Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 6 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1859 the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • section 210 of the English Companies Act, 1948,
  • section 397 or 398 of the Companies Act, 1956
  • sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act.8.
  • section 397 and/or 398 of the Companies Act.
  • sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act.
  • SECTION 397 COMPANIES ACT
  • SECTION 210 A COMPANIES ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 6 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1859 the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • section 210 of the English Companies Act, 1948,
  • section 397 or 398 of the Companies Act, 1956
  • sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act.8.
  • section 397 and/or 398 of the Companies Act.
  • sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act.
  • SECTION 397 COMPANIES ACT
  • SECTION 210 A COMPANIES ACT
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Company Petition No. 573 of 1984

Factual and Procedural Background

Company Petition No. 573 of 1984 is a petition under sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act filed by shareholders representing about 35% of the share‑holding in the 5th respondent company, Reliable Extraction Industries Pvt. Ltd. Respondents Nos. 1 to 4 hold an aggregate of about 31% of the equity shares. At the material times petitioners Nos. 1, 2, 3 and respondent No. 1 constituted the Board of Directors of the 5th respondent company.

At the interim stage, the parties agreed that respondent No. 9 would be appointed as the Chairman and Managing Director of the 5th respondent company, and certain interim orders were taken in the Company Petition. Following the filing of the petition and subsequently, events transpired which the petitioners seek to incorporate into the petition by way of amendment.

The Company Application before the court sought (a) addition of Respondents Nos. 6, 7, 8 and 9 as party respondents to the main petition and (b) insertion of paragraphs 30A to 30T and several additional prayers (set out in the Schedule to the Company Application). The proposed amendments describe events said to have occurred after filing, including an alleged notice dated 11‑5‑1987 convening an extraordinary general meeting on 2‑6‑1987 (the validity and occurrence of which are disputed), alleged removal of respondent No. 9 as Chairman and Managing Director and of petitioner No. 1 as Executive Director, and appointment of respondents Nos. 6, 7 and 8 as Executive Directors. The petitioners also allege criminal charges involving respondents Nos. 7 and 8 and allege further acts of fraud and misappropriation by respondent No. 1 from 1984 onwards.

The present opinion concerns the Company Application for amendment to include these matters and the additional parties. The court considered the application on its merits and made specific directions (described below) allowing the amendments and fixing timelines for filing affidavits and hearing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petition may be amended to add Respondents Nos. 6, 7, 8 and 9 and to incorporate subsequent events (i.e., events occurring after filing of the petition) in a petition under sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act.
  2. Whether events or conduct occurring after the date of filing a petition under sections 397 and 398 can be considered by the court for determining reliefs in such a petition (i.e., the scope of admissible events in a section 397/398 petition).
  3. Whether grievances that arise in the capacity of directors (as distinct from grievances as members/shareholders) can form the subject matter of a petition under section 397 and/or section 398, or whether relief under these sections is confined strictly to conduct affecting petitioners in their capacity as members.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Contentions

  • The petitioners sought to amend the petition to add respondents and to include paragraphs 30A–30T describing subsequent events said to amount to oppression and mismanagement by respondent No. 1 and his group after February–March 1987.
  • The petitioners allege that shareholders in the group of respondent No. 1 issued a notice dated 11‑5‑1987 for an extraordinary general meeting on 2‑6‑1987 and that it is disputed whether this meeting was held and whether it was validly convened.
  • It is alleged that at the alleged extraordinary general meeting resolutions were passed removing respondent No. 9 as Chairman and Managing Director, removing petitioner No. 1 as Executive Director, and appointing respondents Nos. 6, 7 and 8 as Executive Directors; the petitioners challenge those actions and a subsequently convened meeting of the newly constituted Board.
  • The petitioners assert that respondents Nos. 7 and 8 are involved in criminal charges (criminal conspiracy to abduct, torture and extort money), that they have been arrested and released on bail and the case is pending, and that the petitioners seek to restrain respondents Nos. 7 and 8 from acting as directors.
  • Additional alleged acts of fraud and misappropriation of funds by respondent No. 1 in 1984 and thereafter are set out in the proposed amendments and the petitioners maintain these matters should be part of the petition.

Respondents' (Opposing) Arguments

  • Mr. Chinoy, appearing for respondents Nos. 1, 2 and 4, stated he had no objection to adding respondents Nos. 6, 7 and 8 as party respondents but opposed the remainder of the amendments.
  • He contended that the additional amendments relate to events subsequent to the filing of Company Petition No. 573 of 1984 and that such subsequent events cannot be gone into in deciding a petition under sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act.
  • In support he relied on Rajahmundry Electric Supply Corporation Ltd. v. A. Nageshwara Rao (reported at AIR ... SC 213) to argue that subsequent changes in shareholder consent after presentation of a valid petition are irrelevant; he advanced this as supporting the broader proposition that subsequent events cannot be considered.
  • He also relied on Shanti Prasad Jain v. Kalinga Tubes Ltd. (1965) to emphasize the statement that oppressive conduct must continue "up to the date of petition" and submitted that only conduct up to that date can be looked at under sections 397/398.
  • Finally, he contended that grievances arising in the capacity of directors (as opposed to members/shareholders) are not matters suitable for a petition under section 397/398.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rajahmundry Electric Supply Corporation Ltd. v. A. Nageshwara Rao (reported in AIR 1756 SC 213) That subsequent withdrawal of consent by shareholders after a petition is filed does not invalidate a petition that had required support when filed. The court held this case did not support the respondents' broader contention that subsequent events cannot be considered; it only stands for the narrow proposition about withdrawal of consent after filing and does not preclude looking at subsequent events on merits.
Shanti Prasad Jain v. Kalinga Tubes Ltd. ((1965) 35 Comp. Cas. 351) That oppressive conduct should be a continuous course of conduct "up to the date of petition" to sustain a petition under sections 397 and 398. The court accepted that the judgment requires continuous conduct up to the date of petition but rejected the respondents' reading that it bars consideration of subsequent acts by amendment; it noted the case does not decide on subsequent conduct after filing.
Promode Kumar Mittal v. Southern Steel Ltd. ((1980) 50 Comp. Cas. 555) That in petitions under sections 397/398 the court can take notice of subsequent events to grant final relief and that interim orders, meetings under court-appointed chairpersons and subsequent resolutions are relevant. The court cited this authority to support the proposition that there is no bar to incorporating subsequent events by amendment if necessary for proper determination of issues.
Inder Kumar Jain v. Osra Bottling Co. (P.) Ltd. ((1977) 47 Comp. Cas. 194) That by analogy to Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC, the High Court has power to grant leave to amend pleadings in petitions under sections 397 or 398. The court relied on this authority to conclude that the Code of Civil Procedure's amendment principles apply and that leave to amend may be granted in company petitions under sections 397/398.
Bastar Transport and Trading Co. v. Court of Wards (AIR 1955 Nagpur 78) That the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, so far as applicable, govern proceedings under the Companies Act. The court cited this to support the application of civil procedure rules (including amendment provisions) to company petitions, reinforcing the correctness of permitting amendments.
Re Lundie Brothers Ltd. ((1965) 2 All E.R. 692) That a petitioner seeking relief equivalent to section 210 (English Companies Act; equated to section 397) who complains only of being ousted as a working director and without showing unfairness to him as shareholder is not entitled to relief under that provision. The court relied on this case to explain that relief under member‑based provisions cannot be granted where the grievance exists solely in the capacity of a director; but the court distinguished the present facts because the alleged acts here affected petitioners as shareholders as well.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded to examine the application to amend on merits. It first observed that although the proposed amendments were lengthy and could have been more concise, that alone was not a ground for rejection.

The key analytical questions were whether (a) subsequent events occurring after the filing of a petition under sections 397/398 could be incorporated by amendment and considered by the court, and (b) whether grievances arising in the capacity of directors could be the subject of such a petition.

On the first question, the court reviewed the authorities cited by the respondents and other relevant cases:

  • Rajahmundry was interpreted narrowly: it stands for the proposition that withdrawal of consent after a petition is filed does not invalidate a petition that had required support when presented; it does not establish that subsequent events cannot be considered on the merits of a petition.
  • Shanti Prasad Jain was read as requiring continuous oppressive conduct up to the date of the petition to sustain the petition — it does not speak to events occurring after the date of filing, and thus cannot be taken to prohibit incorporation of subsequent acts by amendment.
  • The court relied on Rule 6 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1859 (which makes the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure applicable, so far as relevant) and authorities such as Promode Kumar Mittal and Inder Kumar Jain that allow consideration of subsequent events and permit leave to amend pleadings in company petitions by analogy to Order VI Rule 17 CPC.
  • Bastar Transport and Trading Co. was cited for the proposition that CPC provisions govern proceedings under the Companies Act where applicable, reinforcing that amendment rules apply.

The court concluded that there is no provision in the Companies Act that prohibits the court from looking at subsequent events in a petition under sections 397 and 398 and that amendments incorporating subsequent events are permissible where necessary for a proper determination of the issues between the parties. The court therefore rejected the respondents' contention that subsequent events are wholly irrelevant.

On the second question, the court acknowledged the principle in Re Lundie Brothers Ltd. that relief under member‑based provisions cannot be granted where the grievance exists only in the capacity of a director and not as a member. However, the court found that the present amendments do not solely concern removal of directors in their capacity as directors. The alleged acts—requisitioning shareholders, convening an extraordinary general meeting, passing resolutions removing/appointing key office‑holders—affected the petitioners as shareholders as well. The court therefore held the amendments could not be rejected on the ground that they related only to director‑capacity grievances.

Having considered these points, and having found the authorities relied upon by the respondents distinguishable or inapplicable to the broad proposition urged by them, the court allowed the amendments to be made and provided consequential directions for pleadings and timetable for replies and hearings.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The court made the Judge's Summons absolute in terms of prayer (a) and allowed the proposed amendments to be made to Company Petition No. 573 of 1984. The court held that amendments incorporating subsequent events are not barred as a matter of law in petitions under sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act where such amendments are necessary for proper determination of issues.

Immediate Orders and Consequences:

  • The proposed amendments were to be carried out within one week.
  • Respondents Nos. 1 to 4 were granted liberty to file an additional affidavit in reply in Company Petition No. 573 of 1984 confined to the amendments.
  • Newly added respondents Nos. 6 to 9 were directed to file affidavits in reply within three weeks from being joined and served.
  • Costs were ordered to be costs in the cause.
  • The Company Petition No. 573 of 1984 was to be placed on board for hearing after six weeks.

Broader Implication: The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel or binding precedent beyond applying existing authorities and procedural rules; it records that amendments incorporating subsequent events are permissible under the Companies Act procedure where relevant — the court did not state or record the creation of a new legal principle beyond these applications.

Order: Order accordingly.

    Khimji M. Shah v. Ratilal Damodardas Modi

    1. This is a Company Application for amendment of the petition by adding Respondents Nos. 6, 7, 8 and 9 in the Company Application as party Respondents to the main petition and for adding paragraphs 30A to 30T as well as several additional prayers as set out in the Schedule to the Company Application. The length of the amendments proposed could have been substantially reduced had the Applicants applied themselves to it. But this is no ground for rejecting the application. Hence I propose to consider the amendments on merits.

    2. Company Petition No. 573 of 1984 is a Petition under Sections 397 and 398 filed by the shareholders representing about 35 per cent of the share-holding in the 5th respondent-Company — Reliable Extraction Industries Pvt. Ltd. Respondents Nos. 1 to 4 in the petition hold an aggregate of about 31 per cent of the equity shares in the said Company. Petitioners Nos. 1, 2, 3 and respondent No. 1 constituted, at the material time, the Board of Directors of the 5th Respondent Company. It seems that by reason of events which have transpired subsequent to the filing of the petition the present amendments are being sought. After the filing of the present Petition, at the interim stage the parties agreed that the 9th respondent would be appointed as the Chairman and Managing Director of the 5th Respondent Company. There upon certain orders were taken in the Company Petition. The events which led to the appointment of respondent No. 9 as the Chairman and Managing Director of the 5th Respondent Company have been set out in the proposed amendments.

    3. It is the case of the petitioners that after February-March 1987 respondent No. 1 and/or the share-holders belonging to his group consisting of his sons and daughters have committed various acts which also amount to oppression and mismanagement. It seems that some of the share-holders belonging to the group of the 1st respondent issued a notice dated 11-5-1987 for convening an extraordinary general meeting of the shareholders of the 5th Respondent Company on 2-6-1987 at the registered office of the Company. The dispute is as to whether this extraordinary general meeting was at all held and whether this alleged extraordinary general meeting was validly convened as prescribed by law. It is contended by the respondents that at this alleged extraordinary general meeting resolutions were passed removing respondent No. 9 as the Chairman and Managing Director, removing petitioner No. 1 as the Executive Director of the Company and appointing respondents Nos. 6, 7 and 8 as the Executive Directors of the Company with immediate effect. The respondents have also allegedly convened a meeting of the newly constituted Board of Directors, which is challenged by the amendment.

    4. It is also the contention of the petitioners that Respondents Nos. 7 and 8, who are the alleged newly appointed Executive Directors of the 5th Respondent Company, have been involved in offences involving moral turpitude inasmuch as these respondents were arrested in connection with offences of criminal conspiracy to abduct, torture and extort money. They have been released on bail and the case is still pending against them. By the amendment the petitioners want to restrain respondents Nos. 7 and 8 from acting as the Directors of the Company. Some additional acts of fraud and misappropriation of funds in the year 1984 and thereafter by respondent No. 1 have also been set out in the proposed amendments.

    5. Mr. Chinoy who appeared for respondents Nos. 1, 2 and 4 to oppose the amendments, stated that he had no objection to respondents Nos. 6, 7 and 8 being added as party-respondents to the Company Petition No. 573 of 1984. He, however, submitted that rest of the amendments should not be allowed because, according to him, these amendments deal with the events subsequent to the filing of Company Petition No. 573 of 1984. It is his contention that such subsequent events cannot be gone into in deciding a Company Petition under sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act. In support he relied upon a decision in the case of Rajahmundry Electric Supplycorporation Ltd. v. 1. A. Nageshwara Rao reported in AIR 1756 SC 213. In this case the applicants had obtained the consent of not less than 1/10th of the members of the Company while filing a petition under sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act. After the petition was presented some of the share-holders withdrew their consent. The Court held that this subsequent withdrawal of consent is not relevant if the petition had the support of the requisite number of members at the time when the petition was presented. This case does not support the contention of Mr. Chinoy. The judgment merely states that if a petition is validly filed and complies with all the requirements of sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act at the date when it is filed, any subsequent withdrawal of consent by some of the shareholders would not invalidate the petition. The decision does not set out that subsequent events cannot be looked into in deciding a petition under sections 397 and 398 on merits.

    6. The second case relied upon by Mr. Chinoy was that of Shanti Prasad Jain v. Kalinga Tubes Ltd. reported in (1965) 35 Comp. Cas. 351 at p. 366. The Cour there held that it is necessary in a petition under sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act to show that the conduct of the majority share-holders was oppressive to the minority as members. Also, the events had to be considered not in isolation but as a part of a consecutive story. It said “There must be continuous acts on the part of the majority shareholders, continuing up to the date of petition, showing that the affairs of the company were being conducted in a manner oppressive to some part of the members.” Mr. Chinoy emphasised the words “up to the date of petition” and submitted that only conduct up to the date of the petition can be looked at in such a petition. I am unable to agree. The judgment points out that there should be a course of conduct which could be considered as oppressive to some of the members, burdensome, harsh and wrongful and such conduct should continue till the date of the petition. Stray acts which may amount to such burdensome conduct cannot be enough. There should be continuous course of conduct up to the date of petition. The judgment does not deal with any subsequent conduct after the date of filing of the petition. It merely says that if there is no such conduct continuing till the date of the petition, the petition would fail. From this a conclusion cannot be drawn that if there are any subsequent acts of oppression or mismanagement after the date of the filing of the petition, those cannot be incorporated in a petition by way of amendment.

    7. Under Rule 6 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1859 the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, so far as applicable shall apply to all proceedings under the Companies Act. The provisions relating to amendment of pleadings would, therefore, apply to amendment of pleadings under the Companies Act. There is no bar to an amendment which incorporates subsequent events if the amendment is otherwise necessary for proper determination of issues between the parties. In the case of Promode Kumar Mittal v. Southern Steel Ltd. reported in (1980) 50 Comp. Cos. 555 the Culcutta High Court observed in a petition under sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act that the court can take notice of all subsequent events to grant reliefs finally after trial in a company matter and the interim orders passed from time to time by the court in all applications, the meetings held under the chairman appointed by the Court, and the resolutions passed by majority shareholders and directors present therein are all relevant. In the case of Inder Kumar Jain v. Osra Bottling Co. (P.) Ltd. reported in (1977) 47 Comp. Cas. 194 the Delhi High Court has held that on an analogy of Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the High Court has power to grant leave to amend a pleading in a petition under section 397 or 398 of the Companies Act, 1956 for relief against mismanagement or oppression in the affairs of a company. In the case of Bastar Transport and Trading Co. v. Court of Wards reported in AIR 1955 Nagpur 78 the Court has held that the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, so far as applicable, would govern proceedings under the Companies Act also. There is thus no provision under the Companies Act which prohibits a Court from looking at subsequent events in a petition under sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act.

    8. It is next contended on behalf of the respondents that in a Company Petition of this nature only the grievance of the petitioners as shareholders can be enquired into; if they have any grievance as directors of a company such grievance cannot form the subject-matter of a petition under section 397 and/or 398 of the Companies Act. It is undoubtedly correct that petitions under section 397 deal with applications by members of a company who complain that the affairs of the company are being conducted in a manner prejudicial to the public interest or in a manner oppressive to any member or members. Similarly, section 398 deals with applications by members of the company who complain that the affairs of the company are being conducted in a manner prejudicial to public interest or in a manner prejudicial to the interest of the company or that a material change has taken place in the management or control of the company and by reason of such change it is likely that the affairs of the Company will be conducted in a manner prejudicial to the public interest or in a manner prejudicial to the interest of the company. These are all applications by members. In the case of Re Lundie Brothers Ltd. reported in (1965) 2 All E.R 692 a petitioner who was one of three directors and shareholders in a private company; presented a petition for relief under section 210 of the English Companies Act, 1948, which is equivalent to section 397 of the Companies Act. The petitioner was ousted from the control of the company and was removed as a working director of the company. It was held that no element of lack of probity or fair dealing to the petitioner in his capacity as shareholder in the company had been established. For his having been ousted as a working director related to his status as director and not as shareholder. It was held that the petitioner was not entitled to relief under section 210 of the Companies Act. In the present case however, the, amendments do not deal merely with removal of directors of the 5th Respondent Company. The acts complained of relate to requisition from various shareholders of the 5th Respondent Company, as a result of which an extraordinary general meeting is purported to have been held and certain new directors appointed. At this meeting the Chairman and Managing Director was also sought to be removed. The petitioners contend that some of the directors so appointed are involved in charges of criminal conspiracy and if they are appointed as directors of the Company, the affairs of the Company will be so conducted as to be oppressive to the shareholders, especially the petitioners. It cannot be said that the amendments relate only to the petitioners' grievance as directors of the Company. The acts complained of affect them as shareholders also. In any case, this is a matter which can be looked into in depth at the hearing of the petition. The amendments cannot be rejected on this ground.

    9. In the premises, Judge's Summons is made absolute in terms of prayer (a). Amendments to be carried out within one week. Liberty to the Respondents Nos. 1 to 4 to file an additional affidavit in reply in Company Petition No. 573 of 1984 confined to the amendments.

    10. Newly added Respondents Nos. 6 to 9 to file their affidavit in reply within 3 weeks from being joined as respondents and served.

    11. Costs to be costs in the cause. Company Petition No. 573 of 1984 to be on board for hearing after six weeks.

    Order accordingly.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Khimji M. Shah v. Ratilal Damodardas Modi
    (Sep 11, 1987)