting is held, unless the period is extended by its State Government, for reasons to be recorded in writing, for a period not exceeding one year so however that total period does not exceed six years in, the aggregate.”

    The difference in the language of the two sub-sections is apparent; Under the sub-sec. (2) of S. 73C as it stood prior to 1986, though the term of the office of a committee or members was five years, they continued to be in office “untill immediately before the first meeting of the members of the new committee”. Under the substituted sub-sec. (2) the term of five years may be extended by the State Government to a period not exceeding one year. It is, however, clearly provided that the total period cannot exceed 6 years in the aggregate. Sub-sec. (2B) of S. 73G which was also inserted by the very same 1986 Amendment Act further provides:

    “(2B) “Where, for any reason whatsoever, the election of the members of the committee was not held or could not be held before the expiry of the term or the extended term, as the case may be, of the existing committee, the members, including the officers of the committee shall cease to hold office on the expiry of its term or extended term, as the case may be, and they shall be deemed to have vacated their offices.”

    Provided……………”

    This sub-section lays down what would happen if “for any reason whatsoever” the election of the members of the committee “was not held” or “could not be held” before the expiry of “term” or “the extended term” as the case may be. It clearly says that in such cases (i) the existing committee, its members shall cease to held office on the expiry of its term or extended term and (ii) they shall be deemed to have vacated their offices. No provisions similar to sub-sec. (2B) was there in the Act prior to insertion of the above sub-section in 1986. On the other hand, under sub-sec. (2) of S. 73G, as it stood prior to 1986, the position was just reverse, it provided that the committee once elected shall continue in office until the first meeting of the members of the new committee.

    5. clause (b) of s. 77a has to be read along with S. 73C(2) and (2B) (as amended in 1986) because the “term” or “extended term” of the committee is specified in that section. S. 77A empowers the Registrar to appoint administrator in case of expiry of the term or extended term of the committee. In the instant case, the election was held in the year 1984. The five year term expired in 1989. There is nothing to show that it was extended by the State Government at any time. Even if that be so, the aggregate period of six years also expired in the year 1990 and on the expiry of 6 years, in terms of S. 73G(2B) the committee and its members ceased to hold office and were deemed to have vacated their office. That being so, S. 77A is clearly attracted. In the eye of law, the committee elected in the year 1984 is not deemed to be in office in any event after the expiry of six years and their continuation in office after that period is contrary to the express terms of S. 73G(2B) of the Act. The Director of Sugar (Administration), who is also holding the office of Additional Registrar, Co-operative Society also, was therefore fully justified in exercising powers under S. 11A of the Act and appointing administrator for the said society. Equally justified was the appellate authority, the Additional Chief Secretary to Government of Maharashtra, in confirming the said order and dismissing the appeal of the petitioners.

    6. I have also perused the decision of this Court in Ghatageppa Parreppa Mugeri (supra) referred to by the learned counsel. This judgment was rendered in the context of S. 73G(2) as it stood then which contained an express provision to the effect that the elected members of the managing committee who hold office for a period of five years shall continue in office until immediately before the first meeting of the members of the new committee. It was observed by this Court that under the above provision the members of committee were entitled to continue to function as such till the first meeting of the newly elected managing committee — who were the successors to the office. This is clear from the following observation in the above decision:

    “It is necessary to point that the mere fact that the period of office of an elected Managing Committee has expired does not mean that the members of the Managing Committee become functus officio immediately. There is an express provision in S. 73G(2) of the Act which provides that the elected members of the Managing Committee who hold office for a period of five years “shall continue in office until immediately before the first meeting of the members of the new committee”. Under this provision the members of the Managing Committee are entitled to continue to function as such till the first meeting of the newly elected managing committee who are the successors-in-office.”

    That position no more exists after the amendment of S. 73G in the year 1986 and substitution of sub-sec. (2) by sub-sections (2), (2A) and (2B) which provide to the contrary. It is now stated in express terms in sub-section (2) of S. 73G that the term of office of the elected members shall be for a period of five years from the date on which the first meeting is held, unless the period is extended by the State Government. The power of the State Government to extend the period is also restricted to one year that too can be exercised for reasons to be recorded in writing. The aggregate term, in any event, cannot exceed six years. In sub-sec. (2B) of S. 73C, it has been made clear beyond all doubts that on the expiry of the term or the extended term, the committee and the members shall cease to hold office and they shall be deemed to have vacated their office. On the face of this express provision, it is difficult to accept the contention of the petitioners that though they were elected in 1984, their term has not expired within the meaning of Cl. (b) of S. 77A of the Act so as to empower the Registrar to dismiss them and to appoint an Administrator. Reliance on the decision of this Court in Chatagappa Pareeppa Mugeri (supra) is totally misplaced and unjustified.

    7. In view of the foregoing discussion, I am of the clear opinion that there is no merit in this writ petition. The order of the Director of Sugar dated 20th November, 1993 under S. 77A of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 is strictly in accordance with the law and there is no infirmity in the same. The appellate authority was, therefore, justified in dismissing the appeal against the said order.

    8. This writ petition is, therefore, dismissed at the admission stage itself.

    9. Under the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.

    10. Certified copy expedited.

    Petition dismissed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shamburaj Shivajirao Desai And Others v. Director Of Sugar, Maharashtra State, Pune And Others
    (Feb 3, 1994)