Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of section 167 of the Code and under sub-section (1) of section 167,
  • Sessions Judge section 167 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • provisions of section (4)(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 267(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • NARCOTIC DRUGS AND PSYCHOTROPIC SUBSTANCES ACT 1985
  • section 167 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973,
  • provisions of sub-section 2 of section 167
  • SECTION 161 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • SECTION 167 A CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • clause (c) of sub-section (1) of section 36A,
  • provisions of section 41 of NDPS Act
  • sub-section (1) of section 167
  • sub-section (1) of section 267
  • section 167(2) of the Code.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of section 167 of the Code and under sub-section (1) of section 167,
  • Sessions Judge section 167 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • provisions of section (4)(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 267(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • NARCOTIC DRUGS AND PSYCHOTROPIC SUBSTANCES ACT 1985
  • section 167 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973,
  • provisions of sub-section 2 of section 167
  • SECTION 161 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • SECTION 167 A CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • clause (c) of sub-section (1) of section 36A,
  • provisions of section 41 of NDPS Act
  • sub-section (1) of section 167
  • sub-section (1) of section 267
  • section 167(2) of the Code.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On July 19, 1989, Customs officials intercepted two Fiat cars and apprehended two persons, respondents No. 2 and 3, who attempted to take away the vehicles. Searches revealed 100 packets of heroin estimated to be worth approximately Rs. 2,50,00,000/-, bearing markings indicating Pakistani origin. Following their arrest, respondents 1, 4, and 5 were also apprehended. The accused were produced before the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate and remanded to judicial custody. Applications were made to the Magistrate and subsequently to the Additional Sessions Judge for issuance of examination warrants and for custody of the accused to be handed over to Customs authorities for investigation. The Additional Sessions Judge rejected the application for issuance of an examination warrant and held that under section 267 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC), Customs officers, not being police officers, cannot have custody of the accused. This order is challenged by the present application seeking directions for examination warrants and custody arrangements under section 267 or other provisions of the CrPC.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether section 267 of the Criminal Procedure Code permits the issuance of an examination warrant for production of accused persons in custody of Customs or other Central Government agencies for investigation purposes.
  2. Whether Customs officers or other Central Government investigating agencies can be granted custody of accused persons for the purpose of investigation under section 167 of the CrPC or any other provision, despite not being police officers.
  3. The scope and applicability of custody provisions under the CrPC and the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (NDPS Act) concerning detention and investigation by non-police agencies.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The Customs authorities and other Central Government agencies require custody of accused persons to effectively carry out investigations into serious offences under Central Acts.
  • Investigation entails more than recording statements; it may require showing accused to witnesses, obtaining assistance to locate relevant places, and confronting witnesses, which cannot be effectively done if the accused remain only in judicial custody.
  • The learned Judge in Prashant Kumar v. Mancharlal Bhagatram Bhatia recognized the necessity of custody by Customs officers for facilitating investigation, especially in cases involving large-scale conspiracy and high-value contraband.
  • Section 167(2) CrPC allows the Magistrate to authorize detention in custody as deemed fit, and prohibition on police custody beyond fifteen days does not preclude custody by other agencies such as Customs.
  • Statements recorded by Customs officers are admissible evidence, and there is no legal bar to granting them custody for investigation.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Section 167 CrPC contemplates only two types of custody: police custody and judicial custody; hence, once in judicial custody, accused cannot be placed in any other custody.
  • The order of the Additional Sessions Judge was based on apprehensions about the safety and protection of the accused if handed over to Customs officers, including risks of absconding, ill-treatment, or assault during custody transfer.
  • Certain statements made by respondents were rejected, and on that basis, they should not be handed over to Customs officers for further investigation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State (Delhi Administration) v. Dharam Pal (1982 Cr. L.J 1103) Interpretation of custody under section 167(2) CrPC, clarifying that custody may shift between judicial and police custody within fifteen days. The Court rejected the respondents' contention that only police and judicial custody exist, highlighting that custody can be authorized as the Magistrate thinks fit, except police custody beyond fifteen days.
Prashant Kumar v. Mancharlal Bhagatram Bhatia (1987 Mh. L.J 1026; 1988 Cri. L.J 1463) Necessity of Customs officers' custody for facilitating investigation, especially in large-scale drug cases. The Court relied on this to affirm that Customs officers need custody to effectively investigate, even if they lack lock-ups, and that judicial custody alone might hinder investigation progress.
R.N. Kaker, Dy. Director, N.C.B v. Shabir Fidahusein (1989 (1) Bombay Cases Reporter 503) Admissibility of statements recorded by Customs officers, unlike police statements under section 161 CrPC. The Court noted that statements recorded by Customs officers can be admissible evidence, supporting the authority of Customs officers in investigation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the provisions of sections 167 and 267 of the Criminal Procedure Code and relevant provisions of the NDPS Act. It observed that section 267(1) CrPC applies only to production of persons confined in prison for answering charges or giving evidence before the Court and does not extend to production for investigation by investigating agencies. The Court noted that section 167 CrPC authorizes Magistrates to detain accused persons in custody for investigation, and the prohibition on police custody beyond fifteen days does not preclude custody by other agencies such as Customs officers. The NDPS Act further empowers Customs and other Central Government officers with investigative powers similar to police officers, including arrest and detention.

The Court rejected the respondents' argument that only police and judicial custody are permissible, emphasizing the discretion of the Magistrate to order custody in such agency as deemed fit. It acknowledged the practical difficulties faced by Customs authorities in conducting investigations without custody and recognized that statements recorded by Customs officers are admissible evidence. The Court also addressed and dismissed the Additional Sessions Judge's apprehensions regarding safety and responsibility during custody transfer, holding that the investigating officer, being a gazetted officer, is accountable to the Court and expected to act in good faith.

Considering the gravity of the offence involving large quantities of heroin and its societal impact, the Court concluded that Customs officers should be granted custody of the accused to facilitate effective investigation.

Holding and Implications

The Court set aside the order of the learned Additional Sessions Judge and directed that the accused respondents be placed in the custody of the Customs authorities initially for a period of seven days, with liberty to the Judge to consider further remand thereafter.

The Court further directed that the Customs authorities be permitted to take the respondents from judicial custody for investigation purposes daily from 11:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., restoring them to judicial custody after that period. The request for stay of this order was rejected.

The direct effect of this decision is to empower Customs and similar Central Government agencies to obtain custody of accused persons for facilitating investigation under the NDPS Act and CrPC, expanding the practical scope of investigative custody beyond traditional police custody. No new precedent was set beyond clarifying and affirming existing statutory provisions and judicial interpretations regarding custody and investigative powers.

    B.S. Rawat v. Mohmed Azan Khan

    1. Faced with the difficulty created by the order passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Greater Bombay, by which he refused the Customs authorities or any other Central Government Agency such as D.R.I, Central Excise, Narcotic Control Bureau, Enforcement Directorate to have the accused placed in their custody, the Asstt. Collector of Customs by this application seeks a direction for issue of an examination warrant for production of respondents 1 to 5 for investigation and for holding that under the provisions of section 267 or any other provisions of Criminal Procedure Code, 1973, the authorities abovementioned are entitled to move the Competent Court for production of accused persons in judicial custody for being handed over to such agency for carrying out investigation and enquiries under any of the Central Enactments by issue of examination warrant.

    2. On July 19, 1989 the staff of the Preventive Collectorate intercepted two Fiat cars at the junction of Tejpal Lane, Off Govalia Tank Bus Terminus and apprehended two persons Aslam — respondent No. 3 and Mohmed Yakub Shekh — respondent No. 2 who attempted to take away the two Fiat cars after they opened the door and entered into the said cars. Aslam Mohmed is said to have attempted to take away one of the cars, but on seeing the Customs Officers, tried to run away, but was immediately apprehended on the spot. Mohmed Shekh was apprehended while he was entering the other car. The searches of the two cars led to the recovery of 100 packets of brown coloured powder suspected to be narcotic drug which when tested with narcotic testing showed the presence of Heroin. The packets bore markings in Urdu pointing to their Pakistani origin and were estimated to be worth about Rs. 2,50,00,000/-. The two accused were arrested and articles were seized. The follow up action led to the apprehension of respondents 1, 4 and 5 in R.K Hotel at Lamington Road and their statements came to be recorded and it appeared that the two drivers had been engaged by respondent No. 1. Respondents 4 and 5 are said to be employed for arranging delivery at Bombay for export of the contraband outside India. These persons after their arrest were produced before Addl. Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, who granted remand till 4th August, 1989 to judicial custody. On 31-7-1989 an application was made by the authority concerned to the Magistrate for issue of examination warrant, but since the respondents were produced in the meantime before the Additional Sessions Judge, an application was made on August 2, 1989 to the Additional Sessions Judge who rejected that application. The learned Additional Sessions Judge permitted the authority to interrogate the respondents. On August 10, 1989 another application was made to the learned Additional Sessions Judge for direction to hand over the respondents to the Customs authorities with liberty to lodge them with Azad Maidan Police Station. That application was not pressed. While deciding the application dated 2nd of August, 1989 the learned Additional Sessions Judge took the view that section 267 which was sought to be invoked would not apply to the present situation and in no event enabled the Court to issue an examination warrant. In the view of the learned Additional Sessions Judge section 167 of the Code of Criminal Procedure contemplates only two types of custody, judicial and police. Since Customs Officers are not Police Officers the custody of accused is not contemplated by section 167 of the Criminal Procedure Code. It is this order which is being challenged by the present application. Section 267(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 provides that whenever in the course of an inquiry, trial or other proceedings under this Code, it appears to the Criminal Court that a person confined or detained in a prison should be brought before the Court for answering to a charge of an offence or for the purpose of any proceedings against him or that it is necessary for the ends of justice to examine such person as a witness, the Court may make an order requiring the Officer in charge of the prison to produce such person before the Court for answering the charge or for the purpose of such proceeding, or, as the case may be for giving evidence. It is apparent that in order that sub-section (1) of section 267 should apply, it is necessary that the requirement should be that he has to be brought before the Court for one or the other purposes mentioned in clauses (a) and (b) and it would not apply to a situation where it is necessary to produce the person for the purposes of investigation, before the agency which is engaged in the investigation. The learned Additional Sessions Judge was, therefore, right in pointing out that this provision would not apply to the stage at which the request was made by the investigating authorities to him.

    3. In this context, reference may be made to the provisions of section 167 of the Code and under sub-section (1) of section 167, if an investigation cannot be completed within the period of twentyfour hours fixed by section 57 and there are grounds for believing that the accusation and information is well founded the officer-in-charge of the police station or the police officer making the investigation if he is not below the rank of Sub-Inspector, shall forthwith transmit to the nearest Judicial Magistrate a copy of the entries in the diary and shall at the same time forward the accused to such Magistrate. Under sub-section (2), the Magistrate may authorise detention for a term not exceeding fifteen days in the whole; and if he has no jurisdiction to try the case or commit it for trial and considers further detention unnecessary, he may order the accused to be forwarded to the Magistrate having such jurisdiction. The later part of sub-section (2) will not apply to the cases which would come within the purview of Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 as amended (NDPS for short), because by virtue of section 36A, the Magistrate cannot authorise detention for a period exceeding fifteen days in the whole and the further detention has to be authorised by the Special Court to whom the person is to be forwarded. Under clause (c) of sub-section (1) of section 36A, the Special Court may exercise in relation to the person forwarded to it under clause (b), the same power which a Magistrate having jurisdiction to try a case may exercise under section 167 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, in relation to an accused person in such case who has been forwarded to him under that section.

    4. The object of authorising the detention having by this very sub-section (1) of section 167 is that some time should be available for completing the investigation which cannot be completed during the period of first twentyfour hours fixed by section 57 and for facilitating the investigation should the Magistrate consider further detention of the accused necessary. Under proviso (a) to section 167, no Magistrate shall authorise the detention of the accused person otherwise than in custody of the police beyond the period of fifteen days, if he, is satisfied that adequate grounds exist for doing so, but it shall not be for a period exceeding 90 days in the case of an offence punishable with imprisonment for life or imprisonment for a term of not less than ten years or sixty days where the investigation relates to any other offence. The repeated use of the word investigation in the context of section 167 as well as in the proviso emphasizes the object for which the detention is considered necessary.

    5. Obviously, in the present case, the investigation is not being done by the police and the provisions of section (4)(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure do not directly apply as that section speaks of all offences under the Indian Penal Code which shall be investigated, inquired into, tried, and otherwise dealt with according to the provisions, but subject to the enactment for the time being in force regulating the manner or place of investigating, inquiring into, trying or otherwise dealing with such offences.

    6. That takes me to the relevant provisions of the NDPS Act. Chapter 4 thereof creates offences and prescribes penalties and Chapter V lays down the procedure. Under section 41, Metropolitan Magistrate is empowered to issue a warrant of arrest. Sub-section (2) refers to the powers of officers of gazetted rank of the departments of central excise, narcotics, customs, revenue intelligence or any other department of the Central Government or of the Border Security Force as is empowered in this behalf by general or special order by the Central Government for arresting persons or searching buildings, conveyance or places. Section 42 relates to power of entry, search, seizure and arrest without warrant or authorisation. Section 43 gives the power of seizure and arrest at public places while section 53 enables the Central Government after consultation with the State Government to invest any officer of the department of Central Excise, narcotics, customs, revenue intelligence or Border Security Force or any class of such officers with the powers of an officer-in-charge of a police station for the investigation of the offences under the Act. Under section 67 any authorised officer has power to call for the information from any person for the purposes of satisfying him whether there has been any contravention of the provisions of the Act or any rule or order made thereunder and require any person to produce or deliver any document or thing useful or relevant to the enquiry. It is not necessary to set out the detailed provisions enacted for the purpose of facilitating investigation into the offences, created by it, but it would be apparent that the powers of investigation conferred on the authorities under the N.D.P.S Act are as comprehensive and wide as those of police officers, though they are not police officers in the strict sense of the term.

    7. On behalf of the respondents, it was urged that section 167, Criminal Procedure Code contemplates only two types of custodies, police custody and judicial custody and, therefore, once the person is allowed to be detained in judicial custody, he cannot be placed in any other custody. This submission runs counter to the clear provisions of sub-section 2 of section 167 which enables the Magistrate to authorise detention in such custody as the Magistrate thinks fit. Proviso (a) to that sub-section only prohibits the custody of police beyond the period of fifteen days. The observation in State (Delhi Administration) v. Dharam Pal (1982 Cr. L.J 1103) on which reliance was placed do not lend support to the contention that the choice is between only judicial custody and police custody. What the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court observed was that the nature of the custody can be altered from judicial custody to police custody and vice versa during the first period of fifteen days mentioned in section 167(2) of the Code. After fifteen days, the accused can only be kept in judicial custody or in any other custody as ordered by the Magistrate, but not the custody of the police. There is no dispute here that Customs Officers are not Police Officers and the statements recorded before the Customs Officers unlike the statements recorded under section 161 of the Criminal Procedure Code can come in evidence in proper cases. Similarly, there is no bar to the admissibility of the statements recorded by Customs Officers though they may be inculpatory as obtains in the case of statements before the police and this position is apparent from the observations of this Court in R.N Kaker, Dy. Director, N.C.B v. Shabir Fidahusein, (1989 (1) Bombay Cases Reporter 503). Having regard to the above factors, it is obvious that there is no legal bar to the Magistrate or the Additional Sessions Judge under the NDPS Act to grant a remand either to the judicial custody or custody of other agency such as Customs Officers who are not Police Officers if the circumstances so require.

    8. Shri Gupte, the learned counsel for the applicant urged that it would be extremely difficult for the Customs Authorities and other agencies who have to investigate into serious offences under the Central Acts to make any progress with the investigation if directions are not given by the Magistrate or the other authorities for enabling the investigating agency to carry on the investigation by providing for even temporary custody as was sought in the present case. Investigation does not mean only recording of statements of witnesses and the accused persons, but it may be necessary also to show the accused persons to the witneses who may be in a position to identify them or to enlist the assistance of the accused persons for pointing out places which have relevance to the circumstances in which the offences might have been committed. It may be that the witnesses may be unwilling to go to jail where the accused are lodged and their assitance may be necessary either for confronting the accused with witnesses or for the witnesses to identify the accused persons and the only place where these functions can be suitably performed by the Customs Officers may be the Customs Offices or the offices of the other Central Agencies which have to carry on investigation. It is apparent that this difficulty was recognised by this Court in Prashant Kumar v. Mancharlal Bhagatram Bhatia, 1987 Mh. L.J 1026 : 1988 Cri. L.J 1463 where the learned Judge observed as follows:—

    “Customs Officers do not have their lock-ups and consequently are in no position to seek the accused's remand into customs custody. They are, therefore, left only to seek remand to judicial custody. That, however, does not mean that the custody of the accused is not necessary to facilitate the progress of the investigation. Whenever the Customs Officers require the custody of the accused, they approach the Magistrate for handing over the accused in their custody from judicial custody for facilitating the progress of investigation. The remand of the accused to judicial custody may become necessary to prevent the abscondence of the accused at the initial stages of the investigation and to prevent him from tampering with the evidence and thereby hampering the progress of the investigation. These aspects assume importance in cases of large scale conspiracy involving number of persons and contraband of high value which may be the subject matter of investigation.”

    9. It is apparent that the offences in life-destroying drugs and economic offences have been on the increase and the smugglers disrupt the economy of the nation and erode the valuable foreign exchange. Clearly these aspects cannot be ignored by the Courts when considering their own powers and the ever increasing requirement of the changing situation where often the offenders outsmart the investigating agency. To say that while in judicial custody, the person against whom serious allegations are being made should never be made available to the investigating agency would be to shut out of investigation and put the offenders beyond the reach of the arms of law. Such a narrow construction cannot be placed on the provisions of section 167 which affords a very wide discretion to the Magistrate or the provisions of NDPS which clothe the Additional Sessions Judge with identical powers. What is frowned upon is police custody beyond fifteen days and what is permitted is any other custody beyond the period of fifteen days. The restriction on the term by limiting it to fifteen days would be only in respect of police custody and not the other custody and in proper cases it would be open to the Magistrate or the Additional Sessions Judge or the Special Court to pass orders remanding the offenders to any other custody besides the police custody.

    10. The learned Additional Sessions Judge in his order dated 21st August, 1989 has expressed certain apprehensions which may be extracted here:

    “Once the accused is produced before this Court from jail the responsibility of the authorities ceases in connection with the accused, and till such time that the accused remains in Court, he remains in custody of the Court and it is the Court which has the responsibility for protection of that accused and such other requirements. If the accused is handed over to the Customs Officer and while he is on his way, he may be shot at and killed, he may jump and abscond, he can be ill-treated or assaulted by officers during the custody, he may assault Customs Officer and all these things may happen while he is in the custody of this Court.”

    11. All these apprehensions appear to me to be unreal. The person who is in-charge of the investigation is a gazetted Officer in view of the provisions of section 41 of NDPS Act and if the custody of the accused is handed over to him, he would be responsible for the safety of the accused as well as for the damage that the offender is likely to cause while in his custody and if he gets the custody of the accused under the orders of the Court, he would evidently be accountable to the Court in every matter concerning the accused and in appropriate cases, it would be for the Court to decide whether the trust reposed in the investigating officer has been properly discharged. It would be entirely wrong to view every act of the investigating agency with suspicion and it must be remembered that when statutory responsibility is reposed on the investigating officers, they are expected to act honestly and in good faith. If they abuse their position, the Court can always protect the accused and take suitable action against the defaulting officer.

    12. The learned Additional Sessions Judge has referred to the position that certain statements made by the respondents have been rejected and that in these circumstances, they cannot be handed over to the Customs Officers for further investigation. Normally this caution is exercised in relation to a person who has made a confession or offers to make a confession and refuses to do so and this bar normally would not apply to the officers other than police officers who ask for the custody of the accused persons, though it would be the duty of the Magistrate and the Judge to give proper consideration to such grievances when they are made while passing orders for granting or refusing custody to the investigating agency, but on that count alone it cannot be said that no such power is vested in the Magistrate or the Additional Sessions Judge. In the present case, I find that having regard to the enormous quantity of drug seized, the astronomical value, of the contraband and the deleterious effect the consumption of such drugs have on the society, it was necessary that the Customs Officers should have been given custody of the accused persons.

    13. While setting aside the order passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, it is directed that the Additional Sessions Judge should grant custody of the respondents to the Customs authorities initially for a period of seven days and thereafter consider whether further remand to that custody is necessary. Rule made absolute in these terms.

    14. The learned counsel for the respondents urges that this order should be stayed for a period of fifteen days for enabling him to approach the Supreme Court as the matter involves an important question of law. The request is rejected. While setting aside the order passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, it is directed that the Additional Sessions Judge should grant permission to the Customs authorities to take the respondents from judicial custody for the purposes of investigation from 11.00 a.m to 5.00 p.m and restore them to judicial custody initially for a period of seven days and thereafter consider whether any further remand is necessary. Rule made absolute in these terms if any further directions are necessary.

    Order accordingly.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    B.S. Rawat v. Mohmed Azan Khan
    (Aug 31, 1989)