AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 392 read with 34 of the Indian Penal Code,
  • section 342 read with 34, Indian Penal Code
  • section 392 read with 34, Indian Penal Code
  • section 392 as also 397, Indian Penal Code.
  • section 342 of the Indian Penal Code.
  • section 397, Indian Penal Code.
  • section 392, Indian Penal Code.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 392 read with 34 of the Indian Penal Code,
  • section 342 read with 34, Indian Penal Code
  • section 392 read with 34, Indian Penal Code
  • section 392 as also 397, Indian Penal Code.
  • section 342 of the Indian Penal Code.
  • section 397, Indian Penal Code.
  • section 392, Indian Penal Code.
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion — Daud, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The complainant, P.W.1 Rajendrakumar, operated a diamond-polishing workshop at Shop No. 10, Tulsi Vrindavan Building, L.T. Road, Borivli (West), Bombay, with a workforce of about 10–12 employees who sometimes slept at the workshop. On 22 August 1985, at about 8:10 p.m., appellants Babulal and Michael entered the workshop; Babulal allegedly flourished a knife and Michael displayed what looked like a pistol. The intruders took seven packets containing rough and polished diamonds and fled. Rajendrakumar lodged a report (Ex. 6) at Borivli Police Station. The police arrested Babulal on 30-8-1985 and Michael on 31-8-1985. Statements led to recoveries: Michael's statement (Ex. 16) led to recovery of the knife and the toy pistol; Babulal led the police to another person (P.W.6 Adityanath), from whom further diamonds were recovered (Exs. 18–22). An identification parade on 5-9-1985 before Executive Magistrate Mulye resulted in victims identifying both appellants (identification memorandum Ex. 28; original misplaced). A charge-sheet was filed and the case was tried before an Additional Sessions Judge, Greater Bombay.

At trial, both appellants pleaded not guilty and claimed false implication. The trial Judge convicted them under sections 392 and 342 read with 34, and under section 392 read with 397 of the Indian Penal Code. Sentences imposed included seven years' rigorous imprisonment for the offence punishable under section 392 read with 34 and an additional sentence under 392 read with 397; the substantive sentences were ordered to run concurrently. The present appeal challenges conviction and sentences.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the evidence established the culpability of Babulal and Michael for the robbery (sections 392 and 342 read with 34, IPC).
  2. Whether the appellants could properly be convicted under section 397 IPC in addition to section 392 IPC, or whether section 397 merely affects sentencing for a single robbery offence.
  3. Whether Michael could be convicted under section 397 IPC where the weapon he used was a toy pistol (i.e., whether a toy or fake pistol qualifies as a "deadly weapon" within section 397 IPC).
  4. Appropriate sentences for the appellants, particularly whether Michael's sentence under section 397 should be maintained or reduced.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (as advanced by Mr. Jadhav)

  • The evidence did not satisfactorily establish the culpability of the appellants for the robbery.
  • Only one offence was committed (robbery), and it was erroneous for the trial court to convict under both section 392 and section 397 as if they were distinct offences.
  • Specifically as to Michael, section 397 predicates the use of a deadly weapon; the instrument used by Michael was a toy pistol which cannot be characterised as a deadly weapon, so he should not have been convicted under section 397.
  • Challenge to the identification parade: selection of dummies allegedly inappropriate (age mismatch), and absence of physical touching by identifying witnesses could undermine identification.

Prosecution's Arguments (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The eyewitness evidence (Rajendrakumar, Pravinkumar and Karsanbhai) and recoveries linked the appellants to the robbery; identification parade supported their identification.
  • A weapon may be treated as deadly by virtue of the effect produced on victims; thus, a weapon that creates that effect could attract section 397.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in several clear steps, confined to the material before it:

  1. Evaluation of the evidence of identification and eyewitness testimony:
    • The court found the testimony of eye-witnesses Rajendrakumar, Pravinkumar and Karsanbhai reliable on the crucial point that the appellants entered the shop at closing time, Babulal wielding a knife and Michael displaying what looked like a pistol, and that seven packets of diamonds were taken.
    • The court accepted the recovery evidence: Michael's statement (Ex. 16) led to recovery of the knife and toy pistol; Babulal led to other recoveries through Adityanath and the attached exhibits (Exs. 18–22).
    • The identification parade conducted on 5-9-1985 (Ex. 28) chaired by Executive Magistrate Mulye resulted in the victims identifying both appellants; though the original of Ex. 28 was missing, the court found the copy admissible and the parade admissible.
    • Challenges to the parade (selection of dummies and lack of physical contact during identification) were considered and rejected. The court observed that several dummies were close in age to the appellants and that pointing out a suspect is not materially different from touching for identification purposes.
  2. Legal characterisation of offences and applicability of section 397:
    • The court explained that section 397 is an aggravated form of robbery/dacoity and does not create a separate substantive offence distinct from robbery; rather, it increases punishment if, among other things, a deadly weapon is used while committing robbery.
    • The trial court's approach of convicting separately under section 392 read with 34 and under section 392 read with 397 was described as procedurally incorrect in form: the appellants committed a single offence of robbery (section 392 read with 34), and whether section 397 is attracted affects sentence rather than constituting a separate offence.
  3. Specific analysis of the toy pistol issue (Michael):
    • The defence submission that a toy pistol cannot be a "deadly weapon" for the purposes of section 397 was given detailed consideration.
    • The court examined competing positions: prosecution's submission that a weapon becomes deadly by the effect it produces on victims versus the defence's position that the weapon must have deadly potential in itself.
    • The court concluded that the language of sections 397 and 398 indicates the weapon used must be a deadly weapon as such; a toy pistol remains a toy pistol despite the terror it may induce. Therefore, the element of a deadly weapon required for the enhanced punishment under section 397 was absent in Michael's case.
  4. Sentencing consequences:
    • Because section 397 does not create a separate substantive offence, the conviction under section 392 read with 397 should be treated as relevant only to sentencing. The court accepted that the trial Judge had imposed separate sentences, but corrected the legal characterisation.
    • For Babulal, the court affirmed conviction and the sentence of seven years' rigorous imprisonment (the opinion notes the Penal Code prescribes a minimum of seven years in relation to appellant Babulal in the relevant context).
    • For Michael, the court held that conviction under section 397 could not be sustained; his conviction was converted to one under section 392 read with 34 and his sentence was reduced to three years' rigorous imprisonment, which the court considered appropriate for the offence proved against him.

Holding and Implications

Appeal partly allowed.

Final dispositions and direct consequences recorded by the court:

  • Babulal: Convictions for offences punishable under sections 392 and 342 read with 34, IPC are affirmed. The sentence of seven years' rigorous imprisonment in respect of the robbery offence (with reference to section 397 in sentencing considerations) is maintained.
  • Michael: Conviction under section 342 read with 34, IPC is confirmed. His conviction that was recorded under section 392 read with 397 is converted to a conviction under section 392 read with 34, IPC only. His sentence is reduced to three years' rigorous imprisonment.
  • Both appellants are to be released after expiry of their sentences unless otherwise required by law.

Implications: The decision corrected the trial court's approach by treating section 397 as an aggravation relevant to sentencing rather than a distinct substantive offence. The court declined to treat a toy pistol as a "deadly weapon" within the meaning of section 397 for purposes of enhanced punishment in Michael's case. The opinion does not indicate that it establishes any novel precedent beyond the application of established statutory interpretation to the facts of this case.

Appeal partly allowed.

    Babulal Jairam Maurya And Another v. State Of Maharashtra .

    Daud, J.:— This appeal takes exception to the conviction and sentences recorded against the appellants for the offences punishable under sections 392 and 342 read with 34 and 397 of the Indian Penal Code.

    2. The prosecution case is that complainant-P.W 1 Rajendrakumar is in the business of diamond polishing. His workshop is located at Shop No. 10, Tulsi Vrindavan Building, L.T Road, Borivli (West), Bombay. For the purpose of polishing diamonds there is a work force of about 10-12 employees — some of them being related to the employer. The rest of the employees use the workshop also for sleeping at nights. The normal working hours of the workshop are 8.00 a.m to 8.00 p.m Rajendrakumar gets unpolished diamonds from his customers and returns the same to them after the polishing has been completed.

    3. The incident figuring in this appeal took place on 22nd August 1985. Inside the cabin of the employer were Rajendrakumar and a friend of his Karsanbhai. All the employees were inside except one who had left the shop a little early to attend to a guest. At about 10 minutes past 8.00 p.m the inmates of Shop No. 10 were surprised by the arrival of appellants Babulal and Michael. Babulal was flourishing a knife while Michael had with him what looked like a pistol. The frightened inmates of the shop were overawed by the armed appellants who therefore managed to take away seven packets containing diamonds — rough and polished both. After doing their deed, the culprits fled. Rajendrakumar went to the Borivli Police Station and there lodged a report which is at Ex. 6. An offence was registered. The police arrested Babulal on 30-8-1985 and Michael on 31-8-1985. While in police custody both gave statements. So far as Michael is concerned, his statement is at Ex. 16 and it led to the recovery of the knife and the toy pistol used in the commission of the crime. Babulal gave out that he had made over diamonds to a resident of Malad who had been entrusted the task of disposing them of. He agreed and led the police and the panchas to the Malad man. It was P.W 6 Adityanath and Adityanath in turn had made over the diamonds to different persons. The entire booty was recovered and attached under Exs. 18 to 22. On 5-9-1985 at the request of the police, the Executive Magistrate P.W 10 Mulye scheduled an identification parade. In this parade the victims identified Babulal and Michael as those who had participated in the robbery using for that purpose a knife and what looked like a pistol. True copy of the identification memorandum is at Ex. 28. The Investigating Officer has established that the original of Ex. 28 has been misplaced and that renders Ex. 28 admissible in evidence. After completion of the investigation a charge-sheet was lodged and in due course Babulal and Michael found themselves before an Additional Sessions Judge of Greater Bombay.

    4. To the charge of having committed offences punishable under sections 392 read with 34 and 397 as also 342 read with 34, Indian Penal Code, Babulal and Michael pleaded not guilty. Their defence was that they had been falsely implicated.

    5. To substantiate the accusation levelled against the appellants, the prosecution examined Rajendrakumar, Karsanbhai, Pravinkumar, Babu, Adityanath, Mulye and a number of others. The learned trial Judge found appellants guilty under sections 392 and 342 both read with 34 of the Indian Penal Code and 392 read with 397 of the Indian Penal Code. For the offence punishable under section 392 read with 34 of the Indian Penal Code, the appellants were sentenced to suffer seven years' R.I For the offence punishable under section 392 read with 397 the appellants were sentenced to suffer seven years R.I and no separate sentence was awarded for the offence of wrongful confinement punishable under section 342 of the Indian Penal Code. The substantive sentences were to run concurrently.

    6. Mr. Jadhav arguing the appeal on behalf of the appellants contends firstly that the evidence did not establish the culpability of his clients, and next that in any case, the trial Court was in error in finding appellants guilty under section 392 as also 397, Indian Penal Code. Learned counsel submits, and with some justification, that only one offence was committed — if at all — by the appellants and that the application of section 397, Indian Penal Code vis-a-vis Michael was an error.

    7. To take up the major contention of Mr. Jadhav it is not possible for us to agree with learned counsel's submission that the evidence vis-a-vis the commission of robbery by Babulal and Michael is in any sense vulnerable. First, there are the eye-witnesses Rajendrakumar, Pravinkumar and Karsanbhai who all testify to the appellants coming at about closing time into Shop No. 10, Babulal being armed with a knife which he was flourishing and Michael armed with what looked like a real pistol which also was flourished by him. The frightened inmates were too stunned to look closely at the toy pistol which Michael was using. Believing that the same was genuine, the victims raised not a finger to resist the robbers. The robbers made away with seven packets of diamonds. The next weapon in the prosecution armoury is the recovery of the weapons used and the stolen diamonds at the instance of Michael and Babulal respectively. The evidence adduced on this aspect of the case is fully acceptable. The last feature is a virtual clincher in that Babulal and Michael were identified by the victims on 5-9-1985 in an identification parade which was chaired by the Special Executive Magistrate Mulye. Mr. Jadhav argues that the Magistrate had not taken care in the selection of the dummies. Babulal was a teenager and Michael little better. The dummies chosen were aged persons and therefore the test identification cannot be said to be free from the taint of the witnesses being virtually given a clue as to who the culprits were. It is not possible to agree with the submission of learned counsel. The identification memorandum shows that near about four persons were in the age group 22 to 23 years. Of the total of 16 persons barely two to four could be said to be outside the age range considered comparable material vis-a-vis the appellants. Even those beyond 23 years may have been in build and appearance similar to the appellants. Mr. Jadhav argues that the identifying witnesses did not actually touch appellants. We do not see how this would constitute a serious infirmity. A witness standing before a suspect and pointing out him as the criminal is not different from another who places his finger against the person of the criminal identified by him. The arrest of the appellants took place in the last two days of August 1985. The crime itself had taken place at about the start of the last week of August 1985 and the identification parade was held on 5-9-1985. By that time the weapons used and the looted property had also been recovered. Considered as a whole, the evidence is a sure pointer to the culpability of the appellants.

    8. The next question is whether appellants should have been convicted under section 397 as distinct from 392, Indian Penal Code? Section 397 is an aggravated form of robbery or dacoity. This section is attracted to one found guilty of the offence of robbery or dacoity, if amongst other things, he uses a deadly weapon at the time of committing the offence. Section 397 does not create a different offence by itself. One found guilty under section 392 merits the punishment prescribed by section 397, if, while committing the offence of robbery he does various things one of them being, use of a deadly weapon. In imposing the sentence upon the appellants the learned trial Judge has proceeded to impose two sentences upon them — one being under section 392 read with 34 and the other being 392 read with 397, Indian Penal Code. Truly speaking, the appellants had committed a single offence that being the offence of robbery punishable under section 392 read with 34, Indian Penal Code. As to whether or not section 397, Indian Penal Code was attracted would be a matter of significance only in relation to the sentence that the offender merited.

    9. This brings us to the last contention of Mr. Jadhav that assuming the prosecution case to be true, appellant-Michael could not have been convicted under section 397, Indian Penal Code. Learned counsel says that section 397 predicates the use of a deadly weapon. The Weapon used must have a deadly potential. A toy pistol can never be said to be a deadly weapon whatever the impression it seeks on the frightened victims. In other words, a fake pistol though used as a deadly weapon and assumed to be one by the victims, is not a deadly weapon as contemplated by section 397, Indian Penal Code. A toy pistol continues to be a toy pistol whatever be its impact on the frightened victims. The learned Public Prosecutor disputes this contention saying that a weapon becomes deadly when it is used as such a weapon and has that effect upon the victims. The language of sections 397 and 398 which deal with “deadly weapons” indicates the correctness of Mr. Jadhav's submission. The weapon used has to be a deadly weapon and not assumed or mistaken to be a deadly weapon. Michael was using a toy pistol and that is the end of the matter so far as the applicability of section 397, Indian Penal Code is concerned. He merited a conviction only under section 392, Indian Penal Code. As to the sentence, the Penal Code prescribes for a minimum of seven years vis-a-vis appellant Babulal. So far as Michael is concerned, three years R.I would be more than adequate for the offence brought home to him.

    10. The result of the foregoing discussion is that the appeal has to be partly allowed. We affirm the conviction recorded against Babulal for the offences punishable under sections 392 and 342 read with 34 and haying regard to section 397, Indian Penal Code the sentence of 7 years R.I imposed upon him.

    11. Michael's conviction under section 342 read with 34, Indian Penal Code is confirmed. However his conviction under section 392 read with 397 is converted to one falling under section 392 read with 34, Indian Penal Code only. His sentence is reduced to three years' R.I

    12. Appellants be released after the expiry of their sentences unless otherwise required.

    Appeal partly allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Babulal Jairam Maurya And Another v. State Of Maharashtra .
    (Feb 17, 1992)